7 Best Painters Near Islandia, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Islandia, NY and the surrounding Suffolk County area have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with strong review histories and verified credentials. Whether you need specialty decorative finishes, a full exterior refresh, or detailed interior work, the top-rated companies on Chooz Painters consistently earn praise for reliability, clean work, and clear communication.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Interior Finishing NYC had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. What stands out in the reviews is the range of projects customers bring to owner Dorian Golemi - from cork wallpaper installations and ceiling gilding to faux finish repairs that need to match existing walls perfectly. Several customers mention that Dorian provided quotes quickly over the phone or video call, saving them time before any on-site visit. With over 22 years in business and a three-year workmanship warranty, this is a strong option if you need decorative or specialty finish work that goes beyond standard painting.

• Customers frequently describe projects involving wallpaper, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and limewash - finishes most general painters do not offer
• Crew members like Marvin and Joe are named individually in reviews for plaster work, framing, and floor repairs
• Multiple reviewers note that the team completed complex projects in a single day

"Dorian did a fantastic job wallpapering an accent wall with a thick cork paper. And he suggested wallpapering a nearby accent wall as well. The room looks great. Very responsive and a fair price." - Julie Kelly, Google Review

Also serving the Islandia, NY area, Mr Star Painting Corp brings a crew-driven approach backed by over 235 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, 100% recommended on Facebook, and a Chooz Score of 87.3%. With 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk Counties, the company has built a reputation around a consistent team that customers learn by name. Reviewers describe crews arriving in uniform, introducing themselves, and walking through the scope of work before starting. If you want a company where you will see the same faces from estimate to final walkthrough, Mr Star is a solid choice.

• Owners Ricardo and Mario are mentioned in nearly every review for hands-on involvement during and after projects
• Customers describe the crew handling skim coating, plastering, and cabinet refinishing alongside standard painting
• Several reviewers highlight that the team cleaned up daily and moved furniture back into place after each phase

"They are the most professional, kind and wonderful painters I've ever had. They were neat, always on time and friendly. I will only use this company moving forward." - Kathy Smith, Google Review

For homeowners looking for fast turnarounds on both interior and exterior work, Todd's Painting has built a following across central Suffolk County. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, and reviews also span Facebook and Yelp. A recurring pattern in the reviews is how quickly Todd responds to estimate requests and how often jobs are completed ahead of schedule. Customers describe kitchen cabinet painting, deck staining, power washing, and full interior repaints handled with the same level of care. If you value a contractor who picks up the phone and gets work done quickly without cutting corners, Todd's Painting is worth considering.

• Multiple customers describe receiving estimates the same day and having work completed within 24 to 48 hours
• Reviewers mention Todd personally supervising every project and correcting any touch-up requests within days
• The company handles a wide range of services including power washing, deck staining, and vinyl siding painting

"Todd and his team did an incredible job painting my house. His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient. Couldn't have asked for a better job!" - Brandon Shoman, Google Review

When it comes to protecting your home during the painting process, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. The company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau and has been recognized as a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. With nearly 20 years in business, their crews are praised for covering furniture, protecting floors, and leaving spaces spotless after every job. If you are particular about cleanliness during and after a paint project, this company consistently delivers on that front.

• Manager Chris is mentioned frequently for staying in contact throughout projects and conducting final walkthroughs
• Customers describe the team handling exterior projects on older homes with multiple surface types, including deck board replacement

"From the estimate visit to the job completion Precision Painting was competent, responsive and friendly. They did a fine job." - Bill Q, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for JRT Pro Painters LLC. With over 65 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook, this company earned a Chooz Score of 84.3%. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas is named in the majority of reviews, and customers describe him as quick to respond, fair with pricing, and personally involved in every project. With 4 years in business and a Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License, JRT is a good fit if you want an owner-operated company where the person giving your estimate is the same person overseeing the work.

• Customers highlight careful prep work including hole filling, sanding, priming, and full furniture protection before any paint is applied
• Several reviewers mention hiring JRT for drywall repair and ceiling work in addition to painting
• The crew handles door and molding replacement alongside paint projects

"We hired Brayan and his team to paint several rooms in our home and replace interior doors and mouldings. We could not be happier with the results. They were reasonably priced, very professional, neat and efficient." - Jackie S, Google Review

With over 6 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk Counties, Long Island Painting and Restoration has earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego is described in reviews as spending significant time during estimates, going room by room and offering color consultations at no extra charge. The team is known for completing large projects quickly, with several reviewers describing whole-home painting jobs finished in under two days. If you need a company that can scale up crew size to meet a tight deadline, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a reliable option.

• Crew members Nelson and Joey are praised by name for spackling, skim coating, and wall repair work
• Customers describe Andres matching paint colors for garage doors and front doors with precision
• The company handles both residential and commercial projects, including office spaces

"Andres was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his team!" - Christine Li, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality and workmanship are the most frequently praised aspects of painting contractors serving Islandia, NY and the broader Suffolk County area. Across hundreds of reviews, customers consistently describe finished results that exceeded their expectations, with particular attention to prep work, clean lines, and smooth finishes. Interior Finishing NYC earns praise for specialty finishes like Roman clay and Venetian plaster, with one reviewer noting that the crew handled plaster work, framing, drywall installation, and floor repair all in one project. Mr Star Painting Corp reviewers describe skim coating that left previously uneven walls perfectly smooth. Todd's Painting customers highlight cabinet painting and deck staining results that made old surfaces look brand new.

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County receives consistent feedback about the care their crews take with exterior projects on older homes, including surface preparation and board replacement before painting begins. JRT Pro Painters LLC customers describe prep work that goes beyond the original scope, with crews identifying and repairing drywall issues before starting paint work. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, with over 190 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, is praised for handling complex projects like cabinet refinishing and staircase railing painting. "Once everything was completed, the finished product was beautiful. Attention to detail was excellent." - J Lutz, Google Review. "The workmanship was excellent, and Manny and Team worked neat and clean and got the job done as scheduled." - RJF, Google Review. "The guys skim coated them flawlessly before painting, for a fair price of course." - Michael Bunicci, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is one of the strongest themes across reviews for painting contractors near Islandia, NY. Customers regularly describe crews arriving on time or early, completing projects ahead of schedule, and communicating clearly about timelines. Todd's Painting is especially noted for fast turnarounds, with several customers describing entire interior paint jobs completed in a single day. Long Island Painting and Restoration reviewers describe whole-home projects completed in under 48 hours by larger crews that owner Andres scales up as needed. "They showed up early both days and finished on time!" - Beth I, Google Review. "Todd came for the estimate on time as promised. We had our bathroom painted and it looks great. Very neat work, quick and nicely done." - Karen C, Google Review.

JRT Pro Painters LLC and Mr Star Painting Corp also receive consistent praise for punctuality. Multiple JRT reviewers describe the crew arriving as scheduled and putting in full 8 to 9 hour days. Mr Star customers note that owners Ricardo and Mario set clear timelines during the estimate and follow through on every deadline. Interior Finishing NYC is described as responsive to initial inquiries, with owner Dorian often providing quotes over the phone the same day. "His crew came on time every day as he said. They spackled and prepped interior of my house and painted the whole interior." - Diego Sanchez, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and prep work are among the most commonly praised qualities of painting contractors serving Islandia, NY. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County receives especially frequent mentions of cleanliness, with customers describing furniture carefully covered, floors protected, and workspaces left spotless at the end of each day. Several reviewers mention that the crew helped put furniture and pictures back in place after the job was done. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp customers describe a similar approach, with one reviewer noting that the team covered all furniture, laid paper on floors, and vacuumed before starting any paint work. "They were very careful to keep all surfaces covered with no paint mess." - Denise Valentine, Google Review. "They covered all my furniture, like a well-oiled machine, and left the place spotless when they were done." - Andy Mcadam, Google Review.

Mr Star Painting Corp and JRT Pro Painters LLC also earn high marks for tidiness. Mr Star reviewers describe daily cleanup and crews arriving in identifiable uniforms. JRT customers note that the crew took all garbage with them at the end of the project. Todd's Painting customers highlight that the team left the area clean at the end of each day of work. "Brayan and his colleague, Antonio, were professional, respectful and kind. They thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up when they were finished." - Janette Payne, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication and professionalism are consistent strengths across top-rated painting contractors near Islandia, NY. Mr Star Painting Corp reviewers describe owners Ricardo and Mario explaining the full scope of work during the estimate, staying in contact throughout the project, and returning promptly for any touch-ups. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers praise owner Andres for detailed walkthroughs, written estimates with full cost breakdowns, and free color consultations. "Both Mario and Ricardo were very helpful throughout the whole process, explained everything that they will be doing, and stayed communicating to us the whole time." - Brianna F, Google Review. "Andres and his team went above and beyond. He had great recommendations and knows his craft." - Jenny Efron, Google Review.

JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan is described as quick to respond to messages and easy to deal with throughout the project. Interior Finishing NYC reviewers highlight Dorian's willingness to explain his process and accommodate last-minute requests. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers frequently mention manager Chris for keeping them informed at every stage. "He communicated with me every step of the way and did an amazing job!" - H B, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Value and pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Islandia, NY. Across multiple companies, customers describe receiving competitive estimates and feeling the final cost was fair for the quality of work delivered. Todd's Painting customers regularly use words like "fair" and "reasonable" when describing pricing, with one reviewer noting they were able to add extra work to the project because the initial price came in lower than expected. JRT Pro Painters LLC reviewers describe Brayan as straightforward about pricing from the start, with no surprises at the end. "His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient." - Brandon Shoman, Google Review. "Very reasonable estimate, and did the work in a professional and exceptional manner." - Tracie Dalessandro, Google Review.

Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp with over 28 years in business is consistently praised for competitive pricing, and Interior Finishing NYC reviewers note that Dorian's specialty finish work comes at prices they consider reasonable for the skill involved. Mr Star Painting Corp customers describe fair pricing paired with transparent walk-throughs and detailed quotes. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County reviewers note the value of getting a thorough job with full cleanup included. "They were affordable, punctual and showed impeccable detail when it comes to prepping a house prior to painting." - Pamela Matzner, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat business is one of the strongest signals of quality among painting contractors near Islandia, NY, and several companies show clear patterns of customers returning for additional projects. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp has customers who have been calling them back for 10, 15, and even over 20 years. Multiple reviewers describe hiring the company for their second or third project before the current one is even finished. Mr Star Painting Corp shows a similar pattern, with several documented repeat customers spanning nearly a decade of projects. Todd's Painting has built a loyal following over decades, with one reviewer describing over 30 years of repeat business across multiple properties. "I've known Todd for many years now and have had him and his crew paint our shop, our home, and now my mother's home." - S. B., Google Review.

JRT Pro Painters LLC reviewers frequently mention returning for second and third projects, with one customer describing having her entire house painted room by room over several years. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns repeat business from customers who follow owner Andres from one home to the next. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has customers who describe using the company multiple times since 2014. "This was the second time we used them. Would recommend them. The team was easy to work with." - Stephen Larberg, Google Review. "I previously used this company for my home and this time was for my office." - Jennifer Leeds, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp