Homeowners in Shelter Island Heights, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors serving the East End of Long Island. Our Chooz Score analysis evaluated companies across Google, Facebook, and Yelp, and the standout qualities across this group are fast turnarounds, strong communication, and thorough prep work.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, appearing on Facebook and Yelp as well. The company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Todd's range of work covers exterior painting and staining, power washing, kitchen cabinet refinishing, commercial interiors, and painting over wallpaper without removal. Reviews describe Todd as taking careful notes during estimates and personally supervising each job. If you're looking for a versatile, hands-on contractor who handles both residential and commercial projects, Todd's Painting is a good fit.
- Cabinet refinishing is a recurring specialty - Todd's crew removes doors, sprays them off-site professionally, and reinstalls them to a finish customers describe as factory-quality.
- Long-term loyalty runs deep in the reviews, with multiple customers describing 10, 20, and even 30 years of returning to Todd's Painting across multiple properties.
"Todd...a pencil waving, note taking, detailed craftsman who genuinely wants his customers happy." - Ann Douglas, Google Review
For homeowners seeking a painter with deep East End experience, AJ Painting earned a Chooz Score of 84.9%, with over 70 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and 100% recommended on Facebook. AJ Painting is a North Fork Chamber of Commerce member and 2025 Best of the Best award winner. Reviews describe careful prep and skilled application on premium Farrow and Ball paints, historic North Fork farmhouses, and Hamptons studios requiring fast turnarounds with precision. If you own a premium East End property or a historic home with complex painting needs, AJ Painting is worth a call.
- Premium paint expertise is well-documented - customers describe Farrow and Ball applications handled with professional-grade prep and consistency across high-end East End properties.
- Repeat customers appear prominently throughout the reviews, with several homeowners describing AJ as their go-to for every interior and exterior project at their home.
"AJ is very accessible, and accommodating on the project. His guys are trustworthy and very detail-oriented. You only have to ask once for what you're looking for." - Liz Genovesi, Google Review
While AJ Painting focuses on the East End premium market, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings a structured operation with formal project management to Long Island painting. The company earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%, with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. It has been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015 and is a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. Project managers - named in reviews as Chris, Jason, Amy, Jonathan, Matt, and Fernando - visit job sites daily and stay communicative throughout. If you prefer formal systems around quoting, scheduling, and on-site oversight, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a solid choice.
- Named project managers appear consistently across reviews, with Jason, Chris, and Matt cited as attentive and present throughout multi-day projects.
- Wallpaper removal and installation, skim coating, and sheetrock patching are among the capabilities reviewers document.
"The project managers, both Amy and Jonathan kept me well informed during the entire process." - Stuart Ebner, Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Long Island Painting and Restoration, which earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 55 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect mark across every review on file. With over 6 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, the company has grown almost entirely through word-of-mouth. Owner Andres Gallego is cited by name in nearly every review and handles walkthroughs and color consultations personally. If you want the owner directly involved from estimate to final walkthrough, Long Island Painting and Restoration stands out.
- Andres is named in nearly every review, personally handling walkthroughs, color consultations, and site check-ins throughout each project.
- True restoration capabilities appear in reviews: wood rot repair on a nearly century-old home, wallpaper removal, and skim coating are documented alongside standard painting.
"The crew showed up when they said they would, worked hard and efficiently, and finished the job earlier than anticipated." - Jill Simson, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Shelter Island Heights, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earned a Chooz Score of 81.5% with over 28 years in business. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Founded in 1997, the company holds active Suffolk County License No. HI-67566 and Nassau County License No. H380731. Crew leader Manny is named in the large majority of reviews and is described as personally involved in color selection, prep planning, and quality checks throughout. If you're looking for a long-established Long Island contractor with formal licensing credentials and a proven track record, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is a strong choice.
- Color consultation is built into the service - Manny is described in reviews as helping households choose finishes for every room before work begins.
- The prep routine is systematic: crews photograph rooms, remove artwork and fixtures, cover everything with plastic, and complete all spackling before painting starts.
"They come in, take pictures, then take all decorations and pictures down, cover everything and go to work. Lots of time spent on preparation before painting." - Tom Wedell, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
