7 Best Painters Near Selden, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Selden, NY sits in the heart of central Suffolk County, and homeowners here have access to a strong group of painting contractors who have collectively earned hundreds of five-star reviews. The painters serving this area stand out for personal owner involvement, thorough prep processes, and the kind of follow-through that turns one-time customers into long-term clients. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, the top-rated contractors in Selden, NY included the following companies.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC leads the list with a Chooz Score of 89.0%, the highest among painters serving Selden, NY. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, backed by equally strong marks on Yelp and Angi. Owner Todd Rumfola runs a crew-based operation where team members Rich, Jerry, and Alex appear across dozens of reviews by name - a consistent indicator of stable staffing and quality control. Several customers describe leaving for errands or heading out of town while the crew worked, comfortable enough not to stay home and supervise. That level of trust is not common for a service business. With over 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County, South Bay holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License verified active through 2027 and lead-safe certification for older homes. If you're looking for a single team that can handle both interior painting and exterior power washing, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC is a strong starting point.

• Named crew members Rich, Jerry, and Alex appear consistently across reviews, suggesting low staff turnover and reliable team quality from project to project.
• Owner Todd personally responds to every Google review and handles estimates directly, staying involved from first contact through project completion.
• Customers frequently return for repeat projects covering everything from power washing and gutter cleaning to multi-room interior painting.

"Rich and Jerry did incredible! They turned our house into a beautiful home. The attention to detail, trust, professionalism was something you can't find these days. We would 1000% percent recommend Todd and South Bay." - John P., Google Review

For homeowners with a specialty or decorative finish project that other contractors won't take on, Interior Finishing NYC brings a different skill set entirely. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and his company has built its reputation around high-end techniques - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic applications, and wallpaper installation across challenging surfaces. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. With over 22 years in business since founding in 2003, they back all projects with a three-year workmanship warranty. Multiple reviewers mention that other painters turned down their projects before Dorian accepted and delivered results that matched the inspiration photos. If you're dealing with pre-war details, non-standard surfaces, or a finish that requires an artist's eye rather than a standard brush, Interior Finishing NYC is worth calling first.

• Specialized in decorative finishes including limewash, Venetian plaster, Roman clay, and gilding - skills that go beyond what most local painters offer.
• Three-year workmanship warranty on all projects, with a documented touch-up process.
• Dorian personally handles estimates and is on site for the vast majority of projects, often alongside a consistent crew of Jose, Amir, Marvin, and Joe.
• Reviews include ceiling gilding in Times Square, grasscloth on difficult walls, and pre-war woodwork restoration - projects others declined to bid.

"Dori was prompt and very professional. His Venetian plaster work on my kitchen walls are unbelievable. I always get compliments from our guests!" - Charlie V., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Selden, NY, CRD Painting Inc out of Yaphank earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 90 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, plus a matching 5.0 stars on Yelp. What stands out in this company's review pattern is the depth of customer relationships - multiple reviewers document 10 to 15 years of continued work with owner Camilo, and one customer has hired CRD across five different homes and an office. With over 8 years in business and a Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License active through 2027, their track record is built on genuine referrals and returning clients. Reviewers consistently highlight Camilo's precision on fine interior elements - trim, moldings, wainscoting, and spindles - areas where less careful painters tend to rush. Other trades, including a 60-year Long Island drywall company, route their own customers to CRD specifically for painting work.

• Multiple reviewers cite 10 to 15-year relationships with owner Camilo, and one customer has hired the company across five different properties.
• Detail work on trim, moldings, spindles, and wainscoting receives consistent mention throughout reviews.
• Referred by other trades - a 60-year Long Island drywall company directs their clients to CRD for painted finishes.

"CRD has now painted two homes for me and I'd gladly use them again. Great communication and attention to detail was greatly appreciated. They did really detailed work on our moldings and wainscoting." - John A., Google Review

A hands-on owner-led operation, Big Expert Painting LLC out of Amityville earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, with consistent marks on Yelp as well. Owner Denis personally handles every estimate, works alongside his crew on projects, and - based on multiple reviews - follows up weeks or months after job completion to confirm satisfaction. The company holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification, making them a strong choice for pre-1978 homes. The pattern across reviews is scope expansion: customers who hire Denis for two or three rooms come back to book additional spaces. If you want a team that treats the relationship as ongoing rather than transactional, Big Expert Painting LLC fits that profile.

• Owner Denis personally handles estimates, often responding to quote requests the same day including weekends.
• Customers consistently expand initial scopes - hiring for a few rooms and returning for whole-home work across multiple visits.
• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified for work on pre-1978 homes, an important credential in older Suffolk County neighborhoods.
• Post-project follow-up calls documented in multiple reviews - an uncommon practice that customers consistently highlight.

"Denis and his team did an amazing job in my home. Originally I hired him for a few rooms and I was so pleased I asked him to return to do other jobs. His team was professional, clean, timely, and excellent quality." - Jackie H., Google Review

With over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, Todd's Painting out of Centereach earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% and maintains strong marks across Google, Facebook, and Yelp. Long-term loyalty runs through the reviews here in a way that's unusual even for well-rated contractors - one customer has used Todd's Painting for over 30 years across multiple properties, and others describe choosing Todd for a new home after using him in a previous one. Cabinet painting stands out as a specialty: Darlene Romashko describes it as Todd's personal focus area, with results she calls a "true master of his craft." Reviews also cover deck staining, fence painting, power washing, and whole-home interiors - a broader service range than most single painters offer. If you're in the Selden area and want one reliable call for a range of exterior and interior projects, Todd's Painting covers more ground than most.

• Cabinet painting repeatedly highlighted as a specialty, with reviewers describing results comparable to full cabinet replacement at a fraction of the cost.
• Service range extends beyond standard painting to include power washing, deck staining, fence painting, and pool deck work.
• Long-term loyalty is a defining pattern - multiple reviewers reference decades-long relationships, not just a single positive experience.

"Start to finish, Todd's painting was a great decision! Communication was prompt and concise. Work was completed as described. Todd and his crew are professional. They left the area clean at the end of each day and returned as promised, on time." - Donna D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Quality of work is the most consistent thread across reviews for contractors serving Selden, NY. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC reviewers regularly describe results that stand up over time, with specific mention of prep work, smooth finishes, and clean lines that distinguish professional work from a quick coat. CRD Painting Inc earns particular praise for fine interior detail work - moldings, wainscoting, and spiral staircase spindles appear across multiple reviews, with customers noting that owner Camilo approaches those elements with precision that goes beyond the walls. Several customers describe receiving more compliments on their finished rooms than expected, crediting the quality to careful surface preparation before paint even went on.

Decorative finishes represent a separate tier of craftsmanship, and Interior Finishing NYC handles this category across the area. Owner Dorian Golemi's fine arts background shows in how reviewers describe his output - limewash, Venetian plaster, and Roman clay applications that customers say match their inspiration photos and consistently draw compliments from guests. Big Expert Painting LLC and Todd's Painting also draw strong quality mentions for standard interior and exterior work, with reviewers pointing to coverage, sheen consistency, and clean paint lines as evidence of careful technique. Cabinet painting in particular comes up as a standout skill at Todd's, where several reviewers describe results comparable to full cabinet replacement at a much lower cost.

"We hired Dorian and his team to paint our living room and guest bedroom in lime wash paint. His team was professional, skilled, clean, and incredibly fast. They painted both rooms in a single day, and the results are amazing. We couldn't be happier." - Matt B., Google Review"CRD has now painted two homes for me and I'd gladly use them again. Great communication and attention to detail was greatly appreciated. They did really detailed work on our moldings and wainscoting." - John A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Professionalism and clear communication are consistent strengths across the top-rated painters in Selden, NY. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC owner Todd Rumfola responds personally to every Google review and handles estimates directly, giving customers a direct line to the decision-maker from the start. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis is known for picking up calls directly and frequently responding to quote requests the same day, including on weekends. Reviewers describe him walking through the scope of work in detail before starting and checking in throughout the project. Both companies reflect a clear pattern: owner involvement and communication quality tend to go hand in hand.

CRD Painting Inc and JRT Pro Painters LLC also earn high marks for responsiveness throughout their reviews. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas of JRT Pro is described as easy to contact and quick to reply, with one reviewer noting he worked around a medical delay without issue. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi offers estimates over phone or video call to save customers time, and reviews consistently describe him as communicative and accessible even for complex specialty projects. Todd's Painting is called out for prompt communication from first contact through job completion. For homeowners who value direct access and clear explanations of the work being done, the top contractors serving Selden, NY generally deliver on that front.

"Owner, Dorian, was tremendous to work with remotely for repainting corporate office. Communicative, effective and customer-service oriented - I'd happily use Dorian and Interior Finishing NYC again!" - K. Fowler, Google Review"Bryan at JRT Painters was easy to work with, cleaned up each day, very professional and a pleasure to do business with. The paint jobs he did in my home were terrific! I used him twice and would not hesitate to call him back." - Miriam R., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing observations across reviews for contractors serving Selden, NY center on value rather than lowest cost. Reviewers consistently describe prices as fair and reasonable rather than cheap, with the emphasis on getting what they paid for. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC receives consistent mentions of reasonable pricing alongside quality output, with Michele Maratea specifically noting prices as reasonable while describing the work as exceptional. CRD Painting Inc earns similar marks, with multiple reviewers calling prices fair while ranking Camilo among the best painters on Long Island. The pattern suggests a market where contractors with the best reviews charge fairly rather than cheaply - and customers who chose on value rather than the lowest bid describe fewer surprises.

Big Expert Painting LLC is described as competitively priced across reviews, with Jackie Hernandez calling out pricing alongside quality and professionalism. JRT Pro Painters LLC takes an interesting position - reviewer Kristen Drapesa acknowledges the company is priced above some alternatives but follows immediately with an explanation of why she keeps returning: consistent quality across multiple jobs. Todd's Painting comes up with "awesome" pricing mentioned specifically by Savannah Southard, a repeat customer. If you're comparing estimates across painters in the Selden, NY area, the top-rated contractors generally offer pricing that aligns with the quality of the finished work, with few reports of hidden costs or unexpected charges.

"Very professional. The price was fair. And I couldn't believe how fast everything was done. Not only that but he swept up the leaves he tracked in. Who does that now a days? No one." - Stafi T., Google Review"He is pricey, but they do a great job always." - Kristen D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

On-time arrival and schedule reliability appear throughout reviews for the top painters in Selden, NY. Todd's Painting receives specific praise for speed and turnaround - several reviewers describe estimates completed one day and projects finished the next, including one full multi-room job wrapped up before 5pm the same day work started. JRT Pro Painters LLC is consistently described as arriving at scheduled times and putting in full eight to nine hour work days. Martin Moran and Sher each highlight the crew's punctual arrivals and full work days as key parts of what made their projects run smoothly. The pattern suggests a crew that treats scheduled start times as a firm commitment rather than an estimate.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC and CRD Painting Inc also draw reliable scheduling reviews, with customers noting arrivals that matched the quoted times and project timelines that held close to what was discussed upfront. Big Expert Painting LLC earns specific note for keeping an exterior project on schedule even through the heat of July - not a given for outdoor work in summer. For homeowners coordinating painting around other contractors, family schedules, or firm deadlines, the top-rated painters in Selden, NY generally demonstrate the kind of reliability that makes project management easier rather than harder.

"They showed up punctually, cleaned up and left. Level of experience showed in their work incredible. Such a smooth experience, will use them again in 2025." - Mark P., Google Review"They arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanup are areas where the top-rated painters in Selden, NY consistently distinguish themselves. JRT Pro Painters LLC receives specific mention of thorough prep across reviews - hole filling, sanding, priming, skim coating, and full protection of furniture and floors before paint goes on. One reviewer notes that the JRT crew identified and repaired drywall nail pops left by a prior contractor before starting the paint work - going beyond the original scope without being asked. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC earns similar cleanup praise, with Susan Birk noting that painter Jerry kept everything clean throughout her co-op project and left the area spotless on the way out.

CRD Painting Inc draws repeated cleanup mentions - Penny Sichel specifically noted that the crew cleaned up after each individual room they completed, not just at the end of the job as a whole. Big Expert Painting LLC reviews describe furniture protection, floor covering, and dust control as standard parts of the process. Stafi Thukral's review stands out for an unexpected detail: Denis swept up leaves his crew had tracked in on the way out - the kind of extra step that appears in reviews precisely because it's rare. For homeowners who want a clean job site throughout the project rather than just at the end, the contractors in this group treat cleanup as part of the work rather than an afterthought.

"They spackled and skimmed the walls, making them look new. They arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review"They were at my house for 2 1/2 days, they arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Several of the top-rated painters serving Selden, NY handle specialty work that goes well beyond a standard coat of paint. Interior Finishing NYC represents the most specialized end of the market, with owner Dorian Golemi trained in decorative techniques including limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic finishes, gilding, and wallpaper installation across complex surfaces. His company has handled ceiling gilding in Times Square, grasscloth on challenging walls, and pre-war woodwork restoration - projects that most local contractors won't bid at all. A three-year warranty on all work reflects the confidence that comes with genuine specialty expertise. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC offers exterior power washing alongside painting, and reviews describe Todd's crew handling gutter cleaning and deck work as well.

Todd's Painting is frequently called on for cabinet painting - a specialty Darlene Romashko describes as Todd's personal focus area - along with deck staining, fence painting, and pool deck work. Big Expert Painting LLC handles drywall repair, crown molding installation, and door and trim work in addition to standard painting, making them a useful call when a project involves more than just walls. JRT Pro Painters LLC also handles drywall repair and interior door and molding replacement, with Jackie S. describing a room refresh that included completely replaced interior doors and trim alongside fresh paint. For homeowners whose project falls outside the standard scope, the top contractors in Selden, NY cover a broader range of services than the label "painter" might suggest.

"Bryan and his team just finished painting our kitchen cabinets and I can't believe how good they look. Absolute kitchen make over for so much less than replacing cabinets in very good condition." - Michael S. M., Google Review"I needed someone to do wallpaper hanging, some drywall repair and gilding in my home. It was hard to find a contractor that does all of the services we needed, especially gilding contractor in NYC. Luckily we found Dorian." - Kha A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google