Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Mr Star Painting Corp
When Valerie Stone needed her Long Island home repainted after eight years, she called the same company that did the original work. Her review captures what brings customers back to Mr. Star Painting Corp, describing the team as delivering results that were "even better than the first time." This pattern of repeat business defines how owners Ricardo Almendarez and Mario Matute Fernandez have built their company since incorporating in June 2015.
The fully licensed and insured team operates from Port Jefferson Station, serving Nassau and Suffolk Counties with interior painting, exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, drywall repair, and commercial projects. Crew members Jonathan, Michael, Angel, and Willy appear consistently across customer reviews, reflecting stable team composition rather than rotating subcontractors.
Mr. Star Painting Corp holds active Home Improvement licenses in both Nassau and Suffolk Counties, with insurance coverage verified for painting work. The company serves communities including Huntington, Smithtown, Dix Hills, Garden City, Massapequa, and Great Neck throughout Long Island.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Unlike companies where owners disappear after the estimate, Ricardo and Mario maintain hands-on involvement from start to finish. Customers consistently note their presence on job sites. Christine describes how "Ricardo and Mario were professional, knowledgeable, and always kept me updated through the whole process." Joseph, who has hired them three times, emphasizes that "Ricardo or Mario will be with each customer from start to finish."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Punctuality emerges as one of the strongest patterns across reviews. Michael P. states the crew was "always on time every single day" during his project. Emily notes they "showed up early and got right to work." Patricia confirms "they arrived promptly as scheduled." This consistency extends from the initial estimate through final walkthrough, with customers rarely mentioning scheduling issues.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cleanup receives nearly as much praise as the painting itself. Customers frequently mention coming home to spotless conditions. Karisma describes finding her home "cleaner than before they started." Matthew notes "at the end of each day the men made sure the house was left in immaculate condition." Drop cloths, furniture protection, and daily cleanup appear standard rather than exceptional.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cabinet projects represent a specialty that generates enthusiastic reviews. Joan describes her kitchen transformation where cabinets went from "tired looking to looking like new cabinets." Christine notes that Mario "suggested adding new Sheetrock and installing some beams" to improve her ceiling before painting. The attention to preparation before refinishing contributes to results customers describe as exceeding expectations.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Eight documented repeat customers within two years suggests strong satisfaction. Valerie Stone returned after eight years, calling results "even better than the first time." Joseph Consalazio has hired them three times. Christopher Eccleston used them for multiple projects between 2022 and 2025. Brian hired them twice. The pattern indicates customers trust the company enough to call back rather than shopping around.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The single critical review came from Louis, who felt the estimate was "twice as expensive" as a competitor. No work was performed, and the company did not respond defensively. Among completed projects, Jeff noted minor concerns about cleanup and communication but still awarded five stars after issues were "addressed and it looks excellent." Professional resolution rather than argument characterizes the response pattern.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Specific names appear repeatedly across unrelated reviews, indicating crew stability. Jonathan receives praise for his patience and tolerance with homeowners. Michael and Angel are mentioned for attention to detail. Willy and Daniel appear across exterior and interior projects. Orlin is described as "exceptional with his attention to detail with fixing my window sill, ceiling, and walls." This consistency suggests dedicated employees rather than rotating subcontractors.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Mr. Star Painting Corp is a Domestic Business Corporation registered with the New York Department of State since June 10, 2015, with Entity Status showing Active. The company holds Nassau County Home Improvement License No. H3808430000, Status Licensed, expiring August 31, 2027, with verified insurance coverage for painting. In Suffolk County, the company holds two active licenses under principal Mario Matute-Fernandez. License No. H-54956 covers Sheet Rock/Spackling, Power Washing, and Painting, while License No. CP-54957 is also active. Both Suffolk licenses expire April 1, 2027. Nassau County records show zero complaints and zero violations for 2026. Suffolk County records show one complaint filed in the last five years (Record ID CMP-23-422), which has been closed with zero open issues.
-Verification Sources: NY Department of State Division of Corporations, Nassau County Consumer Affairs, Suffolk County Consumer Affairs
Updated: 04-07-2026