Homeowners in Farmingville, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing a different specialty and approach to the table. Whether you need a full interior repaint, decorative finishes, cabinet work, or exterior power washing, the companies serving this Suffolk County community consistently earn praise for honest pricing, reliable scheduling, and clean job sites. Here are the top-rated painting contractors based on our Chooz Score analysis.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, with additional perfect ratings of 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Todd Rumfola runs this veteran-owned company out of East Islip, with over 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe leaving their homes in Todd's hands without hesitation, trusting the crew to work independently while they ran errands or were away at work. If you need reliable power washing or painting and want a contractor who communicates every step of the way, South Bay is a strong fit.
Customers frequently describe Todd as someone who will talk them out of unnecessary work. One reviewer noted that Todd advised waiting before power washing because the surface was not ready, turning down an easy sale to protect the homeowner's investment. Crew members Rich, Jerry, and Alex earn consistent praise across projects ranging from paver cleaning to full interior repaints.
- Several reviewers describe hiring South Bay for a second, third, or even fourth project, with repeat business spanning multiple years and different types of work
- Customers note that Todd texts updates throughout the job and responds to inquiries the same day, including weekends
- Multiple reviews highlight that pavers, decks, and siding looked brand new after power washing, even on surfaces over 20 years old
"We are very pleased with the work performed by Todd from South Bay. Our house and property look magnificent. We were amazed how beautiful our property looks. Todd was honest, friendly, and did a fantastic job." - Paul Weber, Google Review
For homeowners in Farmingville, NY looking for specialty decorative finishes that most contractors will not attempt, Interior Finishing NYC stands apart. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi, who studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, brings over 22 years in business and specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and wallpaper installation. If you have a project that other painters have turned down or need an artistic finish for an accent wall, Dorian and his crew are a strong choice.
What is notable about the reviews is how often customers describe Dorian personally adjusting paint and plaster formulas on site until the color matched their vision exactly. Team members Jose, Marvin, and Joe appear across reviews as a consistent unit, and several customers mention that Dorian completed full apartment repaints in a single day.
- Reviewers consistently describe wallpaper installations with no visible seams, even on difficult surfaces like cork and grasscloth
- Multiple customers hired Dorian after other contractors either refused the job or delivered unsatisfactory results
- Commercial clients including offices, hotels, and retail spaces appear alongside residential projects in the review record
"Dorian and his team did an excellent job installing textured wallpapers and Roman clay application for the walls. They were very detail oriented, punctual and professional. Would definitely recommend." - Dwellistic LLC, Google Review
With over 12 years in business and a perfect record across platforms, Big Expert Painting LLC has built a loyal following on Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis handles every estimate personally and is known for following up weeks after a project to make sure everything still looks right. If you want a responsive contractor who provides same-day estimates, including on weekends, Big Expert is worth contacting.
A pattern in the reviews is how many customers started with a small job and then immediately hired Denis back for additional rooms or projects. Several reviewers mention having Denis return three or four times over the years for different areas of their home. The crew is consistently described as fast without cutting corners, and multiple customers note how carefully furniture and floors were covered before work began.
- Customers describe complete room turnarounds in one to two days, with projects finished on or ahead of schedule
- Bilingual service noted by several Spanish-speaking reviewers who appreciated being able to communicate in their preferred language
- Power washing, drywall repair, crown molding, and cabinet work are frequently bundled alongside painting projects
"Initially, I had Denis come to do three rooms of my home. We were so impressed that we had him and his crew come back to do two more rooms and patch up a few things around the house." - Sara Galante, Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Todd's Painting. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, with additional reviews on Facebook and Yelp. Based in Centereach, this company has become a go-to for kitchen cabinet painting across Suffolk County, with dozens of reviewers specifically praising the cabinet refinishing results. If you are considering updating your kitchen without the cost of a full renovation, Todd's Painting is a good fit.
One of the most telling patterns in the reviews is how many customers describe homes that had not been painted in 20 or even 30 years. Todd and his crew take on these large-scale refreshes, including cathedral ceilings and detailed trim work, and consistently finish on time. Several reviewers mention that Todd personally walked through each room at the end to confirm every detail met expectations.
- Kitchen cabinet spray painting is a standout specialty, with multiple reviewers describing cabinets that look factory-finished
- Customers describe Todd arriving early each morning with his crew ready to work, with no delays across multi-day projects
- Several reviews mention Todd traveling a significant distance to complete jobs, showing flexibility in his service range
"Todd and his crew were a godsend. Fixing up my brother's house who passed away. He not only came quite a distant, but made the house look beautiful after being neglected so long. Definitely a keeper." - Margaret DiStefano, Google Review
When it comes to thorough preparation and protecting your home during the painting process, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. With nearly two decades in business, they have earned BBB accreditation and recognition as a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. If you have a historic home or a complex exterior project that requires careful surface preparation, Precision Painting Plus has the experience to handle it.
Reviewers frequently describe a well-organized operation where a field manager visits before the project to review colors and scope, and then a dedicated crew handles the work from start to finish. Manager Chris is mentioned by name in several reviews for his responsiveness and professionalism.
- Multiple customers describe furniture carefully covered and floors protected as standard practice, with rooms left cleaner than before the crew arrived
- Exterior projects on older homes receive particular praise, including a 230-year-old house that required extensive prep and multiple surface types
"From the estimate visit to the job completion Precision Painting was competent, responsive and friendly. They did a fine job." - Bill Q, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Farmingville, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration brings a hands-on, owner-led approach that customers consistently praise. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego is known for spending extended time on initial walkthroughs, offering color consultations and detailed written estimates before any work begins. If you want a contractor who will invest real time understanding your vision before picking up a brush, this company is a good choice.
The speed and efficiency of Andres's crew stands out across the reviews. Multiple customers describe full home interiors completed in under 48 hours, and several renovation projects where the painting team coordinated seamlessly with general contractors. Crew size often reaches five or six painters, allowing large projects to be wrapped up quickly without sacrificing quality.
- Several customers found Long Island Painting through word-of-mouth referrals and describe the experience as exceeding what friends and family had promised
- Andres offers honest color recommendations, with reviewers noting he steered them toward choices that looked better than what they originally planned
- Exterior projects on older homes, including a nearly 100-year-old house with a detached garage, are handled with care for wood restoration and surface prep
"Andres and his team went above and beyond. Andrea's had great recommendations and knows his craft. They left our home better than when they arrived. We recommended them to our friends and they too were happy." - Jenny Efron, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
