8 Best Painters Near Port Jefferson Station, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Port Jefferson Station, NY have access to a strong group of reviewed painting contractors - from specialists in decorative finishes to crews known for speed, careful prep, and long-term customer loyalty. The companies below earned the highest Chooz Scores among painters serving the area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Interior Finishing NYC had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.3%. Owner Dorian Golemi trained at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, specializing in work most painters won't attempt - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, ceiling gilding, and complex wallpaper installations. Several reviewers describe projects other contractors declined before Dorian accepted and delivered results. With over 22 years in business since 2003, the company backs projects with a three-year workmanship warranty.

• Dorian works alongside his crew on every project and is referenced by name across the large majority of reviews, from wallpaper installs to pre-war plaster restoration
• Specialty wallcovering projects include grasscloth, cork, vinyl, and large-format murals, with consistent praise for seamless pattern matching

"His knowledge of painting and specialty finishes is second-to-none. Will definitely be enlisting their services again, and would highly recommend." - Robert Sternheim, Google Review

If you need wallcoverings, Venetian plaster, or ceiling gilding, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong fit for homeowners seeking specialty decorative work.

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for CRD Painting Inc, which earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 90 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo has been serving Long Island homeowners for over 8 years, and several customers document a decade or more of returning work. Careful prep is a consistent theme - floors covered before paint goes on, furniture protected, and cleanup that leaves rooms undisturbed. The company holds Suffolk County HIC License H-59404, verified active through 2027.

• Work spans interior and exterior painting, staining, and detailed surfaces like spiral staircase spindles and architectural molding
• Customers describe routinely referring family and friends to CRD, with those referrals returning their own strong reviews across platforms

"I have been a client for many years now. They are always professional, neat, are master painters and always complete projects in a timely manner." - Michael Moore, Google Review

CRD Painting Inc is a good fit for homeowners who want a contractor they can return to across multiple projects with confidence in consistent results.

For homeowners who want the owner on the job site, Big Expert Painting LLC fills that role. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis handles every estimate personally, responds the same day to quote requests, and holds both a Suffolk County HIC License (HI-68388) and an EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes.

• Multiple customers extended their initial project mid-job after seeing the quality of the first phase, adding rooms or additional services on the spot
• Denis has maintained working relationships with some customers for over 7 years, and the crew handles everything from interior painting to deck staining, power washing, and molding installation

"Originally I hired him for a few rooms and I was so pleased I asked him to return to do other jobs. His team was professional, clean, timely, and excellent quality." - Jackie Hernandez, Google Review

Big Expert Painting LLC is a good fit for older properties or multi-phase projects where you want a hands-on owner engaged throughout.

With loyal customers stretching back decades, Todd's Painting has built one of the stronger followings among Suffolk County painters. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Cabinet painting is a signature service - Todd removes door fronts and drawer faces so customers don't need to empty their cabinets, delivering a smooth spray finish. Color guidance also appears across reviews, with several homeowners noting Todd's suggestions improved the final result.

• Projects consistently finish faster than expected - multiple reviewers describe full rooms, including spackle, ceiling, and trim, completed in a single day
• Exterior work, fence and shed painting, and deck staining complement a full range of interior services

"2nd time using Todd's and they did not disappoint. ALWAYS on time, ready to go, and carry themselves professionally. The work area was left spotless after painting and the walls were crisp and even." - Robert Villano, Google Review

Todd's Painting is a good fit for homeowners who need fast results without sacrificing quality - particularly for cabinet refreshes or exterior projects.

Also serving Port Jefferson Station, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings structured project management alongside consistent crews whose names appear across dozens of unrelated reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus BBB accreditation since 2015 and 100% recommended on Facebook. With over 18 years in business, they hold a Suffolk County HIC License (HI-73176) active through January 2028.

• Project managers provide status updates at each stage - multiple customers note they always knew exactly where the crew was in the process
• Crews handle multi-day renovations while leaving the home livable each evening, with several homeowners trusting them with a house key for unsupervised work

"From the estimate to job completion, Brendan was there. Communication was frequent and clear. I always knew what point they were at, and they did a magnificent job on my floors and walls." - Theresa Westergard, Google Review

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is a good fit for larger or multi-room projects where you want structured communication, crew consistency, and a long local track record.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Quality of finished work is the most frequently cited theme in reviews of painting contractors serving Port Jefferson Station, NY. Customers across the top-rated companies describe results that exceed their initial expectations - whether the project involves standard interior rooms, detailed trim, or specialty decorative finishes. Interior Finishing NYC draws particular attention for its specialty work, with customers describing Venetian plaster and limewash finishes that prompt compliments from visitors who don't realize the surface was painted, and wallpaper pattern matching that holds up to close inspection on large-format murals. Todd's Painting earns strong quality marks specifically on cabinets - reviewers describe spray-finish results that make old kitchens look factory-new.

"Made our 100 year old house look brand new! His team was fast, reliable, and clean." - Rachel Ulrich, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

Attention to detail signals quality craftsmanship at CRD Painting Inc and Big Expert Painting LLC as well. CRD customers describe Camilo's crew repairing cathedral ceiling damage, cracked plaster, and drywall imperfections with results described as better than the original surface. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, customers praise full skim coating on damaged walls before final paint goes on - with results described as looking completely replaced rather than patched and painted over.

"Owner Camilo and his team did an amazing job on our Sag Harbor home! They are true professionals with exacting attention to details. We've used them for all our painting needs and will continue to." - Gloria Gali, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Repeat business and long-term loyalty appear throughout the reviews of painting contractors serving Port Jefferson Station, NY. Across the top-rated companies on Chooz Painters, it's common to find customers who have used the same painter for years - and in some cases, decades - returning for room after room and home after home. CRD Painting Inc shows the most concentrated loyalty pattern, with several customers documenting relationships spanning 10 to 15 years. The same dynamic shows up at Big Expert Painting LLC, where customers have worked with Denis for over 7 years across a wide range of project types, and at Todd's Painting, where reviewers describe calling on Todd across 30 years and multiple properties.

"I've used C.R.D. Painting Inc. (Camilo) twice since my wife and I purchased our home in 2020. Both interactions were flawless - reliable service, fair pricing, and quality work. I sincerely and wholeheartedly recommend him and his company." - Larry Goodman, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

The loyalty pattern is also strong at JRT Pro Painters LLC and Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge. JRT customers describe returning for second, third, and fourth projects with owner Brayan, often citing consistent prep quality as the reason. One reviewer first hired JRT in 2021 under a tight deadline, then kept coming back until Brayan had painted her entire house over multiple years. At Precision Painting Plus, satisfied customers frequently refer family members, with those referrals returning their own strong reviews - a word-of-mouth cycle that reflects consistent results across a long period of service.

"Brayan has officially painted my whole house! I was first recommended JRT in 2021 when I had an impossible task of being ready for Thanksgiving. Brayan and his coworker are neat, extremely punctual, precise and perfectionist at what they work on." - Christina Shiwbalak, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Professionalism and clear communication are highlighted consistently across reviews of painters serving Port Jefferson Station, NY. What customers describe goes beyond showing up and completing the work - it includes responsive estimates, owners who stay personally involved, and crews that communicate clearly on the job. At Interior Finishing NYC, owner Dorian Golemi responds to virtually every Google review with personalized replies, and provides quotes over phone or video call when an in-person visit isn't feasible. At Big Expert Painting LLC, customers describe Denis answering calls directly and responding to estimate requests the same day, including weekends - a standard that appears across multiple unrelated reviews.

"Excellent communication, professional services." - Bryan Serrano, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the project management structure specifically earns praise for communication - reviewers describe knowing exactly where the crew was in the process at any given time, with project managers checking in at each stage of work. At CRD Painting Inc, Camilo's courteous approach is reflected in a review describing him returning to repaint a wall on short notice when a homeowner wasn't happy with a color choice, ahead of flooring installation the following day. Across Todd's Painting reviews, customers describe a low-friction experience from first call to final walkthrough.

"The communication regarding quotes and scheduling was clear cut and very impressive. The finished product looks amazing, exactly what we wanted!" - Tom DiEmidio, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Timeliness is a consistent strength across the top-rated painting contractors serving Port Jefferson Station, NY. Reviews describe crews arriving on schedule, completing work within promised timelines, and in several cases finishing faster than the homeowner anticipated. At Todd's Painting, fast turnarounds stand out - customers describe receiving an estimate on one day, having the crew arrive the next morning, and completing a multi-room project well before evening. Several reviewers had full rooms including spackle, ceiling, walls, and trim completed in a single day. Big Expert Painting LLC earns similar feedback, with Denis and his crew described as prompt and on-schedule across projects of varying size.

"Todd worked with our schedule and most importantly, his crew showed up when expected and completed the job in a timely manner. It came out great and I would definitely use him again." - JPI, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, project managers set clear timelines from the outset, and crews hit them consistently. One reviewer noted a job quoted at four to five days wrapped up exactly on time across a large full-home repaint. JRT Pro Painters LLC earns praise for full-day commitment throughout each project - customers describe crews arriving as scheduled and working eight to nine hour days from start to finish, with cleanup completed at the end of every session. At CRD Painting Inc, reliable scheduling is a recurring reason customers describe recommending Camilo to family and friends.

"They were at my house for 2.5 days, they arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Cleanup habits and prep quality are among the most common reasons homeowners in Port Jefferson Station, NY describe being impressed enough to leave a review. At CRD Painting Inc, customers describe floors fully covered before work begins, furniture protected throughout, and rooms left undisturbed at the end of each day. At JRT Pro Painters LLC, hole filling, sanding, priming, and skim coating appear consistently as standard steps before paint is applied - and one reviewer noted the crew identified and repaired drywall issues left by a prior contractor before starting their own scope of work, going well beyond what was originally agreed.

"They exhibited exceptional discipline and care in their painting. They thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up when they were finished. Their work was excellent." - Janette Payne, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, crews handle multi-day projects while leaving the home livable each evening - surfaces swept, furniture repositioned, and spaces fully functional. Several homeowners trusted the team with a house key for extended renovations and described the level of care throughout as well-earned. At Big Expert Painting LLC, Denis's crew draws comments that go beyond the job scope - one reviewer noted he swept up leaves tracked in during the project, a detail nobody asked him to address. Todd's Painting cabinet jobs receive specific praise for careful masking of surrounding countertops and appliances, leaving no overspray behind.

"C.R.D Painting Inc did a spectacular job painting in my house. Very professional and most importantly cleaned up after every room they did." - Penny Sichel, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Value and pricing come up consistently in reviews of painting contractors serving Port Jefferson Station, NY, with customers across multiple companies describing estimates as fair, competitive, or better than expected relative to other quotes they received. Big Expert Painting LLC earns frequent mentions for competitive pricing alongside strong quality - customers describe estimates that came in at a reasonable level without any reduction in the time, care, or materials applied. At CRD Painting Inc, fair pricing is part of a broader value package that includes quality prep, reliable scheduling, and an owner who communicates clearly. Several reviewers note they gathered multiple quotes before selecting Camilo, with his combination of track record and price making the decision easy.

"Denis and his crew painted our home. It was a clean, fast job. I trust him to do more work for us in the future." - Linda Hammond, Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, customers describe competitive estimates even for jobs other painters declined. One reviewer gathered three separate quotes and described Precision as by far the most reasonably priced. Todd's Painting receives similar feedback on cabinet jobs - customers note the quality of the spray finish and careful cleanup would likely have cost significantly more elsewhere. At Interior Finishing NYC, several customers describe Dorian's pricing as fair given the specialized nature of his decorative work, with one reviewer noting he came in more affordable than other painters contacted despite the complexity of the project. JRT Pro Painters LLC customers describe estimates that landed in the middle of the range when gathering multiple quotes - and results well above what they expected for the price paid.

"Of all the price quotes we received, theirs was right in the middle. We definitely got high value for the price we paid." - Kent Corso, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook