3 Best Painters Near Sagaponack, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The Hamptons and East End communities like Sagaponack, NY attract painting contractors who work on some of the most demanding properties on Long Island, from weathered cedar-shingled beach houses to high-end estate interiors with intricate millwork. The top-rated contractors on Chooz Painters have built their reputations through referrals, returning customers, and years of consistent results across the region.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Chameleon Painting Inc. had over 170 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 86.8%. Led by Juan Guillermo Jaramillo and his family, this father-and-son operation has spent over 10 years in business serving the Hamptons and North Fork. What stands out in the reviews is the level of trust customers place in this crew: several describe leaving for extended trips or running errands while Juan and his team paint the entire home, receiving daily photo updates to stay informed. Juan personally oversees estimates and job-site progress, and the range of projects is broad, from cedar siding staining and deck restoration to wallpaper installation and church hall repaints. If you are a homeowner who needs a crew you can leave unsupervised with confidence, Chameleon Painting Inc. is a strong fit.

• Several customers describe leaving on extended trips, even out of state, while the team painted their entire home, with photo updates provided throughout to keep owners informed
• Projects span a wide range: soft-washing weathered shingles, staining 2,200-square-foot decks, painting cedar siding, wallpapering, and basement epoxy floors
• A family member or supervisor visits job sites daily to check progress and quality before wrapping up each day

"I bought my home in December and then went to Florida and left Juan to paint my whole house while I was gone. He kept me updated with pictures and reports. I came back to see a perfect job." - Ellen, Google Review

Also serving Sagaponack, NY and the surrounding East End, Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, with additional reviews on Yelp and Facebook. Cabinet painting is a specialty that surfaces again and again in reviews: customers describe spray-applied finishes on kitchen cabinets that come out looking factory-new. Todd also handles commercial work, from an animal hospital exterior to a congregation's gallery with very high ceilings. Several reviewers note that Todd proactively suggested a different paint color before starting the job, saving them a costly repaint later. If you want a go-to painter who will handle jobs of all sizes and keep coming back for years, Todd's Painting is a good choice.

• Cabinet refinishing is a frequently requested specialty, with spray-applied finishes described as looking factory-new in multiple reviews
• Commercial work is part of the portfolio: animal hospitals, congregation galleries with high ceilings, and retail spaces alongside residential projects
• Todd proactively advises on paint color choices, with multiple reviewers crediting his recommendation for saving them a repaint down the road
• Long-term loyalty is common, with one customer noting she has used Todd's for over 30 years across multiple properties

"Start to finish, Todd's painting was a great decision! Communication was prompt and concise. Work was completed as described. Todd and his crew are professional. They left the area clean at the end of each day and returned as promised, on time. We are delighted with our maple cabinet makeover." - Donna DiNapoli, Google Review

When it comes to large-scale projects across Long Island's East End, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY brings a structured, full-team approach backed by a strong track record. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.3% with over 200 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and over 100 reviews on Angi at a 4.7-star rating. Owner Jim LaFontaine is named throughout reviews for personal involvement from estimate to final walkthrough, and the office team, including AnnMarie and Jennifer, earns consistent praise for responsiveness and flexibility when project timelines shift. Repeat clients include a property manager of a condo complex who has used the company for over 8 years and a homeowner who returned 11 years later for a second project. If you manage multiple properties on the East End or need a company that can handle volume and complexity, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY is worth calling.

• Office staff AnnMarie and Jennifer earn consistent praise for clear communication and flexibility when projects change or expand
• Crew members Gabriel, Noe, Frank, and Chris are called out by name in reviews for careful edgework and attention to trim details
• Repeat clients include commercial property managers and homeowners who have returned for multiple projects spanning over a decade

"We hired CertaPro of Port Jefferson to paint one of our homes in the Hamptons. Ann Marie, Jennifer, Frank, Jim were a class act from start to finish. Very responsive and professional. It was efficiently completed and we were very happy with the work." - Anthony Iervolino, Google Review

For homeowners working on historic or luxury properties across the East End, AJ Painting has developed a reputation that draws clients back project after project. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.9% with over 70 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and 100% recommended on Facebook. AJ has also been recognized as a North Fork Chamber of Commerce member and a 2025 Best of the Best award winner. Named crew members Angel, Andy, Isay, and Lindo appear across multiple reviews, and the team works with premium paint brands including Farrow & Ball, which requires specific application techniques not every crew handles confidently. Customers note patience with color indecision and a willingness to revisit sections that do not fully meet expectations. If you are working on a historic property or planning a high-end project with premium finishes, AJ Painting is a good fit.

• Experience with historic properties, including a 110-year-old farmhouse in a North Fork historic district that required knowledge of older construction and careful prep throughout
• Farrow & Ball paint application, where technique is critical to achieving the intended finish, is specifically mentioned by name in reviews
• Repeat customers are common, with several reviewers describing both interior and exterior projects completed across multiple seasons

"My husband and I are lucky to have had a lot of expert work done on our 110-year-old farmhouse in a historic district in NoFo over the last 16+ years. But AJ and his incredible team stand out, even among the best craftspeople and professionals out here on the East End." - Kris Kim, Google Review

With nearly two decades in business, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings a manager-driven process that keeps larger projects organized from start to finish. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, and they are accredited with the Better Business Bureau and a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. Project managers Jason, Chris, Dave, and Matt are named throughout reviews as the key point of contact for day-to-day questions. A field manager visits job sites days before work begins to confirm colors and logistics, and customers who were away from home during painting describe returning to completed work and a clean space. If you prefer a company with a formal project management structure and a long track record on Long Island, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a good choice.

• A field manager visits the property before work begins to confirm colors, reducing day-of miscommunication on multi-room jobs
• Project managers Jason, Chris, and Dave are cited by name in reviews as the reason jobs stay on track and communication stays clear
• The team replaces furniture and decor after the job, leaving rooms in the same order they found them

"The field manager came to the house days before to receive the shades of colors that were to be used. All the paint was ordered true to the required colors. The field manager and painters arrived at the time scheduled. The painters were very neat and clean." - CarolJean Canavan, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Sagaponack, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews, every one a five-star rating. In over 6 years in business, owner Andres Gallego has built the company almost entirely on referrals. What stands out in the reviews is the combination of speed and quality: multiple customers describe a full home interior completed in under 48 hours, and one reviewer notes a crew of six arriving to finish a large job in a single day. Andres personally walks through color choices with homeowners before work begins, and several new homeowners describe returning when they purchased a second property. If you are a new homeowner or working with a tight timeline on a full repaint, Long Island Painting and Restoration is worth a call.

• Crew sizes scale to the project: smaller jobs receive a tight, focused team while larger homes can see six or more painters arrive on day one
• New homeowners are a core customer base, with multiple reviewers describing calling Andres for their second or third home after a strong first experience
• Restoration work is part of their portfolio, including older homes requiring wood rot repair, scraping, and thorough surface prep before painting begins

"We had our almost 100 year old house and detached garage's exterior painted by them. And all I can say is Amazing!! They restored wood rot, scraped, sanded and brought back our home to like new condition. They were professional and cleaned up after each work day." - D G, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Painting quality is the theme that runs through nearly every review for contractors serving Sagaponack, NY and the East End. AJ Painting stands out for technically demanding work: one reviewer describes a full interior at an East Hampton home using Farrow & Ball paint, noting that proper application technique was critical to achieving the intended finish. Another long-term customer describes a 110-year-old farmhouse in a North Fork historic district that required specialized prep and careful handling throughout. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY earns consistent praise for detailed craftsmanship, with one reviewer noting intricate trim and wainscoting in a home listed at $2.7 million, where the results drew multiple compliments after listing. Chameleon Painting Inc. reviews highlight precision at any project scale, from multi-color kitchen cabinet refinishing to full exterior cedar siding restoration on Hamptons homes.

Todd's Painting customers frequently describe results that change the feel of a room entirely, particularly on cabinet and exterior projects where the finished product draws compliments from neighbors. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns strong praise for exterior restoration: reviewers describe wood rot repair, thorough scraping, and priming on older homes before a single coat of paint is applied. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp crews approach prep with the same level of care, photographing each room before starting, removing artwork and fixtures, and covering every surface before picking up a brush, a process customers consistently call out as a sign the crew is serious about protecting the finished result.

"AJ approached the project with a level of professionalism and craftsmanship that immediately set him apart. We used premium Farrow & Ball paints throughout the house, and as anyone who has worked with them knows, the application makes all the difference." - Christopher Bruno, Google Review"Andres and his crew did a wonderful job painting our home in such a timely manner! He was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his guys, they are very reliable, neat and friendly to work with!" - Christine Li, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Responsiveness is one of the most consistent themes in reviews for painting contractors serving Sagaponack, NY. Chameleon Painting Inc. customers who are away from home during painting describe receiving photo updates throughout the process, with Juan personally sending progress reports so homeowners feel informed even from a distance. Todd's Painting earns praise for quick replies to texts and calls, and one reviewer notes Todd sent photo updates during an exterior job so she could see the progress without being on-site. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY has an advantage in this area through its office team: AnnMarie and Jennifer are named throughout reviews for responding quickly to emails and calls, accommodating timeline changes, and keeping clients updated as projects move forward. Owner Jim LaFontaine is also noted for being personally reachable by phone.

Long Island Painting and Restoration reviews frequently describe Andres as quick to respond to estimate requests, often within the same day, and customers note he walks through each room during the initial consultation rather than just eyeballing the job. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County assigns named project managers to each job, giving homeowners a direct contact for questions rather than leaving them to chase down answers. AJ Painting customers describe an accessible owner who follows up during the project and is flexible when homeowners change their minds mid-job. Across all six companies, the pattern is clear: the best-reviewed contractors are the ones who keep communication as a priority, not an afterthought.

"Working with CertaPro was amazing. I was constantly changing the appointment dates and adding projects to my original quote and everyone was very understanding. AnnMarie and Frank were super helpful and great communicators. They always responded to my emails and calls in a timely manner." - Gabrielle LaBranche, Google Review"Todd was very communicative, giving me picture updates throughout and did a perfect job! My home looks amazing!" - Maeve Connolly, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Punctuality and schedule reliability are among the most frequently praised qualities across all painting contractors serving Sagaponack, NY. Chameleon Painting Inc. customers describe projects that started on the exact date discussed and wrapped up by the date promised, with one reviewer noting the entire exterior of their home was completed on schedule and on budget. Todd's Painting crews are described as arriving ready to work, with a commercial client noting the team showed up early both days of a two-day job. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp customers consistently mention that when Manny sets a timeline, the crew delivers: one reviewer who has used the company many times notes that when Manny says something will take two days, it takes two days, no surprises.

Long Island Painting and Restoration stands out for speed: several reviewers describe a full four-bedroom, two-bathroom interior completed in under 48 hours, and one customer notes the job was finished a full day ahead of the projected timeline. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY earns similar praise, with multiple reviewers noting the job was completed within or under the original time estimate. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers describe a process that starts on time and follows through, with one reviewer noting the project finished exactly as promised despite a large and complex scope. For East End homeowners with tight schedules or rental turnover windows, these companies' track records on timing matter.

"It was a 2-day project and they showed up early both days and finished on time! Their work is impeccable, their prices are reasonable and the team is extremely professional and pleasant to work with." - Beth I, Google Review"His team did an efficient, professional, clean job and even got the job completed quicker than expected. Highly recommend!" - Patrick Healy, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Prep work and end-of-day cleanup are two areas where the top-rated painting contractors in Sagaponack, NY clearly separate themselves from the competition. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp crews follow a documented prep routine: they photograph each room before starting, remove artwork, fixtures, and switch plates, and cover every surface before the first coat goes on. Several customers describe coming home to find the room looking exactly as they left it, with everything replaced in its original spot. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY takes a similarly thorough approach, with one reviewer describing the crew plastic-wrapping cabinets and appliances and laying wall-to-wall tarps before starting a kitchen job. Chameleon Painting Inc. crews leave a clean worksite each day, and one reviewer notes the crew reattached downspouts and left no paint on the ground, deck, or trim after completing an exterior job.

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County consistently earns mentions for leaving homes clean and helping move furniture back into place after painting, something several reviewers describe as an unexpected bonus. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers describe the crew cleaning up thoroughly at the end of each work day on multi-day jobs, with the finished space left spotless when work is complete. Todd's Painting follows the same pattern, with multiple reviewers describing clean workspaces at the end of each day and an area left ready to use when the crew wraps up. For homeowners sharing living space during a paint job, these practices make a real difference.

"They come in, take pictures, then take all decorations and pictures down, cover everything and go to work. Lots of time spent on preparation before painting. My house looked perfect when they were done." - Tom Wedell, Google Review"They literally plastic wrapped the cabinets and all appliances as well as wall to wall tarps. The paint job of the walls and ceilings came out beautifully." - Darlene Perillo, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

For a market like the East End, where contractor rates can vary widely, the top-rated painting companies in Sagaponack, NY are consistently described as fair and transparent on price. AJ Painting earns particular praise for offering competitive pricing on high-quality work, with one repeat customer who has used the company for every interior and exterior job noting the prices are competitive without sacrificing results. Long Island Painting and Restoration stands out in this area as well, with one reviewer who obtained multiple quotes noting that Andres and his team offered the best price compared to other companies before delivering work that impressed. Chameleon Painting Inc. customers across many reviews describe pricing as fair and reasonable, with a detailed estimate format that breaks down each aspect of the job rather than offering a single vague number.

Todd's Painting reviews frequently mention price as a reason customers keep returning, and one reviewer notes the quote was so reasonable they added extra work they had not originally planned. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is consistently described as affordable while maintaining quality, with customers noting competitive pricing on everything from full exterior repaints to wallpaper removal and ceiling repairs. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County carries a slightly more premium positioning in some reviews, with a few customers noting the price is higher than others, but adding the quality and communication make it worthwhile. For the East End market, where homes represent significant investments, most reviewers frame reasonable pricing as part of what makes these contractors stand out.

"I have used them for all of my interior and exterior paint jobs. They are clean, efficient, and do quality work quickly and at very competitive prices." - George Birman, Google Review"The price was very good - I actually got more work done than I originally wanted. All-around great experience, definitely highly recommend." - Chris Mc, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Repeat customers and multi-year loyalty tell one of the clearest stories in the reviews for painting contractors serving Sagaponack, NY. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp has some of the deepest roots: with over 28 years in business, the company has customers who have been calling them back for 10, 15, and over 20 years. One reviewer describes the team painting her home continuously since she first moved in as a new homeowner, through renovations and an exterior repaint years later. Several other reviewers describe booking their next project before the current one is even finished, a sign of confidence that is hard to manufacture. Todd's Painting shows a similar pattern, with one customer noting she has used Todd for over 30 years across multiple properties, and another describing a steady relationship for power washing that has gone on for years alongside painting work.

Chameleon Painting Inc. also earns strong repeat business: one reviewer describes hiring Juan and his team for multiple rooms, a fence project, and other work over time, stating the company is the only one she will call for painting going forward. Long Island Painting and Restoration has a notable pattern among new homeowners: multiple reviewers describe using Andres and his team for their first home, then calling him again when they purchased a second property. AJ Painting customers describe returning for both interior and exterior projects across multiple years, and one homeowner has had the entire house painted twice. For contractors serving the East End's second-home market, the ability to build and keep this kind of trust is what drives long-term referral business.

"Anthony's Painting team has been painting my home for 20 years. From updating as new homeowners to renovations and recently the exterior of my home. They are professional, trustworthy and diligent. I wouldn't use anyone else!" - Dawn Scarfo, Google Review"Juan and the team at Chameleon are absolutely fantastic! We have hired them for a variety of projects in our house. They have painted multiple rooms, and most recently, our fence. Every job is done professionally, neatly and timely. We will only use them for any of our painting needs." - Erin Despres, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook