Twenty-eight years in business builds something you can't fake - customer loyalty that spans decades. Anthony's Painting And Decorating has customers who've been calling them back for 10, 15, even over 20 years of repeat projects. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: multiple reviewers describe returning again and again, and recommending the company to family members who become long-term customers themselves:
"We've used Anthony's a couple of times in the last 15 or so years. Always do a great job - on time, friendly and the work is fairly priced." - Bryan, Google Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Anthony's Painting And Decorating had over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 81.5%. With 28 years in business since incorporating in 1997, they've built deep roots on Long Island:
"Been working with Anthony's painting for over a decade. Clean, professional on time and reasonable pricing on projects. Owner is 100% customer driven and makes sure every project is perfect." - K Dalia, Google Review
Crews like Manny and his team get called out by name in review after review for their attention to detail. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong: reviewers mention specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines that reflect genuine customer experiences:
"I consider myself pretty OCD, but Manny was seeing things I didn't and clearly takes pride in his work. They not only met but exceeded our expectations, delivering an amazing paint job that has completely updated our home." - Ryan Colucci, Google Review
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICECrews like Paul and Albert get called out by name across reviews spanning years of work, and customers keep coming back for more. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: multiple reviewers describe returning for 2nd, 3rd, and even annual projects with the same team:
"We've used Paul a few different times for a few different jobs - interior and exterior. Always happy with the results." - Terry B., Google Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paul's Painting & Powerwashing had over 65 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating - all without a single review below five stars. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.6%. With over 12 years in business serving Suffolk County's South Shore, they've built a track record rooted in referrals and repeat work:
"Professionalism and work ethic rarely seen nowadays. The most courteous, punctual and neat painters/carpenters I have ever had work in my home." - Keith B., Google Review
Owner Paul Mercandetti and crew partner Albert handle every project personally, and customers notice the consistency. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component shows the same two names appearing across reviews spanning multiple years and project types:
"Paul and Albert did a fantastic prep job throughout the house. They were very meticulous with the prep and painting. I then recommended Paul to my daughter." - Jim C., Google Review
What sets Todd's Painting apart is the kind of loyalty that only comes from decades of consistent results. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: reviewers don't just recommend this company, they return for project after project over years and even decades:
"Todd has painted a couple of times for us and does amazing work. He painted my chain link fence with slots which gave the fence a whole new look. He painted my vinyl sided shed a totally different color and made the 20 year old shed look brand new." - Patty C., Google Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Reviews span multiple platforms with consistent praise:
"Todd's Painting, what can I say that you probably haven't already heard. Todd painted the entire interior of my home to include the interior stair railings and spindles. The job was nothing short of immaculate and professionally done." - Donald K., Google Review
Customers consistently mention the same thing: Todd and his crew get work done faster than expected without cutting corners. The Chooz Score's recent activity weighting confirms a steady stream of projects, and the reviews back it up with specific timelines:
"Had multiple rooms that needing painting and was looking to get it done ASAP. Todd and his team more than delivered. He stopped by to give me an estimate, and the very next day he and his crew were at my house early and finished with everything before 5pm." - Jenna F., Google Review
One recent review raised concerns about protection of surfaces not being painted, including moldings, ceiling fans, and newly refinished floors. While the overwhelming majority of reviews praise Todd's cleanliness, it's worth confirming upfront. Ask them directly: "What specific steps will your crew take to tape off and protect my trim, ceiling fixtures, and floors during the project?"
"I realized they had not taped off any of my mouldings, devices or ceiling fan. I had personally removed all faceplate covers myself. I also realized that there was a lot of small paint specs on my floor throughout the room which I had to clean up myself." - Magdalena R., Google Review
Owner Denis personally handles every estimate, stays in direct communication throughout each project, and is mentioned by name in the vast majority of reviews. The Chooz Score's owner engagement indicators are strong: Denis is personally referenced in review after review, and customers describe him as easy to work with, responsive, and present on the job site:
"Denis came out himself for the estimate, did the work with his crew the next week, and called a month later to make sure everything was still working perfectly. That's old-school service." - K. F., Google Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Big Expert Painting LLC had over 130 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across every single review. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%. Reviews span multiple platforms with consistent top marks:
"I picked this team because of its many positive references and I was not disappointed. The crew was professional, reasonably priced and did great work repairing a basement wall and ceiling damaged by a major water leak. In less than two days, the room is looking good as new." - James M., Google Review
Customers consistently mention the same thing: once they use Big Expert Painting, they don't call anyone else. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: multiple reviewers describe returning for 2nd, 3rd, and even 7th-year relationships with this company:
"I've known Dennis for over 7 years now. He's done a number of jobs for me from as small as painting the outside columns on my porch to painting the inside of my house. Whatever he does he does with expertise. Everything is clean and neat, his prices are more than fair, and so reliable - shows up when he says he's gonna." - Michael C., Google Review
Customers consistently mention the same thing: Precision Painting Plus crews leave homes cleaner than they found them. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators show consistent mentions of cleanliness and protection of customer property, and it's a theme that runs through reviews across multiple years:
"The crew from Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County were superb. They were very careful to keep all surfaces covered with no paint mess." - Janet, Google Review
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%. With nearly two decades in business, they've built a strong presence across Suffolk County and Long Island:
"Precision Painting is the best! Their name is their work style. They prepped the exterior of the house with all its various surfaces very carefully, were attentive to all the details, communicated what they were doing and planning at every stage of the work." - Leslie B., Google Review
If you're looking for a painting company you can call for years to come, this one has built real loyalty. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: reviewers describe returning for second, third, and even fourth projects, and referring family members along the way:
"We have used Precision Painting Plus numerous times. They are a fantastic company to deal with - their people are prompt, courteous, friendly and their work is first class." - Lucille I., Google Review
The company's Chooz Score showed strong marks across most categories, but one reviewer raised a concern about the estimate process - specifically, the time it took to receive a quote after the initial visit. If you're working with a tight timeline, it's worth confirming upfront: "How quickly can I expect to receive my estimate after the walkthrough, and what's your current scheduling availability?"
"Had an appointment for an estimate, person showed up half hour early when I advised I wasn't available before and on a work call. 11 days later I still haven't received an estimate." - Aasheesh, Google Review (no owner reply)
100% Recommended (4 Reviews)
Every painter listed on this page has been evaluated using the Chooz multi-step quality process. We combine data analysis with human review to identify companies that consistently deliver strong results for property owners in Middle Island, NY.
The Chooz Score is a 100-point rating built on platform reviews, review quality and engagement, website and digital presence, and business authority and operations. We use the same scoring framework nationwide while evaluating each contractor's performance specifically within Middle Island, NY.