Homeowners in Stony Brook, NY have strong options when it comes to finding a reliable painting contractor. The companies reviewed on Chooz Painters cover a wide range of needs, from decorative specialty finishes to full interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, and repair work. Across hundreds of reviews, a few patterns show up consistently: customers value fast response times, careful prep work, and crews who treat their homes with care.
For homeowners seeking decorative and specialty finishes, Interior Finishing NYC stands in a category of its own. Owner Dorian Golemi's background in fine arts shows up directly in the work: reviewers describe limewash applications, Roman clay walls, Venetian plaster, gilded ceilings, and grasscloth wallpaper installations that other contractors declined to attempt. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Interior Finishing NYC had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. With over 22 years in business, the company also backs its work with a three-year workmanship warranty on completed projects.
Reading through the reviews, a few consistent observations stand out: customers with unusual project challenges, including color-matching after water damage, gilding in commercial spaces, and installing difficult wallpapers over imperfect surfaces, describe Dorian approaching these as routine rather than exceptional. Reviewers frequently describe receiving guidance on finish types and product differences as part of the process, not just the painting itself.
- Same-day and next-day responses to quote requests appear frequently across reviews, with customers noting how quickly Dorian followed up compared to other contractors they contacted
- Both residential and commercial clients appear throughout the reviews, ranging from Manhattan co-op apartments and nurseries to corporate offices and retail spaces
- Last-minute and tight-deadline requests show up multiple times, with reviewers noting the crew delivered on compressed timelines without sacrificing quality
- Customers returning for a second project appear across the reviews, many citing the first experience as the reason they came back for limewash, wallpaper, or plaster work in another room
"We hired Dorian and his team to paint our living room and guest bedroom in lime wash paint. His team was professional, skilled, clean, and incredibly fast. They painted both rooms in a single day, and the results are amazing. We couldn't be happier." - Matt B., Google Review
If you're looking for decorative finishes, specialty plaster work, or an experienced team for complex projects, Interior Finishing NYC is a good choice.
While Interior Finishing NYC specializes in artistic finishes, CRD Painting Inc has built an equally strong following on Long Island through long-term relationships with customers who keep calling back. Owner Camilo's track record shows up across reviews spanning multiple homes and many years of repeat business. At the time of our analysis, CRD Painting Inc had over 90 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and a matching 5.0-star rating on Yelp, earning a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The company holds an active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License verified through 2027, with over 8 years serving Long Island homeowners.
The breadth of services customers trust Camilo to handle stands out in the reviews: interior and exterior painting, spackle and skim coat work, wallpaper removal, staining, and ceiling repairs all appear. Several reviewers describe choosing a color they weren't satisfied with after the work began, only to have Camilo return the next day to repaint without hesitation - that kind of responsiveness is noted across multiple accounts.
- Multiple reviewers describe Camilo's crew completing large interiors in a day or two, reflecting well-organized crews and a steady workflow that doesn't sacrifice attention to detail
- Family referrals are a notable pattern, with reviewers describing recommending CRD to siblings, parents, and friends - who then came back with equally positive feedback
- Skim coat and spackle prep alongside painting appears frequently, with customers describing old walls in antique or older homes looking brand new after the prep phase alone
"I couldn't be happier hiring Camilo and CRD painting for our latest house project. From beginning to end, the job went so very smooth. The communication, thoroughness, ease and outcome were all what we've been looking for in a painter. Pricing was on point as well as the finished product." - Erika L., Google Review
If you want a reliable painter your household can call for years, CRD Painting Inc is a good choice.
For homeowners dealing with repair work alongside painting, Big Expert Painting LLC stands out for its full-service approach. Owner Denis Erazo handles everything from standard interior painting to sheetrock repair, crown molding installation, deck staining, power washing, and cabinet resurfacing. The last time we conducted our analysis, Big Expert Painting LLC had over 130 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp, earning a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The company holds an active Suffolk County Home Improvement License plus EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes.
A pattern that appears frequently in reviews is customers adding to the original project scope mid-job after seeing the initial results. Several reviewers describe hiring Denis for a few rooms and immediately requesting more rooms or exterior work once the quality was apparent. One reviewer described calling Denis for a small drywall patch and having him patch, paint, and wall-mount a television all in the same visit - the kind of responsiveness that stands out in the review record.
- Power washing alongside painting is a frequently mentioned service, with reviewers citing decks, pool areas, patio pavers, and exterior siding as part of the same visit as interior work
- Several reviewers mention Denis or crew arriving within the same week as the estimate, sometimes within just a few days of the initial contact
- Kitchen cabinet resurfacing with spray techniques appears across multiple reviews as a distinct specialty, with reviewers describing finishes that looked completely new
"I hired Denis's company to do the exterior cleaning and painting of my house, and I was extremely satisfied with the result. They were punctual, organized, and very professional at every stage of the service. The painting turned out flawless, and the cleaning made the house look brand new." - Will_, Google Review
If you need painting combined with sheetrock repair, deck work, or power washing handled together in one project, Big Expert Painting LLC is a good choice.
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Todd's Painting. The company's review volume is the highest of any contractor in this group, and the patterns point to a contractor who covers a wide range of exterior and interior projects, with a notable specialty in cabinet refinishing. The last time we conducted our analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with reviews spanning Google, Facebook, and Yelp.
Kitchen cabinet painting by spray application shows up throughout the reviews as a distinctive specialty. Clients describe trusting Todd and his crew to work in their homes while they run errands or travel out of state - one reviewer had Todd's crew working in a family property while handling a personal situation out of state. Multiple reviewers also mention Todd stepping in with color guidance before a job started, with customers later crediting that advice as the reason the finished result looked as good as it did.
- Cabinet painting - particularly spray-applied finishes on kitchen cabinets - appears as a distinct specialty mentioned across a significant portion of the reviews
- Commercial projects appear throughout the reviews alongside residential, including an animal hospital exterior and a congregation hall with very high ceilings
- Reviewers repeatedly note the work area being left clean at the end of each day during multi-day projects, with everything reset for a fresh start each morning
- Several reviews describe Todd recommending color changes or alternative approaches before the job started, with customers crediting that guidance for a better finished result
"Todd and his crew are amazing!! From start to finish everything is perfect - he has such an eye for detail. We have used him now to paint our siding on the exterior of the house and the entire interior." - Mary Kate S., Google Review
If you're looking for cabinet refinishing, exterior staining, or a contractor who handles both residential and light commercial projects, Todd's Painting is a good choice.
Rounding out the top painters serving Stony Brook, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a structured project management approach that works especially well for larger or more complex interior jobs. The last time we conducted our analysis, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 84.8%.
What distinguishes Precision Painting Plus in review after review is the dedicated project manager assigned to each job. Customers consistently name David Maloney, Jason Eng, Brendan, or Matt as the person who walked them through the estimate, stayed present throughout the project, and conducted a final walkthrough at completion. Reviewers describe furniture being moved and covered each day, spaces left in usable condition during multi-day jobs, and concerns addressed quickly when they came up.
- Named project managers appear in nearly every review, with customers describing this structure as directly contributing to how smooth the overall experience felt
- Several customers describe returning for second and third jobs over the years, and a number mention referring friends and family who reported equally positive results
- Exterior projects alongside interior appear in reviews, including teak furniture restoration and floor refinishing noted by customers with specific detail
"From Supervisor Jason Eng to Office Manager Trish Gates to expert painter Andreas, I received outstanding customer service! They all went above and beyond and made my experience awsome! A big THANK YOU! HAPPY CUSTOMER!!!!" - Donna M., Google Review
If you prefer a company with a structured management process, dedicated crews, and consistent communication throughout the job, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is a good choice.
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook
