10 Best Painters Near Sayville, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners searching for reliable painters in Sayville, NY have a strong pool of Long Island-based contractors to choose from. Across hundreds of reviews, a few consistent themes emerge: crews that arrive when they say they will, owners who stay personally involved from estimate through final walkthrough, and finished results that hold up well enough to bring customers back for second, third, and even fourth projects years later.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, the highest among local contractors reviewed here. Owner Todd Rumfola runs a dual-service operation covering interior and exterior painting alongside power washing, and his core crew - Rich, Jerry, and Alex - get called out by name across dozens of reviews. Customers describe receiving estimates within hours, along with digital proposals and invoices that make the process unusually organized. With over 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County, and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License (No. HI-61927) verified active through 2027, South Bay has built steady roots across Long Island. If you want an owner-involved team that handles painting and exterior cleaning under one roof, South Bay is a strong pick.

Multiple reviewers describe crews that are not just skilled but genuinely pleasant to have in the house - professional without being stiff, and thorough enough that follow-up calls to fix anything are rare.

• Crew members Rich and Jerry are requested by name on return jobs, suggesting customers feel confident knowing who is showing up at their door
• Todd personally handles estimates and follows up after completion, with reviewers noting same-day callbacks and real-time text updates
• Power washing projects covering decks, driveways, pavers, and vinyl siding are a strong secondary service, with several customers booking painting and washing together

"Todd and his crew Jerry and Richard did a wonderful job! Not only did they do masterful, professional work - they're also nice, considerate people who were a pleasure to have working in the house." - Michele D'Amato, Google Review

For homeowners planning specialty decorative finishes - limewash, Venetian plaster, Roman clay, gilding, or complex wallpaper installations - Interior Finishing NYC stands apart from traditional painting companies. Owner Dorian Golemi, who studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, specializes in high-end finishes that most painting contractors won't attempt. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, with over 120 Google reviews holding a perfect 5.0-star rating. Founded in 2003 and with over 22 years in business, Interior Finishing NYC also backs its work with a three-year workmanship warranty. If you're planning a decorative finish project or complex wallpaper installation - especially one other contractors have declined - Interior Finishing NYC is a good choice.

Dorian works on-site alongside his team for most projects, and several reviewers describe handing over significant trust - including one customer who coordinated the entire job remotely while out of town - with results that matched or exceeded inspiration photos. Projects span residential apartments, corporate offices, and historic pre-war buildings with challenging surfaces.

• Team members Jose, Amir, Marvin, and Joe appear across reviews over multiple years, reflecting a stable, experienced crew
• Dorian provides quotes over phone or video call to save customers time, with pricing consistently described as fair or below other bids received
• The company takes on decorative plaster touch-ups and specialty applications that other well-regarded contractors have passed on

"Dorian and his crew are masters of their craft. I hired them to plaster and skim coat all the walls and ceilings in my apartment and they did a fantastic job for a fair price. I just had them come back for more work." - Armen Stevens, Google Review

Closer to home for many Long Island homeowners, CRD Painting Inc has built the kind of customer relationships that only come from consistent results over time. Owner Camilo and his crew have earned multi-year loyalty from a large share of their customer base, with some relationships spanning 10 to 15 years across multiple homes, renovations, and referrals to friends and family. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, with over 90 Google reviews holding a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Their Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License (No. H-59404) is verified active through 2027. With over 8 years in business, CRD has grown primarily through word-of-mouth. If you want a painter who will learn your home and your preferences over time, CRD is a good fit.

One pattern that stands out in CRD reviews: customers describe being detail-oriented or particular about results - and still ending up completely satisfied. Karen Rauseo changed her mind about the paint color after the job was done, and Camilo came back to repaint without pushing back. Builders and trade professionals refer Camilo regularly, with one Long Island drywall business noting they send every client his way.

• Both interior and exterior projects are served, covering full house repaints, single rooms, garage doors, and exterior power washing
• Color-matching expertise shows up across multiple reviews, with customers describing touch-ups and repairs that blend seamlessly with existing paint
• Multiple reviewers document using CRD across five or more different homes, offices, and rental properties over the years

"I couldn't be happier hiring Camilo and CRD Painting for our latest house project. From beginning to end, the job went so very smooth. The communication, thoroughness, ease and outcome were all what we hoped for and more." - Erika Lazzaruolo, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Big Expert Painting LLC. Owner Denis Erazo earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, with over 130 Google reviews maintaining a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. His Suffolk County Home Improvement License (No. HI-68388) is verified active through 2027, along with EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes. What separates Big Expert from a standard painting company is the scope of work they handle in a single visit - drywall repair, sheetrock, spackle, carpentry, flooring, and painting all done by the same crew without coordinating additional contractors. If you're managing a home improvement project with multiple trades involved, Big Expert Painting is a solid choice.

Several reviewers describe calling Denis for a specific task and ending up expanding the scope once the crew arrived, because the quality impressed them enough to keep adding work. Denis personally follows up after completion - checking in weeks later to confirm everything is still holding - a level of accountability reviewers consistently point out.

• Kitchen cabinet repaints are a recurring specialty, with customers describing results that look like new showroom cabinetry after the project is done
• Commercial work (offices, pool bottoms, outdoor structures) is handled alongside residential projects with the same crew
• Same-day response and flexible scheduling are mentioned repeatedly, including a reviewer who called for a same-day wall patch and TV mount after a mishap

"Denis and his team did an amazing job in my home. Originally I hired him for a few rooms and I was so pleased I asked him to return to do other jobs. His team was professional, clean, timely, and exceeds expectations." - Jackie Hernandez, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Sayville, NY, Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews holding a 5.0-star rating across Google, Facebook, and Yelp. Based in Centereach and serving a wide stretch of Long Island, Todd is known among reviewers for his color advice as much as his paintwork. Multiple customers describe Todd stepping in to recommend a different shade or finish than what they originally requested - and being glad afterward that they listened. He also handles commercial work including an animal hospital exterior and a large congregation gallery with high ceilings, both completed efficiently and at prices reviewers call fair. For homeowners who want a painter with practical design input and a fast, clean team, Todd's Painting is a good choice.

Lori Lucia has used Todd's Painting for over 30 years across multiple properties, a loyalty that is hard to earn and harder to maintain. Ann Douglas, after collecting several competing estimates, says that one look at the inside of Todd's truck told her everything she needed to know about his commitment to the craft.

• Cabinet spray painting is a core specialty - Todd's crew removes doors and hardware, preps thoroughly, and produces factory-level finishes that multiple reviewers compare favorably to replacement
• Fast start-to-finish timelines are common, with several projects going from estimate to completion within 24 to 48 hours
• Staining, power washing, and exterior painting are offered alongside interior work, making full-service seasonal projects straightforward to book

"Todd and his team did an incredible job painting my house. His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient. Couldn't have asked for a better job!" - Brandon Shoman, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Quality of workmanship is the most common theme across reviews for painting contractors in Sayville, NY. For companies like CRD Painting Inc and South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, reviewers describe results that go well beyond a basic coat of paint - careful surface prep, clean edges on architectural details, and finishes that hold up season after season. Sarah Clark, a CRD customer who had Camilo and his crew work through every room in her home over two years, notes that quality, neatness, and communication stayed consistent across every visit. Interior Finishing NYC approaches craftsmanship differently: owner Dorian Golemi's fine arts background allows his company to take on limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, gilding, and other decorative applications that most painting contractors won't touch.

Reviewers for Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge repeatedly use words like "perfection" and "flawless" to describe completed projects, from exterior repaints to full interior skim coat and paint jobs. Todd's Painting customers describe walls looking brand new even in homes that haven't been painted in 20 or 30 years, with Rachel Ulrich noting her 100-year-old home looked completely refreshed after the job. Big Expert Painting LLC rounds out the quality picture with a crew that handles sheetrock repair, spackle, and drywall prep alongside the painting itself - so surfaces are done right before any paint is applied.

• Interior Finishing NYC has taken on decorative plaster touch-ups that other well-regarded contractors declined, with reviewers describing seamless matches to existing specialty finishes
• CRD Painting Inc customers describe architectural details - moldings, wainscoting, spiral staircases - handled with the same care as flat walls

"Absolutely five stars! Impeccable precision, a great eye for style, and top-quality work. The flowered wallpaper in our kitchen looks stunning - elegant and perfectly executed." - Bjorn de Carro, Google Review"Camillo and his crew exceeded my expectations! They were so professional and handled all of my detailed requests like a pro - still managing to make everything look better than expected! It's rare to find a contractor that shows up on time and respects their customers as much as they do!" - Andrea Chadaev, Google Review"Perfection - is how I'd describe it! This company was so professional from start to finish and I will definitely be using them for my next project." - Kevin Kitson, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Across hundreds of reviews for painters in Sayville, NY, communication stands out as one of the most appreciated qualities - and one of the clearest differentiators between contractors. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC owner Todd Rumfola receives repeated praise for responding to calls and texts within hours, providing digital estimates the same day he visits, and following up with customers after the job is done. Katie Rosario described receiving a texted and emailed estimate less than an hour after Todd left her home. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi handles inquiries quickly and often provides quotes over phone or video call to save customers a trip, which reviewers in NYC and on Long Island both find especially practical for busy schedules.

For Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, project manager David Maloney is named in the majority of positive reviews for explaining project scope clearly, checking in throughout the job, and being reachable throughout. CRD Painting Inc owner Camilo is described as easy to reach by text or phone, with fast turnaround on scheduling after the estimate is agreed. Todd's Painting customers frequently mention that Todd stayed in contact through photos and updates during exterior projects, particularly useful for customers who couldn't be home every day. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis is noted for answering calls directly rather than routing through an office, including on weekends.

"It was perfection from the first phone call to formal estimate and the completion of the work." - Darren Chan, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)"A very positive experience! From the estimate to job completion, Brendan was there. Communication was frequent and clear. I always knew what point they were at." - Theresa Westergard, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)"South Bay Painting and Power Washing were excellent. I called to set up an estimate and Todd responded right away, showed up when he said he was going to, emailed and texted the estimate not even an hour later." - Katie Rosario, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Punctuality and on-schedule completion are two of the most consistent themes across painter reviews in Sayville, NY. Todd's Painting customers regularly describe fast turnarounds - Danielle Buglino had her project completed within 48 hours of the estimate, while Laura Contino's bathroom, foyer, and entryway were finished between 8am and 3pm in a single day. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC receives repeated praise for showing up exactly when promised, with Mark Pfisterer describing his experience as "such a smooth experience" specifically because the crew arrived on time and finished cleanly. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis is noted for sticking to the timelines he quotes, with multiple reviewers surprised that the job wrapped up ahead of the original estimate.

CRD Painting Inc reviews frequently note that Camilo's crew arrives on time every day of multi-day projects without requiring reminders or follow-up calls. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge handled Jeffrey Negrin's full 2,300-square-foot home repaint - including full skim coating in several rooms - and Negrin described the crew's efficiency as exceeding every previous contractor he'd worked with. Interior Finishing NYC reviewers note that Dorian builds realistic timelines into his estimates, with B Rauch noting the team finished ahead of schedule with no hidden costs added afterward.

"They showed up punctually, cleaned up and left. Level of experience showed in their work. Such a smooth experience, will use them again." - Mark Pfisterer, Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)"Todd and his crew were excellent, on time, efficient and neat. I'm very happy with the exterior painting of my house. I would recommend him without a doubt!" - Rosemarie Fairchild, Google Review (Todd's Painting)"Dorian and his team finished ahead of schedule, on time, no hidden costs, did everything they said they would." - B Rauch, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and surface preparation are two of the most frequently mentioned factors in reviews for painting contractors in Sayville, NY. CRD Painting Inc customers consistently describe floors and furniture covered before a single drop is applied, with daily cleanup leaving homes usable at the end of each workday. Anthony LoCurto had his entryway, kitchen, and dining room painted and noted the crew covered all flooring and furniture, then left the home in excellent condition. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge received the same feedback from homeowners who had multi-day projects, with Richard Kasten describing the crew as going above and beyond what was required, including cleaning up at the end of each day without being asked.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC painters are noted for leaving job sites clean even on power washing projects, where mess is harder to contain. Big Expert Painting LLC handles prep work beyond just protecting furniture - skim coating, spackling, and drywall repair are all done before any paint is applied, which reviewers describe as producing a noticeably smoother finish than what they've received from other contractors. Todd's Painting customers describe protected areas, clean edges, and no debris left behind, with Christine Curzio noting Todd helped her plan which furniture to move before the crew arrived to make the process less stressful.

"Camilo and his team painted my entry way, kitchen and dining room. Very easy to work with. Showed up when they said they would. Covered all my flooring and furniture and left my home in excellent condition." - Anthony LoCurto, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"These guys did an amazing job. Went above and beyond to make sure the finish was perfect. Covered and cleaned up everything. Didn't leave until we inspected each room." - J Miller, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)"Jerry was the painter who painted my co-op, was always on time. Very friendly and professional. Everything was kept clean - couldn't be happier with the results." - Susan Birk, Google Review (South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Several of the top-rated painting contractors serving Sayville, NY have built specific followings for specialty work that goes well beyond standard interior repaints. Interior Finishing NYC is the clearest example: owner Dorian Golemi holds a fine arts degree and specializes in decorative techniques including limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, gilding, marmorino, and metallic applications. Multiple reviewers note that Dorian took on their projects after other contractors declined, and the results consistently matched or exceeded inspiration photos. Leanne Burns had Roman clay applied in her master bedroom and described the attention to detail as going well beyond what she'd expected from a standard painting company.

Todd's Painting and Big Expert Painting LLC both have strong followings specifically for kitchen cabinet repaints - a specialty that requires thorough prep, proper primer, and careful spray work to achieve a smooth finish. Todd's crew removes all cabinet doors and hardware before spray painting, and multiple customers describe results that look comparable to new cabinetry. Ronnie Morales had Big Expert paint old kitchen cabinets that now look like they came directly from a showroom, including new hardware installed by the same crew. CRD Painting Inc also handles kitchen cabinet painting alongside standard wall and ceiling work, with Elissa Lynch describing her kitchen cabinets turning out more beautiful than she imagined possible.

"We had him do a Roman Clay application in our master bedroom and we couldn't be happier. His attention to detail and skillful application really went the extra mile." - Leanne Burns, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)"Todd's painting did an excellent job spray painting my kitchen cabinets. My wife and I could not be any happier. They came in, removed all of the cabinet doors and the faces, and the end result is beautiful." - Keith Barbone, Google Review (Todd's Painting)"Big Expert painting was amazing! Dennis and his crew are experts at their craft! They painted my old outdated kitchen cabinets and made them look like they came direct from the showroom! They also installed new hardware." - Ronnie Morales, Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Fair, competitive pricing is a recurring theme across reviews for painting contractors in Sayville, NY - and notably, most reviewers emphasize value rather than just low cost. CRD Painting Inc is described across dozens of reviews as offering "fair and reasonable" pricing, with Edgardo Contreras calling Camilo the best painter on Long Island and noting his prices as part of the overall value. Interior Finishing NYC is consistently noted as being priced below other bids received, which surprises many customers given the specialty nature of the work - Tova Kalkstein noted Dorian was more affordable than every other painter she contacted. Todd's Painting reviewer Chris Mc received such a competitive price that he ended up adding scope to the project beyond what he originally planned.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge draws customers who collect multiple estimates before deciding: Helen Grygo got three quotes and chose Precision as the most reasonably priced, while Joe C described David's pricing as the reason he called despite finding them through a competitor recommendation. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers note pricing as reasonable across both painting and power washing services, with several mentioning they had used the company for years specifically because they never felt overcharged. Big Expert Painting LLC customers frequently note that Denis's crew delivers results that would cost more from other contractors - and with the added value of handling drywall and carpentry in the same visit.

"Dorian was very responsive and courteous, and did a great job! He was also more affordable than the other painters we called." - Tova Kalkstein, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)"The price was fair. And I couldn't believe how fast everything was done. Not only that but he swept up the leaves he tracked in. Who does that nowadays?" - Stafi Thukral, Google Review (Big Expert Painting LLC)"I hired Precision Painting after getting 3 estimates. They are by far the most reasonably priced. I had the pleasure of dealing with David Maloney, the project manager. He was very professional and explained everything clearly." - Helen Grygo, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp