8 Best Painters Near Holtsville, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Holtsville, NY and the surrounding Suffolk County communities have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with strong review histories and verified credentials. Whether you need interior painting, exterior work, power washing, or specialty finishes, these companies have earned consistent praise for delivering on their promises.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This veteran-owned company earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, with additional ratings of 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Todd Rumfola runs the business out of East Islip and is known for personally handling every estimate, often texting back within hours. Reviewers frequently describe leaving their homes in the crew's care without hesitation, a sign of deep trust that is hard to earn. With over 10 years in business and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License, this is a strong choice if you want a responsive, owner-operated contractor who handles both painting and power washing across Long Island.

• Crew members Rich, Jerry, and Alex show up by name across reviews, suggesting a stable team rather than rotating subcontractors
• Multiple customers describe hiring South Bay for annual power washing and returning year after year for additional projects
• Todd has been noted for advising homeowners to wait on services their property did not yet need, putting long-term care over short-term profit

"Rich and Jerry did incredible! They turned our house into a beautiful home. The attention to detail, trust, professionalism was something you can't find these days." - John Petito, Google Review

For homeowners seeking specialty decorative finishes that most painting contractors simply do not offer, Interior Finishing NYC stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% and specialize in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and wallpaper installation. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and personally works alongside his crew on most projects. If you have a challenging project that other painters have turned down, this company regularly takes on work competitors avoid, from pre-war woodwork restoration to ceiling gilding and cork wallpaper installations.

• Dorian provides quotes over phone or video call to save customers time, and adjusts custom color formulas until they match exactly what the client envisions
• Reviewers describe projects spanning commercial offices, Manhattan apartments, and Long Island residences, showing the range of their capabilities
• Team members Jose, Marvin, and Joe appear consistently in reviews as a reliable, skilled unit

"Dori was prompt and very professional. His Venetian plaster work on my kitchen walls are unbelievable. I always get compliments from our guests!" - Charlie Vela, Google Review

With over 12 years in business and a perfect record across every reviewed platform, Big Expert Painting LLC has built a loyal customer base in the Holtsville, NY area. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis handles every estimate personally, often responding the same day including weekends. Customers who start with one room frequently call back for additional projects, and several reviews mention Denis checking in weeks after the job to confirm everything still looks great. If you are looking for a dependable, hands-on contractor for interior or exterior residential painting, Big Expert is a solid option.

• Several bilingual reviewers praise the company in both English and Spanish, reflecting a customer base that values Denis's ability to communicate comfortably in both languages
• Reviewers consistently describe the crew as fast without cutting corners, with multi-room jobs often completed ahead of schedule
• The company holds Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388 and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification

"I've known Dennis for over 7 years now. He's done a number of jobs for me from as small as painting the outside columns on my porch to painting the inside of my house, kitchen, living room, dining room." - Michael Curley, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Todd's Painting, based in Centereach and serving the greater Holtsville, NY area. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, with reviews also spanning Facebook and Yelp. What stands out in the reviews is the sheer number of customers who describe hiring Todd for a second, third, or even fourth project. Kitchen cabinet painting has become a particular specialty, with multiple homeowners describing cabinets that look factory-finished. If you need a painter who can handle everything from a full interior refresh to cabinet refinishing, Todd's Painting is a great fit.

• Several reviewers describe homes that had not been painted in 20 or 30 years, with Todd and his crew bringing them back to life in just a few days
• A recurring theme is Todd's willingness to suggest colors and finishes, helping homeowners who feel unsure about their choices
• Commercial customers have also praised the company, with one describing a two-day commercial painting project completed early both days

"Todd and his crew were a godsend. Fixing up my brother's house who passed away. He not only came quite a distant, but made the house look beautiful after being neglected so long." - Margaret DiStefano, Google Review

With nearly 20 years in business, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings an established track record to the Holtsville, NY area. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. The company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau and has been recognized as a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. Field managers like Chris and Jason appear across reviews, providing consistent on-site supervision that customers appreciate. If you want a larger, well-organized painting company with dedicated project managers, Precision Painting Plus is a reliable choice.

• Multiple long-term customers describe using the company repeatedly since 2014, returning for wallpaper, interior painting, and exterior work
• The crew's habit of helping move furniture back into place and hanging pictures after a job is a small touch that several reviewers highlight

"From start to finish Precision Painting Plus was outstanding!! Communication was constant and fast. Jason was very informative and present throughout." - Lorinda Butler, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Holtsville, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration brings a hands-on, owner-led approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego personally conducts every estimate and stays involved from the first call through the final walkthrough. Reviewers describe entire homes being painted in under 48 hours, and the company also handles drywall repair, wallpaper removal, and exterior restoration work. If you are renovating and need a team that can move quickly while keeping quality high, Long Island Painting and Restoration is worth a call.

• Several customers found the company during home renovations and were impressed enough to hire them for additional projects at new properties
• Crew members Nelson, Delmer, and Joey earn individual praise across reviews for their spackling and wall prep skills
• The company has handled both residential and commercial work, including office buildings and multi-unit properties

"We found Andres through our contractor during our renovation. His team came in and got the job done in 2 days! We are very happy with the work and recommend to everyone." - Chris C, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Painting quality is the most frequently praised aspect of contractors serving Holtsville, NY. Reviewers across multiple companies describe results that exceed their expectations, with several noting that rooms, exteriors, and cabinets look better than they imagined. The attention to surface preparation, clean lines, and even coverage comes up repeatedly, whether the project involves a single bedroom or a full-home repaint.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC earns praise for power washing results that make 20-year-old pavers look new, while their interior painting work draws comments about flawless wall finishes. "Todd and his crew Jerry and Richard did a wonderful job! Not only did they do masterful, professional work - they're also nice, considerate people." - Michele D'Amato, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC stands apart with specialty finishes that most contractors will not attempt, with one reviewer describing Roman clay accent walls that matched inspiration photos perfectly. "Dorian and his team were incredibly helpful. The faux finishing accent wall came out as work of art." - Prince Julien, Google Review. Todd's Painting has built a reputation for kitchen cabinet refinishing, with homeowners describing factory-quality results. "Todd did a fantastic job on making them look like new." - Chad Smith, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration consistently delivers on larger projects, with one customer describing a complete exterior restoration on a nearly 100-year-old home that brought it back to life. "They restored wood rot, scraped, sanded and brought back our home." - D G, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication and professionalism rank among the most common themes in reviews for painting contractors serving Holtsville, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe responsive owners who return calls and texts quickly, provide detailed estimates, and keep homeowners informed throughout the project. Several reviewers specifically mention the relief of working with contractors who do what they say they will do.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC owner Todd Rumfola is frequently described as someone who responds to inquiries within hours, sends digital proposals promptly, and communicates via both text and email. "I reached out for a quote on a Sunday afternoon and received almost an immediate response. Todd came the very next day." - Julia Sisco, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis earns similar praise for direct, personal communication, with customers noting he answers calls himself rather than routing through an office. "Dennis and team were outstanding! I already scheduled another two jobs for him next week at my house." - Ken Smitelli, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County takes a more structured approach, with field managers like Chris and Jason serving as consistent points of contact. "Chris was polite and on time. What he said was done and the guys he sent to do the work were professional and clean." - John Burns, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres Gallego is described as quick to respond and thorough in his walkthrough process. "The owner, did a thorough walk through and gave a very reasonable estimate." - Leah G, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness and scheduling reliability are consistent strengths among painting contractors serving Holtsville, NY. Reviewers regularly describe crews that arrive on time, stick to quoted timelines, and often finish ahead of schedule. For homeowners juggling work and family obligations, this dependability is frequently cited as a deciding factor in recommending a contractor.

Todd's Painting earns repeated mentions for showing up early and completing multi-day projects on or ahead of schedule. "Todd and his crew were excellent, on time, efficient and neat. I'm very happy with the exterior painting of my house." - Rosemarie Fairchild, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration has impressed customers with speed, completing entire homes in as little as 48 hours. "His team came in and got the job done in 2 days!" - Chris C, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe multi-room jobs wrapped up faster than expected, with one reviewer noting the crew finished ahead of a two-day estimate. "I couldn't believe how fast everything was done." - Stafi Thukral, Google Review. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC also receives praise for sticking to promised schedules, with customers noting that Todd texts ahead of arrival and completes power washing projects within the quoted timeframe. "They said they would be completed in a certain amount of time and they were." - Janet Trifaro, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and fair pricing come up often in reviews for painting contractors serving Holtsville, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe getting competitive quotes, with many noting they compared several estimates before choosing their contractor. The overall sentiment is that these companies deliver quality work at prices homeowners feel comfortable with.

Todd's Painting earns frequent mentions for pricing that customers call reasonable relative to the quality delivered. "Very professional and well done. Great price point and done quickly." - Todd Ujazdowski, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers similarly highlight affordability, with several noting Denis provides same-day estimates and transparent pricing. "He always does a great job at a fair price! I would highly recommend using him!" - David Roberts, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres Gallego provides detailed written estimates with full cost breakdowns, and customers frequently describe his pricing as competitive. "Extremely competitive pricing and amazing detail oriented work." - Kiran Kapoor, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County receives mostly positive pricing feedback, though one reviewer noted they felt the job was pricey and recommended shopping around. Most customers, however, describe the value as strong for the quality and professionalism provided. "Great crew, fair prices, quick service, high quality." - Jason Goldsmith, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and property protection are frequently praised by customers of painting contractors serving Holtsville, NY. Reviewers across several companies describe crews that cover furniture and floors before starting, clean up at the end of each day, and leave homes looking spotless once the project is complete. This is a consistent theme regardless of whether the job is interior, exterior, or power washing.

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns some of the strongest cleanup praise, with customers describing crews that go beyond expectations. "The crew that arrived was prompt, courteous, and very professional. They did a great job!" - Denise Valentine, Google Review. Several reviewers mention that the Precision crew helped put furniture back and rehang pictures after completing the paint work. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers note that Todd and his team take care to protect flowers and shrubs during exterior power washing. "They explained everything that had to be done and were careful not to harm the flowers and shrubs alongside my home." - Joan Kyriacou, Google Review. Todd's Painting reviewers describe work areas left spotless after painting. "They left the area clean at the end of every day." - Robert Villano, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC also draws praise for covering personal items before starting and cleaning thoroughly when finished. "They made sure they covered my personal items before starting and moved fast!" - Chantel B, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Painting contractors serving Holtsville, NY offer a range of specialty services beyond standard interior and exterior painting. From decorative plaster finishes to cabinet refinishing and full exterior restoration, homeowners have access to contractors with specialized skills that go well beyond a basic coat of paint.

Interior Finishing NYC leads in specialty decorative work, offering limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic applications, and professional wallpaper installation including grasscloth, cork, and vinyl. "We worked with Dorian and his team in a very complex project including gilding of a ceiling, wallpaper removal, plaster repairs, painting and wallpaper installation." - Rafael Villamizar Alvarez, Google Review. Todd's Painting has developed a strong reputation for kitchen cabinet painting, with homeowners describing results that make old cabinets look brand new. "Keith and I could not be any happier. What a major difference." - Keith Barbone, Google Review. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC combines painting with professional power washing, soft washing, deck staining, and gutter cleaning, making them a one-stop option for homeowners who need both painting and exterior maintenance. Long Island Painting and Restoration handles drywall repair, wallpaper removal, popcorn ceiling removal, and exterior wood rot restoration alongside painting. "Andres and his crew did an incredible job removing two layers of very old wall paper, removing our popcorn ceiling and painting the entire room." - Daniel, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC adds kitchen remodeling, crown molding installation, and wood staining to their painting services.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google