3 Best Painters Near Wading River, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Wading River, NY have access to a strong and diverse group of painting contractors serving Suffolk County - from specialty decorative finish specialists to high-volume residential crews. The contractors below are ranked by their Chooz Scores, which weigh review volume, platform ratings, and business credibility indicators.

For homeowners seeking decorative and specialty finishes that go well beyond standard paint work, Interior Finishing NYC is the top-ranked contractor in this dataset, earning a Chooz Score of 87.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating - a particularly notable achievement for a specialty contractor whose work includes limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, gilding, and wallpaper installation on challenging surfaces. Owner Dorian Golemi brings a fine arts background to each project and is physically on-site for all jobs, working alongside his crew. If you're looking for a painter who can tackle complex decorative work that other contractors won't attempt, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong choice.

Customers who hire Dorian often end up expanding their project mid-job after seeing the initial results. Several reviewers who booked a single room describe immediately scheduling additional spaces. The team also handles commercial turnarounds for retail and office environments, and Dorian's ability to color-match pre-existing specialty finishes - including faux textures, strie paint, and damaged ornate woodwork on older buildings - comes up across multiple reviews as a skill most contractors simply can't offer.

• Customers who hired the team for one room frequently return to have additional spaces done in the same season.
• Commercial clients including retail spaces, corporate offices, and co-op buildings use this team for tight-deadline projects.
• Dorian's ability to match pre-existing specialty finishes - including faux and strie applications - is highlighted across multiple reviews as rare in the industry.
• Quotes are often provided by phone or video call, saving customers an in-person scheduling step.

"Dorian and his team did a great job with our apartment. He worked closely with us to finalize the right color for each room and was incredibly knowledgeable about the product and process. We used a specialty lime wash paint and the application was executed perfectly, including one room we entirely color-drenched." - Jon B., Google Review

For homeowners looking for a reliable, versatile local painter with an unusually broad scope of work, Todd's Painting has built a dedicated following across Suffolk County. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Todd's crew covers everything from interior painting and cabinet refinishing to power washing, deck staining, exterior painting, and fence work. If you want a painter who handles multiple surfaces in a single project - and who will give you an honest color recommendation before work begins - Todd's Painting is a strong fit.

Cabinet refinishing shows up across dozens of reviews as a particular specialty, with customers describing finished results that look freshly factory-made. Beyond standard projects, Todd regularly takes on surfaces other painters decline - vinyl sheds, chain-link fencing, pool decks, and stair railings. Multiple homeowners describe leaving the crew with full, unsupervised access to their home while traveling or out of state, which reflects the trust this company has built over years of consistent work.

• Cabinet painting is a noted specialty, with customers describing results that look professionally refinished rather than hand-painted.
• Unusual surfaces - vinyl siding, fences, pool decks, and exterior staining - are part of his regular scope, not exceptions.
• Todd proactively flags color choices before work begins, catching potential issues customers didn't see themselves.

"The color my son picked was too bright and Todd recommended to change it which I was so grateful for. The room came out perfect and we all were happy! Other painters would of just painted the room with the color and we would of had to repaint it." - Karen F., Google Review

While Todd's Painting covers a broad range of surfaces and project types, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY brings a structured, team-based approach to larger and more complex residential and commercial jobs. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, plus over 100 reviews on Angi with a 4.7-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 85.3%. With over 7 years in business serving Central Suffolk County, the Hamptons, and the North Fork, this team is well-suited for homeowners who want a clear estimate process and a coordinated project management structure from start to finish. For larger jobs with multiple moving parts, CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY is a solid choice.

Owner Jim LaFontaine is described in review after review as hands-on with estimates and personally involved with clients throughout the project. Beyond residential work, the team handles HOA communities, commercial spaces, and large-scale property management accounts. Their scope extends into drywall repair, wallpaper removal, and accent wall installation - and they offer in-house color consultation so customers don't need a separate designer.

• Owner Jim LaFontaine is consistently named in reviews as personally involved from the estimate through project completion.
• Commercial and HOA work - including long-running relationships with large condo and property management clients - is a regular part of their business.
• Their project scope includes drywall repair, mold remediation, skim coating, and structural accent work beyond standard painting.

"They did such a great job painting my house interior and fixing my living room ceiling, replacing the damaged drywall and installing an accent wood shiplap wall. We challenged them and they delivered above and beyond." - Scott C., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 84.5%. With nearly two decades in business and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2015, this company brings a more structured, project-managed experience to jobs of all sizes. Named project managers - including Jason, Chris, Matt, and David - appear across reviews, creating a more coordinated workflow than smaller crews. If you value clear communication at every stage and want a company you can call back for multiple projects over the years, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is a strong choice.

The company's scope extends well beyond interior painting - they handle wallpaper installation and removal, deck staining and board repair, and exterior work on homes with complex, multi-surface construction. One review describes a project on a home over 200 years old that required careful exterior preparation before painting could begin. Referral chains appear throughout the reviews, with customers routinely sending neighbors, family members, and friends.

• Named project managers provide updates and oversight across multi-day jobs, creating a more organized experience than single-person operations.
• Their scope extends to wallpaper removal and installation, deck staining, and thorough exterior prep on older and historically significant homes.
• Referral patterns appear frequently in reviews, with customers sending neighbors, friends, and family members to the same crew.

"Communication was constant and fast. Jason was very informative and present throughout. Trish was quick with the finances and paint colors. Fernando and his crew were friendly, courteous and quick with their painting. Everything was left spotless." - Lorinda B., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Wading River, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration has built a near-perfect reputation almost entirely through word-of-mouth. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 55 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating - every single review a five-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%. Owner Andres Gallego personally handles estimates, walks through every room before work begins, and gives honest color recommendations as part of the process. With over 6 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, this crew handles a broader scope than their size suggests - from interior painting and wall prep to exterior restoration, popcorn ceiling removal, and staining. If you've just moved into a new home and want it refreshed from top to bottom quickly, this team is a strong fit.

Several reviewers describe calling Andres when they bought a second home, having trusted him with their first. The crew scales up for large jobs when needed, and projects consistently finish ahead of schedule. Beyond standard painting, they handle multi-layer wallpaper stripping, skim coating, and brick repair on older exteriors as part of their standard scope.

• Projects consistently finish ahead of schedule, with multiple reviewers describing surprise at how quickly large jobs wrapped up.
• The crew handles significant prep work - popcorn ceiling removal, multi-layer wallpaper stripping, and brick repair - before painting begins.
• Repeat customers appear throughout the reviews, including homeowners who called Andres when they bought their second property.

"He was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his guys - they are very reliable, neat and friendly to work with!" - Christine L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Across the contractors serving Wading River, NY, quality of the finished work is one of the most consistently mentioned themes in customer reviews - and for several of these companies, it's the primary reason customers return. Interior Finishing NYC draws particular praise for specialty applications that go far beyond standard brushwork. Owner Dorian Golemi's fine arts background shows in the results customers describe - accent walls that match inspiration photos precisely, limewash applications with visible texture and depth, and multi-wall wallpaper murals that required navigating complex structural angles and irregular surfaces. Todd's Painting earns consistent praise for crisp, even results across interiors, with reviewers describing cathedral-ceiling rooms and 30-year-old walls that look completely refreshed after thorough spackle work and careful preparation before any paint was applied.

"Dorian did an incredible job on our wallpaper - he is an artist. It was a big, difficult job with multiple 2-wall murals which involved a lot of awkward structural pieces to work around. He took his time to make sure every piece was perfect, it has come out way better than we ever dreamed." - William C., Google Review

CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY gets strong marks for tackling complex architectural details in high-value homes - including vaulted ceilings with exposed beams, intricate trim, wainscoting, and painted wood panels that require careful edgework and steady crews. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers describe walls that look genuinely refreshed after significant prep - stripping, spackle, and skim coat work is handled in-house before painting begins, and the results reflect that foundation. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has handled exterior projects on homes with significant age and complex multi-surface construction, with customers noting the crew spent considerable time preparing surfaces before any paint was applied. Across all these contractors, quality is reflected not just in the first review but in the number of customers who describe returning for additional projects without hesitation.

"We had wood panels painted white on vaulted ceiling, leaving the exposed beams dark. They did an amazing job!!! Professional and clean. Very happy, highly recommend." - Heather M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Prep work and cleanup are recurring themes across reviews for painters in the Wading River, NY area, and for several of these contractors, thorough preparation is what separates their results from the competition. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp - the longest-operating company in this dataset, with over 28 years in business - is noted across multiple reviews for a pre-painting routine that includes vacuuming surfaces, laying paper on floors, covering furniture with plastic, and taping off all moldings and trim before a brush is picked up. The crew approaches complex rooms - including vaulted ceilings, loft spaces, and staircase areas - with the same level of care as standard spaces. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns consistent marks for thorough surface protection: furniture carefully covered, floors protected, and daily cleanup that left spaces spotless at the end of each workday.

"They are meticulous with prep from vacuuming beforehand, laying paper on floors, moving furniture, and covering everything with plastic before a single brush stroke. The crew painted my great room with vaulted ceilings, loft, stairs and home office." - Sharon D., Google Review

Todd's Painting earns repeat business in part because customers trust the crew to leave areas clean - second-time customers specifically cite cleanliness as one of their reasons for calling again. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY goes a step further on larger jobs, with crews cleaning up at the end of every single workday throughout multi-day projects and treating customer belongings with consistent care. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers note that the crew conducts a final walkthrough after each project to address any areas the homeowner isn't satisfied with before leaving. For homeowners who worry about the disruption of having painters in the house for several days, these contractors have clearly made cleanliness and property protection a core part of their standard process.

"They were perfectionists and made sure that we were happy with the job. They were polite and very skilled. We were also impressed that they cleaned up every day." - Pat H., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Consistent communication is one of the strongest differentiators across reviews for painters in the Wading River, NY area - and the contractors that earn the most loyal repeat customers tend to be the ones who keep homeowners informed at every stage. Interior Finishing NYC customers note that owner Dorian responds quickly to initial inquiries, often providing quotes by phone or video to avoid unnecessary in-person appointments, and handles unexpected complications without leaving clients in the dark - even when managing projects remotely. Todd's Painting reviewers consistently mention prompt returns of texts and calls, with customers noting they always knew exactly when to expect the crew each day.

"Owner Dorian was tremendous to work with remotely for repainting our corporate office. Communicative, effective and customer-service oriented - I'd happily use Dorian and his team again!" - K. Fowler, Google Review

CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY earns marks for flexibility - reviewers describe calling to reschedule, add scope, and change plans without encountering frustration from the office team. Office staff including AnnMarie and Jennifer are mentioned by name across reviews as reliable points of contact. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers highlight project managers as the key communication link during jobs - customers describe daily check-ins, updates on progress, and managers who stay present throughout multi-day projects. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers note that owner Andres responds quickly to calls and messages, provides clear cost breakdowns at the estimate stage, and makes himself available for questions throughout the job. Several reviewers describe him accommodating their schedule or responding at hours other contractors wouldn't bother with.

"We were extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism and attention to detail from start to finish. If you are looking for high quality work at a reasonable price, look no further." - Nicole A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Speed without shortcuts is a consistent theme across reviews for painting contractors serving the Wading River, NY area. Todd's Painting is particularly well-known for fast turnarounds - reviewers describe receiving an estimate and having the full job completed the following day, with crews arriving early and finishing ahead of schedule across both interior and exterior projects. Interior Finishing NYC customers describe full-room specialty finish work - including limewash and wallpaper applications - completed in a single day, with most reviewers noting the timeline was shorter than they had anticipated. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY regularly finishes larger projects within or under the original time estimate, with reviewers noting they were surprised at how quickly a full-crew job wrapped up without any compromise to the quality of work.

"Certapro painters came, gave me an estimate, and painted it all in the same week - there were about 4 guys painting and got it done in about 9 hours. The paint job was done very nicely." - Sara H., Google Review

Long Island Painting and Restoration scales up crew size when projects require it - a six-person crew has been deployed to complete large whole-home jobs in a single day. Owner Andres Gallego is described across reviews as quick to schedule, often getting crews on-site within days of an initial call, and multiple customers describe their jobs finishing ahead of the estimated timeline. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns specific praise for following through on timeline commitments, with reviewers noting how rare it is in the trades to have a contractor finish on time and within the original quoted price. For homeowners with tight move-in deadlines or specific scheduling constraints, these companies have demonstrated they can work within real timeframes.

"They completed the project for the price they proposed and on time. In my experience this is very rare for any type of service provided." - Peter A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Value and pricing come up throughout reviews for painters serving Wading River, NY, and the picture across these contractors is nuanced. Interior Finishing NYC specializes in decorative finishes that typically carry higher market rates, yet multiple reviewers describe being surprised that Dorian's pricing came in below competing quotes. For the level of specialty skill and finish quality delivered, customers consistently describe the value as strong. Todd's Painting customers across dozens of reviews describe the pricing as fair, reasonable, or better than expected - and several reviewers note that transparent estimates meant no surprises at the end of the job. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, which has been operating for nearly 30 years in the area, earns consistent marks for pricing that stays fair across a wide range of project types and home sizes.

"Dorian was also more affordable than the other painters we called. Very responsive and courteous, and did a great job!!" - Tova K., Google Review

CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY receives some of the most candid value feedback in the dataset - one longtime customer described the company as not the cheapest option, but immediately followed that with high praise for the service, skill, and turnaround speed that justified the investment. That framing appears in other reviews as well, where customers weigh the project management structure and crew quality against initial quotes from lower-priced competitors. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns strong value marks consistently, with multiple customers describing Andres' estimates as the most competitive among several quotes they received. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers describe pricing as reasonable and upfront, with detailed estimates that leave no billing surprises at the end.

"Price was the best compared to other companies I was quoted from. Very happy with final results. Would recommend." - N.G., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Several of the contractors serving the Wading River, NY area distinguish themselves by taking on projects that go well beyond standard interior or exterior painting. Interior Finishing NYC is the clearest example - owner Dorian Golemi's specialty work includes limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, gilding, wallpaper installation on complex surfaces, and restoration of ornate pre-war woodwork. Several reviewers describe coming to Dorian specifically because other contractors had declined their projects. One customer describes hiring the team to restore ornate moldings in a pre-war apartment that had accumulated decades of paint layers - a type of careful stripping and refinishing work requiring expertise most painters don't have. CertaPro Painters of Port Jefferson NY has experience with historically significant structures, including a cedar shake home where the owner is described as a professional who stands fully behind the finished product. Their team also handles architectural trim in high-value listings, drywall replacement, and accent wall construction as natural extensions of a painting project.

"My apartment had decades' worth of paint applied to the woodwork, and I was looking to clean it up. Dorian explained the different options and was completely transparent about what would and would not work for my particular situation." - Claire T., Google Review

Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp handles complex interior scope that includes staircase railings and spindles, built-in furniture, china cabinets, vaulted ceilings, and intricate molding profiles across multiple rooms. Long Island Painting and Restoration regularly takes on whole-home projects that include popcorn ceiling removal, multi-layer wallpaper stripping, and skim coating before a drop of paint is applied - the prep work itself is a significant part of what they offer. Todd's Painting handles unusual exterior surfaces that many painters decline, including vinyl-sided sheds, chain-link fencing, and deck staining - materials and methods that require different preparation and product knowledge than standard brushwork. For homeowners with challenging, unusual, or historically sensitive projects, these contractors have demonstrated they can step up to the task.

"We had multiple rooms with a staircase and railing painted including base, crown and chair moldings throughout. In addition we had a china cabinet sanded and painted. Once everything was completed, the finished product was beautiful." - J. Lutz, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp