3 Best Painters Near New Suffolk, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in New Suffolk, NY and across Long Island's North Fork and Suffolk County have access to several highly-rated painting contractors with strong track records across interior, exterior, cabinet, and restoration work. The top companies on Chooz Painters share a consistent emphasis on thorough prep, reliable scheduling, and workmanship that holds up over the long term. Here's a look at the top-rated contractors currently serving the area.

Todd's Painting leads the rankings with a Chooz Score of 86.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, with additional reviews on Facebook and Yelp. Reading through the reviews, cabinet refinishing stands out as a clear specialty - multiple customers describe Todd's crew removing all cabinet doors and drawer fronts, refinishing them using a spray process, and returning them for results that look factory-new. Todd also handles a wider scope than most painters in the area, including deck staining, fence staining, power washing, and commercial and institutional jobs. If you have a mix of interior painting and exterior maintenance to handle, Todd's Painting is a good fit.

A recurring observation across the reviews is that Todd himself shows up for estimates and offers color recommendations on the spot, which several customers credit with preventing second-guessing and costly repaints. Many customers also describe a high level of trust in the crew, leaving them unsupervised for hours or even going out of state while work continues.

• Cabinet painting uses a full removal-and-spray process - doors and drawer fronts are taken down and refinished for a factory-quality result, and customers report they don't need to empty their cabinets beforehand
• Todd provides color guidance at the estimate stage, with multiple reviewers noting his recommendations saved them from choices that wouldn't have worked in their space
• Commercial and institutional work appears regularly in the reviews, including an animal hospital exterior and a congregation gallery with high vaulted ceilings
• Estimates and project starts often happen within 24-48 hours for smaller jobs, with customers describing next-day scheduling after a same-day estimate visit

"2nd time using Todd's and they did not disappoint. ALWAYS on time, ready to go, and carry themselves professionally. The work area was left spotless after painting and the walls were crisp and even." - Robert Villano, Google Review

While Todd's Painting stands out for its owner-operator feel, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County brings a structured project management approach that suits homeowners with larger or more complex projects. At the time of our analysis, they had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, and earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%. The company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015 and is a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. What stands out from the reviews is the use of named project managers - customers mention Chris, Jason, Amy, Jonathan, and Matt by name, each coordinating a specific job and serving as a consistent point of contact from estimate to final walkthrough. If you're planning a multi-room interior repaint or a full exterior job and want a contractor with management accountability at every stage, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is worth a call.

The reviews also reveal a strong track record with absent homeowners. One customer describes being completely away during the painting process and staying informed through regular updates from two separate project managers. Exterior prep is also notable - one homeowner reports receiving a written list of recommended repairs before painting began, which added longevity to the finished job.

• Named project managers are assigned to each job, providing a dedicated point of contact from scheduling through completion
• The company has managed projects for homeowners who were away during the work, with status updates provided throughout
• Exterior prep includes written repair recommendations before painting begins, addressing clapboard, windowsills, and other surfaces that could affect the finish
• Repeat customers appear throughout the reviews, with several homeowners using the company for three or more separate projects over multiple years

"My situation was a little different as I was going to be away during the painting process. The project managers, both Amy and Jonathan kept me well informed during the entire process. Most importantly, above all else, they delivered." - Stuart Ebner, Google Review

For homeowners who value direct contact with the owner at every stage, Long Island Painting and Restoration is built around that experience. Owner Andres Gallego is mentioned by name in nearly every review, with customers consistently describing him arriving for color consultations, checking in during active jobs, and conducting a final walkthrough at completion. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 55 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating - every review a five-star rating - earning a Chooz Score of 84.2%. With over 6 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, they've built their reputation almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. If you're looking for an owner-operated company with a clean track record and consistent results, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a strong fit.

A pattern that stands out in the reviews is how many customers use the company for a second home after using them at a previous property - a stronger signal than a single five-star rating. Wall restoration work including spackling, skim coating, wallpaper stripping, and popcorn ceiling removal also appears frequently bundled with paint jobs.

• Owner Andres is personally present at estimates and color consultations, with customers describing detailed walk-throughs and honest input on paint and finish selection
• Multiple reviewers hired the company again for a new home after using them at a previous address, reflecting confidence in repeated results across different properties
• Crew sizes scale to project size, with reviews mentioning six-person crews completing full whole-home projects in a single day
• Restoration work - wallpaper removal, popcorn ceiling removal, skim coating, and wood rot repair - is regularly handled alongside painting

"He was our painter for our first place and we knew when we got our second he had to do the job. I highly recommend Andres and his guys, they are very reliable, neat and friendly to work with! Thank you Andres for making our new home come to life!" - Christine Li, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in the New Suffolk, NY area, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings over 25 years in business on Long Island, along with active Suffolk County and Nassau County home improvement contractor licenses. At the time of our analysis, they had over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp, earning a Chooz Score of 81.5%. Reading through the reviews, a distinct pattern emerges: multiple customers describe the crew arriving and immediately dividing into specialized roles - one taping, one spackling, one sanding, one painting ceilings, one cutting corners. This assembly-line approach gets credited repeatedly for both speed and consistency across large multi-room jobs. If you have a large project involving multiple rooms, stairways, trim, and moldings, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is a reliable option.

Crew lead Manny handles much of the customer-facing work, including color selection guidance, scope review, and post-job follow-up. Multiple reviewers mention that Manny's input during the estimate steered them away from color choices that would later have required repainting, and that he offers this guidance as a standard part of the process, not an add-on.

• The crew divides into specialized roles on arrival, with different team members handling taping, spackling, sanding, and ceiling painting simultaneously rather than sequentially
• Manny provides color selection guidance as part of each project, with multiple customers crediting his advice for preventing costly repaints
• Complex work including vaulted ceilings, built-in bookcases, crown and chair moldings, and cabinet refinishing appears regularly across the reviews
• The company holds active licenses in both Suffolk County (No. HI-67566) and Nassau County (No. H380731), with nearly three decades of Long Island experience behind them

"They come in, take pictures, then take all decorations and pictures down, cover everything and go to work. Lots of time spent on preparation before painting. My house looks great!" - Tom Wedell, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality of workmanship is one of the most consistently praised themes across reviews of painting contractors serving New Suffolk, NY and the surrounding Suffolk County area. Customers of Todd's Painting frequently highlight the precision of cabinet refinishing, with several reviewers describing results that rival brand-new cabinetry after Todd's crew completes the spray process. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns strong marks for complex prep work on older homes - reviewers describe scraped, sanded, and restored surfaces on near-century-old properties before a brush touches the paint. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers highlight wall and ceiling repair as part of interior projects, including large sheetrock patches and skim coating. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp draws consistent praise for touching up scratches, dings, and imperfections in trim and drywall that customers hadn't flagged - showing the crew is looking for problems to fix, not just applying paint.

"Made our 100 year old house look brand new! His team was fast, reliable, and clean." - Rachel Ulrich, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

Across all four companies, customers describe finished work holding up over time without peeling, fading, or requiring touch-ups shortly after the job. Several long-term reviewers note returning to the same contractor years later because the prior work still looks good. This durability is most evident with Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, where reviewers describe using the company across multiple projects spanning over a decade. Long Island Painting and Restoration gets specific credit for wall restoration work - spackling, skim coating, and wallpaper removal - that produces a smooth, paint-ready surface rather than painting over existing issues.

"Over the past few months they have painted 3 bedrooms, a living room, hallway and 2 bathrooms in my house. The work in every single room was done with perfection. They are extremely neat and careful to not leave any mess behind." - Kaitlyn Vinberg, Google Review (Long Island Painting and Restoration)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Timeliness is one of the most consistently praised traits across reviews of painting contractors serving the New Suffolk, NY area. Todd's Painting stands out for fast turnaround times - multiple customers describe receiving an estimate on one day and having a crew arrive the next, with several full-room jobs completed before the end of that same day. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns specific praise for finishing ahead of schedule, with reviews describing four-bedroom, two-bathroom homes completed in under 48 hours and entire apartments wrapped up in a matter of hours. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County receives consistent marks for starting and finishing exactly when promised, with multiple reviewers specifically noting that the project closed out within the timeline quoted during the initial estimate visit.

"Todd and his team were awesome. They got the job done in 48 hours after we discussed the job, and were friendly, professional and detail-oriented. Our walls look amazing." - Danielle Buglino, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

For Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, timeliness shows up in how clearly Manny communicates timelines upfront. Reviewers note that when Manny commits to a two-day project, the job wraps up on day two without rushing the quality. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers note that project managers visit the site regularly and coordinate touch-ups before the final day, keeping jobs from running long. Customers across all four companies also mention that crews arrive at agreed-upon times rather than offering vague windows - a common frustration in the home services industry.

"When Manny says it's going to take two days, he means it. We'll definitely be using them again in the future." - Jim Quinn, Google Review (Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Cleanup standards stand out as a defining trait across reviews for painting contractors serving New Suffolk, NY. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns some of the most detailed cleanup praise - customers describe crews vacuuming before starting, laying paper across all flooring, moving furniture, and covering everything with plastic before applying a single brush stroke. Todd's Painting customers regularly mention that the work area was left spotless at the end of each day, with crews removing window blinds, covering furniture, and vacuuming before leaving. Multiple reviewers across both companies describe being surprised at how thoroughly the space was returned to its original condition after what they expected to be a disruptive job.

"His guys took down the blinds, covered everything in plastic, cleaned up and vacuumed afterwards. I was pleasantly surprised." - Christine Curzio, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County customers frequently describe furniture being replaced and rooms left spotless after each day's work, with one reviewer noting that pictures were rehung before the crew departed. Long Island Painting and Restoration customers highlight cleanup after multi-day exterior projects, with homeowners noting that all materials were removed and the property was restored to its original state when the job wrapped up. Across all four companies, the consistent feedback is that the workspace was left in better condition than when the painters arrived - a higher bar than most homeowners anticipate going into a paint project.

"Fernando and his crew were friendly, courteous and quick with their painting. Everything was left clean and spotless. I would definitely recommend Precision Painting Plus." - Lorinda Butler, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Fair pricing and strong value are recurring themes across reviews for the top-rated painting contractors serving New Suffolk, NY. Todd's Painting draws repeated comments about competitive pricing - several customers mention having more work done than originally planned because the final cost came in lower than expected. Long Island Painting and Restoration earns praise for transparent estimates, with customers noting that owner Andres provides a detailed cost breakdown at the estimate stage and that the final bill reflects the original quote with no surprises. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp customers highlight the combination of quality and affordability, with long-term reviewers noting they've returned for multiple projects over the years because the pricing has remained fair and consistent.

"The price was very good - I actually got more work done than I originally wanted. All-around great experience, definitely highly recommend." - chris mc, Google Review (Todd's Painting)

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County draws some of the most specific value feedback, with customers noting the company completed large-scope projects at the exact price quoted during the initial estimate - something several reviewers describe as rare in the trades. Long Island Painting and Restoration is also frequently noted for having the most competitive pricing among multiple quotes received, particularly for exterior work. Across all four top-rated contractors, customers describe pricing as fair relative to the quality of work delivered, with none of the companies drawing consistent complaints about overcharging or unexpected costs added after the job begins.

"They completed the project for the price they proposed and on time. In my experience this is very rare for any type of service provided. I would definitely recommend them to anyone." - Peter Alcazar, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp