7 Best Painters Near East Setauket, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in East Setauket, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing different strengths to the table. Whether you need specialty decorative finishes, a full exterior repaint, or a quick interior refresh, the reviews tell a clear story of professionalism, fair pricing, and consistent results across the board.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Interior Finishing NYC had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. Owner Dorian Golemi brings a fine arts background to every project, and his reviews are filled with customers describing limewash applications, Venetian plaster, wallpaper installations, and gilding work that most contractors simply will not take on. Several reviewers mention that Dorian was the only contractor willing to tackle their project after others turned it down. If you need decorative or specialty finishes in the East Setauket, NY area, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong choice.

Reviewers consistently describe Dorian quoting jobs quickly over the phone and completing work in surprisingly short timeframes. His crew members are frequently named in reviews, and customers describe a team that communicates well and respects the space they work in.

• Multiple customers describe having wallpaper, plaster, and painting all handled in a single project without needing separate contractors
• Dorian offers phone and video estimates, saving customers time on scheduling
• A three-year workmanship warranty is included on all projects

"Could not be any happier with Dorian and his crew. They are not only professional, but genuinely kind and accommodating. His knowledge of painting and speciality finishes is second-to-none." - Robert Sternheim, Google Review

For homeowners who want a company that handles everything from power washing to crown molding installation, Big Expert Painting LLC earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis is mentioned by name throughout the reviews, and customers describe him as someone who answers calls directly, shows up personally for estimates, and follows up after jobs are completed.

What stands out in the reviews is how many customers come back for second and third projects. Multiple reviewers describe starting with a single room and then hiring Denis for the entire house. His team also handles drywall repair, power washing, and light carpentry alongside painting. If you are looking for a reliable, full-service painting crew in East Setauket, NY, Big Expert Painting LLC is a good fit.

• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified for work on pre-1978 homes
• Suffolk County Home Improvement License verified active
• Customers frequently describe same-day or next-day responses to quote requests

"Denis and his team did an amazing job in my home. Originally I hired him for a few rooms and I was so pleased I asked him to return to do other jobs. His team was professional, clean, timely, and excellent." - Jackie Hernandez, Google Review

With over 150 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, Todd's Painting has built a loyal following right in the Centereach area near East Setauket, NY. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Todd is known for kitchen cabinet painting, exterior staining, and full interior repaints. Reviews consistently describe a hands-on owner who shows up with his crew every day and communicates throughout the project. If you want a local painter who personally oversees your job from start to finish, Todd's Painting is a solid option.

A recurring theme in the reviews is how many customers describe homes that had not been painted in 20 or even 30 years and came out looking brand new. Todd also handles power washing, deck staining, and fence painting, making him a versatile choice for exterior work.

• Kitchen cabinet refinishing is a frequently praised specialty, with multiple reviewers sharing before-and-after results
• Several reviewers describe receiving estimates and having work completed within days
• Reviews span Google, Facebook, and Yelp with consistent praise across all platforms

"Made our 100 year old house look brand new! His team was fast, reliable, and clean." - Rachel Ulrich, Google Review

Also serving the East Setauket, NY area, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY brings the structure of a national franchise with the personal touch of a locally owned operation. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.3% with over 200 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. They also have 4.7 stars on Angi with over 100 reviews on that platform. With over 7 years in business serving Central Suffolk County, they handle both residential and commercial projects at scale. If you manage a property or HOA and need a contractor who can handle large-scale work, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson is worth considering.

Reviewers describe a structured process that includes color consultations, detailed prep work, and consistent communication from the office team through project completion.

• Crew members like Frank and Jim are praised by name across multiple reviews for responsiveness and professionalism
• Commercial clients describe multi-year relationships with consistent satisfaction
• Owner Jim is described as hands-on and responsive even on evenings and weekends

"Great experience! Frank and Jim were both awesome to work with and so responsive even on weekends and evenings. The guys who came to do work were courteous, prompt, and did a great job!" - Tracy Grim, Google Review

When it comes to thorough prep work and leaving a home spotless after the job, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. With nearly 20 years in business, they are accredited with the Better Business Bureau and are a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. If you want a company with a long track record and a structured approach to project management, Precision Painting Plus is a good choice.

Their field manager Chris is mentioned frequently in reviews for staying on top of every detail, and customers describe a process where colors are confirmed, materials are ordered in advance, and crews arrive organized and ready to go.

• Customers describe furniture being moved, floors protected, and spaces left cleaner than before the crew arrived
• Wallpaper installation and removal are offered alongside standard painting
• Multiple reviewers have hired them two or more times over several years

"From the estimate visit to the job completion Precision Painting was competent, responsive and friendly. They did a fine job." - Bill Q, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in East Setauket, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration has earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego is named in nearly every review, and customers consistently describe him as responsive, fair, and present on the job site. With over 6 years in business, the company has grown almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. If you are looking for an owner-operated painting company where the person who gives you the estimate is the same person overseeing the work, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a great fit.

What is notable about this company is the speed at which they complete projects. Multiple reviewers describe whole-home jobs completed in a single day, with large crews arriving organized and finishing well ahead of schedule.

• Andres offers free color consultations and detailed written estimates with full cost breakdowns
• Crew sizes scale up for larger projects, keeping timelines tight without sacrificing quality
• Repeat customers describe following Andres from one home to the next

"Andres and his team were a pleasure to work with. Our project was completed just over a week after we reached out for a quote. We were extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism and attention to detail." - Nicole Albanese, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Professionalism and clear communication are among the most frequently praised qualities in reviews for painting contractors serving East Setauket, NY. Customers describe painters who answer calls promptly, show up when they say they will, and keep homeowners informed throughout every stage of the project.

Big Expert Painting LLC earns consistent praise for owner Denis's direct communication style. Reviewers describe him picking up the phone personally and responding to messages on weekends. "Denis was responsive, pleasant and reliable. Great work ethic and experience!" - Charlie Rappa, Google Review. Todd's Painting is described by customers as easy to reach and straightforward with scheduling. "Communication was prompt and concise. Work was completed as described." - Donna DiNapoli, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres is praised for providing detailed estimates and checking in regularly. "When the quality of work matches the level of courteous professionalism the decision to go with Long Island Painting and Restoration was a no brainer." - Daniel McQuail, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian is described as always willing to explain his process and work through unexpected issues on behalf of the customer. "He was also more affordable than the other painters we called." - Tova Kalkstein, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Quality and attention to detail are the most common themes across reviews for painting contractors in East Setauket, NY. Customers describe results that exceed expectations, with careful edgework, smooth finishes, and projects that hold up well over time.

Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp consistently earns praise for the quality of their prep work and finished results. Crew leader Manny is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews, and customers describe him catching details they would have missed themselves. "Manny and his Team were extremely professional, with excellent attention to detail. They were the best painters and interior designers I've ever seen since building my home 20 years ago." - vic scotto, Google Review. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY reviews highlight careful handling of trim, wainscoting, and cabinet work. "The painters arrived on time, did beautiful neat work, and cleaned everything up. It was a great job!" - Ann Worrell, Google Review. Todd's Painting customers frequently describe older homes being brought back to life. "Todd and his crew have been at our house for the past 3 days painting the interior that hasn't been painted in 30 years. Every room has cathedral ceilings and the living room has 17ft ceilings." - Diana Kopf, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is described by long-time customers as delivering consistent results project after project. "An incredible company and I can't praise them enough. True masters at their craft." - Ray Messina, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is one of the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractors serving East Setauket, NY. Reviewers consistently describe crews that arrive on schedule, complete work within the estimated timeframe, and often finish ahead of schedule.

Long Island Painting and Restoration is especially notable for fast turnarounds. Multiple reviewers describe entire homes being completed in a single day with large, organized crews. "They showed up on time every day, respectful, cleaned up at the end of each day. Highly recommend!" - Vanessa, Google Review. Todd's Painting customers describe receiving estimates and having work completed within days. "My house came out great! They were responsive, punctual and pricing was fair!" - Jacquelyn Riker, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC reviewers describe Denis keeping to the timeline and finishing when promised. "Gave me a estimate of 3 days to complete and was done on time." - Chantel B, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC customers describe Dorian completing limewash and wallpaper projects in a single day. "The guys were super fast and professional, they got everything done and it was in a timely fashion." - Adam Bates, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and prep work are among the most commonly praised aspects of painting contractors serving East Setauket, NY. Customers describe crews that protect furniture, cover floors, and leave spaces spotless when the work is done.

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns some of the strongest praise for cleanup. Reviewers describe crews covering everything with care and even helping put furniture back in place after painting. "They were on time and the did a great job and cleaned up afterwards and even helped me put my furniture and pictures back up." - Tracey Giardini, Google Review. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp crews are described as vacuuming before starting, laying paper on floors, and covering everything with plastic. "When they were done there was nothing for me to clean up." - Stuart Rock, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers note that Denis's team sweeps up after themselves and takes care not to leave any trace behind. "Not only that but he swept up the leaves he tracked in. Who does that now?" - Stafi Thukral, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration reviewers consistently use words like "spotless" and "clean" to describe the state of their home after the job. "Super quick, quiet, clean and efficient. Awesome, professional job." - Laura Bottan, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors in East Setauket, NY. While specific prices vary based on project scope, customers consistently describe receiving competitive quotes and feeling that the quality of work justified the cost.

Todd's Painting is frequently described as offering competitive pricing alongside strong results. "Very professional, stuck to the deadline and the price was very good that I actually got more work done than I originally wanted." - chris mc, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe Denis as upfront with estimates and competitively priced. "BigExpert Painting was great. Denis was easy to work with and gave very competitive pricing." - Daniel Marques, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres is praised for transparent pricing with no surprises. "Pricing was fair and transparent, and we're very happy with the quality of the finished work." - Garrett Monasterio, Google Review. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp reviewers describe fair prices paired with high-quality prep work and finishing. "Affordable, punctual and impeccable detail when it comes to prepping a house prior to painting." - Pamela Matzner, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Several painting contractors serving East Setauket, NY offer services beyond standard interior and exterior painting. From decorative plaster applications to cabinet refinishing and wallpaper installation, homeowners have access to specialty work without needing to look far.

Interior Finishing NYC specializes in decorative finishes including limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and gilding. Owner Dorian also handles wallpaper installation across a wide range of materials including grasscloth, cork, and vinyl. "Dori was prompt and very professional. His Venetian plaster work on my kitchen walls are unbelievable. I always get compliments from our guests!" - Charlie Vela, Google Review. Todd's Painting has developed a strong reputation for kitchen cabinet painting and refinishing, with multiple reviewers describing cabinets that look brand new. "Todd did an excellent job spray painting my kitchen cabinets. My wife and I could not be any happier." - Keith Barbone, Google Review. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp handles wallpaper removal, skim coating, and cabinet refinishing in addition to standard painting. "From removing wallpaper and smoothing out walls to painting walls, ceilings, trim, they did a great job." - Maria P, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County offers wallpaper installation and removal alongside their painting services. "Everything was great, the crew was neat and polite, on time. I've used this company twice for wallpaper and painting." - Davetta Acerra, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google