6 Best Painters Near Mount Sinai, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Mount Sinai, NY cover everything from standard interior and exterior work to specialty decorative finishes, cabinet painting, and historic wallpaper removal. The companies that rise to the top across Chooz Painters share a few things in common: owner involvement, thorough prep work, and results that bring customers back project after project.

Interior Finishing NYC holds the highest Chooz Score in the area at a Chooz Score of 87.3%. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in decorative techniques that most painters simply won't attempt: limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, and gilded ceilings. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 22 years in business, this company handles residential and commercial spaces alike, from Manhattan apartments to corporate offices.

Several customers note that Dorian took on projects other contractors had already declined. His scope extends well beyond walls - reviews mention drywall repair, window film installation, wallpaper hanging over challenging surfaces, and gilded ceilings in commercial spaces. Customers working remotely during their projects describe Dorian as easy to manage from a distance, with clear communication throughout.

• Once customers bring in Interior Finishing NYC for one space, many hire them back for additional rooms - one reviewer hired Dorian for a nursery limewash, loved the result, and brought him back for a powder room and home office
• Team members Jose, Amir, and Marvin appear across reviews as a consistent crew working alongside Dorian on each job
• Dorian offers quotes by phone or video call, making the process accessible for busy homeowners or those managing projects remotely

If you're looking for specialty decorative finishes or have a complex project other contractors have turned down, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong choice.

While decorative specialty work defines Interior Finishing NYC, CRD Painting Inc out of Yaphank has built something different: a deep bench of loyal customers who've been calling Camilo for a decade or more. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 90 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp, and over 8 years in business serving Long Island.

Camilo's work spans an unusually wide range of surfaces - staining wooden beams and front doors, painting window frames black across an entire house, and tackling antique homes with floor-to-ceiling wallpaper. One reviewer called when she wasn't happy with her original color choice, and Camilo returned the next day to repaint without hesitation. That kind of flexibility keeps clients loyal for years.

• Customers document relationships spanning 10 to 15 years, often calling Camilo across multiple homes and properties over that time
• Exterior painting, power washing, specialty bathroom ceiling coats, and skim coating round out the services alongside standard interior work
• All furniture and floors are covered before work begins, and job sites are cleaned up daily throughout each project

If you're looking for a reliable painter you can call for both small and large projects over many years, CRD Painting Inc is a good fit.

For homeowners who need more than just paint, Big Expert Painting LLC out of Amityville handles an unusually wide range of services under one roof. Also holding a Chooz Score of 87.0%, they had over 130 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. They hold an EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes.

Beyond painting, Denis and his crew take on drywall repair, sheetrock installation, crown molding, pool painting with specialty primer, power washing, and cabinet resurfacing. Wallpaper removal is another specialty - one customer had paper up for over 15 years, and after removal, skim coating, and painting, the walls showed no trace of it. Owner Denis responds to calls the same day and has maintained customer relationships spanning seven or more years.

• Denis and his crew handle everything from small patch jobs to full home interior and exterior projects in one call
• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification makes them a responsible choice for older Long Island homes built before 1978
• Customers who bring Denis in for one task often add more rooms or services before the project wraps up

If you have a multi-service renovation or an older home that needs more than fresh paint, Big Expert Painting LLC is a practical choice.

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Todd's Painting out of Centereach. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating - the highest review volume among the top contractors serving Mount Sinai, NY. Reviews span Google, Facebook, and Yelp.

What stands out across the reviews is how many customers specifically mention Todd's cabinet painting. Multiple homeowners describe hiring the crew to spray-paint kitchen cabinets and getting results that made existing cabinets look new without full replacement. Todd also offers proactive color guidance, stepping in when a choice isn't working rather than applying whatever was selected. His crew has handled congregation galleries with very high ceilings, an animal hospital exterior, and whole-home interiors in addition to standard paint jobs.

• Cabinet spray painting is a clear specialty, with multiple customers describing results that made existing cabinets look like they came from a showroom
• Todd gives proactive color advice rather than painting whatever was selected and moving on
• Customers routinely leave Todd and his crew to work unsupervised in empty homes, noting the trust has always been earned

If you're focused on kitchen cabinet painting or want a painter you can trust to work independently, Todd's Painting is a strong option.

Also serving the Mount Sinai, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a larger-company structure with dedicated project managers and named crews who appear across multiple customer accounts. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, is 100% recommended on Facebook, holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2015), and has been in business over 18 years.

Project managers David Maloney, Jason Eng, Brendan, and TJ are each referenced across multiple reviews from different customers, and crew members Carlos, Amilcar, Fernando, Jose, and Hernando appear by name on unrelated projects. One homeowner trusted the crew with a house key for a multi-day renovation on a 2,300 square-foot home. Another customer lives out of state and coordinated the entire project remotely without difficulty. The team also handles floor refinishing and epoxy applications alongside painting.

• Named project managers stay involved day-to-day across each project, not just at the estimate stage
• The same named crew members appear across different customers' reviews, meaning fewer surprises about who shows up at your door
• Floor refinishing, epoxy applications, and wallpaper installation extend their service offering beyond standard painting

If you have a large-scale project or want the oversight of a team with dedicated management, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is a reliable option.

Rounding out the top contractors serving Mount Sinai, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration out of Bay Shore handles residential and commercial work under owner Andres Gallego. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, and has been in business over 6 years.

Andres conducts personal walkthroughs for every estimate and offers color consultations for homeowners uncertain about their choices. The company has handled two-layer wallpaper removal, popcorn ceiling removal, exterior painting, commercial building work, and whole-home painting for new buyers. Several reviewers had projects completed ahead of schedule, with crew sizes scaled to match the scope of the job.

• Andres handles every estimate personally and includes color consultation for homeowners who want guidance on their choices
• Projects consistently finish on time or ahead of schedule, with crew sizes adjusted to match the job scope
• Serves both residential and commercial clients across Nassau and Suffolk counties

For new homeowners painting a whole house or customers who want an involved owner from start to finish, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a good call.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Quality of workmanship is one of the most consistently praised qualities across reviews for painters serving Mount Sinai, NY. Interior Finishing NYC earns standout marks for decorative finishes that require an artistic foundation - customers describe limewash walls that match inspiration photos exactly, Roman clay accent walls with dramatic results, and Venetian plaster surfaces that continue drawing compliments long after the job is done. CRD Painting Inc customers highlight how walls and ceilings go from surfaces with cracks and water damage to finishes that look completely replaced, with Camilo overseeing the careful prep work that makes results last. "Dorian and his team are excellent. Superb attention to detail on wallpaper and painting job. On time, no hidden costs, did everything they said they would and finished ahead of schedule. 10/10!" - B. Rauch, Google Review

Big Expert Painting LLC customers specifically call out the quality of wallpaper removal and skim coating, with results described as looking brand new where old paper once sat. Todd's Painting reviewers focus on the precision of cabinet spray painting, with existing cabinets described as looking like they came from a showroom, alongside careful spackle and prep before paint is applied. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge draws consistent praise for correcting surface imperfections left by previous work before painting begins, and customers often note the job was better than promised. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns consistent marks for clean, even coverage on both interior and exterior surfaces, with multiple customers returning to Andres specifically for the quality they know they'll get. "The work done by Amilcar and co was amazing. They were clean, neat, quiet, and really did such a great job. My project manager Dave was excellent. Dave was on top of my project and addressed every issue I mentioned." - Brett H., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Professionalism and clear communication come up more than almost any other theme across reviews for painters serving Mount Sinai, NY. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi is described across multiple reviews as quick to respond, thorough in his initial consultations, and consistent about sharing updates throughout multi-day projects. Customers who coordinated work remotely - including one managing a corporate office repaint from out of town - describe Dorian as easy to reach and proactive about keeping them informed. CRD Painting Inc owner Camilo earns specific praise for returning calls and texts promptly, providing clear timelines from the estimate forward, and accommodating schedule changes without friction. "We've used Dorian for our company's office needs a number of times now and each time the experience has been easy and efficient. Dorian is quick to communicate, patient when it comes to bureaucratic delays, and always does a beautiful job on the work itself." - Charlotte M., Google Review

Todd's Painting customers consistently note Todd's responsiveness from the very first call - one reviewer described him arriving the same week she reached out, providing a clear estimate, and completing the work days later for the quoted price. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge stands out for layered communication: dedicated office staff handle scheduling and follow-up while project managers like David Maloney and Jason Eng stay in contact throughout the job. One out-of-state homeowner coordinated an entire painting project through Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge without being present and described the experience as seamless. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres is repeatedly described as quick to respond and easy to reach from initial inquiry through final walkthrough. "Todd was very communicative giving me picture updates throughout and did a perfect job! My home looks amazing!" - Maeve C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Finishing on or ahead of schedule is one of the most frequently mentioned strengths across reviews for painters serving Mount Sinai, NY. Todd's Painting delivers some of the fastest turnarounds in the area: one customer had an estimate and a completed multi-room job the very next day, with the crew finished before 5pm. Another homeowner had a bathroom, foyer, and front entrance done in a single visit between 8am and 3pm. CRD Painting Inc customers regularly note that Camilo starts and finishes on the dates he commits to, with reviewers specifically mentioning that painting, spackling, and power washing were each completed within tight schedule windows. "I had a very tight timeline with my home improvements and he worked it out so my house painting and power washing was completed." - Lisa J., Google Review

Interior Finishing NYC customers note that Dorian's team consistently finishes ahead of schedule while keeping spaces clean at every stage. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis gave one customer an estimate of three days and delivered the project in two. Long Island Painting and Restoration consistently scales crew size to the scope of the work - a six-person crew completed a large whole-home project in a single day for one reviewer. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge manages multi-day jobs by maintaining a livable home throughout, with customers describing the team arriving on time each morning and cleaning up at the end of each workday. "Andres was easy to work with. When his crew came, there were six of them. They took care of everything from the set up to the painting to the cleanup. I am amazed that they were able to finish such a big job in just one day!" - Keri S., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Thorough prep work and clean job sites are themes that run through reviews across all painters serving Mount Sinai, NY. CRD Painting Inc customers frequently describe furniture and floors fully covered before work begins, with Camilo and his crew cleaning up daily so the home looks undisturbed at the end of each day. Prep goes beyond surface coverage - the crew applies multiple coats for specialty surfaces like bathroom ceilings, handles skim coating for damaged walls, and addresses cracks and imperfections before any paint touches the surface. Big Expert Painting LLC handles prep-heavy projects like wallpaper removal and skim coating, protecting areas outside the scope of work throughout the job. "From start to finish, the team was professional, punctual, and incredibly detail-oriented. They took great care in prepping the space, protecting our floors and furniture, and making sure every surface was perfectly finished." - Jennifer W., Google Review

Todd's Painting crews take down blinds, cover everything in plastic, clean up, and vacuum when the job is done - one customer described being pleasantly surprised to find her home in better shape than expected, with her belongings exactly where they started. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge handles multi-day renovations by restoring the home to livable condition at the end of each workday, with furniture carefully moved, covered, and returned to its original position. Interior Finishing NYC customers describe crews who respect the space throughout the project, whether working in residential apartments or commercial offices. Long Island Painting and Restoration consistently draws praise for leaving spaces spotless, with reviewers noting the crew cleaned up each day and returned the home to order before leaving. "His guys took down the blinds, covered everything in plastic, cleaned up and vacuumed afterwards. I was pleasantly surprised." - Christine C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Fair, transparent pricing is a consistent theme across reviews for painters serving Mount Sinai, NY. Multiple customers across all six companies note that the final invoice matched the original estimate with no surprise charges added after the work was done. CRD Painting Inc is regularly described as fair and reasonable by long-term customers who have returned for projects spanning years, noting they continue to call Camilo specifically because the combination of quality and price holds up over time. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis responds to quote requests the same day and is described as competitive against other estimates, with customers noting they were surprised by how much was included at the price quoted. "The initial quote was accurate with no nonsense charges added at the end. Would definitely use again!" - Danny T., Google Review

Todd's Painting reviews frequently note that the pricing opened the door to doing more work than originally planned - at least one reviewer added additional rooms and tasks specifically because the cost worked within their budget. Interior Finishing NYC customers acknowledge that specialty decorative finishes come at a premium but consistently describe the pricing as fair relative to the expertise and artistry involved. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns specific mentions for providing competitive estimates on complicated jobs that other painters had priced higher, with customers noting the company delivers more than the price alone suggests. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres provides detailed estimates after personal walkthroughs, with customers describing the quotes as thorough and competitive against other bids received. "PPP gave us an amazing price but more importantly the work was awesome and the communication was fantastic." - Andrew M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Mount Sinai, NY homeowners looking for specialty finishes have a strong option in Interior Finishing NYC, where owner Dorian Golemi trained at the University of Fine Arts in Albania and brings over 22 years of experience in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic finishes, and gilded surfaces. Customers describe bringing him in for full-room color drenching, pre-war woodwork restoration, grasscloth and cork wallpaper installation on challenging walls, and ceiling gilding in commercial spaces. Several reviewers specifically note that other contractors had declined their projects before Dorian agreed to take them on - and delivered results that matched the original inspiration photos. His service area includes Nassau and Suffolk counties, meaning Long Island homeowners can access this level of finish work without traveling to Manhattan. "Dori was prompt and very professional. His Venetian plaster work on my kitchen walls are unbelievable. I always get compliments from our guests!" - Charlie V., Google Review

For kitchen cabinet painting without full replacement, Todd's Painting has developed a clear specialty on Long Island. Multiple recent reviews describe Todd's crew removing all cabinet doors, spray-painting the frames in place, and returning the doors with a finish customers describe as looking showroom-fresh. Todd also guides customers on color selection proactively, steering them away from choices that won't work before a drop of paint goes down. Big Expert Painting LLC also handles cabinet resurfacing alongside painting, drywall, and backsplash work. For homeowners interested in limewash or Roman clay finishes across Long Island, Interior Finishing NYC has completed residential projects in Nassau and Suffolk counties in addition to its Manhattan work. "Painting cabinets is his personal specialty and he's a true master of his craft! Excited for my new counters and backsplash to complete the look!" - Darlene R., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google