3 Best Painters Near Mattituck, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The Mattituck, NY area sits at the heart of the North Fork, serving a mix of year-round residents, seasonal homeowners, and vacation property owners who often need a crew they can trust to work without them being present. The painting contractors earning top marks on Chooz Painters here share a consistent set of qualities: owner involvement, responsive communication, and crews that treat homes with real care from start to finish.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Chameleon Painting Inc. had over 170 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.8%. Owner Juan Guillermo Jaramillo has run this family operation for over 10 years, personally handling every estimate, visiting job sites daily, and sending photo updates to homeowners who can't be on-site during the work. That last detail carries real weight on the North Fork, where many clients are coordinating projects remotely. If you need a team you can hand a key and trust completely, Chameleon Painting Inc. is a strong fit.

A few patterns stand out when reading through the reviews. Several clients describe handing over a key and leaving for out-of-state trips, returning to find the job done perfectly. The crew works quietly with no music playing, which multiple reviewers note let them work from home without disruption during longer projects. Wallpaper installation, cedar shingle staining, deck work, and cabinet refinishing all appear alongside standard interior and exterior painting.

• Juan is frequently described as proactively sending photos and updates to clients who are away, keeping them informed without needing to ask
• Multiple reviews highlight thorough daily cleanup, leaving the home fully livable during multi-day jobs
• Projects range widely in scale - from a single porch to a 2,200-square-foot deck to a church hall that hadn't been painted in 40 years

"I bought my home in December and then went to Florida and left Juan to paint my whole house while I was gone. He kept me updated with pictures and reports. I came back to see a perfect job." - Ellen, Google Review

While Chameleon Painting Inc. is built around its family-run, owner-led approach, Todd's Painting has earned its following through a different kind of loyalty - customers who return year after year, some for over three decades. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, with reviews also appearing on Yelp and Facebook. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Customers describe Todd as bringing over 35 years of experience to every job, and the variety of work he handles reflects that depth - interior rooms, kitchen cabinet refinishing, power washing, deck staining, and commercial spaces. For homeowners who want a versatile contractor comfortable with both small detail work and larger exterior projects, Todd's Painting is a good fit.

Cabinet refinishing is a standout specialty. Todd's crew removes cabinet doors and drawer fronts, takes them to the shop for professional spray finishing, and reinstalls - customers describe results that look factory-fresh. Todd also brings a consultative style: at least one reviewer describes him recommending a color change before starting because the client's original choice was too bright, which the homeowner described as a genuine relief in hindsight.

• Crew member Dean is specifically praised for cabinet work, with customers describing thorough prep and high-quality spray results
• Multiple reviews mention Todd returning without hesitation for small touch-ups after job completion
• Power washing for pavers, pool decks, and fences is frequently mentioned alongside painting work

"Todd came on time to paint a room for my son. The color my son picked was too bright and Todd recommended to change it which I was so grateful for. The room came out perfect and we all were happy!!" - Karen F., Google Review

As a North Fork Chamber of Commerce member and 2025 Best of the Best award winner with Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition, AJ Painting has built strong East End community roots. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, AJ Painting had over 70 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.9%. For high-end interiors, premium paint applications, or complex historic properties on the North Fork, AJ Painting is worth contacting.

Projects described in reviews require real expertise: a 110-year-old farmhouse in a historic North Fork district, luxury Hamptons interiors with premium Farrow and Ball paints, and exterior jobs involving full vine removal and comprehensive scraping before a single brush stroke. Named crew members - Angel, Andy, Isay, and Lindo - appear across multiple reviews, which points to a stable, consistent team. Wallpaper hanging is also offered, coordinated alongside the painting work.

• Multiple customers describe specifically seeking AJ out for a new home after a first project at a previous address - a clear sign of sustained satisfaction
• Exterior prep is described in thorough detail across several reviews, including full vine removal and complete surface scraping before painting begins
• Customers who requested changes mid-project describe AJ as patient and willing to redo areas without pushback

"They were not cheap and it took a long time but my god: it's like I have a new house! They did such careful work - the place needed an enormous amount of prep, including removing a tangle of vines and all sorts of other greenery." - Customer Review, Google

For larger projects where coordination and communication across multiple rooms and phases matter, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings a structured operation that stands out. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015 and a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner, this company has been operating for nearly 20 years. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%. If you want clear project management structure and named points of contact throughout a larger job, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a good fit.

A field manager visits before painting day to confirm colors and plan prep - not a detail most companies bother with. During the work, named project managers (Jason and Chris appear most often in reviews) maintain daily on-site presence. Skim coating, wallpaper installation, and deck repair are handled in-house, and the company's portfolio includes HOA properties and commercial work alongside residential jobs.

• Customers describe receiving a written estimate and contract upfront, with a clear payment schedule and detailed scope of work before anything starts
• Return customers describe escalating project sizes over time - starting with one room and coming back for whole-house work
• Homeowners who were away during painting describe being kept informed by named project managers throughout the job

"The field manager came to the house days before to receive the shades of colors that were to be used. All the paint was ordered true to the required colors. The painters arrived at the time scheduled and the job was completed before expected." - CarolJean C., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Mattituck, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration holds a record that is hard to argue with - every single one of their over 55 Google reviews carries a five-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%. Owner Andres Gallego handles each estimate personally, often spending extended time on a room-by-room walkthrough and offering a color consultation before work begins. With over 6 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, growth has been driven almost entirely by referrals. For new homeowners needing a fast, thorough refresh or repeat clients who need reliable crews on a tight timeline, Long Island Painting and Restoration is worth a call.

Speed without shortcuts is a recurring theme in reviews. A six-person crew has wrapped full whole-home interiors in a single day; a 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home was finished in under 48 hours. Andres also follows through after the job - at least one reviewer describes a post-project issue unrelated to painting that Andres addressed within two days of a call. Foreman Nelson and crew member Delmer appear by name in reviews, confirming a consistent team from project to project.

• Color consultations are standard practice - customers describe getting professional recommendations from Andres at no extra charge during the initial walkthrough
• Challenging starting conditions are handled without issue - customers describe extreme color situations, heavy wallpaper removal, and soot-stained walls all cleaned up and painted beautifully
• Post-project responsiveness is noted across multiple reviews, with Andres described as quick to answer and send crews back when needed

"He was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his guys - they are very reliable, neat and friendly to work with!" - Christine L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Across all contractors serving the Mattituck, NY area, professionalism and communication consistently top the list of things customers mention first. At Chameleon Painting Inc., reviewers describe feeling comfortable enough to hand over a house key and leave - sometimes for extended out-of-state trips - trusting Juan and his crew completely. At Todd's Painting, responsiveness is a signature trait: customers describe texts and calls answered quickly, and several reviews note Todd returned without complaint to address small concerns after job completion. AJ Painting earns consistent praise for professionalism from the first contact through the final walkthrough, with one reviewer describing the whole process as seamless from scheduling to cleanup.

"AJ Painting was a pleasure to work with and they do great work! AJ is very accessible, and accommodating on the project. His guys are trustworthy and very detail-oriented. You only have to ask once for what you're looking for." - Liz G., Google Review

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County takes a structured approach to communication - customers describe a named estimator arriving on time, a project manager maintaining daily contact, and a written contract in place before any work starts. At Long Island Painting and Restoration, Andres earns praise for being reachable and responsive not just during the project, but after - including showing up quickly for issues that arose weeks later. A common thread across all five companies is that reviewers specifically mention trusting the crew in their home without concern, which speaks to how these teams carry themselves on the job.

"From start to finish Precision Painting Plus was outstanding!! Communication was constant and fast. Jason was very informative and present throughout." - Lorinda B., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Quality and craftsmanship are front and center in reviews for Mattituck, NY area painting contractors. AJ Painting earns detailed praise for high-skill interior work - one reviewer describes a project involving premium Farrow and Ball paints throughout a Hamptons home, with thorough sanding, patching, and priming producing what he called a smooth, architectural finish. A separate review describes a 110-year-old North Fork farmhouse project spanning two full floors, including kitchen cabinets, built-ins, three stairwells, and intricate molding and trim - completed on time and on budget. Chameleon Painting Inc. earns similar marks for prep quality, with customers describing walls carefully washed, caulking replaced, and detailed line-item estimates that give customers confidence before the first brush stroke.

"The sanding, patching, repairs, and priming where required were done with no shortcuts. No rushed areas. The result is a smooth, architectural finish that elevates the entire home." - Christopher B., Google Review (AJ Painting)

Todd's Painting customers highlight cabinet refinishing as a craftsmanship standout - doors taken to the shop and professionally sprayed rather than painted in place, with results customers describe as looking like they came from the original factory. Long Island Painting and Restoration reviews describe consistent attention to detail even on fast-moving projects, with walls inspected and touch-ups handled before the crew leaves each day. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, the pre-job field manager visit to confirm colors and plan prep is described as ensuring the quality standard is set before the first coat goes on.

"They did such careful work - the place needed an enormous amount of prep, including removing a tangle of vines and all sorts of other greenery. They scraped all the old peeling paint off the house and repainted it fresh. It looks terrific!" - Customer Review, Google (AJ Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Scheduling reliability and fast turnarounds are recurring strengths across top contractors in the Mattituck, NY area. Todd's Painting is particularly noted for speed - customers describe getting an estimate and having the full crew on site the following day, with entire multi-room jobs wrapped up before the end of that same day. Long Island Painting and Restoration takes this further: a six-person crew has completed full whole-home interior projects in a single day, and a 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home was finished in under 48 hours. Chameleon Painting Inc. earns consistent praise for start-date reliability - Juan gives a projected schedule at the estimate, and reviewers confirm the crew arrived exactly when promised and finished on time.

"Had multiple rooms that needed painting and was looking to get it done ASAP. Todd and his team more than delivered. He stopped by to give me an estimate, and the very next day he and his crew were at my house early and finished with everything before 5pm." - Jenna F., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

AJ Painting reviewers describe a punctual team that communicates proactively when any schedule adjustments are needed. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, multiple customers describe projects completing ahead of the projected date while still meeting the full scope of work. Across all five companies, reviewers consistently highlight crews simply showing up when they said they would - a basic expectation that these contractors meet reliably in a market where scheduling dependability is not always guaranteed.

"They finished my entire home ahead of schedule and were prompt every morning and even worked late to assist. Highly recommend!!" - Kiran K., Google Review (Long Island Painting and Restoration)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Cleanup and property protection are among the most frequently mentioned strengths in reviews for Mattituck, NY painting contractors. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County builds its reputation around it - customers describe furniture covered, floors protected, and daily cleanup treated as standard practice rather than an extra. At Chameleon Painting Inc., reviewers note the crew covering everything from furniture to cameras, light switches, and outlets before starting, and leaving the work site tidy at the end of each day so the home remains livable during multi-day projects. Several customers across both companies describe being genuinely surprised at how clean the space was when the crew finished.

"Their work is excellent - a very professional crew who knew what they were doing, they arrived on time and left everything spotless when they were finished." - Risa K., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

Long Island Painting and Restoration customers describe the crew replacing furniture to its original placement and leaving rooms cleaner than expected after even large-scale jobs. At Todd's Painting, reviewers mention crews removing blinds before painting, covering floors and furniture with plastic, vacuuming after spackle work, and reinstalling fixtures afterward - a thorough approach to protecting the space. AJ Painting customers describe careful daily cleanup as part of the standard process, with the team treating the home with the same care from day one to the last day on site.

"His guys took down the blinds, covered everything in plastic, cleaned up and vacuumed afterwards. I was pleasantly surprised and already recommended him to a few friends." - Christine C., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Value and pricing come up consistently in reviews for painting contractors serving the Mattituck, NY area, and the picture across top-rated companies is broadly positive: fair pricing, transparent estimates, and no unexpected charges at the end. Chameleon Painting Inc. is repeatedly described as providing detailed, line-item estimates that break each project area down by scope and cost - several reviewers mention this level of detail was more thorough than any other company they received quotes from. Todd's Painting customers describe pricing as reasonable for the quality delivered, with some noting they were able to expand the scope of work because the per-unit pricing left room in their budget. At AJ Painting, customers describe competitive estimates on complex projects that still came in on time and on budget.

"Our experience with Precision Painting Plus was excellent. They offered a very competitive price on a large project. They completed the project for the price they proposed and on time. In my experience this is very rare for any type of service provided." - Peter A., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

Long Island Painting and Restoration reviews consistently describe Andres's estimates as competitive and clearly broken down, with multiple customers noting his price came in lower than other quotes they received for the same scope. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, customers describe a written contract upfront, structured payment stages, and professional invoicing throughout. A common theme across all five companies is that customers who expected to pay more in the Hamptons and North Fork market were pleasantly surprised, and several describe returning specifically because the value matched the quality on the first job.

"He answered the phone right away, came quickly for a free estimate and did the job for the price he quoted." - Steven B., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook