9 Best Painters Near Plainview, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Plainview, NY have earned strong review records across Google, Yelp, and Facebook, with seven companies carrying Chooz Scores above 83% at the time of our analysis. Reviews from homeowners across Long Island share consistent themes: thorough prep work, consistent named crews, and owner involvement from estimate through final walkthrough. Here are the top-ranked companies serving the area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning them the top Chooz Score of 87.6% among painters serving Plainview, NY. Owner Charlie Cascio handles estimates personally, provides detailed itemized quotes, and stays in direct communication throughout each project - customers frequently mention same-day responses to calls and texts. Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692 is verified active, and all work is backed by a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee.

Reading through the reviews, a standout pattern is how often first-time customers become repeat customers. Projects range from standard interior paint jobs to stucco exteriors, western red cedar restoration, cabinet refinishing, and commercial studio renovations, suggesting the crew handles non-standard work without issue.

• Named crew members including Rene, Oscar, Ricardo, Anthony, Victor, Thomas, and Douglas appear across unrelated reviews, pointing to consistent in-house staffing across projects
• Multiple reviewers describe a final walkthrough with Charlie confirming satisfaction before the job is closed out
• Commercial work - including a fitness studio and a salon renovation - appears among the residential reviews, reflecting a range of project types

"Charlie was the best, fair, honest and very customer oriented. Renee and Oscar great painters - very punctual, courteous and respectful. Final touch up and walkthrough great experience would highly recommend Charlie and his team at TEALL painting." - Jim Gould, Google Review

If you want an owner-involved contractor with a written warranty and a proven track record on Long Island, Teall Painting is a strong choice.

For homeowners looking for specialty decorative finishes that most painters won't attempt, Interior Finishing NYC brings a distinct skill set. Owner Dorian Golemi, trained at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, and metallic applications. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. The last time we conducted our analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and have been in business for over 22 years, with a 3-year workmanship warranty on all projects.

A recurring pattern in the reviews: customers start with one room, love the result, and immediately book Dorian back for more. One reviewer hired him for a nursery limewash, then brought him back for a powder room and an office. Dorian is physically on site working alongside his crew and handles estimates personally, often over phone or video call.

• Several reviewers describe projects other contractors refused to take on, including pre-war woodwork stripping, specialty plaster repair, and faux finish color matching
• Grasscloth, cork, vinyl, and large-scale mural wallpaper installations appear alongside decorative plaster in the review record
• Team members Jose, Amir, Marvin, and Joe appear consistently across reviews as a reliable crew unit

"Our lime wash came out beautiful. Dorian explained to us the difference between different lime paint brands and what would work best for our color. They were quick and professional. We're very satisfied with the service and highly recommend Dorian and his team." - Ormira Domnori, Google Review

If you need specialty decorative finishes or high-end wallpaper work, Interior Finishing NYC is a clear standout.

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for CRD Painting Inc, which earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 90 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, matched by 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Camilo has been running the company for over 8 years, and multiple customers describe working relationships stretching 10 to 15 years. Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-59404 is verified active through 2027.

What stands out across CRD's reviews is how often customers describe returning. One reviewer has used Camilo across more than five different homes and an office. A Long Island drywall company of 60 years makes CRD their standard referral for builders, noting Camilo makes their work look good every time. His pricing comes up across reviews as consistent with the initial quote, with no surprise charges at the end.

• Wall preparation - skim coating, spackling, cathedral ceiling crack repair, and water-damage restoration - appears as a recurring strength across unrelated reviews
• Projects range from a single front door staining to complete interior and exterior overhauls of multi-room homes
• Booking, estimate scheduling, and communication throughout the job consistently draw positive mentions alongside the finished work

"We repeatedly have hired C.R.D Painting Inc for interior projects in our home and couldn't be more pleased. They arrive promptly, work efficiently and cleanly, and treat our home with real care. The painting work they complete is flawless due to the amount of surface preparation that isn't skimped on." - W Palumbo, Google Review

If you want a painter you'll keep calling back for years, CRD Painting Inc has the track record to back it up.

Also serving the Plainview, NY area, Big Expert Painting LLC offers a broader scope of work than most painting contractors. Owner Denis Erazo handles standard interior and exterior painting alongside sheetrock installation, crown molding, deck staining, pool-bottom painting, and power washing. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The last time we conducted our analysis, they had over 130 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and matching 5.0 stars on Yelp. Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388 is verified active through 2027, and they hold EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work in pre-1978 homes.

Denis answers calls directly and is mentioned across reviews as someone who responds promptly, including on weekends. A pattern across the reviews: customers hire Big Expert for one job and immediately schedule the next. One reviewer hired them for skim coating and ceilings, was so pleased he added kitchen cabinets before the crew left.

• Crew members Eric, Joshua, Michael, and Pedro appear across multiple unrelated reviews, pointing to a consistent in-house team
• Reviews cover an unusually wide project range - gym studio renovations, salon refreshes, waterfront deck restoration, and same-day patch-and-paint calls
• Multiple reviewers note the price quoted was the price charged, with no add-ons at billing

"Denis and his crew did an amazing job skim coating/painting my ceilings and walls - after they were done it looked so good that I booked him to paint my kitchen cabinets as well. They treated my home like it was their own during the whole process and went over and beyond to make everything look perfect." - Anthony Dilillo, Google Review

If you need painting combined with carpentry, drywall, or power washing in one project, Big Expert Painting LLC is worth a call.

Rounding out the top tier in Plainview, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a structured company model with dedicated project managers overseeing field crews. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, are 100% recommended on Facebook, and are Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2015. With over 18 years in business on Long Island, they are a well-established operation. Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-73176 is verified active through January 2028.

Territory manager David Maloney appears by name in more reviews than almost any other individual across all seven companies in this group - customers describe him walking each room of the home on estimate day and checking in throughout the project. Crews including Carlos, Jose, Fernando, Amilcar, and Hernando appear across reviews from different customers on different projects, reflecting stable staffing. One homeowner trusted the crew with a house key for a full-week renovation of his entire home.

• The company's office coordinator Trish Gates gets positive mentions alongside field crew, reflecting a well-organized operation from phone to job site
• Projects range from single-room refreshes to six-day whole-home renovations, with epoxy floor coating and wallpaper installation alongside standard painting
• Out-of-state homeowners have managed full projects remotely through Precision Painting's coordination

"We just had our living room and kitchen area painted by Precision Painting Plus, and from the very beginning the experience was outstanding. Dave, the project manager, came out to walk through everything with us and made the entire process seamless." - Jaime Solonchak, Google Review

If you prefer a company with structured project management and a named supervisor assigned to your job, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is a good fit.

With 4 years in business on Long Island, JRT Pro Painters LLC has built its reputation through repeat customers and direct referrals. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 65 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas is personally involved in most projects. Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-66725 is verified active.

Several reviewers describe being referred to JRT by a general contractor or HVAC company after seeing their work firsthand. One customer hired Brayan in 2021 for a Thanksgiving deadline, then returned years later to finish painting the rest of the house. Brayan stays reachable throughout each job, with reviewers noting same-day text and call responses.

• Deck stripping and staining draws several detailed positive mentions, with Brayan advising on material choices for durability
• Interior door replacement, crown molding, and skim coating appear alongside painting in multiple reviews
• One reviewer notes Brayan identified improper drywall installation during the job and addressed it without being asked - the kind of observation that shows up when the owner is on site

"I never had such a pleasant experience with people working at my house like I did with JRT Pro Painters crew. They are absolute the best!! From the care that they had with our home to the result of their hard work, it was a great experience. I would give 10 stars if was possible." - Janice Simonetti, Google Review

If you prefer a tight-knit owner-led crew with direct access to the person running the job, JRT Pro Painters LLC is worth considering.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, BBB

Quality of finished work is one of the most consistent themes across reviews for painters serving Plainview, NY. Customers describe results that hold up over time and exceed initial expectations, particularly around prep work, trim precision, and specialty applications. Teall Painting reviews frequently mention crisp lines and detailed surface preparation - one reviewer hired them to repaint an exterior that had been chipping and cracking, and described the result as looking brand new, good enough to delay residing the house for several years. CRD Painting Inc earns similar praise for prep: reviewers describe spackling, skim coating, and addressing cathedral ceiling cracks before any paint goes on, with one customer noting that walls repaired after removal of decades-old floor-to-ceiling wallpaper came out looking freshly replaced. Interior Finishing NYC draws some of the most detailed quality descriptions in the group, with customers calling owner Dorian Golemi's limewash and Roman clay applications equal to the inspiration photos they brought him.

For Big Expert Painting LLC, quality praise often comes alongside descriptions of challenging repair work: ceilings damaged by water leaks, basement walls with sheetrock replacement, and color matching on previously painted surfaces where you couldn't tell the repaired section from the original. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge reviews consistently note that crew members don't leave until every room has been walked through and any concerns addressed - one reviewer described the team refusing to finish the job until nail pops found during the work were properly resolved. JRT Pro Painters LLC customers highlight a similar thoroughness: reviewers describe skim-coated walls that look like nothing was done to them, and deck refinishes that look better than new.

"Everything you want in a contractor - quality, price, efficiency and thoroughness." - Seth Levitt, Google Review (Teall Painting)"Their work is extraordinary. They fixed our cathedral ceiling and many cracks throughout. Painted, taped, caulked, spackled, sanded. Call today - you won't be disappointed." - Angela Schoeni, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"The lime-wash finish came out much better than we expected. They are patient, professional and obsessed with doing their job to perfection." - Lenny Blake, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Communication is one of the areas where painters serving Plainview, NY consistently stand out across reviews. Teall Painting customers repeatedly describe owner Charlie Cascio as responsive throughout the project - not just at the estimate stage, but during active work, answering questions the same day by call or text. Multiple reviewers describe receiving updates on scheduling and progress without having to ask. CRD Painting Inc customers describe Camilo as easy to reach at every stage, from the estimate appointment through the final walkthrough, with one long-term customer noting that 15 years of consistent communication is part of why they keep calling him back. Interior Finishing NYC owner Dorian Golemi responds to virtually every Google review with personalized messages referencing project-specific details, and customers describe him offering video call quotes to save time when an in-person visit isn't convenient.

For Big Expert Painting LLC, owner Denis Erazo answers calls directly and is described in multiple reviews as responding to quote requests the same day, including weekends - one reviewer noted he arrived the same day a quick patch job was requested and handled it in a single visit. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge stands out for organized communication from the office side as well, with coordinator Trish Gates mentioned specifically for keeping customers informed between project stages. Territory manager David Maloney's practice of calling and texting throughout multi-day jobs appears repeatedly in reviews. JRT Pro Painters LLC owner Brayan Rivas Ticas gets consistent mentions for same-day text and call responses, with one homeowner describing reaching Brayan mid-project with a concern and getting an immediate response.

"Charlie was very professional and provided a book showing his background and some of his work. Once we walked through the project, I received updates throughout and all my questions were answered." - Michael McCarty, Google Review (Teall Painting)"Communication was easy and timely throughout the job. They were punctual every day, explained the process clearly, and kept everything transparent." - Stephanie, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"Brayan responded, gave me a fair quote and worked with me on a medical delay I incurred. I've dealt with some shady contractors over the years and have had some bad experiences - these guys are the real deal." - Jim C, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Prep work and daily cleanup are among the most commonly praised qualities across reviews for painters serving Plainview, NY. CRD Painting Inc gets some of the most detailed prep-work praise in the group: customers describe plastic sheeting on floors and furniture, careful protection of switches and receptacles, and multiple-coat techniques on bathroom ceilings designed to prevent sweating. One reviewer specifically notes that Camilo uses a layered process on difficult surfaces - not just rolling paint on but preparing and treating the substrate first. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is known for end-of-day cleanup: reviewers describe crews arriving each morning to a clean workspace and leaving each evening with the home fully usable, a particularly noted detail on a six-day whole-home renovation. Teall Painting reviews consistently mention that crews cover floors with builder's paper and drop cloths before any work starts.

Big Expert Painting LLC customers describe furniture moved, covered, and returned to its original position at the end of each day. Several reviewers note that Denis's crew swept up debris - including leaves tracked in from outside - without being asked. JRT Pro Painters LLC reviews highlight that Brayan's crew cleans the workspace at the end of each day so the home remains livable overnight, and one customer noted they took all debris with them when they left, removing the homeowner's need to dispose of anything. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY, which also serves Plainview, NY and carries a Chooz Score of 83.9%, earns specific mentions for prep work on exterior jobs: customers describe thorough scraping, sanding, and carpentry repairs before any paint is applied, with several noting that no touch-ups were needed after completion.

"They protected everything from paint drips, were careful to not paint receptacles, switches or anything else that is not supposed to get painted. Camilo and his team are true professionals." - Reyes Hernandez, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"They left each day with our house in a useable condition. Cleaning up every day and efficiently doing our extensive painting and staining job." - Frank Reganato, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)"They prepared the areas that needed work to ensure dirt, debris and paint would not ruin our belongings - and the areas he touched up blended perfectly. You would never tell it had been patched up." - Monica Oliveira, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, BBB

Timeliness and scheduling reliability are consistent themes across reviews for painters serving Plainview, NY. Teall Painting customers describe crews arriving on time each day and projects finishing within or ahead of the stated timeline - one reviewer specifically noted that Charlie worked to accommodate a tight move-in deadline, adjusting the schedule to fit the homeowner's needs and working longer hours to finish on time. CRD Painting Inc customers describe Camilo showing up when he says he will, consistently, across relationships that span years. One reviewer with 15 years of experience hiring CRD calls scheduling reliability one of the primary reasons they keep coming back. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis Erazo is described across multiple reviews as prompt and on schedule, including on a weather-sensitive exterior job where he monitored the forecast and rescheduled proactively to protect the finished result.

Interior Finishing NYC customers note that owner Dorian Golemi often comes in ahead of schedule - one reviewer described a two-day elevator hall installation that finished within the stated timeframe despite the complexity of the project. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge crews are described as arriving at a consistent start time across multi-day projects, with one customer noting the team showed up at 8:30 AM each day and worked full days despite a heat wave. JRT Pro Painters LLC reviews consistently mention punctuality as a standout quality - Brayan and his crew are described as arriving as scheduled and working full days, with one reviewer noting they completed a 2.5-day job across two-and-a-half full days with no shortened days or late arrivals.

"Charlie immediately responded to any questions, whether by call or text. They not only fit us into their schedule quickly but also worked to accommodate our schedule and made adjustments as needed." - Michael Deerr, Google Review (Teall Painting)"Camilo is punctual and works in an orderly fashion. I can call him for a small spackle job and he will come to repair. I can't say enough - he's AMAZING!!" - Diana Grable, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"They arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Pricing and value come up consistently across reviews for painters serving Plainview, NY, with most customers describing quotes that are fair, competitive, and - importantly - accurate at billing. Teall Painting reviews specifically mention itemized estimates that spell out every element of the job in advance, with one homeowner noting that after getting multiple bids, Charlie's quote offered the best combination of price and workmanship. CRD Painting Inc customers describe Camilo's pricing as consistently reasonable, with multiple reviewers noting the initial quote matched the final bill exactly, with no additions or adjustments. One homeowner who has used CRD for over 15 years cites fair pricing alongside quality and reliability as the reason for the long relationship. Big Expert Painting LLC earns similar mentions: Denis's prices are described as competitive and transparent, and several reviewers note they called Denis back for additional work specifically because the value on the first job was so strong.

JRT Pro Painters LLC reviews describe pricing as transparent and straightforward. One reviewer notes Brayan is upfront about what things cost, calling him easy to deal with and honest about pricing. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers highlight that the company is competitive even on complex jobs - one homeowner with a 2,300-square-foot home who received multiple estimates chose Precision Painting partly on price and partly on the professionalism of the initial consultation. CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY reviews include one veteran customer who cited their long-standing principle of not going with the lowest bid, and said CertaPro was worth every penny on a complex staining project - a reminder that value isn't always the same as the lowest number.

"Pricing was very reasonable and Charlie was thorough in reconfirming the scope before starting. The estimate was detailed and there weren't any surprises." - Amy Badersnider, Google Review (Teall Painting)"The initial quote was accurate with no nonsense charges added at the end. Would definitely use again!" - Danny Tam, Google Review (CRD Painting Inc)"Of all the price quotes we received, theirs was right in the middle. We definitely got high value for the price we paid." - Kent Corso, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters LLC)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, BBB

Painters serving Plainview, NY offer a broader range of specialty services than many homeowners expect. Interior Finishing NYC is the clearest specialist in the group, with owner Dorian Golemi handling limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic finishes, and a full range of wallpaper installation including grasscloth, cork, vinyl, and large-scale mural panels. Several reviewers describe projects other contractors refused before Dorian accepted and completed them. Teall Painting handles specialty exterior work including western red cedar restoration, stucco repainting, mahogany door refinishing, and wainscoting installation - one reviewer with a cedar home described extensive woodpecker damage repair alongside restaining that left the house looking better than expected. CRD Painting Inc owner Camilo offers staining of wooden beams, doors, and decks alongside standard painting, with one customer describing a detailed exterior job at a Sag Harbor home that included black window frame painting and custom stained porch beams.

Big Expert Painting LLC has the widest listed service range in the group: pool-bottom painting with specialty mixed paint, epoxy floor coating, gym flooring installation, marble flooring, crown molding installation, power washing, and sheetrock work alongside standard interior and exterior painting. One reviewer describes Denis handling everything from framing to flooring repair to color-matched painting in a single project. JRT Pro Painters LLC adds deck stripping, staining, and sealing to their painting work, with Brayan advising customers on material selection for durability. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge offers hardwood floor sanding and staining, epoxy garage floor coatings, and wallpaper installation alongside their core painting services, with one reviewer describing a wood stair tread refinished to match surrounding flooring so well that the dog-damaged section was undetectable.

"I hired Dorian as a wallpaper subcontractor and he went the extra mile to properly prepare some unforeseen water damage to a wall, and tackled many non-square walls with ease and attention to detail." - Jeremy Couts, Google Review (Interior Finishing NYC)"I have a mahogany front door that faces south and gets abused by the sunlight. The guys at Teall got the door sanded and refinished in a day and it looks like it is brand new!" - Steve Mazziotti, Google Review (Teall Painting)"Jason knew exactly what I wanted and didn't oversell me on stuff I didn't need. He was also able to sand, stain and lacquer a part of a wood step the dog chewed on - and made it look like it never happened." - Greg Vergith, Google Review (Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook