11 Best Painters Near West Babylon, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving West Babylon, NY show up with strong track records across Suffolk County, where repeat business and referrals tell you as much as any review platform. The following companies earned the highest Chooz Scores in the area, backed by hundreds of verified reviews.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across that volume of feedback is rare for any contractor. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, with matching marks on Yelp and Angi, both at 5.0 stars. With over 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County, owner Todd Rumfola handles both painting and exterior power washing, holding a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and lead-safe certification for older homes. If you need painting and exterior cleaning handled by one reliable crew, South Bay is a good fit.

Customers frequently call out Todd's same-day responsiveness, his use of online proposals and invoices, and his willingness to take on last-minute jobs when schedules allow.

• Handles painting and power washing together, covering siding, pavers, brick walkways, and decks in a single project
• Owner Todd responds to every Google review personally and is often reachable within hours of an initial message
• Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-61927, verified active through 2027, plus lead-safe certification for pre-1978 homes
• Multiple customers describe working with Todd for several consecutive years across different types of projects

"I am so glad we chose South Bay Painting to Power Wash our home! This is a totally professional company from always communicating promptly, to providing online proposals and invoices, to being courteous, and especially doing an impeccable job soft-powerwashing every exterior inch of our home." - Gina Eldredge, Google Review

With over 12 years in business, Teall Painting has developed a following that stretches across Nassau and Suffolk counties, earning a Chooz Score of 87.6% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Owner Charlie Teall is known for issuing detailed, itemized estimates that leave little room for surprises, and every job is backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. If you want a thorough estimate and a crew willing to tackle specialty work like brick exteriors, stucco, or cabinet refinishing, Teall is worth a call.

What stands out from the review record is the range of specialty work Teall's crews take on. Brick exteriors, wainscoting installation, stucco painting, and cabinet refinishing all appear alongside standard interior work, and owner Charlie stays in communication throughout each project, providing daily progress updates.

• Detailed, itemized estimates so homeowners know exactly what they are getting before any work begins
• Owner Charlie Teall stays in contact throughout the project and personally follows up on completion
• 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty with 100% Satisfaction Guarantee backing every job
• Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692, verified active

"Charlie was prompt and professional during the consultation for our interior painting project. His estimate was detailed and addressed all our concerns. His team was respectful of our home and very hard working! We're looking forward to working with the Teall team again!" - Kyle Plati, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for CRD Painting Inc, where owner Camilo and his crew have been trusted by some Long Island homeowners for a decade or longer. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 90 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus matching marks on Yelp. With over 8 years in business, Camilo has built the kind of client relationships where one job turns into five or six across multiple properties. If you want a contractor who offers genuine color guidance and comes back quickly if something isn't right, CRD is a strong choice.

Several reviewers mention Camilo's ability to suggest colors and combinations they hadn't considered. One customer had a living room repainted the very next day after not being satisfied with her original color choice - and then immediately scheduled the den. That kind of responsiveness tends to generate very loyal clients.

• Owner Camilo personally provides color suggestions, acting as a consultant beyond just the paint application
• Customers frequently refer CRD to family members, with multiple reviews describing work done across both their home and a parent's or sibling's home
• Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-59404, verified active through 2027

"Camilo and his team painted our living room which has many different architectural details. Once completed I wasn't happy with the color I chose. I called Camilo and he came the next day and repainted the walls!!! I was ecstatic to say the least." - Karen Rauseo, Google Review

Owner Denis Flores is the name that comes up in nearly every review for Big Expert Painting LLC, which earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating - a perfect mark across every single review on Google. Cross-platform ratings are consistent, with 5.0 stars on Yelp. The company holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes. If you want an owner-run operation where Denis personally estimates and works alongside his crew, Big Expert is a good fit.

A recurring detail in the reviews: Denis and his crew frequently finish ahead of the estimated timeline. One customer was told three days and the job wrapped in two. Another called Denis to correct work from a previous contractor, and the crew arrived on time and cleaned up completely when done. That kind of dependability generates back-to-back referrals.

• Denis typically estimates jobs himself and remains directly accessible by phone throughout the project
• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on homes built before 1978
• Multiple reviewers note crews finishing ahead of schedule without any drop in quality
• Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388, verified active through 2027

"Denis and his team do excellent work! I hired them to fix a previous paint job I was unhappy with. Denis and his team arrived on time, completed quality work and cleaned up when they finished. I highly recommend if you need painting done in your home!" - Susanne Geisweller, Google Review

The range of work in the review record sets Todd's Painting apart. Cathedral ceilings, chain link fences, vinyl-sided sheds, kitchen cabinets, exterior staining, commercial spaces, and multi-day whole-home projects all appear alongside standard interior and exterior work. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% backed by over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, with active reviews on Facebook and Yelp as well. If you have a varied list of projects and want one contractor to handle all of them, Todd's is a practical option.

One detail that stands out: Todd's has commercial clients in the review record too. A business owner hired the crew for a two-day commercial painting job and noted they arrived early both mornings and finished exactly on time. That reliability across residential and commercial work runs through the full review history.

• Handles commercial painting alongside residential, with business owners appearing consistently in the review record
• Projects range from single doors and shutters to full-home interior and exterior jobs and cabinet refinishing
• Owner Todd manages estimates and scheduling directly and responds to reviews personally

"Start to finish, Todd's painting was a great decision! Communication was prompt and concise. Work was completed as described. Todd and his crew are professional. They left the area clean at the end of each day and returned as promised, on time." - Donna DiNapoli, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in West Babylon, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings over 18 years in business and a track record spanning interior, exterior, painting, and staining projects across Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, are 100% recommended on Facebook, and have been BBB accredited since 2015. If you are getting multiple estimates and want a company that regularly wins competitive bids on pricing while delivering consistent results, Precision is worth adding to your list.

Territory manager David Maloney is mentioned by first name across dozens of separate reviews from unrelated customers, described as professional, clear in his communication, and consistently present from estimate through completion. Multiple customers describe using Precision for a second or third property after being satisfied with the first job.

• BBB accredited since 2015, with 100% recommended on Facebook and over 16 new reviews in the last 3 months
• Territory manager David Maloney cited by name across many separate reviews as the primary point of contact
• Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-73176, verified active through January 2028

"I hired Precision Painting after getting 3 estimates. They are by far the most reasonably priced. I had the pleasure of dealing with David Maloney, the project manager. He was very professional, explained everything and was truly a pleasure to deal with." - Helen Grygo, Google Review~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Homeowners in West Babylon, NY consistently point to the quality of the finished work as the reason they call back the same contractor. Across all companies in the Chooz data, the pattern holds: careful prep, thorough application, and a clean final result are the baseline expectations - and most crews meet or exceed them.

CRD Painting Inc draws particular attention for the precision of its finish work. Owner Camilo and his crew handle architectural details, moldings, wainscoting, and trim with care that typically appears only in specialist reviews. Teall Painting takes on non-standard projects that other contractors decline, including mahogany door refinishing and stucco exteriors, earning specific praise in multiple reviews for the finished results. Todd's Painting handles an equally wide range of surfaces, from cathedral ceilings to kitchen cabinets to vinyl-sided sheds, with customers frequently noting that the results go beyond what they expected. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC earns consistent mentions for the care applied to both painting and power washing, with reviewers noting how finished surfaces hold up across multiple seasons and follow-up projects.

"His work is neat, precise and with attention to every detail. He offers excellent suggestions because he has an eye of an artist. His work is impeccable." - Lisa Farrell, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"From the initial visit with Charlie to Victor coming to complete this job, everything ran very smoothly and professionally. Victor was right on time and a pleasure to work with. The job turned out beautifully." - Barbara Rosen, Google Review (Teall Painting)~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Responsiveness is one of the most consistent themes in reviews for painting contractors serving West Babylon, NY. Homeowners describe same-day responses to initial inquiries, direct access to owners by phone, and steady communication from estimate through the final walkthrough.

Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis Flores is frequently cited for answering calls directly and returning quotes the same day, including on weekends. Teall Painting owner Charlie Teall is noted across multiple reviews for keeping customers informed throughout each project, with reviewers describing daily updates and quick replies to texts and calls. JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan Rivas Ticas draws similar mentions, with customers calling him easy to reach and straightforward about pricing and scheduling from the first conversation. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC stands out for its fully digital approach: owner Todd Rumfola uses online proposals and invoices, and multiple reviewers mention receiving replies within hours of sending an initial message - including for last-minute requests.

"Highly recommend! Quick to respond to messages & easy to deal with. They were at my house for 2 1/2 days, they arrived as scheduled & put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)"I contacted Charlie based on a co-worker's recommendation when I was in a jam to get things done quickly before moving into our new home. Charlie and his team were punctual and worked long hours to finish the work." - Shai Bojsa, Google Review (Teall Painting)~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality and scheduling reliability come up in a large share of reviews for painting contractors in West Babylon, NY. For most of the top-rated companies, arriving on time and finishing close to the agreed date is simply the standard - not a standout feature.

Multiple reviewers for Todd's Painting note that crews arrive early and wrap up on or ahead of schedule, including for commercial jobs where deadlines are firm. Big Expert Painting LLC earns similar mentions, with one customer noting the crew finished a three-day estimate in two days without any drop in quality. CRD Painting Inc customers repeatedly describe the same pattern: Camilo shows up when he says he will, works efficiently through the project, and finishes faster than expected. Teall Painting customers note that crew members are clear about what to expect each day, which makes multi-day projects feel organized rather than unpredictable.

"He sent Rene to do the work, he arrived on time every day. Worked steadily all day long. He would ask my opinion during the day. But in the end, I absolutely love the way it turned out." - Angelina Harrington, Google Review (Teall Painting)"Very clean, organized, and respectful of my property. We are delighted with the finished product. Both Bryan and Alex worked tirelessly to complete the job in a timely fashion." - Nolan Schmitz, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Prep work and cleanup are two areas where painting contractors in West Babylon, NY clearly separate themselves. The companies that consistently earn repeat business are the ones homeowners never have to worry about: furniture gets covered, floors get protected, and at the end of each workday, the space is livable again.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns repeated mentions specifically for this: across multiple reviews, customers describe rooms left accessible at the end of each workday even during a six-day whole-home project, with all furniture moved and protected before any painting begins. JRT Pro Painters LLC draws consistent praise for spackling and skimming walls before the first coat goes on, going beyond the paint surface to make sure the walls themselves look new. Big Expert Painting LLC customers note furniture covered before work begins, with the crew moving quickly without creating disruption throughout the home. CRD Painting Inc customers describe a neat, organized process from start to finish, with Camilo's crew covering all flooring and furniture before starting and cleaning as they move between rooms.

"They made sure they covered my personal items before starting and moved fast! Gave me an estimate of 3 days to complete and they finished in 2 days." - Chantel B, Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)"Very professional and most importantly cleaned up after every room they did." - Penny Sichel, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing comes up consistently in reviews for painting contractors in West Babylon, NY, and the general finding is that fair pricing paired with strong quality is what drives the loyalty these companies have built. Customers frequently mention getting several estimates before choosing a contractor, and the companies here win those comparisons regularly.

Teall Painting earns specific mentions from customers who received multiple estimates and chose Teall partly on price, without feeling they gave anything up on quality. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge draws similar reviews, with multiple customers describing the estimate as the most competitive they received after shopping around. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis Flores is called "fair" in reviews across multiple platforms, with customers noting the final invoice matched what was quoted. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers consistently describe Todd's pricing as "incredibly reasonable" for the level of work delivered, particularly for exterior cleaning projects. JRT Pro Painters LLC is noted for being straightforward about pricing from the first conversation, with no surprises when the job wraps up.

"The price was better than any other offers I had gotten. I made the down payment and began our project. Everything was done up to my standard and they were on time and worked without any problems." - Michael Blackcocks, Google Review (Teall Painting)"The customer service was top-notch from start to finish, and the price was incredibly reasonable. Not only was the work done thoroughly and efficiently, but my home looks fantastic." - Anthony Fragala, Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Repeat business is one of the strongest signals in the review data for painting contractors serving West Babylon, NY. Across every company in the Chooz data set, customers describe returning for second, third, and in some cases seventh-year or longer relationships with the same crew. In several cases, homeowners extended that loyalty to family members, calling the same contractor for a parent's or sibling's home after being satisfied with their own.

CRD Painting Inc has the most documented long-term relationships in the data, with multiple customers describing 10 to 15 years of ongoing work with owner Camilo, and one reviewer noting use of the company across more than five different homes. Todd's Painting earns similar loyalty, with one customer describing over 30 years of using the same painter for a range of jobs across multiple properties. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe returning for follow-up projects sometimes within the same week, scheduling additional rooms after seeing the initial results. JRT Pro Painters LLC has documented repeat customers going back to 2021, with clients returning for expanded projects including additional rooms, drywall repairs, and door and moulding replacements. The pattern across West Babylon, NY is consistent: once a crew proves itself, homeowners simply don't look elsewhere.

"We have been using Camilo from CRD painting for over 10 years. The nicest most honest guy you will meet. Top notch, neat, professional and fast service. Excellent prices. Have referred many family and friends all with rave reviews!" - Steve Siero, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"Initially, I had Denis come to do three rooms of my home. We were so impressed that we had him and his crew come back to do two more rooms and patch up a few things around the house." - Sara Galante, Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook