9 Best Painters Near Islip Terrace, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Islip Terrace, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing a different strength to the table. Whether you need a full interior repaint, exterior power washing, or specialty decorative finishes, the companies serving this area have built strong reputations across hundreds of verified reviews.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC had over 160 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This veteran-owned company earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%, with additional 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Todd Rumfola runs estimates personally and is frequently on site working alongside his crew. What stands out in the reviews is how comfortable customers feel leaving their homes while the work is being done, a level of trust that comes up again and again. If you are looking for a contractor who handles both painting and power washing with a hands-on owner, South Bay is a strong choice.

Several reviewers describe the crew members by first name, with Rich, Jerry, and Alex appearing throughout the feedback. Customers who started with a power washing job often return for interior painting, and those who began with a single room end up booking their entire home. With over 10 years in business and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License, the company has deep roots in the community.

• Multiple customers mention Todd texting the night before and morning of the job to confirm timing, a small touch that reviewers say sets him apart from other contractors they have used
• Several reviews describe Rich working for five to seven consecutive days on larger interior jobs, arriving at 8am daily and leaving every surface protected
• Power washing customers frequently note that Todd advised them on the right approach for their specific siding or surface rather than just quoting a flat rate

"Todd did a fantastic job despite the gusty winds and cooler weather. Everything looks nice and fresh. I love having people I can trust to do the job and not have to micromanage." - Laura Bowen, Google Review

For homeowners who want a contractor with a formal project management process and a dedicated crew of experienced painters, Teall Painting offers a structured approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Charlie Teall meets with every customer before work begins, and his crew members Ricardo, Eli, Gavin, and Rene are each praised by name across unrelated reviews. If you have a complex project like exterior brick repainting or cathedral ceiling work, Teall has a track record with non-standard jobs.

With over 12 years in business and a Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License, the company backs all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty. Reviewers consistently note that Charlie provides updates throughout the project and answers questions promptly.

• Customers describe crews arriving with plastic sheathing, builder's paper, and drop cloths before any painting begins, a level of preparation that multiple reviewers call out specifically
• Several homeowners hired Teall after getting quotes from other companies, citing Charlie's detailed explanation of the scope of work as the deciding factor
• Exterior projects like shutter repainting and chimney work appear alongside standard interior jobs, showing the team's range

"Working with Charlie and his crew at Teall Painting was an absolute pleasure. Their work was top quality at a fair price. On time, on budget and extremely responsive." - Nicholas Bryan Contardo, Google Review

When it comes to decorative finishes and specialty wall treatments, Interior Finishing NYC stands out. Owner Dorian Golemi studied fine arts in Albania and specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and metallic applications. The company earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. If you are looking for something beyond standard flat paint, particularly accent walls or faux finishing, this is a contractor worth considering.

With over 22 years in business and a 3-year workmanship warranty, Dorian works on site personally and handles projects ranging from single accent walls to full apartment renovations. Team members Jose, Amir, Marvin, and Joe form a consistent unit across the reviews.

• Multiple reviewers note that other contractors refused their projects before Dorian accepted and delivered results that matched their inspiration photos
• Wallpaper installation, skim coating, and gilding appear alongside painting services, making this a one-stop option for complex interior projects

"Dorian and his crew are masters of their craft. I hired them to plaster and skim coat all the walls and ceilings in my apartment and they did a fantastic job for a fair price." - Armen Stevens, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Big Expert Painting LLC. Owner Denis handles every estimate personally and earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. What comes through in the reviews is how many customers hire Denis for one room and then immediately book additional rooms before the first job is even finished. If you want a responsive owner who answers calls directly and offers same-day estimates, Big Expert is a good fit.

The company holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License and EPA Lead-Safe Certification. Customers describe Denis as someone who checks in after the project is complete to make sure everything is holding up.

• One reviewer hired Denis for three bedrooms and crown molding, was so pleased she booked two more rooms immediately, and plans to call again for future projects
• Speed is a recurring theme, with multiple customers expressing surprise at how quickly the crew completed work without sacrificing quality
• Denis swept up leaves he tracked in during one job, a small detail a customer highlighted as the kind of care that is hard to find

"Dennis and team were outstanding! I already scheduled another two jobs for him next week at my house and referred him to two people." - Ken Smitelli, Google Review

With over 150 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. What sets this company apart is turnaround speed. Reviewers consistently describe getting estimates one day and having the entire job finished the next, without any drop in quality. If you need a quick turnaround for an interior repaint or exterior power washing, Todd's Painting delivers on tight timelines.

Todd's reviews span Google, Facebook, and Yelp, and the company has received over 10 new reviews in just the last three months. Customers who have used Todd for decades continue to leave feedback, which speaks to lasting relationships.

• One customer's six-year-old said the house no longer looks like a haunted house after the exterior was painted, and the family has already booked Todd for interior work
• Cabinet painting appears as a specialty, with one reviewer noting that Todd came back within a day to touch up a few small areas at no extra charge

"Todd and his team did an incredible job painting my house. His pricing was fair, he communicated well, and was very efficient. Could not have asked for a better job!" - Brandon Shoman, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Islip Terrace, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings over 18 years in business and a Chooz Score of 84.8%. They have over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, are 100% recommended on Facebook, and hold BBB accreditation. Project managers like David Maloney and Jason Eng coordinate crews that include Carlos, Jose, and Amilcar, giving this company a more structured, corporate feel than smaller operations. If you have a large-scale project like a whole-home repaint or multi-day renovation, their team approach may be a good match.

• One homeowner handed over a house key for a multi-day renovation, trusting the crew to work unsupervised across his entire home
• Several customers mention getting three or more estimates and choosing Precision because David's pricing was the most competitive for the scope of work
• Crew members are praised for moving furniture carefully, covering floors, and cleaning up at the end of each workday

"The skillful crew of Precision Painting Plus just completed painting my entire home, and they were amazing! The crew arrived every day on time and were always very professional and patient." - Doreen Conte, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality and attention to detail are the most common themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Islip Terrace, NY. Customers consistently describe finished results that exceed their expectations, from smooth wall finishes to clean trim lines and careful color matching.

South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC earns praise for the work of painters like Rich, who multiple customers describe as spending days on a single project to get every detail right. "Todd and his crew Jerry and Richard did a wonderful job! Not only did they do masterful, professional work, they are also nice, considerate people who were a pleasure to have working in the house." - Michele D'Amato, Google Review. Teall Painting tackles non-standard projects like brick house exteriors and shutter repainting, with one customer noting their home "looks brand new" after the crew removed chipping paint and fully repainted the front, chimney, and shutters. - Michael Paolucci, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC handles specialty work that most contractors will not attempt, including Roman clay accent walls and gilding. "I needed someone to do wallpaper hanging, some drywall repair and gilding in my home. It was hard to find a contractor that does all of the services we needed. Luckily we found Dorian." - Kha Asia, Google Review. Todd's Painting customers highlight the quality of cabinet painting and interior spackling, while Big Expert Painting LLC reviews frequently describe Denis repairing work that previous painters did poorly.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Punctuality and reliable scheduling are consistent strengths among the top painting contractors serving Islip Terrace, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe crews arriving on time, projects finishing on or ahead of schedule, and clear communication about timelines before work begins.

Todd's Painting stands out for speed, with reviewers describing same-day estimates and next-day completion on interior repaints. "Todd was professional, timely, intricate, and honest for an interior painting job at my home. He showed up with a crew on time every day and communicated throughout the job." - Amanda Weis, Google Review. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers describe owner Todd Rumfola texting the evening before and morning of each job to confirm, a habit that several reviewers specifically praise. Teall Painting earns mentions for delivering on promised timelines, with one reviewer noting "They came when they said they were coming and completed the job when they said they would." - Eileen Leddy, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge crews arrive on time daily for multi-day projects, with one customer noting the team showed up punctually across six consecutive days. Big Expert Painting LLC reviews highlight Denis completing jobs faster than expected, with one customer expressing surprise at how quickly her rooms were finished without any rush in quality. "The price was fair. And I could not believe how fast everything was done." - Stafi Thukral, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and protection of customer property are frequent topics in reviews for Islip Terrace, NY area painters. Across all the top-rated contractors, customers describe crews that cover furniture and floors before starting, clean up at the end of each workday, and leave homes in better condition than when they arrived.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge earns some of the most detailed cleanup praise, with customers describing crews that move furniture carefully, cover every surface, and leave homes ready to use each evening during multi-day projects. "Just had my ceilings and living room painted and I am impressed! Perfection is how I would describe it! This company was so professional from start to finish." - Kevin Kitson, Google Review. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers note that painter Rich covers floors and furniture carefully during week-long interior jobs. Teall Painting reviewers highlight prep work as a standout, describing plastic sheathing and drop cloths placed before any painting begins. "Renee from Teall did a great job painting my girl's bedrooms and our kitchen. We appreciate his professionalism, promptness to work and his cleanliness." - Cassandra Moussignac, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe Denis leaving spaces spotless, with one reviewer noting he even swept up leaves he tracked in during the project.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Fair pricing is one of the most common compliments across reviews for painting contractors serving Islip Terrace, NY. Customers frequently mention getting multiple estimates and choosing these companies because the combination of price and quality stood out from competitors.

Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge draws specific pricing praise, with one reviewer describing them as "by far the most reasonably priced" after getting three estimates. - Helen Grygo, Google Review. Big Expert Painting LLC customers consistently describe owner Denis as offering fair pricing, with one noting the work was both "wonderful" and the "price was fair." - Stafi Thukral, Google Review. Todd's Painting reviewers mention comparing quotes from several painters before choosing Todd based on both price and the quality of his estimates. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC customers describe Todd Rumfola's prices as reasonable, particularly for the combination of painting and power washing services. Teall Painting owner Charlie Teall provides detailed estimates that explain the scope of work, which reviewers say helped them understand the value. "Working with Charlie and his crew at Teall Painting was an absolute pleasure. Their work was top quality at a fair price." - Nicholas Bryan Contardo, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Clear and responsive communication is a hallmark of the top painting contractors serving Islip Terrace, NY. From initial estimates to project updates and follow-up calls, customers describe contractors who keep them informed at every stage.

Teall Painting owner Charlie Teall is praised for providing consistent updates throughout projects. "From day one we were in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on and completed and what to expect that day." - John Calvacca, Google Review. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC owner Todd Rumfola responds to every single Google review and customers describe him returning calls and texts quickly, often within hours. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis answers calls directly, and one customer noted that Denis called a month after the project was completed to check that everything was still holding up. Todd's Painting customers describe prompt responses to estimate requests and clear communication about timelines. "Communication was prompt and concise. Work was completed as described." - Donna DiNapoli, Google Review. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi is described as fast to reply to inquiries, often providing quotes over phone or video call to save customers time. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge project manager David Maloney earns praise for explaining the process clearly and being available for questions.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Repeat business and referrals are among the strongest indicators of quality across painting contractors serving Islip Terrace, NY. Multiple companies show patterns of customers returning for second, third, and even fourth projects over the span of years.

Big Expert Painting LLC reviews reveal customers who keep coming back. "Initially, I had Denis come to do three rooms of my home. We were so impressed that we had him and his crew come back to do two more rooms and patch up a few things around the house." - Sara Galante, Google Review. South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC has customers who return for entirely different types of work, starting with power washing and moving on to interior painting. One customer has hired them three separate times and says she looks forward to using them for all future projects. Todd's Painting features reviewers who have used Todd for over 30 years, continuing to call for new projects across multiple properties. "I said I would use Todd again, and I did! His crew showed up when expected and completed the job in a timely manner." - JPI, Google Review. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers describe returning for multiple projects, and Teall Painting reviewer Sharon K. notes her exterior project was her second job with the company, with a third already scheduled.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp