4 Best Painters Near West Sayville, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving West Sayville, NY have built strong reputations across Long Island's South Shore communities, with several companies standing out for craftsmanship, reliability, and attentive service. Here is a look at the highest-rated options based on our Chooz Score analysis.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC leads the West Sayville, NY market with a Chooz Score of 89.0%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score maintained across a high volume of feedback. Their cross-platform consistency is equally strong, with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. What stands out across the reviews is how often customers describe feeling completely at ease with the crew in their home - multiple reviewers describe leaving to run errands and returning to a finished project that exceeded their expectations. Owner Todd Rumfola personally walks properties before and after each job, and his habit of texting customers arrival reminders and keeping them in the loop throughout the process comes up in review after review. With over 10 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk Counties, and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License verified active through 2027, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC is a strong fit if you want a contractor who handles both interior painting and power washing with equal care.

• Crew members Rich, Jerry, and Alex are called out by name across dozens of reviews, with customers specifically requesting the same painters for return projects
• Owner Todd provides online proposals and invoices and typically responds to inquiries within hours, including on weekends and evenings
• Lead-safe certification is on file - important for homeowners in older South Shore properties
• Services extend beyond painting to include soft washing, power washing, gutter cleaning, and exterior staining

"Rich and Jerry did incredible! They turned our house into a beautiful home. The attention to detail, trust, professionalism was something you can't find these days." - John Petito, Google Review

For homeowners looking for a company with a structured crew-based approach and specialty project capability, Teall Painting has built a loyal following across Nassau and Suffolk Counties. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Charlie Teall conducts thorough in-person estimates that customers consistently describe as detailed and reassuring - multiple reviewers mention that the estimate alone gave them full confidence before a single painter arrived. The company's in-house crew structure means the same painters handle projects from start to finish, and crew members like Ricardo, Eli, Victor, and Oscar appear across many unrelated reviews. With over 12 years in business, a Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License, and a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty on all work, Teall Painting is a particularly good fit for specialty projects or homeowners who want a company that backs its work in writing.

• Specialty work includes western red cedar restoration, stucco exteriors, wainscoting installation, and cabinet refinishing alongside standard interior and exterior projects
• All work is backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
• Customers regularly describe receiving project updates throughout the job and easy access to owner Charlie from estimate through completion

"Charlie and his team were professional from start to finish. From the thorough inspection/estimate to the finished product, the entire process was seamless." - Michelle Scaduto, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Todd's Painting, which earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% and over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. Speed without sacrificing quality is a recurring theme here - customers describe estimates turned into completed projects within 24 to 48 hours, with multiple reviewers expressing surprise at how quickly work finished on jobs they expected to take much longer. Todd handles everything from interior rooms to exterior staining, commercial spaces, and power washing, and several reviewers describe working with him across multiple properties over many years. If quick turnarounds and a contractor who shows up exactly when he says he will matter most to you, Todd's Painting is a strong option.

• Multiple reviewers describe same-day estimates followed by project starts the very next day
• Handles residential interiors, exterior painting and staining, commercial work, and power washing
• Pricing consistently described as fair and competitive, with no surprise costs after the estimate

"Todd and his team did an incredible job painting my house. His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient. Couldn't have asked for a better job!" - Brandon Shoman, Google Review

Also serving the West Sayville, NY area, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY brings a larger-team approach to projects across Central Suffolk County and beyond. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.3%, with over 200 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, plus 4.7 stars on Angi across over 100 Angi reviews. Named crew members including Gabriel, Noe, Frank, and Chris appear across dozens of reviews for careful prep and clean finish work. Owner Jim LaFontaine and coordinator AnnMarie are both called out for responsiveness and project management. With over 7 years in business serving over 45 communities from Central Suffolk east to the Hamptons and North Fork, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY is a solid fit for larger properties, rentals, or commercial spaces that require a sizable crew and structured project oversight.

• Named crew members appear consistently across reviews spanning multiple years, pointing to a stable, experienced workforce
• Track record includes high-end Hamptons homes, large residential projects, and commercial and multi-unit work
• Projects regularly finish on or ahead of schedule per customer accounts
• Owner Jim and coordinator AnnMarie both receive strong marks for communication and follow-through

"We had an excellent experience with Certa Pro, they were professional, polite, organized, thorough and achieved the job in less than the original time estimate." - Joe Beers, Google Review

With nearly two decades in business, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has one of the most established long-term track records in the area. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%, with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. The company holds BBB accreditation and has been recognized as a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. Customers describe the company's property protection approach as unusually thorough, with reviewers using the phrase "white glove operation" when describing how crews cover furniture, floors, and fixtures before any work begins. Manager Chris is called out by name specifically for keeping projects organized and on track. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a particularly good fit for homeowners looking for a company with long-standing community ties and experience handling HOA, commercial, and recurring residential accounts.

• BBB accredited and a Bethpage Best of Long Island honoree, reflecting sustained community standing
• Handles HOA work, commercial projects, and multi-phase residential accounts with repeat clients going back many years
• Manager Chris is consistently noted for organization, communication, and project follow-through

"An incredible company and I can't praise them enough. True masters at their craft. I have used them inside my home and for our HOA and always a perfect job." - Ray Messina, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in West Sayville, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews - every one a five-star rating. Over 10 new reviews in the last 3 months confirm this is an actively growing company, not one coasting on past momentum. Owner Andres Gallego's involvement goes well beyond the estimate: customers describe him conducting free color consultations, walking properties room by room before work begins, and returning for final walkthroughs after completion. Specialty services including popcorn ceiling removal, old wallpaper stripping, and expert skim coating round out what the company offers. With over 6 years in business, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a strong fit for homeowners who want the owner personally invested in their project from the first call to the last brush stroke.

• Andres provides color consultations and professional color recommendations as part of the estimate process at no extra charge
• Specialty services include wallpaper removal, popcorn ceiling removal, and skim coating in addition to interior and exterior painting
• Crews regularly complete large whole-home projects in 48 hours or less

"This company is the best! They are fairly priced, clean up, honest, trustworthy and reliable! Great to work with! I'm so happy we found them!" - Robyn Damels, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Quality and attention to detail are the themes that come up most consistently in reviews of painting contractors serving West Sayville, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe results that go well beyond a simple coat of paint - it's the prep work, the edge work, and the finishing touches that draw the most praise. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, which holds a Chooz Score of 89.0%, earns repeated recognition for precise technique, with painter Rich called out by multiple customers for careful handling of bay windows, stairs, and crown molding details. Teall Painting draws similar feedback on specialty projects - from mahogany door refinishing to wainscoting installation - that other contractors had either declined or failed to complete correctly. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY consistently earns praise from customers with high-end homes who describe intricate trim and detailed surfaces handled exactly right.

The quality pattern holds across contractors at every price point. Todd's Painting customers describe rooms and exteriors finished to a standard they did not expect at the price they paid. Reviewer after reviewer for Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, which has over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, notes that crew leader Manny caught surface imperfections the homeowner had missed - and corrected them without being asked. Long Island Painting and Restoration handles specialty work including popcorn ceiling removal and skim coating, with customers describing finished walls that look far better than the state of the surfaces before work began.

"I cannot say enough great things about Manny and his amazing crew at Anthony's Painting and Decorating. Everything was outstanding from beginning to end - the prep work, the execution, and the final results." - Diana Silvar, Google Review

"Todd and his crew were excellent, on time, efficient and neat. I'm very happy with the exterior painting of my house. I would recommend him without a doubt!" - Rosemarie Fairchild, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Responsive communication is one of the most frequently praised qualities in reviews of painting contractors serving West Sayville, NY. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC sets the tone here - owner Todd Rumfola is described by reviewers as responding to texts and calls within hours, often reaching out the evening before a scheduled job to confirm arrival time, and following up after completion to make sure customers are satisfied. Multiple reviewers mention receiving emailed estimates within an hour of a walkthrough visit. Teall Painting owner Charlie Teall receives similar marks, with customers describing detailed written estimates that address every question and project updates throughout each job. For homeowners in West Sayville, NY who have dealt with contractors who go quiet after the initial estimate, this level of follow-through stands out.

The pattern continues with Long Island Painting and Restoration, where owner Andres Gallego's rapid response time comes up in review after review - customers mention reaching out and hearing back the same day, with projects sometimes beginning within 48 hours. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers describe a structured process where a field manager makes a separate visit before work begins to review colors and confirm project details, removing the guesswork on the job start day. Across all the top-rated contractors in the area, the common thread is owners and managers who treat communication as part of the service, not an afterthought.

"I am so glad we chose South Bay Painting. This is a totally professional company - from always communicating promptly to providing online proposals and invoices to being courteous throughout." - Gina Eldredge, Google Review

"Our project was completed just over a week after we reached out for a quote. We were extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism, and attention to detail from start to finish." - Nicole Albanese, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Property protection and daily cleanup are consistent themes in reviews of painting contractors serving West Sayville, NY, and the top-rated companies treat this as a non-negotiable part of the job. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County, which holds a Chooz Score of 84.5% and nearly two decades in business, earns particularly specific praise here - customers describe furniture carefully wrapped and floors covered wall-to-wall before a single brush stroke, and several reviewers use the phrase "white glove operation" to describe how crews handle their space. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY receives similar feedback, with customers noting that cabinets, appliances, and all surfaces are completely plastic-wrapped and tarped before any work begins. "Left cleaner than they found it" is language that shows up in multiple reviews across both companies.

Teall Painting customers consistently praise how crews protect finished floors and surfaces with plastic sheathing, builder's paper, and drop cloths before starting. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp crews are described as taking pictures before starting, removing all artwork and decorations, and replacing everything exactly as found after the job is complete. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers mention painter Rich leaving spaces spotless at the end of each workday during multi-day interior projects. For homeowners in West Sayville, NY concerned about protecting furniture, floors, and personal belongings, the review record shows a consistent commitment to care across the top-rated contractors in the area.

"They protected everything from paint spills and left the room spotless. They were on time each day and were patient with our decisions. I cannot sing their praises enough." - Cindy Rantal, Google Review

"The day my house was painted, they showed up on time, covered all my furniture like a moving company would, and left everything exactly as they found it when the job was done." - Andy Mcadam, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Fair pricing and transparent estimates are recurring themes in reviews of painting contractors serving West Sayville, NY. Customers across the top-rated companies consistently describe receiving detailed, itemized estimates where the final cost matched what was quoted - a distinction that stands out in an industry where hidden charges are a common complaint. Todd's Painting, with over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, draws particular praise on this front, with multiple reviewers noting they were quoted a fair price and ended up getting more work done than originally planned because the estimate was so reasonable. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers describe receiving emailed estimates within an hour of a walkthrough, with pricing described as competitive for the quality delivered. Teall Painting reviews frequently describe estimates that were not the cheapest available but felt fair given the specialty capability and warranty backing.

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns consistent marks for transparent pricing on larger projects, with customers noting they received competitive bids on multi-phase jobs and the final invoice matched the proposal. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, with over 28 years in business, is described by reviewers as offering fair pricing on both interior and exterior projects, with one customer noting that the prep work alone justified what others might have considered a premium quote. Across the area's top contractors, the consistent picture is companies that invest in doing the job right and price their work accordingly - without the surprise charges that can follow lower initial bids from other contractors.

"Everything you want in a contractor - quality, price, efficiency and thoroughness." - Seth Levitt, Google Review

"Great quality work, kind employees, great value and transparent pricing. Would absolutely use Precision again for my next paint job!" - Sarah Carpenter, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Reliability and on-time arrival are qualities that customers of painting contractors in West Sayville, NY comment on frequently, and the top-rated companies have built reputations specifically around keeping their word on schedules. Todd's Painting stands out here - multiple customers describe estimates given one day and complete projects delivered the next, and the company's over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating reflect a long track record of showing up when promised. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC owner Todd Rumfola receives repeated praise for sending arrival reminders and keeping homeowners informed of timing throughout each job. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY customers note that crews showed up on time every day of multi-day projects - a consistency that reviewers specifically describe as unusual.

Long Island Painting and Restoration earns strong marks for fast project starts after estimates, with multiple customers describing projects beginning within 24 to 48 hours of reaching out. Teall Painting customers consistently note punctual crew arrivals and project completion within the timeline promised during the estimate. For homeowners in West Sayville, NY who have experienced the frustration of contractors who do not show up or miss deadlines, the review record across these companies reflects a different standard - businesses that treat scheduling reliability as central to their service.

"Victor was right on time and a pleasure to work with. The job turned out beautifully and was completed in less time than expected." - Barbara Rosen, Google Review

"I called and spoke to the owner. His response time was quick! We needed the work done and it was completed the next day. The workers were neat, courteous, and left their areas clean." - Janette Carosone, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customer loyalty is one of the most telling indicators of quality in the home services industry, and the painting contractors serving West Sayville, NY that score highest on Chooz have earned an unusual level of long-term repeat business. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, with a Chooz Score of 89.0%, has customers who have called Todd and his crew back for second, third, and fourth projects spanning several years - and several describe recommending him to neighbors and family members who have since become long-term customers themselves. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has built similar loyalty, with reviewers describing relationships going back to 2014 and beyond, including customers who call the company for every painting, wallpapering, and power washing project at their home.

Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, which has been in business for over 28 years and holds over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, has customers who describe working with the company for 10, 15, and even over 20 years. Todd's Painting has reviewers who have trusted the company with their shop, their home, and their mother's home over many years, and who describe the peace of mind that comes from knowing the work will be done right even when they are not present. For homeowners in West Sayville, NY looking to find a painting contractor they can call for years to come, the repeat-customer patterns across these companies are a strong signal.

"We have used Todd the past three years and consider him a friend! Todd is a true professional who aims to please - dependable, easy to communicate with, great customer service, and does an A1 job!" - Barbara C., Google Review

"I used this company a couple of times since 2014. They are very professional and do a great job from start to finish. I would highly recommend them." - Vivian B., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook