Chooz Score Insights
Customers Keep Coming Back
Seven of the reviewers we analyzed describe returning to AJ Painting for additional work, and that kind of loyalty doesn't happen by accident. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: reviewers mention returning for 2nd, 3rd, and even "all" of their painting projects over the years:
- George Birman has used them for every interior and exterior paint job, Jerry Silverstein has hired them three times, and Alexandra K. Hawkins had her whole house painted twice
- Patriot P. used AJ for years of interior work before trusting them with a full exterior, and Alice Van describes a professional job "every time" they paint at her house
"We have had AJ painting at our house three times. AJ does a wonderfully neat and careful job and runs his business with dependable integrity." - Jerry S., Google Review
The Reviews Speak for Themselves
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, AJ Painting Inc. had over 70 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.9%. Reviews span multiple platforms with consistent top marks:
- 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook, reflecting the same quality across every platform where customers leave feedback
- North Fork Chamber of Commerce member and 2025 Best of the Best award winner, with Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition from the local community
"AJ did a phenomenal job and went so far above and beyond to work on our Watermill studio - he is a 10 star company and made so many adjustments as we did a very fast turn around." - Kendell B., Google Review
Craftsmanship You Can See
Customers don't just say the work is good, they describe it in detail. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong: reviewers mention specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines that paint a consistent picture of careful, deliberate work:
- Christopher Bruno's East Hampton project with premium Farrow & Ball paints required meticulous sanding, patching, and priming, producing what he calls "a smooth, architectural finish that elevates the entire home"
- Kris Kim's 110-year-old farmhouse in a historic North Fork district required floor-to-ceiling work across two floors, including kitchen cabinets, built-ins, three stairwells, a fireplace, and detailed molding and trim, and AJ came in on time and on budget
"My husband & I are lucky to have had a lot of expert work done on our 110-year-old farmhouse in a historic district in NoFo over the last 16+ years. But AJ and his incredible team stand out, even among the best craftspeople and professionals out here on the East End." - Kris K., Google Review
Worked with this company?
All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.
Additional Questions Answered
What do customers say about AJ Painting's approach to surface preparation before the actual painting begins?
Customers describe meticulous prep as a defining feature of the company's work. Christopher Bruno noted that sanding, patching, repairs and priming were handled without shortcuts, producing a smooth architectural finish. Helcat explained that the crew scraped all the old peeling paint off the house and removed overgrown vines before repainting. Kimberly Keith praised how thoroughly the team removed wallpaper throughout the entire home and cleaned up at the end of each workday.
How do reviewers describe the professionalism and demeanor of AJ Painting's crew members?
Homeowners frequently single out individual crew members by name. Ronald CAFFREY credited Angel, Andy, Isay and Lindo for an amazing interior job. Kendell Brenner, Head of Operations for Tracy Anderson Mind and Body, called AJ a ten-star company after a fast-turnaround studio project in Watermill. Liz Genovesi described the team as trustworthy and detail-oriented, saying you only have to ask once for what you are looking for.
Is there evidence that AJ Painting handles premium or specialty paint products effectively?
Christopher Bruno's review provides the clearest example. He described using Farrow & Ball paints throughout his East Hampton home and emphasized that the depth of color, consistency of finish and precision of lines were flawless. He added that the final product felt refined, tailored and intentional, and that it genuinely changed the character of the house.
How responsive is AJ Painting when issues arise after a project is completed?
Shannon Taylor's experience speaks directly to post-project responsiveness. After a ceiling leak occurred following the paint job, AJ was able to quickly come back and fix everything. She noted the team was flexible with timing and efficient in coordinating both painting and wallpaper installation in one project.
Do customers return to AJ Painting for additional projects, and what does that say about their satisfaction?
Multiple reviewers confirm repeat business. Alexandra Hawkins wrote that AJ has painted her whole house twice. Jerry Silverstein reported hiring them three times, praising AJ's neat, careful work and dependable integrity. George Birman stated he has used them for all of his interior and exterior paint jobs. Patriot P. on Yelp noted using AJ Painting for years for interior work before hiring them for a full exterior repaint.
What types of exterior projects has AJ Painting completed, and how do homeowners rate the results?
Exterior work ranges from full house repaints to targeted projects. Fred de la Vega praised the team's work painting the exterior of his house, including decks and a front gate. Helcat described a comprehensive exterior job that involved removing vines, scraping decades of peeling paint and repainting the entire house. miranda dempster plans to hire AJ for exterior work after a successful interior project.
What is AJ Painting's licensing and business registration status in New York?
AJ Painting holds an active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor license (H-57396), issued August 2016 with expiration in August 2028. The business entity AJ Painting & Renovations, Corp. is registered as a Domestic Business Corporation with the New York Department of State (DOS ID 5505583), with an initial filing date of March 2019 and entity status listed as Active.
-Verification Sources: Suffolk County DCA, NY Department of State Division of Corporations