10 Best Painters Near Patchogue, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The Patchogue, NY area is served by a strong group of painting contractors, each with a distinct approach. Reading through hundreds of customer reviews, a few consistent themes emerge: crews who show up when promised, painters who treat homes with care, and owners who stay personally involved from estimate to final walkthrough. The five companies below earned the highest Chooz Scores among painters serving Patchogue, NY.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC leads the group with a Chooz Score of 89.0%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. What stands out in the reviews is the trust factor: customers describe leaving their homes for hours while the crew works, completely at ease. Owner Todd Rumfola personally handles estimates and frequently works alongside his team. Painters Jerry and Rich are called out by name across dozens of reviews, praised for their consistency and precision. With over 10 years in business, a Suffolk County Home Improvement License active through 2027, and lead-safe certification for older homes, South Bay covers both painting and power washing - a convenience that shows up in the reviews. If you want a single contractor who can handle exterior cleaning and interior or exterior painting, South Bay is a strong choice.

• Offers both painting and power washing under one company - convenient for homeowners tackling multiple projects at once.
• Jerry and Rich earn consistent praise for showing up punctually and maintaining craftsmanship through multi-day projects.
• Todd responds to quote requests quickly, including evenings and weekends.
• Lead-safe certified for work on pre-1978 homes, with Suffolk County HI License No. HI-61927 verified through 2027.

"Rich was here for 7 days. He was a very easy person to have around. He was prompt, arriving at 8am every day and worked very carefully to see that every single detail was done correctly and professionally." - Nancy K., Google Review

For homeowners interested in specialty decorative finishes that most Long Island contractors won't attempt, Interior Finishing NYC earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and marmorino. Multiple reviewers describe other contractors declining their projects before Dorian accepted and delivered. The company has been in business for over 22 years and backs all work with a three-year warranty. If you're planning a decorative finish project - accent walls, color drenching, or specialty plaster - Interior Finishing NYC is a good fit.

• Specializes in limewash, Roman clay, and Venetian plaster - techniques that require artistic training most painters lack.
• Dorian is on site working alongside his crew on every project.
• Several customers came back for additional rooms after seeing results from an initial project.

"We originally hired Dorian to just paint our nursery but it came out so amazing we actually had him come back to redo our powder room and our office. We went with limewash in all three rooms and it came out better than we could have imagined." - Frishta Y., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for CRD Painting Inc, which earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 90 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo has built relationships that span not just years but decades - several reviewers describe working with him across multiple homes, not just multiple rooms. One customer has used Camilo across over 5 different homes and an office. Color consulting is another thread running through the reviews: customers describe Camilo suggesting color changes that improve the final result, and reviewers compare his eye to that of an artist. With over 8 years in business and a Suffolk County HI License active through 2027, CRD is a reliable choice. For homeowners who want a painter they can call for the next home they own - not just the next room - CRD Painting is a great fit.

• Customer relationships span 10-15 years and multiple homes - unusual loyalty for any service contractor.
• Color consulting is part of the process, with Camilo offering design input that consistently improves the finished result.
• Takes on both interior and exterior projects, including staining, window frames, and covered porches.
• Long-standing referral relationship with a 60-year local drywall business reflects the trust Camilo has earned in the trade.

"They do quality work, are very neat and clean, they show up on time and have fair prices. Over the last 2 years, they've painted every room in my house as well as the wooden front porch deck!" - Sarah C., Google Review

Also serving the Patchogue, NY area, Big Expert Painting LLC handles a wider scope of work than most painting-only contractors. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, with over 130 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis personally handles every estimate and is mentioned by name across the vast majority of reviews. What sets this company apart is the range: drywall repair, sheetrock replacement, crown molding installation, cabinet resurfacing, power washing, and pool painting all appear throughout customer accounts. The company also holds Suffolk County HI License No. HI-68388 through 2027 and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes. If you have repair work alongside your paint project, Big Expert Painting is a smart call.

• Denis answers calls directly and often responds to quote requests the same day, including weekends.
• One of the few local contractors combining painting, drywall, power washing, and cabinet work under one contact.
• Denis monitors weather for exterior jobs and proactively reschedules when conditions call for it.

"Denis & his team recently painted most rooms of my house. The job was done on-time (even early) and the work was very neat and came out beautiful - I highly recommended BigExpert for your painting needs!" - Lori H., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Patchogue, NY, Todd's Painting brings over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with a presence on Google, Facebook, and Yelp. Cabinet painting has become a signature service: Todd's crew removes doors, brings them to a dedicated shop for professional spray finishing, and reinstalls them - a level of process that shows in the results. Customers also describe a color consulting habit, with Todd recommending changes on the spot that save homeowners from costly repaints. Commercial clients have included an animal hospital and a large congregational space with very high ceilings. For homeowners updating kitchen cabinets or tackling a mix of interior and exterior projects, Todd's Painting is a strong option.

• Cabinet painting is a signature specialty, with doors removed and sprayed at a shop for a factory-level finish.
• Experience in high-ceiling commercial spaces as well as standard residential projects.
• Frequently completes large multi-room jobs in 1-2 days, giving homeowners fast turnarounds.

"Their work was superior and everything came out above our expectations. Top notch painter with 35 years experience and very personable. I highly recommended Todd's Painting for any job you have." - Diana K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Across hundreds of reviews from painters serving Patchogue, NY, quality of work is the single most consistent theme. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, customers describe results that go beyond expectations - Dawn Martin wrote about the skill and attention to detail with the enthusiasm of someone genuinely surprised by the outcome. At CRD Painting Inc, owner Camilo brings a design perspective to every job: customers describe him offering suggestions that improve the result, and the finished work reflects a precision that comes through in reviews describing crisp lines, flawless coverage, and surfaces prepared well before the paint ever goes on. Ryan Nocella noted he was "fairly particular" and "typically tries to DIY as much as possible," but walked away genuinely impressed by the quality of the finished project.

Interior Finishing NYC occupies a different tier of craftsmanship, handling techniques most area contractors won't attempt. Decorative plaster, gilded ceilings, and limewash application require skills that go well beyond standard painting, and Dorian Golemi has built a reputation for exactly this kind of work - several reviewers describe him taking on projects that previous contractors turned down. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the craftsmanship reputation comes through in the prep work: customers describe the crew spackling and addressing imperfections before a brush touches a wall, with results that hold up to close inspection. Jeffrey Negrin described the crew's work as "way above my expectations" on a whole-home repaint that included full skim coating in several rooms. Quality is not a differentiator among the best painters serving Patchogue, NY - it is the baseline.

"We are so happy with their work, the skill, the attention to detail, neat, professional, they did an amazing job! Clients for life for sure." - Dawn M., Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)

"Dorian is an artist and really takes pride in what he does. I can't recommend him enough." - Armen S., Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)

"I'm fairly particular about things and typically try to DIY as much as possible, but I was really impressed with the quality of the work upon seeing the completed project." - Ryan N., Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

In the Patchogue, NY area, customers routinely describe their contractors as easy to reach, prompt to respond, and clear about what to expect throughout the project. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, Julia Sisco described reaching out on a Sunday afternoon and receiving an almost immediate response - owner Todd came out the very next day to provide a quote. That kind of availability is a hallmark of owner-operated businesses and shows up frequently in South Bay's reviews. Big Expert Painting LLC earns similar praise: Denis answers calls directly, and multiple reviewers describe him following up after a project wraps to confirm everything looked right - the kind of check-in that most contractors skip.

At Interior Finishing NYC, Dorian Golemi responds personally to virtually every Google review, and customers describe him handling quotes over phone or video call to save time. For homeowners who prefer a structured project management system, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge offers a different approach: named project managers like David Maloney and Jason Eng are assigned to each job, and customers describe receiving daily updates and prompt replies to every question throughout the project. Cara Gross noted that David provided daily progress reports and was responsive throughout, even after completion. Whether a homeowner prefers direct owner communication or a formal project management structure, painters serving Patchogue, NY offer both options.

"I reached out for a quote on a Sunday afternoon and received almost an immediate response. Todd came the very next day, provided the quote within an hour or so of being at our home and made the booking process so simple and easy." - Julia S., Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)

"Communication was excellent. David was responsive to my questions and concerns throughout the entire process, provided me daily updates and his attention to detail was exceptional." - Cara G., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)

"Camilo responds so fast and scheduled the job quickly. So easy to work with. Would highly recommend." - Mary B., Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is a recurring strength among painting contractors serving Patchogue, NY. At CRD Painting Inc, owner Camilo earns consistent praise for setting realistic timelines and holding to them. Danny Tam noted the initial quote was accurate with no surprises added at the end, and Stephanie described a multi-room interior project that ran from January 5 to January 8, 2026 - exactly as promised, with daily cleanup throughout. At Big Expert Painting LLC, Denis earns similar feedback: Chantel B. received an estimate of 3 days for her project and watched the crew finish in 2 days. Denis is also noted for monitoring weather before exterior jobs and rescheduling proactively - the kind of planning that prevents delays before they start.

At Todd's Painting, fast turnarounds are almost a signature. LaNae Netter described a full exterior staining project that moved from estimate on Thursday to power washing on Friday, with staining completed by the following Thursday - all finished beyond expectations and right on schedule. Multiple Todd's customers describe large multi-room interiors finished in a single day, with crews arriving early and wrapping up by mid-afternoon. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC earns consistent marks for punctuality too: painter Rich showed up at 8am every day across a 7-day project, a track record that customers specifically call out because it's unusual. For homeowners in the Patchogue, NY area working around tight schedules, these contractors take deadlines as seriously as the quality of the work itself.

"Everything was done beyond our expectations!! The crew was on time, courteous, cleaned up everything when they were done, and best of all... our house looks AMAZING!!!!" - LaNae N., Google Review (Todd's Painting)

"The initial quote was accurate with no nonsense charges added at the end. Would definitely use again!" - Danny T., Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

"Gave me an estimate of 3 days to complete and they finished in 2 days." - Chantel B., Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Among painters serving Patchogue, NY, prep work and cleanup receive some of the most detailed attention in customer reviews - suggesting that homeowners here pay close attention, and that the best contractors know it. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, painter Rich has earned specific praise for neatness throughout a project. E Frisina called him "THE NEATEST WORKER" with the kind of emphasis that comes from being genuinely surprised by how little disruption a multi-day project caused. At CRD Painting Inc, the prep work is a recurring topic: multiple reviewers describe the crew covering floors and furniture before a single can is opened and cleaning up each day before leaving. W Palumbo described the work as "flawless due to the amount of surface preparation that isn't skimped on" - noting that thorough prep is what produces a smooth, professional finish that holds up over time.

Big Expert Painting LLC earns similar feedback for how carefully the crew handles spaces outside the painting scope. Karen Chilicki described painters who cleaned up after themselves every day and moved furniture back to its original position when the job was done - details that matter when you're living in a home during a paint project. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the crew takes a structured approach to prep: furniture is moved and covered before work begins, imperfections in walls and ceilings are addressed before painting starts, and a final walk-through is conducted before the team leaves. J Miller described a crew that "didn't leave until we inspected each room" - the kind of finish-line accountability that signals a company taking genuine ownership of the outcome. For homeowners in Patchogue, NY, prep and cleanup aren't afterthoughts for these contractors.

"EXCEPTIONAL job! Rich was courteous, professional, thorough and THE NEATEST WORKER! I highly recommend South Bay Painting and Power Washing." - E. Frisina, Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)

"The painting work they complete is flawless due to the amount of surface preparation that isn't skimped on. The resulting finish is smooth and professionally done, so the attention to detail is what we have come to expect." - W P., Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

"Always cleaned up after themselves and moved furniture back to where it was when they were finished. Our walls look fantastic! Will definitely be using Big Expert Painting again in the future." - Karen C., Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)

"Went above and beyond to make sure the finish was perfect. Covered and cleaned up everything. Didn't leave until we inspected each room." - J M., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing comes up frequently in reviews for painters serving Patchogue, NY, and the consistent theme is value - customers describe feeling like they got more than they paid for. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, Anthony Fragala described the price as "incredibly reasonable" and noted the work was done thoroughly and efficiently. CRD Painting Inc earns similar feedback: owner Camilo is noted for delivering accurate quotes with no surprises at the end, and Karen Rauseo described a situation where she wanted the color changed partway through - Camilo returned the next day and repainted without any additional friction. That kind of flexibility within a fair price point is a recurring theme across CRD's reviews.

Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis earns consistent praise for transparent pricing. Chris B. described the job as done at a "VERY reasonable price" and noted the thoroughness and cleanliness of the work in the same breath - a pairing that reflects customers feeling the price was more than justified by the results. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the value conversation often begins with the estimate: David Maloney is described by multiple customers as upfront about costs and delivering exactly what was agreed upon. Matt Parish summarized it directly: the pricing is "remarkable for the quality paint and attention to detail craftsmanship" received. For homeowners in the Patchogue, NY area comparing quotes, these contractors have a track record of pricing that feels fair before the job starts - and still fair when it's done.

"The price was incredibly reasonable. Not only was the work done thoroughly and efficiently, but my home looks fantastic. I highly recommend them for any power washing or painting needs!" - Anthony F., Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)

"A very thorough and clean job at a VERY reasonable price. Highly recommend this company! Grateful for a beautiful paint job." - Chris B., Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)

"Their pricing is remarkable for the quality paint and attention to detail craftsmanship that you will receive. Trust me, your house will thank you for it." - Matt P., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat business is one of the strongest signals of a reliable contractor, and painters serving Patchogue, NY show unusually strong customer loyalty. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, Joanna Castagnaro described using the company for several years and stated she will keep going back year after year - a sentiment echoed by multiple other reviewers who returned after a first project went well. CRD Painting Inc builds relationships that go well beyond a single project: Marylou Pilewski noted her third time using the company and described herself as already looking forward to the next job. Owner Camilo's color consulting and communication keep customers calling back, and several reviewers describe recommending him to family and friends who then also become repeat customers themselves.

Todd's Painting earns particularly strong loyalty: customers like Lori Lucia have been calling on Todd's crew for over 30 years. Reviewer JPI used Todd's twice and updated their original Google review to document that the second experience matched the first - a pattern that speaks to consistency across time. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the loyalty shows up in the details: R Santos described using the company three times and noted that they "share beneficial ideas too so that the results are far and above what I expected" - the kind of ongoing relationship where the contractor becomes a trusted advisor. In the Patchogue, NY area, these contractors aren't just completing jobs - they're building track records that turn first-time customers into long-term ones.

"We have been using him for several years now and never disappoints in quality and communication as well. Will keep going back year after year!" - Joanna C., Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)

"My third time using this company. They were professional and neat. I loved the whole experience. Can't wait to use them again." - Marylou P., Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)

"This is the 3rd time we've used Precision Painting in our home. They share beneficial ideas too so that the results are far and above what I expected." - R S., Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp