5 Best Painters Near Brookhaven, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in the Brookhaven, NY area have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing a different combination of services, team structure, and customer experience. Across hundreds of reviews, customers in and around Suffolk County consistently highlight responsive communication, careful prep work, and crews that treat homes with respect.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, with additional ratings of 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. With over 10 years in business across Nassau and Suffolk County, owner Todd Rumfola has built a company where customers routinely return for second and third projects. Several reviewers mention feeling comfortable leaving their homes while the crew worked, and a number of power washing customers describe surfaces looking brand new after years of buildup. If you want an owner-operated company where the same person handles your estimate, does the work, and follows up afterward, South Bay is a strong choice.

• Multiple reviewers describe receiving a quote within hours of their initial call, including on weekends
• Power washing customers frequently note that pavers and siding looked decades younger after service
• Crew members Rich, Jerry, and Alex are praised individually across unrelated projects for consistent quality

"Working with South Bay was such a great experience! I reached out for a quote on a Sunday afternoon and received almost an immediate response. Todd came the very next day, provided the quote within an hour or so of being at our home and made the whole process so easy." - Julia Sisco, Google Review

For homeowners who need both painting and repair work handled by a single company, Big Expert Painting LLC offers a broad range of services. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Denis is named in nearly every review, and customers describe him as someone who answers his phone directly and follows through weeks after a project wraps. Several reviewers hired Big Expert for a small job, then immediately booked additional work after seeing the results. If you are looking for a contractor who handles everything from drywall repair to full exterior repaints and power washing at competitive rates, Big Expert is a good fit.

• Bilingual service noted by several reviewers who appreciated being able to communicate in Spanish
• Customers describe Denis sweeping up tracked-in leaves and leaving spaces cleaner than he found them
• Several reviews mention same-week scheduling availability, even during peak summer months

"5 STARS!!! Dennis and team were outstanding! I already scheduled another two jobs for him next week at my house and referred him to two people. Very professional, very honest, very fair and very good work." - Ken Smitelli, Google Review

With over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, Todd's Painting has earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Reviews span Google, Facebook, and Yelp, and what stands out most is the speed at which projects are completed. Multiple customers describe entire interior repaints finished in a single day or two, and several mention that Todd personally handles color selection advice alongside the painting itself. Homeowners who have put off painting for years and want to get it done quickly without sacrificing quality will find Todd's Painting a natural match.

• Kitchen cabinet painting is a frequently praised specialty, with customers describing factory-like finishes
• Exterior staining projects draw repeat customers who return annually for deck and fence maintenance
• One customer noted Todd's truck was so organized it gave her confidence in the quality of his work before he even started

"Excellent job! My house came out great! They were responsive, punctual and pricing was fair! My 6yr old son said our house looks sooooo pretty and doesn't look like a haunted house anymore!!!" - Jacquelyn Riker, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Brookhaven, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. They are 100% recommended on Facebook and hold an accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2015, backed by over 18 years in business. What distinguishes this company is the consistency of its field crews. Names like Carlos, Jose, and Amilcar appear across reviews from completely different customers, which suggests a stable in-house team rather than rotating subcontractors. If your project involves a whole-home repaint or complex multi-room renovation where crew consistency matters, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is worth considering.

• Territory manager David Maloney is praised by name in numerous reviews for clear communication and follow-through
• Customers with multi-day projects describe the house being left in usable condition at the end of each workday
• One homeowner who is a contractor himself praised their process as a model for the industry

"I've owned a number of homes before. These guys were way above my expectations. They were there every day for full days and performed quality work on my 2300 square foot home." - Jeffrey Negrin, Google Review

Also serving the Brookhaven, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings nearly two decades of experience and a Chooz Score of 84.5%. They had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating at the time of our analysis, and they are a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner and BBB accredited since 2015. Reviewers frequently describe this company as a reliable option for exterior work on older homes, including prep-intensive projects that require scraping, priming, and multiple coats. If you own an older home in Suffolk County and want a company experienced with the specific challenges that come with it, this is a strong option.

• Field manager Chris is frequently praised for punctuality and clear communication about project stages
• Multiple reviewers describe repeat use spanning several years, including customers who return for every painting need

"Our 230 year old house was in serious need of an exterior paint job. After speaking with three painting companies, we decided on Precision Painting Plus and we are extremely happy with our decision." - Jim Gabriel, Google Review

A crew-first operation led by owner Andres Gallego, Long Island Painting and Restoration earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 6 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, this company has grown almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. Andres is named in nearly every review, and customers consistently mention his willingness to answer questions throughout a project. Several reviewers describe large crews of five or six painters arriving and completing whole-home interiors in a single day. If you need a project done on a tight timeline with a hands-on owner who stays involved from estimate to final walkthrough, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a great fit.

• Customers who recently purchased homes describe having entire interiors repainted before move-in day
• Renovation contractors recommend this company to their own clients for post-construction painting
• Cleanup after large crew days is mentioned repeatedly, with reviewers noting the home was left spotless

"Andres and his team were the best! I just bought a home and the whole house was covered in the worst orange and pink colors. They showed up on time every day, respectful, cleaned up at the end of each day and did excellent work." - Vanessa, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality is the most common theme across painting contractor reviews in Brookhaven, NY and the surrounding Suffolk County area. Customers describe finished results that exceed their expectations, with many noting the difference between DIY attempts and professional outcomes. At South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, reviewers describe interior rooms that look magazine-ready and power washing results that take years off the appearance of siding and pavers. Todd's Painting draws particular praise for kitchen cabinet work, with customers describing smooth, even finishes that rival factory quality. "Todd and his crew did an outstanding job! Great attention to detail and finished sooner than I had anticipated." - Doug Gordon, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers frequently highlight drywall repair quality alongside painting, with one reviewer noting that a water-damaged basement ceiling looked new after just two days of work.

At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, reviewers with large-scale projects describe wall-to-wall consistency across every room, including difficult areas like cathedral ceilings and stairwells. "On a scale of one to 10 I choose a 14!! The work they did was amazing." - Jerry Corallo, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns praise for skim coating and spackling, with customers specifically hiring them for wall repair work before painting. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers with older homes describe careful surface preparation that ensures paint adheres properly and lasts. "They prepped the exterior of the house with all its various surfaces very carefully and were attentive to all the details." - Leslie B., Google Review. Across all six companies, the consistent message from reviewers is that professional prep work is what separates a good paint job from a great one.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Timeliness is one of the strongest themes across painting reviews in Brookhaven, NY. Customers consistently describe crews arriving on time and projects finishing ahead of schedule. Todd's Painting stands out for fast turnarounds, with multiple reviewers describing entire interior repaints completed in a single day. "He stopped by to give me an estimate, and the very next day he and his crew were at my house early and finished with everything before 5pm." - Jenna Fanelli, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration also impresses with speed, regularly scaling up crew sizes to meet tight deadlines. One customer described a six-person team completing a whole-home interior in a single day.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC reviewers praise quick response times from owner Todd, with several customers noting same-day estimates and next-day scheduling for power washing work. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers with multi-day projects describe crews arriving early each morning and maintaining a steady pace throughout. "From the estimate to job completion, Brendan was there. Communication was frequent and clear. I always knew what point they were at." - Theresa Westergard, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC reviewers note that Denis often provides quotes the same day as the initial call, and Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers describe well-organized scheduling from field manager Chris.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Pricing and value come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Brookhaven, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe receiving competitive quotes and feeling that the final cost reflected the quality of work delivered. Big Expert Painting LLC reviewers consistently use words like "fair" and "reasonable," with several noting they compared multiple estimates before choosing Denis and his team. "Very professional, the quality of work is amazing and the reliability is superb. Five stars all across the board." - Marcos Batista, Google Review. Todd's Painting customers describe competitive pricing paired with fast timelines, and one reviewer mentioned getting more work done than originally planned because the price was so good.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers describe transparent pricing delivered through online proposals and invoices, making it easy to understand costs before work begins. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge reviewers who compared multiple bids describe this company as reasonably priced relative to the scope and quality of work. "His professionalism and price set him far apart from the other estimates I had received." - Helen Grygo, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration draws praise from customers who describe owner Andres providing detailed written estimates with full cost breakdowns, and Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers note fair pricing especially for larger exterior projects.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and protection of customer property is a recurring theme across reviews in Brookhaven, NY. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge receives some of the strongest praise in this area, with customers describing furniture carefully moved, floors covered, and homes left spotless at the end of each workday. "They were very careful to keep all surfaces covered with no paint mess." - Janet, Google Review for Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC reviewers note that Todd explains his process upfront, including how landscaping and outdoor surfaces will be protected during power washing.

Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe Denis and his crew leaving spaces cleaner than when they arrived, with one reviewer specifically noting that Denis swept up leaves he had tracked in. Long Island Painting and Restoration reviewers describe large crews completing fast turnarounds while still taking the time to clean thoroughly at the end of the day. "After the work was done, they did a great job cleaning up and leaving the home spotless." - Jacob Kraniak, Google Review. Todd's Painting customers describe tidy workspaces with everything covered and protected during interior projects. Overall, cleanup stands out as a consistent strength across painting contractors in the Brookhaven, NY area.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication is a top priority for painting contractors in Brookhaven, NY, and reviews reflect it. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers describe owner Todd as highly responsive via both phone and text, with several noting they received replies within hours of their initial inquiry. "He is very easy to work with and great with communication. Cannot recommend him enough!" - Barbara Meddis, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis is described as someone who answers calls directly, often on weekends, and follows up with customers weeks after the project is completed to make sure everything looks right.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge uses a team-based communication approach, with territory manager David Maloney and project supervisors keeping customers informed at every stage. Todd's Painting reviewers note that Todd provides clear updates throughout multi-day projects and is easy to reach if any touch-ups are needed. "He communicated well, and was very efficient. Couldn't have asked for a better job!" - Brandon Shoman, Google Review. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres is praised for answering questions in person during walkthroughs and remaining available throughout projects. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers highlight field manager Chris for clear communication about project timelines and scheduling.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Customer loyalty is a strong indicator of quality, and painting contractors in Brookhaven, NY show impressive repeat business rates. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC has some of the most visible repeat customer patterns, with reviewers describing second, third, and even fourth projects with the company spanning several years. "Great company! Used 2 yrs in a row. First year power washed the back of our house and fences. This year did our driveway." - Karen Burke, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe multi-year relationships with owner Denis, with one reviewer noting a seven-year working relationship across projects of all sizes.

Todd's Painting has some of the deepest customer loyalty in the area, with reviewers describing relationships spanning decades. Annual exterior maintenance and repeat interior projects are common themes. "I've known Todd for many years now and have had him and his crew paint our shop, our home, and now my mother's home." - S. B., Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers describe returning for multiple projects and referring family members. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns repeat business for both interior and exterior work, and Long Island Painting and Restoration customers frequently mention recommending the company to friends and neighbors. Referral chains that flow through families and neighborhoods are a consistent pattern across contractors in this area.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp