Homeowners in Fishers Island, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors serving Long Island and the surrounding areas. Across these companies, customers regularly highlight reliable scheduling, fair pricing, and crews that leave work areas spotless after the job is done.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Todd's Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% and also carries a 92% recommended rating on Facebook. Todd personally handles estimates, often visiting the same day a homeowner calls, and reviewers frequently mention his willingness to offer color advice and honest recommendations. If you are looking for a responsive, owner-operated painter who can handle everything from cabinet refinishing to full exterior jobs, Todd's Painting is a strong choice.
Several customers describe Todd's hands-on involvement from start to finish, including showing up early, keeping homeowners updated with photos during exterior work, and returning within days to touch up any concerns at no extra charge. Commercial clients, including a local animal hospital and a congregation with high ceilings, also praise his ability to scale up for larger projects.
- Repeat customers make up a notable share of reviews, with homeowners returning for second and third projects years apart
- Multiple reviewers mention being surprised at how quickly jobs wrapped up, with some interior projects completed in a single day
- Kitchen cabinet painting is a frequently praised specialty, with several homeowners choosing to refinish rather than replace after seeing Todd's results
"He's a true professional and I found his pricing to be very fair. One look at the inside of his truck and I knew that he was passionate about his business and what he does for a living." - Paul Genova, Google Review
For homeowners who want a company with a dedicated project management structure, Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County offers a more corporate approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5% with over 180 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. The company has been BBB accredited since 2015 and is a Bethpage Best of Long Island winner. If you prefer working with a team that includes a field manager who visits daily and a coordinator who schedules around your availability, Precision Painting Plus is a good fit.
Reviewers frequently describe a structured process where the field manager visits before work begins, paint is ordered to exact specifications, and daily inspections keep quality consistent. Several customers mention that the crew handled extra tasks during the job, such as installing new shutters or removing vines, without inflating the price.
- Customers who own historic or older homes praise the company's ability to handle complex exterior prep work on aging surfaces
- The field manager Chris is mentioned by name across multiple reviews for his professionalism and punctuality
- Wallpapering and deck restoration are offered alongside standard painting services
"Our 230-year-old house was in serious need of an exterior paint job. Within a week, our house looked as good as new." - Jim Gabriel, Google Review
With a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 55 Google reviews, Long Island Painting and Restoration has built its reputation almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. This company earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% and has been serving Nassau and Suffolk counties for over 6 years. Owner Andres Gallego personally handles every estimate and stays involved through the final walkthrough, making this a good choice if you value direct communication with the business owner throughout your project.
Customers consistently describe Andres as someone who spends significant time during the initial consultation, walking through homes room by room and offering color recommendations. His crew scales up for larger jobs, and several reviewers note being impressed that whole-home projects were wrapped up in under 48 hours without sacrificing quality.
- Crew members Nelson and Joey are called out by name for expert spackling and wall repair work
- Several homeowners describe hiring the company for a second home after being pleased with the first project
- Pricing is frequently described as the most competitive among multiple quotes received
"Our project was completed just over a week after we reached out for a quote. We were extremely impressed with the communication, professionalism and attention to detail from start to finish." - Nicole Albanese, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors serving Fishers Island, NY, Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp brings over 28 years in business and a Chooz Score of 81.5%. They carry over 190 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. If you have a complex project like cabinet refinishing, wallpaper removal, or painting in a home with ornate moldings and high ceilings, Anthony's experienced crews are well equipped to handle it.
Crew lead Manny is the most frequently named employee in the reviews, with customers describing his habit of photographing rooms before starting, carefully removing all wall decorations, and covering every surface with plastic before painting begins. Multiple reviewers describe booking their next project before the current one is even finished.
- Customers with 10, 15, and even 20-plus year relationships with the company appear throughout the reviews
- Prep work is a standout theme, with reviewers describing extensive vacuuming, floor protection, and furniture moving before any painting starts
- The company holds active Suffolk County and Nassau County home improvement contractor licenses
"Manny and his crew are real professionals. They come in, take pictures, then take all decorations and pictures down, cover everything and go to work. Lots of time spent on preparation before painting." - Tom Wedell, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
