5 Best Painters Near Middle Island, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Middle Island, NY handle everything from single-room refreshes to full exterior repaints, and the top-rated companies on Chooz Painters consistently earn strong marks for clear estimates, skilled crews, and results that prompt repeat business.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Big Expert Painting LLC had over 130 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%. Owner Denis Erazo personally handles estimates and is frequently described as reachable by phone even on weekends. The company's scope extends well beyond painting - interior sheetrock repairs, crown molding, pool painting, and power washing all appear in the reviews, and several customers describe starting with one room and expanding the project after seeing the quality firsthand. Crew members Eric and Joshua are called out by name in multiple reviews, suggesting the quality extends throughout the team. The company also carries a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes. If you want an accessible owner and a team capable of handling both painting and related home improvement work, Big Expert Painting LLC is a good fit.

• Denis provides same-day responses to quote requests, including on weekends, according to multiple reviewers.
• Projects cover a wide range: single rooms, whole-home interiors, exterior repaints, deck staining, power washing, and sheetrock work.
• Several customers hired the company for one job and immediately scheduled a second before the first was complete.

"The job was done on-time, even early, and the work was very neat." - Lori H., Google Review

For homeowners focused on kitchen cabinet refinishing alongside a full range of interior and exterior work, Todd's Painting brings a clear specialty to the table. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Todd's spray-painting process for kitchen cabinets earns dedicated praise - reviewers describe doors removed, refinished, and rehung with a factory-quality result at a fraction of replacement cost. Beyond cabinets, the company handles power washing, deck staining, fence painting, commercial interiors, and exterior house painting. One client has called Todd back for over 30 years across multiple properties. If you're planning a cabinet project or want a company you can rely on for multiple property types, Todd's Painting is a good fit.

• Cabinet spray painting is a personal specialty, with customers describing showroom-quality results on existing cabinets.
• Turnaround times are among the fastest in the area, with estimates and completed jobs often within 24-48 hours.
• Power washing brings many clients back annually for patio, paver, and pool deck maintenance as a standalone service.

"From start to finish, everything is perfect - such an eye for detail." - Mary Kate Slattery, Google Review

Also serving the Middle Island, NY area, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY brings a structured office operation to projects of all sizes. With over 200 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, over 100 Angi reviews with 4.7 stars, and a Chooz Score of 85.3%, they've built a track record spanning over 7 years in business across more than 45 communities. Owner Jim LaFontaine leads a team that includes dedicated office staff and field crew members Gabriel, Noe, Frank, and Chris, each called out by name across the reviews. The company offers in-house color consultation, so customers who need help with paint selection don't need to hire a separate designer. Project scale ranges from individual apartment repaints to homeowner association complexes with hundreds of units. If you have a larger or complex project, or want professional color guidance built in, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY is worth a call.

• In-house color consultation is available at no extra charge - reviewers describe this as a useful step before finalizing selections.
• Daily cleanup and surface protection are described consistently across years of reviews from different customers.
• Multi-decade client relationships appear throughout the reviews, including an 8-year ongoing relationship with a large condo association.

"They were very accommodating. We changed colors several times without any complaints." - Tombstone City, Google Review

With nearly two decades in business, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has developed a structured approach that sets it apart from smaller contractors in the area. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau since 2015, and recognition as a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. A field manager visits the job site before painting begins to confirm colors and scope, a step customers mention as reducing surprises on project day. Project managers like Jason Ng are described as present throughout multi-day jobs, following up daily to confirm finishing touches are handled correctly. Services include residential repaints, exterior painting, deck work, wallpaper removal, cabinet refinishing, and HOA projects. If you prefer a company with formal accreditation, structured pre-job processes, and a dedicated point of contact, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a good choice.

• A field manager pre-visits homes before work starts to review color selections and scope with the homeowner.
• Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015, one of the few area contractors to hold this credential.
• Referral chains appear frequently, with customers sending neighbors, family members, and friends to the company after their own projects.

"Great quality work, kind employees, great value and transparent pricing." - Sarah Carpenter, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Middle Island, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration is built around the direct involvement of owner Andres Gallego. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 55 Google reviews. Andres personally handles every estimate and is described in review after review as the first person on site, often spending considerable time walking through a home before quoting. Once work begins, crews scale up to match the scope - a six-person team completed a whole-home project in a single day, and a 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home finished in under 48 hours. Crew members Nelson and Delmer are named for their attention to detail on spackling and prep work. With over 6 years in business built largely on word-of-mouth referrals, they've maintained a perfect rating. If you want an owner who stays involved from the first estimate to the final walkthrough, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a strong pick.

• Andres provides detailed written estimates and returns for color consultations at no additional charge.
• Crew size scales up for large projects - whole-home interiors have been completed in a single day by larger teams.

"They are fairly priced, clean up, honest, trustworthy and reliable!" - Robyn Damels, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Across the top-rated contractors serving Middle Island, NY, painting quality and finished workmanship stand out as the most consistent themes in customer reviews. At Big Expert Painting LLC, the crew's range extends to sheetrock repairs, skim coating, and crown molding installation alongside standard painting - several reviewers describe the crew catching and correcting surface imperfections they hadn't noticed themselves. At Todd's Painting, cabinet refinishing earns detailed praise, with customers describing the spray process yielding factory-quality finishes on doors that were removed, sanded, and rehung with precision. The company also handled 17-foot vaulted ceilings across every room in one customer's home, with results described as perfect throughout. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY customers describe careful edgework on complex architectural features including wainscoting, painted ceiling beams, and intricate exterior trim.

At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, pre-job surface preparation - wall sanding, skim coating, and proper priming - is highlighted as the reason the finished work looks as clean as it does. Customers describe fresh paint applied to properly prepared surfaces rather than layered over existing imperfections. At Long Island Painting and Restoration, the repeat business pattern tells its own story: Kaitlyn Vinberg described the team working seamlessly and precisely in multiple areas of her home across several project phases over many months. For homeowners in Middle Island, NY who want results worth photographing, all five contractors have built their reputations on exactly that kind of work.

"Their attention to detail and professionalism truly brought the place to life." - Jaiden Fernandes-Duran, Google Review"True masters at their craft. Always a perfect job." - Ray Messina, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Communication from first contact through project completion is a consistent strength across the top-rated painting contractors serving Middle Island, NY. At Big Expert Painting LLC, owner Denis Erazo is described by multiple reviewers as answering calls directly and returning messages quickly - including on weekends. Several customers mention he checked in during the project and followed up after completion to confirm satisfaction. At Todd's Painting, responsiveness when issues come up after the job is a pattern reviewers highlight. Tina Barry described texting Todd with concerns and having him return within a couple of days to address them without hassle. Paul Genova's review described checking out the inside of Todd's truck before the job began as a signal of the crew's organization - and said the work confirmed that impression throughout.

CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY runs a dedicated office operation with staff including AnnMarie and Jennifer supporting owner Jim LaFontaine in managing scheduling, estimates, and client communication. Reviewers who needed to reschedule or change scope mid-project describe the team accommodating them without friction. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, field managers call before the crew arrives to confirm scope, and project managers follow up daily during multi-day jobs. At Long Island Painting and Restoration, owner Andres is described as quick to respond and easy to reach throughout each project, with customers noting they were always informed about what was happening and what was next on the schedule. For homeowners in Middle Island, NY who want to stay informed throughout their project, these contractors offer consistent track records.

"Communication was prompt and concise. Work was completed as described." - Donna DiNapoli, Google Review"We were extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism and attention to detail." - Nicole Albanese, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Preparation before painting and cleanup after the job is done are areas where the top-rated contractors in Middle Island, NY receive consistent praise. At Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, the prep routine is described in specific terms: crews vacuum work areas before starting, lay paper on floors, move furniture, and cover everything with plastic before picking up a brush. Tom Wedell, a repeat customer, noted the crew photographs wall art and decor before removing it and replaces each item exactly as it was when the job is done - a detail homeowners with personal arrangements on display will appreciate. At Long Island Painting and Restoration, customers describe being comfortable leaving the crew in their homes without being present, noting the space was left clean at the end of each work day. At Big Expert Painting LLC, Chantel B. noted all personal items were covered before work began and the crew moved quickly without leaving a mess behind.

CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY protection measures go beyond basic drop cloths on larger jobs. James Buckley described a multi-day project where the crew cleaned up at the end of each day and treated the house with care throughout. At Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, the crew is described as moving furniture back into place after completing a job, with customers arriving home to find their spaces in better condition than expected. For homeowners in Middle Island, NY concerned about protecting floors, furniture, trim, and personal belongings during a paint project, these contractors have built consistent reputations in exactly that area.

"When they were done there was nothing for me to clean up." - Stuart Rock, Google Review"They cleaned up and even swept the area when done." - Laverne B., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Showing up when promised and finishing within the agreed timeframe are strengths across the top-rated painting contractors in Middle Island, NY. Todd's Painting stands out for fast turnarounds - Danielle Buglino had her project wrapped up within 48 hours of the initial discussion, and Laura Contino described a crew that completed an entire bathroom, foyer, and entryway between 8am and 3pm in a single day. These timelines are described as consistently fast without sacrificing quality. At Big Expert Painting LLC, multiple reviewers note the crew showed up on time each day and wrapped up ahead of the estimated completion date. Melva M. Miller described the crew as arriving right on time every day without exception, which she said made the entire process seamless.

Long Island Painting and Restoration scales up crew size to keep large projects on tight timelines - Kiran Kapoor described the company finishing a whole-home project ahead of schedule, and Keri Sab's six-person crew handled the full setup, painting, and cleanup for a whole-home job in a single day. At CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY, Joe Beers noted the project was completed in less time than the original estimate, and multi-day projects are described as consistent with daily start times. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers describe start dates being honored and projects finishing within quoted windows. For homeowners in Middle Island, NY planning around a specific schedule, these contractors offer strong collective records for meeting deadlines.

"They got the job done in 48 hours after we discussed the job." - Danielle Buglino, Google Review"They finished my entire home ahead of schedule." - Kiran Kapoor, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Pricing comes up consistently across reviews for the top-rated painting contractors in Middle Island, NY, and the most common theme isn't simply that prices are fair - it's that customers felt the quality received made the price worth paying. At Big Expert Painting LLC, reviewers reach for words like "reasonable," "fair," and "competitive" when describing Denis's quotes. Several customers note that estimates matched their final bills without additions or surprises. At Todd's Painting, pricing is often cited as a reason customers extended their project scope - one reviewer described adding more work than originally planned because the price gave him room to do so. Cabinet refinishing pricing is consistently framed as significantly more affordable than cabinet replacement, with multiple reviewers noting the finished quality was comparable to buying new.

At Long Island Painting and Restoration, Andres's detailed estimate process means customers know exactly what they're paying before any work begins, and multiple reviews confirm the final price matched the quote. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY is positioned at a higher price point - one reviewer acknowledged the company is not the least expensive option but described the service, skill, and speed as worth it for complex projects. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns frequent mentions for fair pricing alongside quality, with reviewers describing estimates as clear and prices as reasonable for the level of work delivered. For homeowners in Middle Island, NY comparing quotes from multiple painters, these companies offer a range of price points with strong records for delivering on what's promised.

"Very reasonable price, very good and professional at what they do." - Chris Garcia, Google Review"Affordable, punctual and impeccable detail when it comes to prepping a house." - Pamela Matzner, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi