Homeowners in Mastic, NY have a strong set of painting contractors to consider across Suffolk County. Whether you're refreshing kitchen cabinets, tackling a full exterior on an older Long Island home, or handling a commercial space, the top painters on Chooz Painters in this area have built their reputations on reliability, thorough prep, and consistent follow-through. Here are the top-rated painters in Mastic, NY, ranked by Chooz Score.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Based in Centereach and serving Suffolk County broadly, Todd and his crew handle everything from interior rooms and kitchen cabinet refinishing to exterior staining, deck work, and commercial jobs for businesses and congregations. One pattern that stands out in the reviews is how often customers mention Todd returning within a day or two to address any area they were not fully satisfied with - no arguments, no delay. Another recurring detail: customers describe Todd stepping in with color advice and steering them away from choices they might have regretted. If you want a painter who stays accountable after the job is done and communicates throughout, Todd's Painting is a strong choice.
Beyond residential work, Todd has painted commercial offices, an animal hospital, and a congregation gallery with high ceilings - projects that require different logistics than a typical house job. That versatility comes through in the reviews, where customers repeatedly describe a crew that adapts to the scope without adding complications.
- Customers describe calling Todd back for multiple projects across different properties, with one long-term client noting she has trusted him for over 30 years.
- Todd's crew divides tasks from the start, with each person assigned a specific role, which reviewers say keeps jobs moving efficiently from day one.
- Several reviewers mention Todd identified and painted additional items outside the original scope - sheds, fences, shutters - that became highlights of the finished project.
"We are thrilled with our home after Todd's Painting gave it a much needed refresh. Easy to work with, communicative, quality workmanship, attention to detail, tidy and timely! I appreciated knowing when to expect them each day and that they arrived promptly. We are already planning 2 more projects with them!" - Angie Evenson, Google Review
For homeowners who want a company with deep roots across Suffolk County and a more structured operation, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has nearly two decades in business and a Chooz Score of 84.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. The company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015 and is a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. What sets them apart operationally is the project manager model - named managers like Jason, David, and Matt stay involved from estimate through final walkthrough, which customers say makes a real difference on multi-day projects. If you prefer a painting company that runs with clear processes and a dedicated point of contact rather than a single owner handling everything, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is worth considering.
The company handles complex and commercial work alongside standard residential jobs - HOA buildings, after-hours signage, wallpaper installation, and ceiling repair from flood damage have all appeared in reviews. One customer specifically praised them for completing a large project exactly on budget with no overruns, calling it genuinely rare in her experience with home services.
- Multiple customers describe returning for a second or third project after their first experience, with one who started with a single bedroom eventually having the whole house done.
- Named crew members - including foreman Steve and manager Jason - get specific mentions for quality and for keeping customers informed at each stage of the job.
- At least one customer described leaving for the full duration of the project and returning to find everything completed to spec, with the project manager staying in contact throughout.
"From start to finish Precision Painting Plus was outstanding!! Communication was constant and fast. Jason was very informative and present throughout. Trish was quick with the finances and paint colors. Fernando and his crew were friendly, courteous and quick with their painting. Everything was left incredibly clean." - Lorinda Butler, Google Review
A hands-on owner sets Long Island Painting and Restoration apart from most options in the area. Owner Andres Gallego handles estimates personally, offers color recommendations during the walkthrough, and stays in touch through the job rather than delegating entirely once the crew is on site. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews - every single one a 5.0-star rating. Based in Bay Shore and serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, the company has built its reputation almost entirely through referrals in over 6 years in business. They are a particularly good fit for first-time homeowners, buyers inheriting someone else's color choices, or homeowners tackling an older property that needs restoration work alongside fresh paint.
The reviews include commercial projects alongside residential jobs - a medical building and an office space were both completed under tight timelines without complaints. Andres has earned a reputation for giving direct, honest opinions on color rather than simply agreeing with whatever the customer suggests, which several reviewers specifically appreciated.
- Customers who commissioned whole-home repaints describe crews finishing ahead of the estimated timeline without sacrificing quality, with one six-person crew completing a large project in a single day.
- The company handles restoration work - stripping wallpaper, repairing wood rot, scraping and sanding on older exteriors - not just standard painting, which sets them apart for older Long Island properties.
- Several reviewers describe Andres as their go-to painter after a first experience, with multiple properties and return visits already scheduled.
"From initial consultation to the final product, we had a 10/10 experience with Andres and his team. Pricing was fair and competitive. His team did an efficient, professional, clean job and even got the job completed quicker than expected. Highly Recommend!" - Patrick Healy, Google Review
Rounding out the top painters in Mastic, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings nearly 30 years in business to every job. Based in Yaphank and operating since 1997, they earned a Chooz Score of 81.5% with over 190 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus a 5.0-star rating on Yelp. They hold active licenses in both Suffolk and Nassau counties. Crew foreman Manny runs jobs with a structured, task-divided approach - reviewers consistently describe arriving to find furniture covered, walls vacuumed and taped, and a team where each person has a clear assignment from the first hour. If you have a project that involves significant prep work - extensive spackle, vaulted ceilings, wallpaper removal, or older walls with multiple layers - Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is built for that kind of job.
The company's depth of customer relationships stands out even in a field where repeat business is common. Reviewers describe using Anthony's for 10, 15, and over 20 years across multiple homes and family members. Manny's flexibility around schedules is also noted - several customers say he accommodated their timing across jobs that required multiple visits over different days.
- Manny is known for sticking to stated timelines - reviewers call this out specifically after dealing with other contractors who made promises they did not keep.
- The same crew handles a job from start to finish, which customers say contributes to quality consistency compared to companies that swap workers mid-project.
- Anthony's handles a wide range of surfaces beyond drywall - custom fences, coops, stair railings and spindles, and cabinet refinishing all appear in recent reviews.
"Manny and his crew did a great job in removing wallpaper and painting. They were always on time and always cleaned up afterwards. Manny was especially helpful in working around my schedule in completing several different jobs." - Norma Spund, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
