3 Best Painters Near South Jamesport, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving South Jamesport, NY bring a wide range of skills to the table, from quick cabinet refreshes to full exterior restoration on older homes. The top-ranked companies on Chooz Painters have built strong reputations across Long Island, with consistent five-star reviews spanning multiple years and multiple projects. Here is a look at the highest-rated painters in the area, ranked by Chooz Score.

Todd's Painting earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%, the highest among contractors serving South Jamesport, NY. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus additional reviews on Yelp and Facebook. Cabinet refinishing is a recurring standout in the reviews: crews remove door fronts and drawer faces, take them to the shop for professional spray finishing, and reinstall them looking factory-new. Reviewers also describe Todd handling full interior repaints, exterior staining, deck work, power washing, and fence painting. With over 35 years of experience, Todd personally supervises projects and returns quickly to fix anything a customer flags. If you want a dependable local painter who handles a wide range of projects and stands behind the finished work, Todd's Painting is a strong choice.

A pattern that stands out across the reviews is trust. Several customers describe leaving Todd and his crew working in their home or business unattended without any concern. He also proactively flags color choices before starting, occasionally redirecting customers away from shades that would not work in the space - a detail several reviewers credit with saving them a repaint.

• Cabinet doors and drawer fronts are removed and shop-sprayed for a factory-level finish, a process reviewers describe as producing results that look like they came straight from the factory.
• The team handles commercial jobs alongside residential work, including a congregation gallery with very high ceilings and an animal hospital exterior.
• Todd proactively flags color choices before work begins, with customers frequently noting this guidance led to better final results.
• Issues flagged after the job are addressed within a day or two, with no pushback from the crew.

"They got the job done in 48 hours after we discussed the job, and were friendly, professional and detail-oriented. Our walls look amazing and he even touched up a few nicks in rooms that weren't part of the job." - Danielle Buglino, Google Review

For homeowners looking for a company with strong systems and structured project management, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County offers a different kind of experience. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%, with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. With nearly two decades in business, this company holds BBB accreditation since 2015 and has been recognized as a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. Reviews highlight a multi-layered approach: field managers confirm colors before work begins, on-site managers inspect work daily, and project coordinators keep customers informed throughout. One reviewer praised the fact that they were away from home during the entire project and still felt fully informed at every step. If you want clear communication at every stage and a company with a formal quality review process, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is worth calling.

The company handles a wide range of project types, from single-apartment interior painting to a 230-year-old historic home needing a full exterior refresh. Reviewers mention successful outcomes with wallpaper removal, sheetrock patching, deck repair and staining, and HOA painting as well as standard single-family homes.

• A field manager visits before the job begins to confirm colors, then inspects work on-site each day throughout the project.
• Project coordinators stay in contact during the work, keeping homeowners informed even when they are traveling or away from home.
• Staff have handled project prep extras, including vine removal from a historic home exterior, at rates reviewers describe as very fair.
• The company has served residential, HOA, and commercial projects with consistent praise for staying on budget and on schedule.

"My situation was a little different as I was going to be away during the painting process. The project managers, both Amy and Jonathan kept me well informed during the entire process. Most importantly, above all else, they did an exceptional job." - Stuart Ebner, Google Review

A newer presence on the North Fork, Long Island Painting and Restoration has built its reputation quickly through referrals and word-of-mouth. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% with over 55 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating - every review on the platform a five-star rating. With over 6 years in business, owner Andres Gallego personally handles every estimate, walking through a home room by room and offering color recommendations at no extra charge. Crews are led by foreman Nelson, and crew member Joey has earned repeated callouts in reviews for expert spackling and skim coating. Projects consistently finish ahead of schedule, with crews scaling up as needed. If you are tackling a full-house project, a restoration job on an older property, or want an owner who stays personally involved from first call to final walkthrough, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a good fit.

The company handles restoration work alongside painting, including wood rot repair, popcorn ceiling removal, and two-layer wallpaper stripping. Several customers describe returning to this company when they moved to a new home, specifically seeking out Andres and his crew for the new property.

• Several reviewers came back to this company after moving, specifically requesting Andres and his team for their new property.
• The company responds quickly after job completion - one reviewer reports a crew dispatched within two days for a ceiling repair after a post-paint shower leak.
• Crews scale up for large jobs, completing whole-home interior repaints with six-person crews in a single day.

"Andres was easy to work with. When his crew came, there were six of them. They took care of everything from the set up to the painting to the cleanup. I am amazed that they were able to finish such a big job in just one day!" - Keri sab, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in South Jamesport, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings over 28 years in business and a loyal customer base built over decades. They earned a Chooz Score of 81.5%, with over 190 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, plus a 5.0-star rating on Yelp. Lead crew member Manny is named in review after review for a thorough preparation process: the crew vacuums the space before starting, lays paper across all flooring, moves furniture, and covers everything with plastic before a single brush stroke. The team works exclusively with high-quality Benjamin Moore paint and operates with assembly-line efficiency, with each crew member handling a specific role. The company holds an active Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License. If you want an experienced, well-organized crew with deep Long Island roots and a proven process, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp is worth contacting.

Repeat and referral business defines this company. Multiple customers describe booking their next project before the current one is even finished, and several have referred neighbors, family members, and friends who have all become regular customers. The team handles architecturally challenging work including ornate moldings, vaulted and cathedral ceilings, and challenging color transitions requiring precise masking across an entire home.

• The team manages complex color work with precision, including dark accent walls against white ceilings and multi-color trim work requiring careful masking throughout an entire home.
• The company works exclusively with Benjamin Moore paint, a detail long-term customers frequently call out as a reason they keep returning.
• Crew members work specialized roles simultaneously - taping, spackling, sanding, ceiling painting, and trim painting all happen at once, speeding up the project without any shortcuts.
• Several reviewers report using Anthony's for a second home, a mother's home, or a neighbor's home after a first positive experience at their own property.

"Attention to detail was evident with Manny and his crew. Furthermore, the crew was always punctual, courteous and very respectful. We were very happy with the result and would highly recommend them." - J Lutz, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Customers across South Jamesport, NY consistently describe results that exceed their expectations, whether the project is a single bathroom or a multi-room whole-home repaint. Todd's Painting draws particular praise for the quality of its cabinet work, with reviewers describing the shop-spray process as producing finishes that look completely factory-new. For larger interior projects, the team has handled homes with cathedral ceilings over 17 feet tall, taking on prep and multiple coats without cutting corners. Reviewers working with Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County describe precise color matching, clean lines on trim work, and a quality walk-through at the end of every project to confirm the customer is satisfied before the crew leaves.

Long Island Painting and Restoration earns quality marks on challenging jobs including wood rot repair, popcorn ceiling removal, and wallpaper stripping ahead of paint. Reviewers describe their finished walls as flawless across multiple room types. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns consistent quality praise for its prep discipline and trim work, with long-term customers pointing to the moldings, ceiling edges, and hard-to-reach corners as places where less careful crews tend to cut corners. One customer who described themselves as very particular about their space noted that Manny was spotting imperfections they themselves had missed.

"The walls and ceilings look better than they did on day 1, and we love the color. The trim all looks immaculate." - Nicolas Manganiello, Google Review"Their work was superior and everything came out above our expectations. Top notch painter with 35 years experience and very personable. I highly recommended Todd's Painting for any job you have." - Diana Kopf, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

One of the most consistent themes in reviews for painting contractors serving South Jamesport, NY is that crews show up when promised and finish on or ahead of schedule. Todd's Painting earns repeated praise for fast turnarounds: one reviewer describes a bathroom, foyer, and front entryway completed between early morning and early afternoon in a single day, and another received an estimate and had the entire job finished by the following afternoon. Long Island Painting and Restoration builds speed into how it staffs jobs, scaling up crew sizes for larger projects. Owner Andres has completed full-house repaints in under 48 hours on multiple occasions, and one customer had work done the very next day after calling for a quote.

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County takes a more structured scheduling approach, with pre-job manager visits to confirm colors and daily inspections throughout. Reviewers consistently note that the project started on the date promised and wrapped on or before the completion date. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns similar marks for reliability, with long-term customers specifically noting that Manny's timeline estimates are accurate and that the crew shows up exactly when scheduled, every time.

"They arrived at 8am and were done by 3pm. In that time they did my whole bathroom, my foyer and front entrance way. I am so happy with the work they did and their professionalism." - Laura Contino, Google Review"When Manny says it's going to take two days, he means it. We'll definitely be using them again in the future." - Jim Quinn, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Protecting floors, furniture, and fixtures is something all four top-rated painting contractors in South Jamesport, NY take seriously, and customers notice. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp stands out for a particularly thorough pre-paint process: the crew vacuums the entire space before starting, lays paper across all flooring, moves furniture, and covers everything with plastic before opening a single paint can. Customers consistently describe leaving the crew in their home and returning to find the space cleaner than when they left. Todd's Painting follows similar practices, with crews removing blinds, covering everything in plastic, vacuuming up afterward, and cleaning the area at the end of every visit. Any minor issues flagged by customers are corrected within a day or two at no additional charge.

Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County earns consistent marks for leaving homes spotless at the end of each work day, with reviewers noting furniture moved back into place and no paint mess left behind on any surface. Reviewers describe the operation as a "white glove" experience in terms of care for the home. Long Island Painting and Restoration also gets frequent comments on end-of-day and end-of-job cleanup, with customers noting the crew cleaned thoroughly after each visit and left every room ready to move back into. If protecting your home during a paint job is a priority, any of the top contractors serving South Jamesport, NY have strong records in this area.

"There was no mess, they were careful with all my furniture. They vacuumed and left my house in perfect condition. And when there was a small issue, Manny came back right away and fixed it." - Helen Bartone, Google Review"His guys took down the blinds, covered everything in plastic, cleaned up and vacuumed afterwards. I was pleasantly surprised and already recommended him to a few friends." - Christine Curzio, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving South Jamesport, NY. Todd's Painting earns specific praise for pricing that sometimes surprises customers in a positive way, with reviewers noting they ended up adding work to their project after seeing the initial quote. Estimates are provided free, given in person, and the price quoted is the price charged with no surprises later in the process. Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County is described as transparent from the start, with formal written estimates, clear payment structures, and projects completed within the agreed budget. One reviewer comparing multiple contractors for a large project noted that Precision completed the work on time and for the quoted price, which they described as genuinely rare for any type of home service contractor.

Long Island Painting and Restoration earns strong marks for competitive pricing, with multiple reviewers describing Andres's quote as the best they received when shopping around. Several customers specifically note that the value was strong relative to the quality of the finished work. Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp has built a loyal repeat customer base in part through pricing that customers describe as fair and competitive, especially given the thoroughness of the prep work included. Multiple long-term customers point to the lack of hidden costs or unexpected charges as a key reason they keep calling back year after year.

"The price was very good - I actually got more work done than I originally wanted." - chris mc, Google Review"Price was the best compared to other companies I was quoted from." - N G, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp