4 Best Painters Near Shelter Island, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Shelter Island, NY work in a distinctive market: many clients own seasonal or second homes, projects often run while owners are off the island, and the work ranges from historic shingle cottages to high-end residences requiring specialty decorative finishes. The top contractors listed on Chooz Painters for this area handle all of it - whether you need intricate limewash and plaster work, cedar shingle staining, or a reliable crew you can trust to work independently while you're away.

Interior Finishing NYC leads the area rankings with a Chooz Score of 87.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Dorian Golemi studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, and brings that artistic background to specialty work that most painting contractors won't attempt - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic applications, and complex wallpaper installation across challenging architectural surfaces. With over 22 years in business and a three-year workmanship warranty, he's built a following of clients who return for project after project. Team members Jose, Amir, Marvin, and Joe appear consistently across reviews as a reliable, skilled unit. If you're looking for something beyond a standard coat of paint - a specialty accent wall, a pre-war woodwork restoration, or a ceiling gilding project - Interior Finishing NYC is a strong first call.

• Dorian personally works on every job site alongside his crew - reviews confirm his on-site presence from estimate to completion.
• Multiple clients report leaving town during projects and returning to completed specialty finish work that matched their vision exactly.
• Projects include grasscloth, cork, vinyl, and large mural wallpapers across complex architectural surfaces, including non-square walls and pre-war molding details.

"We hired Dorian and his team to paint our living room and guest bedroom in lime wash paint. His team was professional, skilled, clean, and incredibly fast. They painted both rooms in a single day, and the results are amazing." - Matt B., Google Review

For homeowners seeking a Hamptons-area family operation with deep roots in the East End, Chameleon Painting Inc. brings a different kind of reliability. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 170 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and a Chooz Score of 86.8%. Father-and-son team Juan Guillermo Jaramillo and his family run every aspect of the business, from estimates to daily job site visits, and Juan personally handled over 97% of all reviews with individualized responses. With over 10 years in business serving the Hamptons and North Fork, the crew handles everything from cedar shingle staining to detailed kitchen cabinet refinishing to church hall repaints. One customer left for Florida while Juan painted her entire house and returned to a finished job after receiving regular photo updates throughout. Chameleon Painting Inc. is a good fit for homeowners who want a hands-on family contractor that stays in close contact throughout the project.

• Detailed written proposals break down each phase by item and price - not a lump sum estimate.
• Cedar shingle, deck, and exterior surface work are regular specialties, well-suited to the shingle-style homes common across the East End.
• Worksites are left clean and organized at the end of every day, with furniture, fixtures, and landscaping protected before any work begins.

"The workers are perfectionists. Best of all, the team was inobtrusive, which was important as I was working in my office every day they were here. Best of all - silence. No radio." - Wendy M., Google Review

Repeat customers tell the story for Todd's Painting. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and a Chooz Score of 86.5%, with reviews spanning Google, Facebook, and Yelp. Lori Lucia has used Todd's for over 30 years across multiple properties, and S. B. trusts the crew to work in her home even while she's out of state. Cabinet refinishing is a particular strength here - spray-finished doors and drawer fronts with no cabinet-emptying required. Todd covers residential and commercial projects, from pool decks to animal hospitals to congregation halls. Todd's Painting is a good fit for homeowners who want a contractor they can rely on for years of projects, not just a one-time job.

• Cabinet painting is a specialty - doors are removed and refinished without requiring clients to empty drawers or cabinets first.
• Todd's crew handles both residential and commercial work, with flexible scheduling and same-day or next-day start times for urgent projects.
• On-site communication is a consistent strength - Todd provides color consultations and talks through the best approach before the crew begins.

"Made our 100 year old house look brand new! His team was fast, reliable, and clean." - Rachel U., Google Review

When it comes to community recognition on the East End, AJ Painting has earned a standing that goes beyond online reviews. They hold a Chooz Score of 84.9% with over 70 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. As a North Fork Chamber of Commerce member and 2025 Best of the Best award winner, AJ has built real local credibility. The crew handles premium interior projects with care - one review describes a full Farrow & Ball interior in an East Hampton home with meticulous sanding, patching, and priming that produced a finish described as "smooth and architectural." AJ also has a dedicated wallpaper installation team for projects combining painting and wallcovering work. AJ Painting is a strong fit for high-end East End properties with exacting standards.

• Crew handles full fixture removal and reinstallation at the end of each job, including complete whole-house wallpaper removal.
• Experienced working on historic properties and in historic districts, with projects completed on a 110-year-old farmhouse in a North Fork historic district.
• AJ remains directly accessible throughout projects and is flexible with schedule adjustments and mid-project changes.
• Dedicated wallpaper installation team available for projects requiring both painting and wallcovering work.

"AJ Painting was on time, professional, and clean. They made sure to remove all fixtures, and fitted them back properly at the end. We had wallpaper EVERYWHERE, and they removed it all, and cleaned up thoroughly at the end of each workday." - Kimberly K., Google Review

With nearly two decades in business and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2015), Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County operates with the kind of structure that larger or more complex projects often require. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and a Chooz Score of 84.5%. Project managers like Chris, Jason, and Matt appear by name throughout reviews, each described as responsive, communicative, and present throughout the job. One customer noted the crew's structure made a complete exterior project seamless while she was away - a dedicated estimator, color coordinator, project manager, and field crew kept everything organized and on schedule. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a good fit for homeowners who want accountability and clear team communication across a structured operation.

• Field managers check in before, during, and after each project to ensure quality and address touch-ups on the spot.
• Handles exterior painting, power washing, deck restoration, and deck board replacement as part of comprehensive project packages.

"My situation was a little different as I was going to be away during the painting process. The project managers were thorough, prompt and professional. I came home to a clean home with beautiful paint work." - Stuart E., Google Review

Also serving the Shelter Island, NY area, Long Island Painting and Restoration rounds out the list with a Chooz Score of 84.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, every one of their over 55 Google reviews carried a 5.0-star rating - a clean sweep. Owner Andres Gallego personally handles estimates with detailed cost breakdowns and offers color consultation recommendations at no additional charge. Foreman Nelson manages job sites while crew member Joey has built a specific reputation for expert spackling and skim coating. With over 6 years in business, they've grown almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. Long Island Painting and Restoration is a good option for homeowners with a tight timeline or a full-home project that needs to come together efficiently.

• Crew scales up for larger projects - a six-person team completed an entire whole-home project in a single day.
• Handles full-scope restoration work including popcorn ceiling removal, double-layer wallpaper stripping, and wood rot repair alongside painting.

"Andres and his team were a pleasure to work with. Our project was completed just over a week after we reached out for a quote. We were extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism and attention to detail from start to finish." - Nicole A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality of workmanship is the most consistently praised theme across reviews for painting contractors serving Shelter Island, NY. Interior Finishing NYC stands apart for the depth of its specialty work - owner Dorian Golemi brings a fine arts education to limewash, Roman clay, and Venetian plaster applications that customers describe as "work of art" results. One reviewer brought in Dorian to recreate a specialty strie wall paint after water damage, and the match was described as undetectable between the repainted and original sections. AJ Painting earns detailed praise for precision on high-end East End projects, with one customer describing a complete Farrow & Ball interior across an East Hampton home - meticulous sanding, priming, and finishing that produced what they called "a smooth, architectural finish that elevates the entire home." For Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, foreman Manny and his crew are called out by name in review after review for thorough prep and consistent coverage, including vaulted ceilings, stairwells, and ornate pre-war molding where other contractors had struggled.

On the exterior side, Chameleon Painting Inc. consistently draws praise for detailed surface work - reviews describe soft-washed cedar shingle homes that looked "like new" after staining, and a 2,200-square-foot deck staining project completed precisely. Long Island Painting and Restoration tackled a nearly 100-year-old house, restoring wood rot, scraping, sanding, and repainting to a condition one reviewer called "like new." Todd's Painting has made cabinet refinishing a signature specialty - customers describe spray-finished cabinet doors that look factory-fresh, with the crew removing doors and drawer fronts and refinishing them off-site for a smooth result. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County receives specific marks for skim coat and sheetrock work alongside painting, with project managers verifying the finish at multiple stages before sign-off.

"Manny and his Team were extremely professional, with excellent attention to detail. They were the best painters and interior designers I've ever seen since building my home 20 years ago." - Vic S., Google Review"AJ and his incredible team stand out, even among the best craftspeople and professionals out here on the East End." - Kris K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Timeliness is a consistent strength among the top painting contractors serving Shelter Island, NY, where seasonal property schedules often mean project windows are tight. Todd's Painting is particularly known for fast turnarounds: one reviewer had her estimate completed one afternoon and the entire multi-room project finished by 5pm the following day, including painting over wallpaper. Another customer described a 48-hour turnaround from estimate to completion. Long Island Painting and Restoration regularly scales crew size to compress project timelines - a six-person crew finished a full whole-home project in a single day, and a four-bedroom, two-bath home was wrapped up in under 48 hours. Owner Andres Gallego sets clear schedules with clients and consistently delivers before the agreed completion date. Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian Golemi provides quick estimates - often over phone or video call - then delivers specialty finish projects on tight timelines, with reviewers noting both a living room and guest bedroom limewashed in a single day.

For homeowners managing properties remotely, communication around scheduling is especially important. Chameleon Painting Inc.'s Juan Guillermo Jaramillo sends photo updates to out-of-town clients throughout the project, and confirms completion before they return to the property. AJ Painting reviewers from the East End consistently note reliable crew arrival times and proactive communication when any schedule changes are needed. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County routes scheduling through dedicated project managers, which keeps larger exterior and interior combination projects coordinated and on track even across multi-week timelines. Several customers describe Precision completing full projects on the exact timeline provided at the start - "very rare for any type of service," as one reviewer put it.

"From initial consultation to the final product, we had a 10/10 experience with Andres and his team. Pricing was fair and competitive. His team did an efficient, professional, clean job and even got the job completed quicker than expected." - Patrick H., Google Review"Todd and his crew did an outstanding job! Great attention to detail and finished sooner than I had anticipated. No mess - very clean, always on time." - Doug G., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Professionalism and communication come up as defining themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Shelter Island, NY. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi is consistently described as responsive from first contact, with clients noting quick quote turnarounds and proactive updates when unexpected issues arise mid-project. One reviewer described Dorian discovering a ceiling leak during a job and coordinating with the building super and management company on the client's behalf while she was out of town - handling circumstances well beyond the original scope. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres Gallego is personally named in nearly every review for his direct accessibility - fast callback times, detailed room-by-room estimate walkthroughs, and follow-up calls after project completion. Chameleon Painting Inc.'s Juan Guillermo Jaramillo has personally replied to over 97% of all reviews with individualized responses referencing specific project details - a habit that reflects how he runs the business day-to-day.

For larger team operations, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County channels communication through dedicated project managers, with reviewers naming Chris, Jason, Matt, and Amy as particularly responsive contacts who check in daily on active projects. Multiple customers hired Precision while traveling and described seamless coordination without needing to be on-site. Todd's Painting customers highlight Todd's personal responsiveness - quick text replies, callbacks, and a willingness to return for touch-ups without delay when something isn't quite right. AJ Painting reviewers describe AJ as directly accessible throughout each project, flexible with mid-project adjustments, and patient when clients change their minds - one reviewer noted the crew redid sections without complaint when she wasn't satisfied with the initial approach.

"Owner, Dorian, was tremendous to work with remotely for repainting our corporate office. Communicative, effective and customer-service oriented... I'd happily use Dorian and his team again!" - K.F., Google Review"Juan is very professional. All work was done in a timely fashion. The painters did an excellent job and were very neat and courteous. I will definitely use them again." - Lynda M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Fair pricing and value are frequently mentioned across reviews for painting contractors serving Shelter Island, NY. AJ Painting earns specific praise for competitive pricing on high-end East End projects - one customer commissioned a complete Farrow & Ball interior in an East Hampton home and described the project as delivered "on time and on budget," which they noted was exceptional for premium material work. Interior Finishing NYC customers consistently note that Dorian's pricing came in below competing quotes, even for specialty decorative finish work that other contractors either wouldn't attempt or priced significantly higher. Chameleon Painting Inc. provides detailed line-item proposals that break down each phase of a project by cost, giving clients a clear picture of what they're paying for. One reviewer contracted Chameleon for a church hall that hadn't been painted in 40 years - Juan's was the best price among three estimates, and he included the garage at no additional charge.

Todd's Painting customers frequently describe his pricing as "very reasonable," particularly for cabinet refinishing and power washing - several note they ended up adding more work than originally planned because the price allowed room to do more. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres Gallego is consistently described as providing the best quote among competing bids, with the finished quality surprising clients who expected a compromise. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County operates at a higher price point on larger structured projects, but reviewers consistently describe the value as strong given the project management structure and quality assurance at every stage. One customer came back to have her entire house painted after a single-bedroom project delivered better value than she expected.

"AJ Painting did a great job painting the exterior of my house, including the decks and front gate. The crew worked hard, was friendly, and got the job done quickly and for a fair price." - Fred D., Google Review"They not only met but exceeded our expectations, delivering an amazing paint job that has completely updated our home." - Ryan C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Prep work and cleanup are consistent differentiators among the top painting contractors serving Shelter Island, NY. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is particularly detailed in its pre-paint preparation - crews vacuum wall surfaces before painting, lay paper on floors, move and cover all furniture, and tape off every surface before a brush or roller touches a wall. One customer described returning after a full interior project to find every decoration back in place and nothing left to clean up. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has built a reputation for treating customers' homes like a "white glove operation" - furniture and floors are covered as standard practice, and crews replace everything to its original position when finished. Multiple reviewers note their homes were cleaner when the painters left than when they arrived. One client specifically called out crew member Steve for a large sheetrock patch job that was handled with thorough attention to detail before any paint was applied.

Chameleon Painting Inc. crews protect nearby landscaping, outdoor furniture, and fixtures before any exterior work begins, and leave jobsites organized at the end of every day - a detail that matters for homeowners living on-site during longer projects. Long Island Painting and Restoration receives credit for thorough room-by-room cleanup after large whole-home projects, with crew members walking through every room for touch-ups and debris checks before leaving. Todd's Painting customers highlight careful coverage of floors and trim throughout multi-day interior jobs, and Interior Finishing NYC's Dorian Golemi patches cracks and preps surfaces before applying any specialty finish, with reviewers consistently describing spotless handoff of their spaces after completion.

"They every day showed up on time, kept the place clean and organized during and after work. Can't recommend them enough." - Henry A., Google Review"Prep work is a consistent highlight - the crew vacuumed beforehand, laid paper on floors, moved furniture, and covered everything with plastic before a single brush stroke. My house looks brand new." - Sharon D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Long-term customer relationships are a defining pattern across the top painting contractors serving Shelter Island, NY. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp stands out for the depth of its loyalty base - with over 28 years in business, the company has clients who have called Manny and his crew back for 10, 15, and even over 20 consecutive years of projects. Dawn Scarfo has had the team paint her home from new homeowner updates through major renovations and a full exterior repaint. Customers like Maria P. and kathleen laviano describe booking their next project before the current one is even finished. Todd's Painting has earned a similar level of loyalty - Lori Lucia has used Todd across multiple properties for over 30 years, and John Popovitch hired Todd for his current bathroom after using him in his previous home, noting he "can't stop using the guy." S. B. has trusted Todd's crew with her shop, her home, and her mother's home, often while she's traveling between states.

AJ Painting has built strong repeat customer loyalty across the North Fork and East End community - George Birman has used the crew for every interior and exterior job at his home, and Alexandra K. Hawkins has had her entire house painted twice by AJ's team. Chameleon Painting Inc. has customers returning across a decade of projects, including one homeowner who has hired Juan's crew for room painting, deck painting, and cabinet refinishing over more than 10 years. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County generates consistent referral chains, with customers recommending the company to family and neighbors who become long-term clients in their own right. For Long Island Painting and Restoration, Christine Li is a notable example of referral loyalty - she used Andres and his crew for her first home and called them back immediately when she moved into her second.

"We've used Anthony's twice. Once to paint most of the rooms in our house when we moved in, and again recently to have our bathrooms redone. They've been excellent both times. They're always on time, they clean up, and get the jobs done fast." - Jim Q., Google Review"Just used Todd's painting again for one of my properties and told him I needed it done immediately - he came in and completed the whole thing within one day. I have known and used him for 30 years." - Lori L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook