Best Painters Near Mastic Beach, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Mastic Beach, NY have access to a strong group of painting contractors, each with a well-documented track record built across hundreds of verified reviews. The top-rated companies on Chooz Painters cover everything from quick single-room refreshes to full exterior and interior overhauls, with consistent five-star ratings driven by on-time crews, thorough prep work, and reliable follow-through.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Based in Centereach and serving the broader Suffolk County area, Todd's Painting handles everything from exterior staining and power washing to full interior jobs, but cabinet painting comes up again and again as a standout specialty. Crews arrive on time, cover all furniture, and regularly finish ahead of schedule. Several reviewers describe going back to Todd for multiple properties, and a few note that he steered them away from paint colors that wouldn't have worked - and they were grateful for it. If you're looking for a contractor who brings honest advice alongside fast, quality work, Todd's Painting is a strong fit.

• Cabinet painting comes up repeatedly as a specialty - spray-finished doors and drawer fronts are a frequent project type, with customers describing results that rival new cabinetry
• Commercial and residential work both appear in the reviews, including an animal hospital exterior and a congregation gallery with very high ceilings, completed quickly and cleanly
• Customers with older or neglected properties describe the crew restoring homes that hadn't been painted in 20 to 30 years, with results that made a dramatic difference

"Todd recommended to change it which I was so grateful for. The room came out perfect and we all were happy!! Other painters would of just painted the room with the wrong color." - Karen Fox, Google Review

For larger projects that benefit from a structured, manager-led process, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings a polished operation built around consistent communication and oversight. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. The company has been in business for nearly two decades and holds accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2015. Named project managers - Chris, Jason, David, and Matt - appear throughout the reviews, with customers noting daily check-ins and thorough walkthroughs at the start and end of every project. Customers who start with one room routinely return for full-home jobs. If you're planning a significant project and want a company with formal oversight and a proven process, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is worth a call.

• Named project managers keep customers informed throughout, with several reviewers noting daily updates and immediate follow-up when small corrections were needed
• Specialty work is part of the portfolio - wallpaper removal, skim coating, deck repairs, and exterior painting on historic homes all appear across the reviews
• One reviewer chose the company after consulting with three contractors to repaint the exterior of a 230-year-old home; the result exceeded expectations
• Repeat hiring and family referrals are common, with customers returning for second, third, and even fourth projects over the years

"From start to finish Precision Painting Plus was outstanding!! Communication was constant and fast. Jason was very informative and present throughout." - Lorinda Butler, Google Review

Also serving the Mastic Beach, NY area, Long Island Painting and Restoration stands out for how closely owner Andres Gallego stays involved from first call to final cleanup. They hold a Chooz Score of 84.2%, with over 55 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating - every single one a five-star review - and over 6 years serving Nassau and Suffolk counties. Andres shows up personally for estimates, offers color recommendations, and brings crews that include foreman Nelson and other named crew members who appear by name in customer reviews. Restoration work - including scraping, sanding, wood rot repair, and popcorn ceiling removal - is part of the company's skill set. If you've recently purchased a home and need a full refresh, or you have older walls with real prep challenges, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a good fit.

• Turnaround times are a consistent highlight - large whole-home projects have been wrapped up in a single day, and full interior paint jobs for 4-bedroom homes completed in under 48 hours
• Andres gives honest color input during consultations, with customers describing him steering them toward choices that will actually look right in their space
• Commercial projects are part of the workload, including office spaces and commercial buildings with tight schedules

"Andre was very honest with color picking and gave us his opinion on what will look the best. We had our WHOLE home painted. Walls had to be stripped, spackled and painted - along with the moldings and doors." - Elizabete Barros, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Mastic Beach, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings over 28 years in business and a customer base that keeps calling back year after year. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating alongside 5.0 stars on Yelp, earning a Chooz Score of 81.5%. Crew lead Manny is front and center in nearly every review - customers describe detailed pre-job conversations about scope, finishes, and color options before any work begins. Complex architectural projects come up often: vaulted ceilings, lofts, stair railings, built-in bookcases, and walls that required significant spackle and repair before paint could be applied. If you want a company with deep Long Island roots and decades of experience handling projects that go beyond standard painting, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is a reliable choice.

• Prep work is a recurring theme - customers describe walls vacuumed, floors papered, furniture covered in plastic, and pictures carefully removed and replaced exactly where they started
• Manny works around customer schedules, especially for phased projects or clients balancing busy households during the work
• Cabinet refinishing, ornate molding work, and high-ceiling rooms with lofts and stairs all appear across the reviews as project types the crew handles with confidence

"My project required significant prep work for peeling tape joints and nail pop outs that were a major concern for me. The crew painted my great room with vaulted ceilings, loft, stairs and home office." - Sharon D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Professionalism and clear communication run through nearly every review for painting contractors serving Mastic Beach, NY. From the initial phone call to the post-job walkthrough, customers describe contractors who are easy to reach, straightforward about scope and pricing, and consistent in following through on what they promise. Several reviewers note that responsiveness alone made the difference in who they chose to hire.

Todd's Painting draws consistent mentions of Todd's personal availability - customers describe texting him about small concerns and hearing back within a day or two. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, the communication is more structured: named project managers like Jason, Chris, and David are credited in review after review for daily check-ins and clear updates throughout each project. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres Gallego earns notes for quick response times and for being present not just at the estimate but throughout the work itself. At Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, Manny is praised for walking customers through every detail of the scope before work begins - colors, finishes, and what to expect each day - so there are no surprises.

"Easy to work with, Manny always responds to your calls promptly, work is on point and clean." - Michael Erdman, Google Review"Todd and his team did an incredible job painting my house. His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient." - Brandon Shoman, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

On-time arrival and efficient completion come up consistently across reviews for painting contractors serving Mastic Beach, NY. Customers repeatedly describe crews that arrived when they said they would - often early - and finished projects faster than expected without cutting corners. For many reviewers, the speed of completion was a genuine surprise.

Todd's Painting has a particularly strong track record for turnaround: one customer had multiple rooms finished the day after the estimate, and another had a bathroom, foyer, and entryway wrapped up between 8am and 3pm in a single visit. Long Island Painting and Restoration draws similar notes - a 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home was completed in under 48 hours, and a full apartment finished in just a few hours. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, projects start and close on the agreed timeline, with a project manager present to keep things moving. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns praise for arriving punctually each day across multi-day projects and finishing on schedule even when significant spackle or drywall repair was involved.

"He stopped by to give me an estimate, and the very next day he and his crew were at my house early and finished with everything before 5pm." - Jenna Fanelli, Google Review"They offered a very competitive price on a large project. They completed the project for the price they proposed and on time. In my experience this is very rare." - Peter Alcazar, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Thorough prep and careful cleanup are two of the most consistent themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Mastic Beach, NY. Customers don't just mention that things were cleaned up - they describe the details: covered furniture, protected floors, carefully removed décor, and spaces left spotless at the end of each day. For many homeowners, the care taken before and after the painting is what earns the repeat call.

Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp draws some of the most detailed prep descriptions in the reviews - customers mention walls vacuumed before paint is applied, paper laid on floors, plastic draped over furniture, and pictures and decorations replaced exactly where they were when the crew arrived. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, several reviewers describe every surface carefully protected from the moment the crew walks in, with furniture moved and replaced after the job is complete. Todd's Painting reviews note crews that leave work areas clean at the end of each day, returning consistently until the project is fully finished. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns notes for end-of-job cleanups that leave homes spotless, with crew members reviewing work together before packing up.

"When they were done there was nothing for me to clean up. Best paint job I ever had!!!" - Stuart Rock, Google Review"They showed up on time every day, respectful, cleaned up at the end of each day and did excellent work. My house looks brand new." - Vanessa, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Quality and attention to detail come through clearly across reviews for painting contractors in the Mastic Beach, NY area. Customers describe results that hold up, color matches that are accurate, and finishes that hold up well even on complex architectural surfaces. Several reviewers mention being particular about their homes and still coming away impressed.

Todd's Painting earns standout reviews for cabinet work - customers describe the spray-finish process on doors and drawer fronts as a genuine specialty, with results that rival custom cabinetry. Interior projects involving cathedral ceilings, 17-foot living rooms, and stair railings and spindles also come up frequently. Long Island Painting and Restoration handles restoration work that goes beyond standard painting - wood rot repair, popcorn ceiling removal, and skim coating appear regularly, and customers describe older homes brought back to near-new condition. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp crews tackle ornate molding, built-in bookcases, and vaulted ceiling rooms with lofts and stairs. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County draws praise for exterior work on older and complex homes, with customers noting that the finished product looked better than they expected going in.

"Painting cabinets is his personal specialty and he's a true master of his craft!" - Darlene Romashko, Google Review"From communication to the actual job being done, if you need work done, please call this company." - K Proctor, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Fair and competitive pricing comes up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Mastic Beach, NY. Customers describe receiving estimates that felt reasonable for the scope of work, having those quotes honored at completion, and feeling the results were worth what they paid. Several reviewers specifically mention comparing multiple bids and choosing based on both price and confidence in the company.

At Long Island Painting and Restoration, multiple reviewers describe getting quotes from several companies and selecting this one because the price was the most competitive - and the quality matched. Todd's Painting earns notes for pricing that left customers comfortable adding more work to their original scope once they saw the estimate. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is praised for honoring quoted prices on large projects - something reviewers note is not common in the home services industry. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp draws notes for reasonable pricing paired with the reliability that comes from over 28 years of consistent results. None of the top-rated companies in this market carry a reputation for being the cheapest option, but customers across all four describe feeling the value was there.

"Price was the best compared to other companies I was quoted from." - N G, Google Review"He's a true professional and I found his pricing to be very fair." - Paul Genova, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google