3 Best Painters Near Peconic, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners on the North Fork of Long Island have access to some of Suffolk County's most consistently reviewed painting contractors. The four companies featured on Chooz Painters serving Peconic, NY have built strong reputations across Google, Facebook, and Yelp, with customers returning for project after project.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, with additional reviews on Yelp and Facebook. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Todd is known for being responsive from the first call and for steering customers toward the right color choices before work begins - one reviewer described how he recommended a color change that saved them a repaint later. He and his crew handle everything from cabinet refinishing and exterior staining to power washing and commercial spaces across Suffolk County.

• Cabinet painting is a clear specialty, with customers describing spray-finished doors, removed drawer fronts, and smooth results on laminate surfaces
• Crews cover work areas completely and leave homes spotless, with multiple reviewers noting nothing was left to clean up afterward
• Todd has served several customers across multiple properties - a shop, a mother's home, and second houses - with consistent results each time

"Easy to work with, communicative, quality workmanship, attention to detail, tidy and timely! We are already planning 2 more projects with Todd!" - Angie E., Google Review

If you're looking for a painter you can call for varied jobs over the long term, Todd's Painting is a strong choice.

Also serving the Peconic, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County takes a structured, company-wide approach backed by nearly two decades in business. They had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2015), and a Bethpage Best of Long Island recognition. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%. Named project managers coordinate each job from estimate through cleanup, and at least one customer away during the entire project returned home to find everything completed correctly after coordinating with the team in advance.

• Challenging properties are handled well, including a 230-year-old home with complex exterior surfaces
• Wallpaper installation and removal is offered alongside standard interior painting
• Repeat customers - including one who started with a single bedroom and later returned for a full house - highlight consistent follow-through

"Two years ago I hired PPP to paint one of my bedrooms and they were fantastic. So, recently I rehired them to paint my entire house." - Sarah I., Google Review

For homeowners who want project oversight, clear communication, and an accredited business with a long track record, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a good fit.

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Long Island Painting and Restoration, where owner Andres Gallego has built an operation almost entirely through word-of-mouth. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews - every single one a 5.0-star rating. Andres goes room by room during the estimate, offers honest color consultations at no extra charge, and crew members Nelson and Joey are called out by name for their spackling and detail work.

• Several reviewers hired Andres for their first home and called him again when they moved to a second property
• Large crew sizes allow full whole-home jobs to wrap up in a single day

"Over the past few months they have painted 3 bedrooms, a living room, hallway and 2 bathrooms in my house. The work in every single room was done beautifully." - Kaitlyn V., Google Review

If you want owner-led involvement at every stage and transparent pricing, Long Island Painting and Restoration is worth a call.

Rounding out the top contractors in Peconic, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings nearly 30 years in business on Long Island and a thorough prep process that stands out in the review record. They earned a Chooz Score of 81.5% with over 190 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Crew leader Manny and his team take photos before moving anything, cover everything with plastic, vacuum before painting, and work as a coordinated unit from start to finish - the same crew handles a job through completion.

• Complex work including china cabinet refinishing, built-in bookcases, and vaulted ceilings appears routinely in the reviews
• Estimate-to-completion timelines are tight: several customers had their job started and finished within days of the initial quote
• Both Suffolk County and Nassau County home improvement contractor licenses are verified active

"Best paint job I ever had!!! It was fast, well done and everything that was removed was replaced exactly as it was before. When they were done there was nothing for me to clean up." - Stuart Rock, Google Review

For homeowners who want an established team with deep Long Island roots and a crew that treats prep as seriously as the painting itself, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is a dependable option.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Professionalism and clear communication are among the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractors serving Peconic, NY. Todd's Painting earns consistent praise for owner Todd's personal responsiveness - customers mention reaching him by text or phone and hearing back quickly, with several noting he offered honest guidance on paint selection before work began. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County takes a structured approach, assigning named project managers to each job so customers have a consistent point of contact from the estimate through final cleanup. One customer who was traveling during the entire project noted they returned home to find everything completed correctly after coordinating with the team in advance.

Owner-led communication stands out at Long Island Painting and Restoration and Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp. Owner Andres at Long Island Painting and Restoration is mentioned by name in nearly every review, with customers describing him as responsive from the first call and willing to spend real time reviewing scope and offering honest recommendations. At Anthony's, Manny is easy to reach, provides clear timelines, and follows through - customers consistently note they knew exactly what to expect before the crew arrived.

"We were extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism and attention to detail from start to finish." - Nicole A., Google Review (Long Island Painting and Restoration)

"His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient. Couldn't have asked for a better job!" - Brandon S., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

"Chris was very accommodating and said they would fix it no problem." - Andrea B., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Scheduling reliability is a consistent theme across reviews for painting contractors in the Peconic, NY area. Todd's Painting is especially noted for fast turnarounds - customers describe whole bathrooms, foyers, and entryways finished in a single morning, and one reviewer had an estimate one day and a completed multi-room job done before 5pm the next. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County handles larger projects on a more structured timeline, with customers describing on-time starts and completions even for complex jobs like full exterior repaints and whole-apartment painting with wallpaper installation.

At Long Island Painting and Restoration, speed without cutting corners is a frequent observation - Andres and his crew are credited with finishing jobs ahead of schedule, and customers describe entire whole-home projects wrapped up in a single day with a larger crew. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp draws praise for holding to the timelines Manny sets at the estimate: when he says a job will take two days, it takes two days - a detail called out directly by multiple reviewers as a reason for confidence.

"Todd and his crew are amazing - they arrived at 8am and were done by 3pm. In that time they did my whole bathroom, my foyer and front entrance way." - Laura C., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

"I am amazed that they were able to finish such a big job in just one day!" - Keri S., Google Review (Long Island Painting and Restoration)

"The project started on time and was completed on time. I really appreciate the quality of work and customer service." - Michelle F., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and property protection are highlighted regularly in reviews for painting contractors serving Peconic, NY. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp stands out for a particularly structured prep routine: Manny and his crew take photos of the room before moving anything, lay paper on floors, cover furniture completely with plastic, vacuum before painting begins, and tape off moldings carefully. Customers with large open living spaces and rooms filled with furniture describe the setup as thorough and the post-job cleanup as complete. Long Island Painting and Restoration draws similar praise, with customers describing crews that set up fully, work efficiently, and leave spaces clean at the end of each day on multi-day projects.

Todd's Painting and Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County also earn consistent marks for cleanliness. Todd's crew covers everything before starting and cleans up completely on departure, with reviewers noting they came home to spotless spaces. Precision Painting Plus is described as careful with furniture before and after a job, with crews restoring rooms to their original arrangement when painting is finished.

"There was no mess, they were careful with all my furniture. They vacuumed and left my house in perfect condition." - Helen B., Google Review (Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp)

"Fernando and his crew were friendly, courteous and quick with their painting. Everything was left clean and neat." - Lorinda B., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

"They arrived early and got right to work. When the job was finished they looked over everything to make sure it was to my liking." - John S., Google Review (Long Island Painting and Restoration)

"Todd and his crew were excellent, on time, efficient and neat." - Rosemarie F., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Customers across all four painting contractors serving Peconic, NY frequently mention fair pricing as a factor in both their initial decision to hire and their decision to return. Todd's Painting earns praise for competitive quotes that hold firm - one customer noted the price was good enough that they added more work to the original scope. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County draws comments about completing large projects exactly at the quoted price and on schedule, which several reviewers call out as genuinely rare in home services.

Long Island Painting and Restoration is frequently described as offering the best price compared to other quotes received, with customers noting that the quality made the value especially strong. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp receives similar observations - pricing is described as reasonable and fair, with the thoroughness of prep and quality of results making the cost feel well worth it. Several reviewers across these companies mention they did not look for additional quotes before calling again for future work.

"The price was very good that I actually got more work done than I originally wanted." - Chris M., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

"They completed the project for the price they proposed and on time. In my experience this is very rare for any type of service provided." - Peter A., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

"Fair prices, quality work, and the attention to detail was unmatched." - Jesse M., Google Review (Long Island Painting and Restoration)

"They painted the exterior of our home quickly and with attention to detail for an affordable price. We were extremely happy with the work." - Stephanie W., Google Review (Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp