10 Best Painters Near Nesconset, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Nesconset, NY bring an impressive range of skills to Long Island homeowners, from reliable interior and exterior repaints to specialty decorative finishes that few crews in the region are equipped to handle. Our Chooz Score analysis reviewed hundreds of customer accounts across Google, Facebook, Yelp, and Angi, and the contractors below consistently earned top marks for quality, reliability, and owner involvement.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, making it one of the most reviewed painting companies in the area. This company earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, with consistent marks across platforms including 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Todd Rumfola handles every estimate personally and responds to nearly every Google review, and that level of engagement comes through clearly in how customers describe working with him. What stands out in the review record is how frequently customers found South Bay through a neighbor or friend's referral before ever searching online. Many clients also use the company for both painting and power washing across multiple seasons, building multi-year relationships with Todd and his crew. If you are looking for a company with both painting and power washing capabilities and a track record of long-term client relationships, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC is a strong starting point.

A closer look at the review record reveals that word-of-mouth is more than a cliche here - specific reviewers name the neighbor or colleague who sent them, then describe an experience that matched the recommendation. Several customers describe the company handling both power washing and interior painting across different visits and years, making South Bay a consistent presence in their home maintenance rotation. Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-61927 is active through 2027, with lead-safe certification covering older homes as well.

• Word-of-mouth drives a significant share of new clients - dozens of reviewers note they were referred by a neighbor or colleague before calling for an estimate.
• Reviews cover both painting and power washing, with many customers using South Bay for both services across multiple seasons and properties.
• Owner Todd responds to virtually every Google review and returns calls and texts promptly, often the same day a message is sent.
• Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-61927 is active through 2027, plus lead-safe certification for older Long Island homes.

"The attention to detail, trust, professionalism was something you can't find these days. We would 1000% recommend Todd and South Bay." - John Petito, Google Review

For homeowners planning decorative finish work that goes well beyond a standard repaint, Interior Finishing NYC offers a specialty rarely found among Long Island painting contractors. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi, who studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, brings over 22 years in business and a three-year workmanship warranty to every project. His team handles limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic applications, ceiling gilding, and wallpaper installation. A pattern visible across the review record: customers describe projects other contractors turned down - pre-war woodwork, damaged plaster walls, complex mural wallpapers - and Dorian's crew delivered. Reviewers include other contractors and interior designers who hire Interior Finishing NYC as a subcontractor, a strong signal from people who know the trade. If you are planning decorative work that requires an artist's precision alongside a tradesperson's skill, Interior Finishing NYC is the specialist to call.

• Specialty finishes include limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, ceiling gilding, and grasscloth wallpaper installation across a range of surfaces.
• Other contractors and interior designers hire Dorian as a subcontractor - peer-level endorsements from people inside the trade.
• Estimates are frequently handled by phone or video call, a convenience that works well for clients who are not yet on-site.
• A three-year workmanship warranty backs every completed project.

"I have been working with Dorian and his team for over 10 years. So far it has been an amazing experience. By far the best painting contractor I have worked with." - Jose M., Google Review

While Interior Finishing NYC focuses on specialty finishes, Big Expert Painting LLC covers the full range of interior and exterior painting across Long Island, with a reputation built on owner accessibility and dependable results. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, with over 130 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating consistent across every review on file. Platform marks include 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis fields calls directly, even on weekends, and is mentioned by name in the vast majority of customer accounts. Several reviewers describe starting with a smaller job and returning for a larger one after seeing the finished results. The crew's range goes beyond standard painting and includes ceiling repair from water damage, basement walls, chimney surfaces, and drywall work. Suffolk County HI-68388 and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification cover both newer and pre-1978 homes. If you are handling a combination of painting and light repair in a single project, Big Expert Painting LLC has the range and licensing to get it done.

• Owner Denis fields calls directly, including on weekends, with clients noting quick callback times and same-day estimate responses.
• The crew handles painting alongside repair work: drywall patching, water-damaged ceilings, basement walls, and chimney surfaces.
• Multiple Spanish-language reviews confirm the company serves a bilingual clientele across Long Island.
• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification is in place for work on homes built before 1978.

"Very punctual, clean, professional and great quality work. Will use Big Expert again." - Tony Peluso, Google Review

A standout in the cabinet painting and whole-home interior category, Todd's Painting has built a loyal following across Long Island through years of consistent results. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating on Google, with a presence across Facebook and Yelp as well. Cabinet painting comes up repeatedly in the review record - customers describe Todd personally overseeing that work, with finished results that frequently exceed the expected cost. A pattern worth noting: Todd brings a consultative approach to estimates, offering color suggestions and project observations before the job begins. Multiple reviewers mention this as a reason they return project after project. If you want a painter who shares his take on your colors and scope before he starts, Todd's Painting is a natural fit.

• Kitchen cabinet painting is a documented specialty, with multiple reviewers naming it as a standout service that delivers real value versus full cabinet replacement.
• Todd handles commercial jobs in addition to residential, with crews completing multi-day commercial projects with early start times and on-schedule finishes.
• Reviewers describe Todd offering color advice and project recommendations during estimates, not just a price.
• His crew handles creative scopes: vinyl shed repaints, chain-link fence painting, pool deck staining, and interior work with cathedral ceilings up to 17 feet.

"He is a true professional and I found his pricing to be very fair. One look at the inside of his truck and I knew that he was passionate about his business and what he does for a living." - Paul Genova, Google Review

Also serving the Nesconset, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a structured, management-driven approach that sets it apart from most independent painters in this market. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.8%, with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. With over 18 years in business, Better Business Bureau accreditation, and 100% recommended on Facebook, the company carries third-party endorsements alongside a strong Google record. Project managers David Maloney, Jason Eng, Brendan, and Matt Zicherman each oversee dedicated field crews, giving customers a consistent point of contact from estimate through completion. A standout pattern in the reviews: multiple customers trusted the crew with unsupervised access for multi-day projects, including one homeowner who coordinated the entire job from out of state. If you are planning a large-scale repaint and want a company with structured management and consistent crew assignments, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is worth getting a quote from.

• Dedicated project managers (David, Jason, Brendan, Matt) provide a consistent customer contact throughout each job - not a different person every call.
• Several reviewers trusted the crew with house keys for multi-day, unsupervised projects, including an out-of-state homeowner who managed the job remotely.
• The company handles complex scopes: vaulted stairwells, full skim coating, multi-room cabinet painting, and large whole-home repaints.
• 100% recommended on Facebook and BBB accreditation add third-party validation to the Google review record.

"I live out of state and working with PPP was simple. They did a fantastic job and I highly recommend their services." - Jim Patti, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Across the review record for painters serving Nesconset, NY, customers consistently highlight the quality of finished work as the primary reason they hire again. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC generates consistent feedback about careful prep before paint goes on - reviewers describe sanding, priming, and smoothing walls that set the stage for a clean finished result. Interior Finishing NYC earns the most specific quality praise in this market, with customers referencing exact finish types - Roman clay, limewash, and Venetian plaster - and describing results that matched or exceeded their inspiration photos. Big Expert Painting LLC draws quality praise across a wide range of project types, from basement ceiling repairs to full exterior repaints, with customers noting the results held steady whether the scope was large or small.

Todd's Painting generates notable quality feedback specific to cabinet work - customers describe doors properly removed, prepped, and returned looking better than new at a fraction of replacement cost. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns workmanship praise for both interior and exterior scopes, with reviewers calling out skim coating, banister finishing, and staining as strong examples of crew skill. JRT Pro Painters LLC draws consistent feedback about prep quality specifically - customers note the crew filled holes, sanded, primed, and skim coated before paint went on, and one reviewer called out the team for repairing prior contractor mistakes before even starting the painting scope. The word "perfect" appears across the review record for multiple companies serving Nesconset, NY.

"Dorian and Amir did an amazing job and it looks absolutely perfect. It was perfection from the first phone call to formal estimate and the completion of the work." - Darren Chan, Google Review

"Todd's Painting did a fantastic job repainting my kitchen cabinets. I'm so happy with my home update. Arrived timely, cleaned up and answered all my questions." - Nicole Alex, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Communication is one of the most frequently cited themes across the review record for painting companies serving Nesconset, NY, and it shows up in specific terms rather than as a general compliment. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC reviewers repeatedly describe receiving estimates within an hour of reaching out, often on the same day. Owner Todd is cited by name as someone who responds to texts and calls reliably and keeps customers informed throughout the project. Interior Finishing NYC draws similar feedback - customers frequently mention Dorian's quick replies to estimate requests, including remote consultations by phone or video call for clients who aren't yet on-site. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis is described across reviews as accessible by phone even on weekends, walking through the scope of work before starting and checking in throughout the job.

Todd's Painting customers highlight communication around scheduling specifically - Todd confirms appointments, sticks to quoted timelines, and returns to address any concerns after completion. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a layered approach through its project manager structure, with David Maloney, Jason Eng, or Brendan serving as a dedicated contact who keeps customers informed across multi-day projects. JRT Pro Painters LLC earns praise for owner Brayan's quick message responses and willingness to return promptly for small follow-up items after project completion. Across all six companies in this market, the pattern is consistent: customers who describe strong communication are the ones most likely to leave five stars and plan a second project.

"South Bay Painting and Power Washing were excellent. I called to set up an estimate and Todd responded right away, showed up when he said he was going to, emailed and texted the estimate not even an hour later." - Katie Rosario, Google Review

"Excellent communication, professional services." - Bryan Serrano, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness is one of the clearest patterns in the review record for painting contractors serving Nesconset, NY, and it comes up consistently enough to stand as a meaningful differentiator in this market. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC reviewers frequently note that Todd and his crew arrived exactly when scheduled, even for smaller power washing and gutter cleaning appointments. Todd's Painting generates specific feedback about fast project completion - customers describe receiving an estimate and having the job finished the following day, with crews arriving before 8am and wrapping up by late afternoon on single-day projects. Big Expert Painting LLC draws repeat mentions of crews arriving on time and completing work within the quoted window, including summer projects in the heat where one reviewer specifically noted the crew stayed on schedule without cutting corners.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge reviewers highlight both prompt daily start times and consistent arrival across multi-day projects, with crews showing up as expected each morning throughout longer renovations. JRT Pro Painters LLC customers specifically call out owner Brayan's crew for putting in full eight- to nine-hour workdays, arriving as scheduled and maintaining that pace across multi-day projects. Interior Finishing NYC reviews reflect similar scheduling reliability, with customers noting Dorian arrives when he says he will and often completes work faster than expected. Late crews and rescheduling issues are nearly absent from the feedback across this market.

"They showed up punctually, cleaned up and left. Level of experience showed in their work incredible. Such a smooth experience, will use them again in 2025." - Mark Pfisterer, Google Review

"They were at my house for 2 1/2 days, they arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day. The end result is amazing." - Sher, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Prep work and cleanup are two of the most telling indicators of a quality paint job, and customers writing about painters serving Nesconset, NY comment on both with notable specificity. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC reviewers mention crews leaving work areas clean at the end of each day, with surrounding plantings and hardscaping left undisturbed after power washing projects. Interior Finishing NYC earns prep work praise for specialty finish applications - customers describe careful surface preparation, priming, and moisture management before decorative work begins, which matters especially for delicate materials like wallpaper and Roman clay on pre-war walls. Big Expert Painting LLC reviews include specific cleanup details - one reviewer noted that Denis swept up leaves the crew tracked in during a job, a detail that prompted specific mention and speaks to the overall standard of care on-site.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns some of the most detailed cleanup feedback in this market - reviewers describe furniture carefully moved and covered, floors fully protected, and every surface cleaned up at the close of each workday throughout multi-day projects. JRT Pro Painters LLC draws consistent prep work praise - customers note the crew filled holes, sanded, primed, and skim coated before paint went on. One reviewer specifically called out the team for identifying and repairing drywall issues left by a prior contractor before even starting the painting scope. Todd's Painting customers describe clean work areas and organized crews, with the majority of reviews noting the job site was left tidy at each day's end.

"Bryan and his partner did a wonderful job repairing my ceiling damage from a roof leak. Replaced sheet rock and insulation, spackle, and painted the entire ceiling to perfection. You can't tell at all." - Louise Trinche, Google Review

"The crew arrived every day on time and were always very professional and patient. They worked with and around my furniture and belongings to ensure everything was protected." - Doreen Conte, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Pricing feedback for painting contractors serving Nesconset, NY generally points toward fair value rather than the lowest possible cost, and that distinction matters when looking at the review record. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC reviewers describe pricing as reasonable given the level of care and quality they received, with several noting they have used Todd for years without feeling they overpaid. Big Expert Painting LLC generates consistent feedback about competitive estimates - several reviewers describe Denis's pricing as fair and note the finished work exceeded what they expected for the cost. Interior Finishing NYC earns pricing praise in the specialty context, with customers noting Dorian's rates were more affordable than the other painters they called, even for highly skilled decorative finish work requiring unique expertise.

Todd's Painting reviews reflect satisfaction with estimate accuracy - customers note the final invoice matched the quote, and several mention finding the pricing so reasonable that they expanded their scope mid-project. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge draws pricing praise from customers who gathered multiple bids before choosing - reviewers describe picking Precision because the quote was competitive despite the project's complexity. JRT Pro Painters LLC includes a candid note from one reviewer who described the pricing as "pricey" but immediately followed with "you get what you pay for," which captures the broader market sentiment: these companies are not the cheapest options on Long Island, but customers consistently feel the quality justifies the investment.

"Excellent quality work for a fair price. Courteous workers and clean job site. Responsive owner and any unanticipated problems are handled properly and with the customer's best interest in mind." - Mark Rosenbloom, Google Review

"They gave me a very good price on a complicated job that most painters will not take. The men are fast and good. Now gave them my outside of house to paint." - Paul Pappas, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

One of the clearest patterns across the review record for painting companies serving Nesconset, NY is the prevalence of repeat customers. These are not one-time reviewers - many describe coming back for a second, third, or fourth project with the same company, sometimes over spans of a decade or more. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC generates some of the strongest repeat business signals in this market, with customers returning year after year for power washing and painting across multiple properties. One reviewer described reaching out specifically for gutter cleaning after foot surgery because she had used Todd's services before and trusted him to follow through on short notice. Big Expert Painting LLC reviews tell a similar story: one customer has relied on owner Denis for over seven years, starting with small porch column work and growing to full interior repaints. Another reviewer hired the crew for three rooms, was satisfied enough to immediately book two more, and planned to call again.

Todd's Painting has customers who have worked with the company for over 30 years. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge shows clear repeat patterns too - one family was on their third project at the time of their review and noted the team shares useful ideas across visits to improve each result. JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan has painted entire homes one room at a time over multiple years with several clients, including one who started in 2021 and kept returning through a full whole-home project. Interior Finishing NYC has clients who have worked with Dorian for over 10 years across multiple residential and commercial projects. Across this market, the pattern is consistent: customers who use these companies once tend to plan their next project before the current one is finished.

"Todd is extremely reliable and does a great job with all projects. We have been using him for several years now and never disappoints in quality and communication as well. Will keep going back year after year." - Joanna Castagnaro, Google Review

"This is the 3rd time we've used Precision Painting in our home. They share beneficial ideas too so that the results are far and above what I expected." - R Santos, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp