The Port Jefferson, NY area serves homeowners with a wide variety of painting needs - from older colonial-style homes inland to coastal properties that see real weather exposure every season. The top-rated painting contractors serving this part of Suffolk County stand out for hands-on owner involvement, specialty skills, and the kind of consistent results that keep customers calling back. Here is a look at the highest-rated names on Chooz Painters, ranked by their Chooz Score.
Interior Finishing NYC leads the rankings with a Chooz Score of 87.3%. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and has built a specialty practice around decorative finishes that most painting contractors won't attempt - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, and metallic applications. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. With over 22 years in business, Dorian also provides a three-year workmanship warranty. If you're looking for a specialty decorative finish like limewash or Roman clay in the Port Jefferson, NY area, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong first call.
What comes through clearly across the reviews is how often customers expand their projects after seeing the initial results - someone hiring for a nursery and ending up adding the powder room, or starting with one accent wall and returning for the full apartment. Dorian personally handles estimates and is described in review after review as physically working on every project alongside his crew. Team members Jose and Amir appear across multiple customer accounts on unrelated jobs.
- Multiple customers describe Dorian taking on projects that other contractors had already declined, including decorative plaster touch-ups and color-matching for damaged faux-finish walls.
- Commercial work appears alongside residential - corporate offices, retail spaces, and a gilded ceiling in Times Square - suggesting experience across project types beyond the typical residential painter.
- Customers consistently describe him as accurate and transparent on pricing, with final costs matching the original quote.
"Dorian and his team did an incredible job doing lime-wash finish at our business on short notice. The lime-wash finish came out much better than we expected. They are patient, professional and obsessed with doing it right." - Lenny Blake, Google Review
While Interior Finishing NYC is built around specialty decorative work, C.R.D Painting Inc has made its name on whole-home reliability - the kind that keeps customers calling Camilo back for a decade or more at a stretch. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 90 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-59404 with over 8 years in business. If you're looking for a trusted Long Island painter for a full interior or exterior project, C.R.D Painting Inc is worth a look.
Several customers describe the same experience: they hired Camilo once for a smaller project and gradually had him paint every room in the house. What sets the work apart based on review patterns is the finishing detail included beyond the paint itself - caulking, spackling, staining wood surfaces, and addressing existing wall damage before anything goes on. Sarah Clark notes they've painted every room in her house over two years, including her wooden front porch deck. Camilo also appears regularly as a resource for color advice, offering input on shade selection rather than just executing whatever is asked.
- Karen Rauseo's review describes Camilo returning the very next day to repaint a color she wasn't happy with - before new flooring went in - without being asked twice.
- A Long Island drywall company with over 60 years in business refers their builders and customers to CRD, a trade endorsement that carries real weight.
- Reviews describe projects running top-to-bottom: interior rooms, exterior surfaces, wooden beams, front doors, and spiral staircase spindles - all in the same customer relationship.
"From start to finish, working with C.R.D Painting Inc. was an exceptional experience. Their precision and attention to detail are truly unmatched - every line, edge, and finish was flawless. Beyond the incredible quality of their work, their kindness and professionalism made the entire process enjoyable." - Tori Sutera, Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell a similar story for Big Expert Painting LLC, based in Amityville with a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 130 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis Erazo holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388 and an EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification - especially relevant for older Long Island homes built before 1978. If you're looking for a versatile contractor who can handle painting alongside drywall, flooring, and light renovation work in one trip, Big Expert Painting LLC is a good fit.
What stands out across the reviews is the scope expansion: customers hire Denis for one project and immediately book another. Anthony Dilillo describes hiring the crew for ceiling skim coating and painting, then booking cabinet work the same day after seeing the quality. Denis personally handles estimates and is described as responsive on weekends and available for same-day smaller jobs. The crew - including Michael, Pedro, Eric, and Joshua - appear by name across separate customer accounts on different projects.
- Reviews span an unusually wide range: pool painting, crown molding installation, marble flooring, sheetrock, chimney painting, exterior power washing, and deck work - broader than a typical painting contractor.
- Power washing and exterior prep work appear alongside interior painting, making this a practical choice for homeowners who want to address multiple exterior needs in one visit.
- Leonard Post's review describes the team painting the entire interior of a new home and installing crown molding in the same engagement - a scope that reflects real versatility.
"BigExpert Painting exceeded all my expectations! They were incredibly punctual, arriving right on time every day, which made the entire process seamless. Their reliability was unmatched - they stayed true to their word and delivered exactly what they promised." - Melva M. Miller, Google Review
For homeowners looking for a proven local name with deep community roots, Todd's Painting, based in Centereach, earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, with consistent feedback across Google, Facebook, and Yelp. Todd handles everything from cabinet painting to pool deck staining to full exterior repaints. If you want a direct, experienced painter who will weigh in on color choices and turn projects around quickly, Todd's Painting is a solid option in the Port Jefferson, NY area.
A pattern that repeats across the reviews is Todd's willingness to call out a bad color decision before starting. Karen Fox describes him recommending against her son's too-bright color choice and how grateful she was for the pushback - a small detail that reflects genuine investment in the result. Todd also takes on commercial work: painting the interior of a congregation's gallery with very high ceilings, an animal hospital exterior, and power washing for commercial properties alongside residential jobs.
- Cabinet painting is called out repeatedly as a specialty, with customers praising the prep work and finish quality as matching or exceeding what they had seen from other painters.
- Eileen Crowley describes Todd sending someone the next day to address a slight issue with a molding after the job was done - the kind of follow-through that generates repeat business over decades.
- Projects span a wide range: chain-link fence painting, vinyl shed refresh, pool deck staining, and a nearly 100-year-old home exterior brought back to looking new.
"Todd and his crew are great! They're not only professional but also friendly, making every experience a pleasure. They really care about getting every detail just right, which is why their work turns out fantastic every single time." - S. Ferraro, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Port Jefferson, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earned a Chooz Score of 84.8%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook. They carry an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, accredited since 2015, and have over 18 years in business. If you're managing a larger renovation and want a company with structured project management, a dedicated office team, and consistent crew assignments, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is worth considering.
What sets this company apart from the others on this list is its organizational structure. Jim Patti's review describes coordinating an entire home repaint while living out of state - a level of remote trust that requires solid communication from project start to finish. Territory manager David Maloney, supervisors Jason Eng and Brendan, office manager Trish Gates, and painters Carlos, Jose, Amilcar, Fernando, and Hernando appear by name across two full years of reviews from separate, unrelated customers - showing consistent staffing rather than a rotating door of different faces.
- Customers describe crews arriving on time each day, cleaning up every evening, and leaving the home fully livable throughout multi-day projects - including a six-day whole-home renovation.
- Brandi Brochu notes the team went beyond the scoped work to address imperfections in walls, checking in with her before moving from room to room.
- R Santos's review of their third engagement with Precision describes the team offering design input that pushed results beyond what the customer originally imagined.
"Precision Painting Plus exceeded my expectations! I hired them to paint two rooms, ceilings, and all of the doors and trim in my house. They handled everything with care and went above and beyond to fix imperfections in my walls. They also made sure everything was done to the highest quality." - Brandi Brochu, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
