Southampton, NY homeowners expect a high standard from their painting contractors - and the companies serving this area have reviews that back it up. Whether you need a specialty decorative finish for a Hamptons estate, cedar shingle staining on a summer home, or a full interior refresh before the season starts, the contractors below cover a wide range of projects. Most hold consistent five-star ratings across platforms, and the pattern across their reviews points to a group of painters who take both craftsmanship and customer service seriously.
Leading the rankings with a Chooz Score of 87.3%, Interior Finishing NYC is the top choice for homeowners with complex decorative projects. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and specializes in finishes most painting contractors won't attempt - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, and metallic applications. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, the company had over 120 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, built over more than 22 years in business. Team members Jose, Amir, Marvin, and Joe appear consistently across reviews, and Dorian is physically on site for nearly every project. A three-year workmanship warranty is included. If you need a specialty finish that other contractors have turned down, this is the team to call.
- Multiple customers describe projects other companies refused - pre-war woodwork restoration, gilded ceilings, and multi-room color drenching - all completed with precision and care.
- Dorian regularly quotes jobs over the phone or video call, saving customers the time of an in-person estimate for straightforward projects.
- Commercial clients, including office managers and retail spaces, describe reliable turnarounds and easy communication on tight schedules.
"We've used Dorian for our company's office needs a number of times now and each time the experience has been easy and efficient. Dorian is quick to communicate, patient when it comes to bureaucratic delays, and always does a beautiful job on the work itself. We will continue to use Dorian for future projects." - Charlotte M., Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals are the strongest indicator of a painting company's real quality, and CRD Painting Inc has both in abundance. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% and, at the time of our analysis, had over 90 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and matching praise on Yelp. Owner Camilo has been in business over 8 years, holds an active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License (No. H-59404, valid through 2027), and has loyal customers who have been calling him back for 10 to 15 years. If you want a painter who will still be your go-to contractor a decade from now, CRD is a strong pick.
- Camilo's crew covers floors and furniture before opening a single can, with daily cleanup leaving no trace of the work behind.
- One homeowner's skylight sheetrock repairs on a 1990s home required considerable patience and skill - the finished result came out looking better than the original construction.
- Camilo regularly helps customers choose colors and offers suggestions during the project - going beyond painting to act as a genuine advisor.
"Highly recommend this family owned and operated business. Camilo and his crew are experts in their craft. Their work was pristine and expeditious. The entire crew was skilled and they worked as a team to finish the job timely. Most noticeable, the cleanliness of the job. They left my home spotless and looking new." - Jason R., Google Review
A true Hamptons specialist, Chameleon Painting Inc. is a family operation with the father-and-son team of Juan Guillermo Jaramillo personally overseeing every project from estimate to completion. Based in Hampton Bays, they earned a Chooz Score of 86.8% and had over 170 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. Over 10 years in business, Juan has built a reputation for detailed, itemized proposals, daily site visits, and responding to over 97% of all reviews personally. For homeowners who want a local crew that understands the specific demands of coastal properties, from weathered exteriors to summer rental turnarounds, this company is a natural fit.
- One homeowner left for Florida after the project started and came home to a perfectly finished house, with Juan sending daily photo updates throughout.
- Projects range from a 2,200-square-foot deck staining to a church hall that hadn't been painted in 40 years, showing the crew's capability across any scale.
- Multiple reviewers note that Chameleon's itemized estimates stood out against vague lump-sum quotes from other contractors.
"I bought my home in December and then went to Florida and left Juan to paint my whole house while I was gone. He kept me updated with pictures and reports. I came back to see a perfect job. I would highly recommend him for any work you might hire him for." - Ellen, Google Review
With over 35 years of experience, Todd's Painting brings the confidence that comes from decades of consistent results. The Centereach-based company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% and had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating at the time of our analysis, with additional reviews on Facebook and Yelp. Todd personally supervises jobs and is hands-on during the work - customers describe him as a note-taking, detail-oriented craftsman who genuinely wants every outcome to be right. From cabinet refinishing and exterior staining to power washing and pool decks, Todd's Painting handles a wide range of services, making them a good pick for homeowners who want one contractor for multiple project types.
- Todd has been known to suggest a better color after seeing it on the walls - saving customers from a repaint and showing real investment in the final result.
- Commercial clients, including a veterinary hospital and a church with very high ceilings, describe efficient and professional results at any scale.
- Todd's crew can paint seamlessly over wallpaper for customers who want to avoid the cost and mess of removal.
"Just used Todd's painting again for one of my properties and told him I needed it done immediately. He came in and completed the whole thing within one day and six guys. I have known and used him for 30 years. Highly recommend." - Lori L., Google Review
When it comes to high-end East End homes, AJ Painting brings a level of craftsmanship that Hamptons residents take notice of. Based in Hampton Bays, the company earned a Chooz Score of 84.9% and had over 70 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. A 2025 North Fork Chamber of Commerce Best of the Best award winner and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite, AJ has particular recognition for premium-finish projects using Farrow & Ball and other high-specification paints. Named crew members Angel, Andy, Isay, and Lindo appear across reviews, confirming a consistent and skilled team. This is an excellent choice for homeowners tackling complex, high-specification interior or exterior work.
- Clients with historic farmhouses and architecturally complex properties choose AJ specifically for their willingness to work carefully through challenges that others avoid.
- AJ's team returns promptly for warranty repairs and follow-up work, with the same professionalism as the original job.
- Scheduling is notably flexible, accommodating mid-project changes and tight turnarounds for seasonal Hamptons properties.
"AJ Painting Inc exceeded every expectation we had for our East Hampton home. From day one, AJ approached the project with a level of professionalism and craftsmanship that immediately set him apart. We used premium Farrow & Ball paints throughout the house, and as anyone who has worked with them knows, they require real expertise to apply properly. The depth of color, the consistency of finish, and the precision of the lines are flawless." - Christopher B., Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors serving Southampton, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings a structured, process-driven approach to every project. The Melville-based company earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% and had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating at the time of our analysis. With nearly two decades in business, they hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2015) and are a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. A dedicated field manager coordinates colors before work begins, visits daily during the project, and conducts a final walkthrough. This is a strong option for homeowners who value organization, transparency, and a well-managed larger project.
- The assigned field manager visits the home days before painting begins to coordinate paint colors and logistics - no surprises on day one.
- Several customers hired the company while away from home and described project managers who kept them fully updated throughout the process.
- One customer's 230-year-old home required detailed pre-work recommendations before painting could begin, including clapboard repairs and vine removal - the team handled all of it.
"My situation was a little different as I was going to be away during the painting process. The project managers, both Amy and Jonathan kept me well informed during the entire process. Most importantly, above all else, they did an exceptional job. I was 100% satisfied with the quality and professionalism." - Stuart E., Google Review
Also serving the Southampton, NY area, Long Island Painting and Restoration holds a Chooz Score of 84.2% and a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 55 Google reviews - one of the highest rating consistencies in the dataset. Over 6 years in business, owner Andres Gallego has built his reputation on thorough walkthroughs, transparent estimates, and large-crew efficiency that gets jobs done ahead of schedule. A six-person crew has completed full whole-home projects in a single day. The company handles everything from wallpaper removal and skim coating to exterior repaints and drywall restoration.
- Foreman Nelson and crew member Joey appear by name in reviews - customers specifically request Joey for expert spackling and wall repair work.
- Andres offers color consultations at no extra charge during the estimate process, and customers describe his recommendations as genuinely helpful.
- Multiple customers hired the team again for their second property after positive experiences with the first - a consistent pattern across reviews.
"He was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second home he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his guys - they are very reliable, neat and friendly to work with. Thank you Andres for making our new home come to life!" - Christine L., Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook
