6 Best Painters Near Sag Harbor, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners and property owners in Sag Harbor, NY have access to a strong field of painting contractors serving the East End, from specialists in fine decorative finishes to crews with decades of loyal followings across the Hamptons. The companies below were ranked by Chooz Painters based on verified customer reviews and platform data, with the highest-scoring companies listed first.

Interior Finishing NYC leads the ranking with a Chooz Score of 87.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi trained at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and brings a fine arts background to specialty work most contractors won't attempt - limewash, Venetian plaster, Roman clay, marmorino, decorative ceiling gilding, and complex wallpaper installations across challenging Manhattan buildings. Several reviewers describe Dorian as the contractor who said yes when others passed, including projects in co-op apartments requiring coordination with building management and large-scale wallpaper murals with non-standard structural obstacles. With over 22 years in business and a three-year workmanship warranty, this company is a strong fit for property owners who need specialty finish work done right.

Team members Marvin, Jose, Joe, and Amir appear consistently in reviews as a reliable crew, and customers note that Dorian often provides estimates by phone or video call to save time, making the process easy from the start. If you're looking for a contractor who can handle drywall repair, plaster, wallpaper, and decorative finishes all in one engagement, Interior Finishing NYC is a good choice.

• Takes on projects other contractors decline, including ceiling gilding, grasscloth wallpaper on curved walls, and decorative plaster in co-op apartments with building access requirements
• Three-year workmanship warranty with a clear touch-up process, and pricing described by multiple reviewers as reasonable relative to the specialty work involved
• Customers often receive quotes remotely by phone or video, with quick turnaround from estimate to job start

"Dorian and his team did an incredible job on our wallpaper, he is an artist! It was a big, difficult job with multiple 2-wall murals which involved a lot of awkward structural pieces to work around. He took his time to make sure every piece was perfect, it has come out way better than we ever dreamed." - William C., Google Review

While Interior Finishing NYC focuses on decorative specialty work, CRD Painting Inc has built its reputation on long-running client relationships and detailed craftsmanship across interior and exterior projects throughout Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 90 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo runs a licensed operation - Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-59404 - and has been serving Long Island for over 8 years. One reviewer (Gloria Gali) specifically calls out their Sag Harbor, NY home as a completed project, and the company's reviews span everything from painted kitchen cabinets to stained wooden beams, front doors, and exterior cedar.

What stands out in the reviews is how often customers describe Camilo making quick adjustments when needed. One reviewer called him the day before new flooring was being installed, unhappy with a color choice, and Camilo came back the very next day to repaint. For homeowners who want a responsive contractor they can call project after project, CRD Painting Inc is a good choice.

• Reviews describe detailed prep work before painting starts - furniture covered, floors protected, and switches and outlets masked off so nothing gets paint that shouldn't
• Even trade professionals refer CRD to their own clients, with a 60-year Long Island drywall family noting they recommend Camilo to all of their builders and customers
• Works on a wide range of surfaces, from stained wooden beams and front doors to exterior cedar, interior wainscoting, and spiral staircase spindles

"I highly recommend C.R.D. Painting. They do exceptional work in a professional way. His work is neat, precise and with attention to every detail. He offers excellent suggestions because he has an eye of an artist. His work is impeccable." - Lisa F., Google Review

For homeowners with Hamptons properties - particularly those with cedar siding, exterior trim, or homes that need trusted crews working on-site independently - Chameleon Painting Inc. brings over 10 years in business serving the Hamptons and North Fork. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.8%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 170 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. The father-and-son team of Juan Guillermo Jaramillo and his family personally manages every estimate and visits job sites regularly. Reviewers note that Chameleon breaks down proposals in detail by project phase - something multiple customers contrast favorably with other estimates they received that offered only a single line-item price. One customer describes leaving Juan a key, flying to Florida, and coming back to a finished home that looked exactly as promised, with photos sent throughout the process.

Chameleon has also taken on projects to repair or redo work from other contractors - including hand-sanding two decks that had been badly stained by another company and restoring them properly. If you own a Hamptons or North Fork property and want a crew that communicates proactively and can be trusted on-site without you present, Chameleon Painting Inc. is a good choice.

• Detailed, itemized proposals that break the project into phases and prices - multiple reviewers note this stood out compared to other bids they received
• Has stepped in to fix work left by other contractors, including full deck restoration requiring hand-sanding before proper finishing
• The father-and-son ownership team responds to virtually all reviews with personalized replies and keeps customers updated throughout jobs with photos when they're away

"I bought my home in December and then went to Florida and left Juan to paint my whole house while I was gone. He kept me updated with pictures and reports. I came back to see a perfect job. I cannot speak highly enough of this company." - Ellen, Google Review

Also serving the Long Island area, Todd's Painting handles a wider variety of surfaces than most painting contractors - cabinet refinishing, exterior staining, metal roof cleaning, chain link fences, vinyl siding, and cedar - in addition to standard interior and exterior painting. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating on Google, with a presence on Facebook and Yelp as well. Reviewers describe Todd as highly accessible - same-day responses, next-day estimates, and crews that show up when they say they will. One reviewer found Todd's card at a local Abbott's paint store and describes being impressed with how Todd handled the consultation before a single brush was picked up.

The kitchen cabinet work stands out across multiple reviews - Todd's crew removes cabinet doors and drawer faces before spraying, so customers don't need to empty the cabinets beforehand. For homeowners dealing with a 30-year-old interior, challenging ceiling heights, or a creative surface you're not sure any painter will take on, Todd's Painting is a good choice.

• Cabinet refinishing is a clear specialty - crews remove and spray doors and faces off-site rather than painting in place, with customers noting the results look new
• Handles hard-to-paint surfaces including metal roofs, chain link fences with slats, and vinyl siding that most painters avoid
• Commercial clients, including business owners, describe the same prompt and organized approach as residential customers

"We are thrilled with our home after Todd's Painting gave it a much needed refresh. Easy to work with, communicative, quality workmanship, attention to detail, tidy and timely! I appreciated knowing when to expect them each day and that they arrived promptly." - Angie E., Google Review

When it comes to high-end properties on the East End, AJ Painting stands out for both their credentials and the quality of their clientele. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.9%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 70 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and were 100% recommended on Facebook. AJ Painting is a North Fork Chamber of Commerce member and a 2025 Best of the Best award winner, with Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition from the local community. Named crew members Angel, Andy, Isay, and Lindo appear across reviews for a 20-room interior project, and a customer managing operations for Tracy Anderson's fitness studio describes AJ completing a full studio refresh on a tight turnaround. Christopher Bruno's East Hampton home was completed using Farrow and Ball paints throughout, and he notes AJ's familiarity with those premium products set him apart from other bids.

AJ Painting also handles wallpaper installation and has returned after job completion to address issues like a ceiling leak that appeared after the project was complete - covering the repair as part of their service. For owners of luxury or historic East End properties, or anyone working with premium materials, AJ Painting is a good choice.

• Experienced with Farrow and Ball and other premium paint lines, with knowledge of their specific application requirements on high-end projects
• Has completed work on properties in East Hampton, Southold, Watermill, and across the North Fork, including a 110-year-old farmhouse in a historic district
• Stands behind the work after job completion - returned to address a post-job ceiling leak at no additional cost

"My husband and I are lucky to have had a lot of expert work done on our 110-year-old farmhouse in a historic district in NoFo over the last 16+ years. But AJ and his incredible team stand out, even among the best craftspeople and professionals out here on the East End." - Kris K., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Sag Harbor, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings nearly two decades of experience to both residential and HOA projects across Suffolk County and Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. The company holds accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2015 and has earned Bethpage Best of Long Island recognition. Manager Chris and crew member Cristhian appear frequently by name in reviews, and the company has handled projects ranging from single-room repaints to full apartment overhauls with wallpaper and an HOA common area repaint. One reviewer who has used them since 2014 describes consistently professional results across multiple jobs.

Precision Painting Plus also handles deck work beyond just painting - one reviewer describes having worn boards and railings replaced alongside the exterior paint job, making it a single coordinated project. For homeowners who want a company with a proven track record, institutional accountability, and experience with larger or more complex scopes, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a good choice.

• BBB accredited since 2015 with a multi-platform review presence and Bethpage Best of Long Island recognition
• Handles deck board and railing replacement as part of exterior painting projects, covering repairs and finishing in one scope
• Has served customers since 2014, with long-term clients noting consistent results across multiple projects over many years

"They power-washed and painted our house and the deck, including replacement of several worn boards and railings on the deck. Their work was excellent - a very professional crew who knew what they were doing, they arrived on time and left everything spotless." - Risa K., Google Review

Also serving both Nassau and Suffolk counties, Long Island Painting and Restoration handles a broader scope than most painting-only contractors, taking on restoration work - soot damage, water damage, siding color changes, and garage doors - alongside standard interior and exterior painting. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis they had over 55 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego personally handles estimates and is known for responsive communication. One reviewer describes going with Andres for their second home after he handled their first, while another specifically mentions that his pricing came in as the best of multiple quotes when repricing an exterior color change - new siding color, garage doors, and shutters all reworked in one visit.

With over 6 years in business, the company has built its client base almost entirely through word-of-mouth. They are a good fit for homeowners who want a contractor that handles both the repair and the painting side of a project without coordinating two separate companies.

• Handles exterior color overhauls including siding, shutters, and garage doors in a single project scope
• Takes on restoration work - soot stains, water damage, deteriorated plaster - before repainting, combining trades into one engagement
• Free estimates with quick scheduling, and pricing described as competitive when compared against other bids

"Andres and his crew did a wonderful job painting our home. He was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his guys - they are very reliable, neat and friendly to work with!" - Christine L., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Quality of workmanship is the theme that runs most consistently through reviews for painters serving Sag Harbor, NY. Across companies, customers describe results that go well beyond a standard coat of paint. Interior Finishing NYC earns some of the most specific praise for technical skill, with customers detailing work on decorative plaster, grasscloth wallpaper, gilded ceilings, and Roman clay accent walls. One reviewer describes a plaster and gilding project in Times Square alongside drywall repair and painting, noting the team handled all of it with precision. Chameleon Painting Inc. receives consistent praise for detailed prep and finish work across Hamptons homes, with reviewer Albert Lee describing a complicated kitchen project completed with thorough attention to detail. AJ Painting customers highlight the company's ability to work with premium materials like Farrow and Ball paints, which require specific handling, and reviewers note that results on high-end East End homes have consistently met or exceeded expectations.

CRD Painting Inc receives detailed praise for work on complex surfaces: wainscoting, spiral staircase spindles, stained wooden beams, and caulking and spackling on cathedral ceilings. Todd's Painting customers highlight how the crew handles difficult interiors - including rooms not painted in 30 years with 17-foot cathedral ceilings - and deliver results customers describe as looking entirely new. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County and Long Island Painting and Restoration both draw praise for thorough prep work and clean results, with Long Island Painting customers noting specific restoration outcomes on damaged walls and exterior surfaces.

"We worked with Dorian and his team on a decorative plaster project as well as gilding a ceiling in Times Square. They are true professionals." - Miguel M., Google Review "Juan and his family do incredibly thorough and finely detailed work. We had a complicated kitchen painting project and they did a truly wonderful job." - Albert L., Google Review "Our living room looks exactly as I dreamed it would! Thank you AJ and Team!" - Ingrid R., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customers reviewing painting contractors serving Sag Harbor, NY mention professional communication nearly as often as the quality of the finished work. Chameleon Painting Inc. stands out for how the family ownership team keeps clients updated throughout a project, including sending photos and status reports when customers are away from their properties during the work. Reviewer Joanna D'Angelo describes being so comfortable with the crew's trustworthiness that she felt at ease leaving them with a key and access to her home - a level of trust that several other Chameleon customers echo. AJ Painting customers describe consistent responsiveness and scheduling flexibility, including adaptations during a fast-moving studio project where timing requirements changed mid-job. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi often handles estimates by phone or video call rather than requiring an in-person visit, which multiple customers describe as a welcome time-saver.

CRD Painting Inc customers highlight owner Camilo's communication specifically around scheduling and quick response when changes come up - including returning the next day to repaint a room after a customer changed their color choice right before new flooring was installed. Todd's Painting customers consistently note that Todd explains his process and material recommendations clearly before work begins, and that the crew shows up when promised each day. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County reviews credit manager Chris for staying on top of communication from estimate to completion, and the company has addressed post-job issues like cracking without complaint. Across the board, painters serving Sag Harbor, NY earn strong marks for being easy to reach and straightforward about what to expect.

"I felt completely comfortable leaving them a key. From start to finish, their professionalism and work ethics were impeccable. Firstly, I was impressed by how trustworthy they were." - Joanna D., Google Review "He was incredibly fast in replying, efficient with coming over to give me a quote and worked diligently with his team in order to limewash my house. He got the job done in one day." - Melissa C., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

On-time performance and quick turnarounds are recurring themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Sag Harbor, NY. Interior Finishing NYC draws specific praise for speed on specialty work - multiple reviewers describe limewash and Roman clay projects completed in a single day, and wallpaper installations across large apartments finished in two days or less. Todd's Painting customers describe estimates given one day and work completed the very next, with crews arriving early and finishing ahead of schedule on projects ranging from single rooms to full interiors. Reviewer Marc Miller notes that Chameleon Painting Inc. started and finished his exterior project on the exact dates promised, which he calls out specifically as rare for any contractor. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers describe a 4-bedroom, 2-bath home completed in under 48 hours, and another reviewer notes their project was ready to go just over a week after they first reached out for a quote.

CRD Painting Inc is described by multiple reviewers as fast and efficient without cutting corners, with crew members working through large projects across multiple rooms in consistent, focused sessions. AJ Painting customers describe the team adapting quickly when scheduling needs shifted on a commercial studio project with a tight turnaround, while Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers note that the crew arrives on time each day and completes projects within the promised window. When scheduling a painting project in Sag Harbor, NY, all of these companies have strong track records for keeping their commitments.

"Todd and his crew came on time every day as he said. They spackled and prepped the interior of my house and painted the whole interior. We are very happy with the final results." - Diego S., Google Review "Juan both started on the exact day he told me and finished the job by the date he promised. Both of those promises are hard to find with any contractor." - Marc M., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Cleanliness and property protection are consistent strengths across painting contractors serving Sag Harbor, NY. CRD Painting Inc customers describe a methodical approach to prep - floors covered, furniture wrapped, and even electrical outlets, switches, and receptacles carefully masked before painting begins. Reviewer Reyes H. notes that the crew is careful not to paint anything that isn't supposed to get painted, a detail they call out specifically because it's not always standard practice. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns one of the more notable descriptions in this category - a reviewer calls their approach a "white glove operation," with furniture covered before work starts, moved back into place afterward, and the space left cleaner than it was found. Reviewer Tracey G. notes the crew even helped her put furniture and wall pictures back up after they finished. Chameleon Painting Inc. crews clean up the job site at the end of every working day, and reviewers note that no loud music or disruptive behavior is part of the experience - just quiet, organized work.

Todd's Painting customers describe the crew covering all surfaces before starting, and for cabinet projects, Todd's team removes doors and drawer faces entirely rather than painting them in place, protecting the surrounding kitchen space. Long Island Painting and Restoration reviews describe crews leaving homes spotless at the end of the job, with no mess left behind even after multi-day projects. For homeowners in Sag Harbor, NY who are particularly concerned about protecting furniture, floors, or valuables during a painting project, any of these companies are worth considering based on how consistently customers describe their protection practices.

"They take the time necessary to protect the space from paint drips, they are careful to not paint receptacles, switches or anything else that is not supposed to get painted. Camilo and his family run an amazing business." - Reyes H., Google Review "They were very careful to keep all surfaces covered with no paint mess. The crew from Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County were superb." - Janet, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Pricing and value come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Sag Harbor, NY, and the consistent theme is that customers feel the quality they receive is worth the price - or better. Interior Finishing NYC stands out here because of what it offers: specialty decorative work at prices multiple reviewers describe as reasonable compared to other bids they received, including reviewer Tova K., who notes Dorian was more affordable than other painters she contacted. AJ Painting customers describe pricing as competitive even on high-end projects requiring premium materials - Fred de la Vega had an East Hampton exterior, decks, and front gate completed at a price he describes as fair. Long Island Painting and Restoration is specifically called out for pricing in multiple reviews: one customer describes Andres's quote as the best of several received for a full exterior color change including siding, garage doors, and shutters.

CRD Painting Inc customers describe pricing as fair and competitive across a range of project types, with long-term customers continuing to return specifically because the value remains consistent. Todd's Painting reviewer Chris M. notes that the price was good enough that he ended up adding more work to the original scope on the spot. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is described as fairly priced for its scope, though at least one reviewer suggests shopping around for comparison on larger jobs. Chameleon Painting Inc. customers across exterior and interior projects describe pricing as fair relative to the quality and the Hamptons market. In general, painters serving Sag Harbor, NY are rated well for providing clear, accurate estimates without surprise charges.

"Price was the best compared to other companies I was quoted from. Very happy with final results." - N G., Google Review "His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient. Couldn't have asked for a better job!" - Brandon S., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Repeat business and long-term relationships are among the strongest signals in the review data for painting contractors serving Sag Harbor, NY. CRD Painting Inc leads this category by a wide margin - multiple customers document relationships spanning over 10 years with owner Camilo, with one reviewer on their third job and counting, and another having used the company across several different properties over more than a decade. Todd's Painting has at least one customer who has called on Todd for over 30 years across multiple properties, and others who describe bringing him to their current home after using him at a previous one. Chameleon Painting Inc. has similarly deep relationships - reviewer Peggy B. describes a 10-year history with the family team covering rooms, decks, and cedar siding across multiple projects at the same home.

Long Island Painting and Restoration customers describe returning after their first experience - one reviewer brought Andres back for their second home after he painted their first. AJ Painting has painted the same customer's house twice in full, and others describe returning for multiple projects over several years. Interior Finishing NYC also sees repeat visits, with one reviewer noting they used Dorian for drywall repair, window film, wallpaper, and painting across a single engagement and plan to return for future projects. For homeowners in Sag Harbor, NY who want a contractor relationship that lasts beyond a single project, these companies have strong records of earning that loyalty.

"This is my 3rd time using this crew and I don't want to use nobody else." - Israel G., Google Review "Andres and his crew have painted my house on numerous occasions from top to bottom. They are great in every way possible. They are all very skilled in what they do and very clean with no mess ever left behind." - Mike S., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp