The painting contractors serving Montauk, NY handle everything from weathered beachside exteriors to high-end Hamptons estate interiors. Chooz Painters reviewed contractors throughout the East End and Long Island to identify the top-rated options in and around Montauk, NY. Here is what the reviews show.
For homeowners looking for decorative finishes and specialty applications that most painters won't take on, Interior Finishing NYC leads the area with a Chooz Score of 87.3%. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and has built his business around finishes like Roman clay, Venetian plaster, limewash, marmorino, and metallic applications. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and over 22 years in business since founding in 2003. A three-year workmanship warranty covers all projects. If you need an accent wall, wallpaper installation, gilded ceiling, or pre-war woodwork restoration, this company is a strong option.
Several reviewers describe searching for contractors willing to take on challenging projects - multi-wall murals, cork and grasscloth papers, commercial gilding - and finding Dorian after other companies declined. Team members Marvin, Joe, Jose, and Amir appear consistently across reviews as a reliable, coordinated crew. Phone and video call estimates are available to save customers time before a project visit.
- Reviewers describe projects other contractors declined, including specialty plaster repairs, ceiling gilding in commercial spaces, and pattern-matched wallpaper installations across non-square walls
- Drywall repair, water damage remediation, and window film installation are handled alongside painting in single visits
- Dorian is physically on-site working and supervising the majority of the time, not managing remotely
"Dori was prompt and very professional. His Venetian plaster work on my kitchen walls are unbelievable. I always get compliments from our guests!" - Charlie V., Google Review
A family-run operation with deep Hamptons roots, Chameleon Painting Inc. earned a Chooz Score of 86.8%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 170 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, with over 10 years in business since incorporating in February 2016. Father-and-son team Juan Guillermo Jaramillo and his family handle every aspect of the business directly, from estimates to final walkthrough. If you're managing a Hamptons property and need a contractor who communicates throughout the project and follows through after the work is done, this is a good choice.
The pattern of trust that shows up in reviews is notable. Multiple customers describe leaving keys and traveling out of state or to Florida for the winter, returning to find the work exactly as expected with photo updates along the way. One reviewer managing her home alone for over 13 years called it the best contractor experience she'd had in that entire time. Projects range from cedar siding restoration and deck staining to kitchen cabinet refinishing and a church hall that hadn't been painted in four decades.
- Detailed written proposals break down each phase of the project separately with specific pricing per area, unlike the broad estimates other companies provide
- Shingle staining, exterior soft washing, and trim painting handled alongside full interior repaints
- Juan and family members appear on job sites personally, not delegated to crew alone
"We just had our shingles stained by Juan and team. We are thrilled with their work, our house looks like a completely new house, and we have already received compliments from guests." - Carolyn A., Google Review
With over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating across Google, Facebook, and Yelp, Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. What stands out in the reviews is the range of projects Todd and his crew take on comfortably: kitchen cabinet painting, chain-link fence work, vinyl shed painting, power washing, exterior staining, and full interior repaints. If you need a reliable contractor for a clear-cut project with consistent scheduling and easy communication, Todd is a good option.
One reviewer noted the insight she gained just from looking at the inside of Todd's truck - organized, cared-for, clearly someone who thinks carefully about the work. Several customers describe crews that show up every day as promised across multi-day jobs with cathedral ceilings and 17-foot living rooms. Cabinet spray painting has become a signature service, with multiple reviewers noting dramatic results on kitchens that hadn't been updated in years.
- Kitchen cabinet spray painting handles door removal, full refinishing, and reinstallation without the homeowner emptying the cabinets
- Power washing, metal roof cleaning, and exterior staining alongside standard painting work
- Customers who travel between states describe trusting Todd to work in their absence without issue
"Start to finish, Todd's painting was a great decision! Communication was prompt and concise. Work was completed as described. Todd and his crew are professional. They left the area clean at the end of each day and returned as promised, on time. We are delighted with our maple cabinet makeover." - Donna D., Google Review
When it comes to East End estate work and high-end finishes, AJ Painting has built a respected name in the North Fork and Hamptons market. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.9% with over 70 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and 100% recommended on Facebook. AJ Painting is a North Fork Chamber of Commerce member, a 2025 Best of the Best award winner, and holds Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition. If you're working with premium materials like Farrow and Ball paints or have a property in a historic preservation district, this crew is worth contacting.
Reviewers describe crews that take direction once and execute precisely, including fast-turnaround commercial studio jobs in Watermill and a 110-year-old farmhouse in a designated historic district that required floor-to-ceiling work across two floors. Wallpaper removal and new wallpaper installation are handled in-house, and the same crews work interior and exterior projects.
- Historic district properties completed on time and on budget alongside new construction and renovation projects
- Commercial clients and repeat customers who've hired AJ for every painting project at their property
- Flexible scheduling and willingness to revisit any area the customer isn't satisfied with
"AJ and his crew were very patient and flexible with my multi-colored interior. He redid some things I wasn't happy with. And took care of all the details. Would recommend, and will have him do exterior next!" - Miranda D., Google Review
Also serving the Montauk, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings nearly two decades in business to a Chooz Score of 84.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. They hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2015) and are a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. If you want a well-established company with a consistent track record across Suffolk County for both residential and HOA work, this is a solid option.
Reviews mention a field manager - often Chris or Cristhian - who visits before the job to confirm paint colors, is on-site during the work, and walks through the finished project. One customer brought them in for a 230-year-old exterior job and received a written plan and timeline before work started. Another customer has used them continuously since 2014 for painting, wallpapering, and power washing projects.
- Field manager visits before the job to review colors and set expectations, then returns during and after the project
- Wallpapering, power washing, deck work, and ceiling repair alongside interior and exterior painting
- HOA and commercial properties handled alongside residential jobs with the same crew structure
"An incredible company and I can't praise them enough. True masters at their craft. I have used them inside my home and for our HOA and always a perfect job. Quick and priced very fair." - Ray M., Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Montauk, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews - every single one a five-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego is mentioned by name across the vast majority of reviews, with customers describing walkthroughs that often include color consultations at no extra charge. With over 6 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, the company has grown almost entirely through referrals. If you've just purchased a home and need a crew that can complete the whole house quickly and leave it spotless, this company is worth calling.
Customers with tight timelines - new home purchases, office renovations, hard contractor deadlines - describe the crew rearranging to accommodate. A six-person crew completed a large whole-home project in a single day, and crew member Joey is specifically called out in multiple reviews for spackling and skim coating work that customers hired the company for specifically.
- Owner Andres and foreman Nelson manage jobs on-site; Joey's wall repair skills are mentioned by name in multiple reviews
- Multiple customers hired the company on a contractor referral and then continued using them for additional properties
- Commercial buildings and multi-unit projects taken alongside single-family residential work
"Andres and his crew have painted my house on numerous occasions from top to bottom. They are great in every way possible. They are all very skilled in what they do and very clean with no mess ever left behind." - Mike S., Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
