3 Best Painters Near Setauket, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The Setauket, NY area draws contractors from across Suffolk County, and several have built strong reputations backed by hundreds of reviews on multiple platforms. Here are the top performers based on Chooz Score rankings.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Mr Star Painting Corp had over 235 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Angi, earning a Chooz Score of 87.3%. With over 10 years in business, the company handles work beyond standard repaints - skim coating, sheetrock, floor epoxy, and commercial renovations all appear across the reviews. Owners Ricardo and Mario make personal mid-project visits to confirm quality. A good fit for homeowners who want a company that stays engaged from estimate through final walkthrough.

• Owners Ricardo and Mario personally check in mid-project to confirm quality and address any concerns.
• Scope extends beyond paint - skim coating, sheetrock, and floor epoxy appear in the reviews alongside commercial chapel work.

"I don't normally give reviews, but Mr Star Painting deserves to be acknowledged. Ricardo and Mario were professional, knowledgeable, and always kept me updated through the whole process." - Patricia L., Google Review

A hands-on owner defines the experience at Big Expert Painting LLC, where owner Denis is one of the most consistently named people in Long Island painting reviews. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 130 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp, earning a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The company holds an EPA Lead-Safe Certification and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License active through 2027. Multi-year customer relationships and fair pricing run throughout the reviews - a good fit if you want one contractor you can rely on long-term.

• EPA Lead-Safe certified for pre-1978 homes, an important credential for Long Island's older housing stock.
• Customers consistently describe the estimate as coming in more reasonable than expected, without upselling.

"I've known Dennis for over 7 years now. He's done a number of jobs for me from as small as outside columns to the entire interior of my house. Whatever he does he does with expertise." - Michael Curley, Google Review

With over 25 years in business, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has built a following that develops over decades. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 245 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, 4.8 stars on Yelp with over 25 Yelp reviews, and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 80 reviews, earning a Chooz Score of 85.7%. Owner Sal is consistently described as reachable, honest about costs, and involved in each project. Work in the reviews covers exterior repaints, kitchen cabinets, skim coating, wallpaper, and basement floors - a good fit for homeowners who want one company to call back year after year.

• One reviewer has used Walker Painting for over 20 years; extended family loyalty patterns appear across the reviews.
• New homeowners preparing a house before unpacking appear as a recurring customer type.

"We've contracted Walker 4x. Always professional, work cleanly, and clearly take pride in the work. Walker has done exterior painting, our entire kitchen including cabinets, a studio apartment, and most recently a basement and bathroom ceilings requiring plaster repair." - Karen Berrios, Google Review

For homeowners and property managers needing a contractor that handles both residential and commercial work, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY brings a structured operation that scales. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and a 4.7-star rating with over 100 Angi reviews, earning a Chooz Score of 85.3%. With over 7 years in business across more than 45 communities, owner Jim LaFontaine handles estimates personally. A colorist specialist is available for paint selection - a good fit when you need professional-level project management and commercial-scale capacity.

• Jim LaFontaine is named in reviews for prompt, flexible estimates and responsive communication throughout.
• Commercial buildings, Hamptons properties, and a 766-unit condo complex all appear in the review history.

"Second time I've used CertaPro. They're not cheap, but the service skill and speed are worth it." - Bill Russo, Google Review

For whole-home projects with complex prep requirements, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge comes up consistently among customers who compared multiple estimates first. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 84.8%. Territory manager David Maloney is named in nearly every review as the primary contact from estimate through final walkthrough. A strong fit for full-home repaints with high ceilings, rough walls, or full skim coating needs.

• David Maloney is cited across reviews for detailed estimates, clear timelines, and consistent follow-through.
• High-difficulty conditions, including full skim coating, high-ceiling rooms, and garage and basement painting, appear regularly in the reviews.

"I have a 2,300 sq ft home needing a total repaint, garage, basement, and full skim coating in several rooms. These guys were way above my expectations. I even gave them a house key - that's how much I liked these guys." - Jeffrey Negrin, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Setauket, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings formal credentials and a long regional track record. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 84.5%. The company holds Better Business Bureau accreditation since 2015 and is a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. Project manager Chris is named for punctuality and direct handling of quality concerns. Services extend beyond paint - wallpaper, power washing, and deck work all appear in reviews.

• BBB accreditation since 2015 and Bethpage Best of Long Island recognition add third-party accountability.
• Services go well beyond painting - reviewers describe wallpaper, power washing, deck repair, and post-job furniture assistance.

"Our 230 year old house was in serious need of an exterior paint job. After speaking with three painting companies, we decided on Precision Painting Plus and we are extremely happy with our decision." - Jim Gabriel, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Across the reviews for painting contractors in Setauket, NY, quality and craftsmanship are the most consistently praised attributes. Customers of Mr Star Painting Corp point frequently to prep work before paint is applied - skim coating uneven surfaces and patching holes shows up across multiple projects. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns similar notes, with reviewers crediting the sanding and skim coating as the reason their finished walls looked noticeably better than after previous contractors. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY shows strength in detailed finish work, with trim lines, cabinet repaints, and surface transitions earning reviews where customers describe results they did not expect from a painting job.

The pattern holds across the other contractors serving Setauket, NY. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers describe projects involving high ceilings and rough walls needing full skim coating, with finished results earning descriptors like "perfection." Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County reviews cover a notable range of conditions, including the exterior repaint of a 230-year-old home. Big Expert Painting LLC rounds this out with consistent feedback about clean, neat execution on both interior and exterior jobs, with customers comparing the results favorably to prior experiences.

"Walker does the best work! It's about the prep - filling holes, sanding and skimming - that made all the difference. Our walls look like new!" - Anne Carfora, Google Review "My walls were very uneven and the guys skim coated them flawlessly before painting. I'm very happy with the results." - Michael Bunicci, Google Review "Just had my ceilings and living room painted and I am impressed! Perfection - is how I'd describe it!" - Kevin Kitson, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Clear communication and professional conduct run through virtually every top-rated contractor in Setauket, NY. Customers of Mr Star Painting Corp describe owners Ricardo and Mario as reliable communicators - explaining the scope upfront and keeping customers updated throughout the project. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns consistent credit for owner Sal's accessibility, with reviewers describing prompt responses by text or phone at every stage. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY has a structured office team behind the field crews, with AnnMarie and Frank named for managing scheduling changes and added scopes without friction.

For Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, territory manager David Maloney is the consistent point of contact from estimate through completion. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis is directly reachable without an answering service, with multiple reviewers noting same-day responses including on weekends. JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan is personally mentioned in most reviews for listening carefully before starting and staying available throughout each job. In Setauket, NY, direct owner or manager involvement from first call to final walkthrough is the common thread among the area's top-rated contractors.

"Both Mario and Ricardo were very helpful throughout the whole process, explained everything that they would be doing, and stayed communicating to us the whole time." - Brianna F., Google Review "I was constantly changing dates and adding projects to my original quote and everyone was understanding. AnnMarie and Frank were super helpful and great communicators." - Gabrielle LaBranche, Google Review "Communication was frequent and clear. I always knew what point they were at, and they did a magnificent job." - Theresa Westergard, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Home protection and end-of-day cleanup are consistent themes across reviews for painting contractors in Setauket, NY. Customers of Mr Star Painting Corp describe crews that clean up each workday and leave spaces spotless at completion, noted across interior and exterior jobs alike. JRT Pro Painters LLC earns frequent mentions for covering furniture and floors before starting, containing debris, and treating daily cleanup as a standard expectation. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge reviews describe homes left cleaner at the end of each workday than when the crew arrived - noted across both short and extended projects.

The prep dimension goes beyond cleanup in Setauket, NY. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns specific credit for what crews do before paint goes on - filling holes, sanding, and skim coating that reviewers describe as the difference between a paint job and a real renovation result. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County reviews note crews addressing surface problems left by previous contractors before beginning their own work. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY receives notes for daily cleanup during multi-day jobs, with customers describing their homes as fully livable each evening during an interior repaint.

"They thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up when they were finished. Their work was excellent. I will be using Brayan for future painting projects." - Janette Payne, Google Review "Besides doing a great job painting, they cleaned up everything to perfection. I would highly recommend them." - Christine Thorn, Google Review "Extremely fast and efficient, leaving my house cleaner than it was when they arrived." - Joe C., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and pricing come up regularly in reviews for contractors in Setauket, NY. Big Expert Painting LLC earns consistent praise, with customers describing direct estimates that came in fair relative to quality delivered. Owner Denis's straightforward approach to quoting, without layers of upselling, appears to drive this perception. JRT Pro Painters LLC draws similar feedback - customers compare multiple estimates, find JRT competitively priced, and describe a level of detail that exceeded what they expected for the cost. Several reviewers note the crew addressed prep and repairs beyond the stated scope without adding charges.

Across the broader Setauket, NY market, value perception is closely tied to what crews address beyond the stated scope. Mr Star Painting Corp customers note fair pricing and prep work handled without extra charges. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns pricing compliments from customers who gathered three or more estimates. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY carries a slightly premium profile - one reviewer noted they were not the cheapest option but the skill and speed made the investment worthwhile.

"Painted the exterior in the heat of July, stayed on schedule, and were very reasonably priced. Highly recommend." - Max Jacob, Google Review "Of all the price quotes we received, theirs was right in the middle. We definitely got high value for the price we paid." - Kent Corso, Google Review "They are by far the most reasonably priced. David Maloney was very professional and explained everything in detail." - Helen grygo, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Reliable scheduling is a baseline expectation, and the top-rated contractors in Setauket, NY consistently deliver on it. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY earns notes for finishing at or ahead of schedule, including one customer describing a multi-phase job completed in less time than quoted. Mr Star Painting Corp reviews describe punctual crew arrivals across interior and exterior projects, with customers noting on-schedule completion contributed to a smooth experience overall. JRT Pro Painters LLC gets specific credit for full workdays - customers describe crews arriving on time and working through eight-to-nine-hour days without gaps or unexplained delays.

Scheduling flexibility is a separate theme in Setauket, NY reviews. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns notes for quick estimate turnaround, with one reviewer describing a same-evening response and next-morning appointment. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe Denis as someone who consistently shows up when he says he will, a trait multiple reviewers flag as more meaningful than it sounds. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns comments about project managers committing to clear timelines from the estimate stage and then delivering on them through multi-day projects.

"Professional and organized from start to finish. They achieved the job in less than the original time estimate." - Joe Beers, Google Review "They were on time, finished on time, and it looks beautiful." - Nicholas Bilello, Google Review "Brayan and his coworker are extremely punctual and precise. Every day they clean up the workspace to start fresh and new the next day." - Christina Shiwbalak, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat customers and referrals are a strong signal of consistent results, and several contractors serving Setauket, NY show clear patterns of both. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis has built multi-year customer relationships, with reviewers describing hiring him repeatedly for different projects in the same home over years. Customers actively refer him as well - one reviewer scheduled two additional jobs and referred two people the same week a project finished. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge draws reviews from customers who have used the company across multiple properties, with several stating they would not call anyone else for future work.

Longer-term loyalty is visible across other contractors in Setauket, NY. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has customers who have used them for over 20 years, with extended family members now calling Walker after an initial good experience. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns notes from customers who first hired them around 2014 and returned multiple times since. JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan has built a similar pattern - one customer hired him across multiple phases of a whole-home repaint over several years. Mr Star Painting Corp counts over 8 documented repeat-customer relationships in the review period, some spanning nearly a decade.

"5 STARS!!! Dennis and team were outstanding! I already scheduled another two jobs and referred him to two people. Very professional, very honest, and very good work!" - Ken Smitelli, Google Review "I'll always use PPP anytime I need my home painted. They do an excellent job and everyone I've dealt with is very nice and professional." - Jacquelyn Carriero, Google Review "I used this company a couple of times since 2014. They are very professional and do a great job from start to finish." - Vivian B, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook