5 Best Painters Near Water Mill, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The painting contractors serving Water Mill, NY reflect the area's high standards, with teams experienced in everything from decorative specialty finishes to large-scale exterior projects on Hamptons homes. Here are the top-rated options based on our Chooz Score analysis.

Owner Dorian Golemi, who studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, brings a formal artistic background to work that sets Interior Finishing NYC apart from most painting contractors. They lead the field in Water Mill, NY with a Chooz Score of 87.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. With over 22 years in business and a three-year workmanship warranty, this is the right call for homeowners who need Roman clay, Venetian plaster, limewash, wallpaper installation, or gilding - work that most contractors simply don't offer. The team handles both residential and commercial projects, including full corporate office repaints, and Dorian maintains close communication with remote clients throughout each job.

• Specialty decorative finishes - Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, and gold gilding - that most painting contractors don't offer
• Wallpaper installation across difficult surfaces, including cork, grasscloth, and vinyl papers in challenging configurations
• Clients going back over 10 years appear in the review history, reflecting consistent results over time
• Three-year workmanship warranty with a documented touch-up process for follow-up after project completion

"From surface preparation to fine painting with details and gilding, all from one contractor - couldn't have been happier." - Alejandro O., Google Review

For homeowners looking for a family-run Hamptons specialist with deep roots in East End painting, Chameleon Painting Inc. stands out. They hold a Chooz Score of 86.8% with over 170 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. Father-and-son owner Juan Guillermo Jaramillo and family have been serving the Hamptons and North Fork since 2016, with Juan personally reviewing each project before sign-off. What stands out in the reviews is the level of trust customers extend - several describe leaving their home in the crew's care while away on vacation, checking in via photo updates. If you want East End exterior experience, cedar siding work, and detailed interior painting from a hands-on family team, Chameleon is a strong fit.

• Cedar shingle and siding restoration is a recurring project type, well-suited to Hamptons-area architecture
• Itemized, detailed written proposals are mentioned by multiple customers as a standout from other bids received
• Owner follows up personally after project completion to confirm satisfaction

"Chameleon is a family business with very much a pride-in-the-work approach." - Glen C., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Todd's Painting, which holds a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, with additional reviews on Facebook and Yelp. The review base shows customers who hired Todd at a previous home calling again for a new one, and others using the company for commercial work, personal residences, and family members' properties over many years. The range is broad - interior, exterior, power washing, cabinet refinishing, staining, and high-clearance spaces including cathedral ceilings up to 17 feet. For homeowners who want quick, reliable work on interior or exterior projects without a long scheduling wait, Todd's is a strong option.

• Cabinet refinishing and kitchen updates are recurring project types in the review base
• Commercial painting appears alongside residential - including multi-day commercial jobs completed on schedule
• Fast turnarounds are a consistent theme - same-day and next-day completions noted across multiple reviews

"Always a joy to work with. Pricing is reasonable." - S.B., Google Review

When it comes to the East End's mix of historic interiors and premium exterior work, AJ Painting has built a loyal following. They hold a Chooz Score of 84.9% with over 70 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and 100% recommended on Facebook. A 2025 Best of the Best award winner and North Fork Chamber of Commerce member, AJ is a strong fit for homeowners with wallpaper removal projects, historic structures, or exterior work including decks and gates. Several reviewers describe calling AJ for every painting project at their home across multiple years.

• Wallpaper removal across entire homes is a recurring project type, with thorough daily cleanup noted between sessions
• Historic structure and detailed molding experience noted by North Fork customers with older properties
• Exterior work includes full house painting, decks, and gate refinishing at competitive prices

"AJ Painting was on time, professional, and clean." - Kimberly K., Google Review

Also serving the Water Mill, NY area, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. Accredited with the BBB since 2015 and a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner, this company's reviews include customers dating back over a decade. Manager Chris is frequently named for his responsive, organized approach. For homeowners with larger exterior projects or multiple surface types to address, this company is a solid fit - bundling power washing, deck repair, and exterior painting into a single project.

• HOA work appears alongside residential, reflecting experience managing larger-scale and multi-unit projects
• Power washing, deck board replacement, and railing repair combined with exterior painting in several customer accounts
• Referral chains run throughout the reviews - customers consistently recommend the company to neighbors and family

"True masters at their craft. Always a perfect job. Quick and priced very fair." - Ray M., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Water Mill, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration holds a Chooz Score of 84.2%, with over 55 Google reviews - every single one a 5.0-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego handles every estimate personally and provides color consultations at no extra charge. With over 6 years in business, the company has grown almost entirely through referrals, and multiple customers describe calling Andres again when moving to a second property. If you're looking for a contractor who stays personally involved from estimate through final walkthrough, Long Island Painting and Restoration is worth a call.

• Restoration work is a specialty - soot staining, water damage, and worn surface conditions handled with care across multiple customer accounts
• Foreman Nelson and crew member Joey are called out by name across multiple reviews for their careful, skilled approach
• Finished spaces are described as spotless, with furniture returned to its original placement after each job

"Professional, clean, and detail oriented. Pricing was fair and transparent." - Garrett M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Among the top-rated painting contractors serving Water Mill, NY, craftsmanship shows up in reviews with specific, detailed praise rather than vague approval. Interior Finishing NYC draws attention for specialty finishes - Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and gilding - that require an artistic background well beyond standard painting. Chameleon Painting Inc. and AJ Painting earn recognition from East End homeowners for careful preparation and precise execution on projects ranging from cedar siding restoration to wallpaper-covered interiors. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, with over 28 years in business on Long Island, draws consistent praise from long-term clients for thorough, craft-focused results across interior and exterior projects alike.

The depth of craft-focused feedback across these companies reflects the standards homeowners in Water Mill, NY bring to painting work. Todd's Painting reviews describe interior spaces with cathedral ceilings up to 17 feet finished cleanly without cutting corners. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers describe restoration work on walls with soot staining and water damage returned to a clean, even finish. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County draws consistent praise for quality on both interior painting and exterior work throughout Long Island.

• "Dorian and his crew are masters of their craft. Fantastic job for a fair price." - Armen S., Google Review
• "Great attention to detail and finished sooner than anticipated. No mess, very clean." - Doug G., Google Review
• "Everything was outstanding from beginning to end." - Diana S., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Responsive communication and professional conduct run through reviews for the top-rated painting contractors in Water Mill, NY. Interior Finishing NYC stands out for its ability to manage remote projects with consistent photo updates and check-ins, with commercial clients noting Dorian's thorough communication throughout. Chameleon Painting Inc. owner Juan Guillermo Jaramillo is consistently described as accessible before, during, and after each project, fielding questions and making real-time adjustments as needed. Long Island Painting and Restoration owner Andres Gallego is frequently cited for quick response times and clear, detail-focused communication from estimate through final walkthrough.

On-site conduct is equally noted across the board. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers specifically call out manager Chris for his organized, professional approach to scheduling and follow-through. AJ Painting reviewers describe courteous crews who communicate clearly about daily plans and properly remove and reinstall fixtures at the start and close of each project. For homeowners managing Hamptons properties from a distance or working with tight move-in timelines, the communication practices of these contractors appear repeatedly as a deciding factor.

• "Tremendous to work with remotely for repainting our corporate office. Communicative, effective and customer-service oriented." - K.F., Google Review
• "Extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism, and attention to detail from start to finish." - Nicole A., Google Review
• "Chris was polite and on time. What he said was done." - John B., Google Review
• "The pricing was very fair and Juan was extremely responsive to all my questions." - Eric S., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Careful prep and thorough cleanup are among the most frequently noted qualities in reviews for top-rated painters in Water Mill, NY. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County crews are consistently described as protecting every surface before starting - floors covered, furniture draped, and no paint mess left behind. AJ Painting reviews note thorough daily cleanup even on multi-day wallpaper removal projects, with fixtures properly removed and reinstalled at the close of each job. Chameleon Painting Inc. crews are praised for covering not just furniture, but cameras, light switches, and outlets before starting. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp crews follow a documented pre-paint routine that includes photographing the space, removing wall hangings, and covering all surfaces before a single brush stroke - a process long-term clients describe as a hallmark of the company's approach.

For homeowners concerned about disruption or mess during a painting project, the cleanup consistency of these contractors is worth noting. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers repeatedly describe arriving home to find the space left spotless, with furniture returned to its original placement. Todd's Painting reviews describe organized, tidy crews across both interior and exterior jobs. Interior Finishing NYC customers note that even complex specialty finish projects involving multiple materials are handled with careful containment and daily cleanup throughout.

• "Furniture moved and covered with no issues. Results look amazing." - Susan C., Google Review
• "Team was on time and worked quick and neat!" - Shira S., Google Review
• "The workers are neat, courteous and left their areas clean." - Janette C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Reliable scheduling and on-time arrival appear consistently in reviews for top-rated painting contractors in Water Mill, NY. Long Island Painting and Restoration shows a strong pattern of fast project completions - customers describe entire home interiors finished over a single day or weekend without any noted drop in quality. Todd's Painting reviews describe same-day and next-day completions as a recurring practice, and customers note that Todd honors the schedule set during the estimate stage. Chameleon Painting Inc. is consistently praised for finishing ahead of projected timelines while still maintaining attention to detail throughout.

For homeowners in the Water Mill, NY area managing seasonal Hamptons properties or working with tight move-in deadlines, the scheduling track record of these contractors is a meaningful advantage. AJ Painting reviewers describe crews arriving on time each day of a multi-day project, with the final completion matching the date discussed at the estimate. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers note that projects run on schedule from start to finish, with consistent daily start times throughout each job.

• "Finished much faster than predicted, did a great job, and cleaned up after themselves." - Honor L., Google Review
• "The crew showed up when they said they would, worked hard and efficiently." - Jill S., Google Review
• "They were responsive, punctual and pricing was fair!" - Jacquelyn R., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Fair pricing relative to scope and quality appears consistently in reviews for top-rated painters in Water Mill, NY. AJ Painting customers mention competitive pricing on larger projects, including full exterior work with decks and gates. Interior Finishing NYC draws praise for keeping specialty decorative work - Roman clay, gilding, Venetian plaster - accessible without a price tag that reflects only the difficulty of the techniques. Todd's Painting customers describe pricing that matches the estimate with no surprises, and several note they ended up having more work done than originally planned because the quote came in under their expectations.

For Long Island Painting and Restoration, free estimates that include color consultations reflect owner Andres Gallego's approach to building trust before any commitment is made. Chameleon Painting Inc. customers point to itemized written proposals that break down each component of the job, making it easier to compare bids and understand exactly what is included. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County reviews from customers going back over a decade suggest pricing consistency that keeps clients returning for multiple projects over the years.

• "Clean, efficient, and do quality work quickly and at very competitive prices." - George B., Google Review
• "Did it all in two days, and the cost didn't break the bank." - Elizabeth A., Google Review
• "They are fairly priced, clean up, honest, trustworthy and reliable!" - Robyn D., Google Review
• "Pricing was fair and the job was done quickly and professionally." - Wayne M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

The Water Mill, NY area creates natural demand for painting contractors who handle more than standard brush-and-roller work. Cedar shingle exteriors, historic homes with detailed molding and trim, high-end interiors requiring specific decorative finishes, and properties managed by absentee owners all show up as recurring project types in reviews for the top contractors here. Interior Finishing NYC is the clearest specialist - owner Dorian Golemi's fine arts background makes the company uniquely equipped to handle Roman clay, Venetian plaster, limewash, marmorino, and gold gilding, as well as complex wallpaper installations across difficult surfaces like cork, grasscloth, and vinyl papers. Several customers describe projects that other contractors declined before Dorian accepted and delivered exceptional results.

Chameleon Painting Inc. draws on years of Hamptons experience to handle cedar siding restoration, deck staining, and large-scale exterior work at properties ranging from private residences to a church hall that hadn't been touched in over 40 years. AJ Painting has built a reputation on the North Fork for working on historic structures with demanding surface prep requirements, and handles full-scale wallpaper removal across entire homes. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County adds interior wallpapering to its service mix, with customers describing full apartment wallpaper projects completed on time and within budget. Long Island Painting and Restoration focuses on restoration scenarios specifically - soot staining, water damage, and worn surfaces on walls that require more than a standard repaint.

• "Dorian did a fantastic job wallpapering an accent wall with a thick cork paper." - Julie K., Google Review
• "Juan and his family do incredibly thorough and finely detailed work." - Albert L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google