About Stoller Precise Painting & Finishes
When Stoller Painting and Precise Finishes merged under one roof, the Bloomington-Normal community gained a team with two decades of combined hands-on knowledge. Husband-and-wife owners Jaime and Sarah Stoller lead a crew that handles residential interiors, full exteriors, cabinet refinishing, faux finishes, concrete epoxy floors, and deck staining for homeowners across McLean County. The company holds a BBB A+ Accreditation and maintains an active LLC registered with the Illinois Secretary of State since 2008.
Customers frequently name individual crew members in their feedback, noting how painters like Wade, Mike, Justin, Josh, and Tony protect furnishings, prep surfaces with multiple coats and precise taping, and communicate throughout the process. Whether the scope covers a single bathroom vanity or every wall, door, and trim piece in a multi-story home, the Stoller Precise team approaches each painting project with the same detailed walk-through, written estimate, and premium Sherwin-Williams materials that have earned a perfect 5.0 Google rating across 54 reviews.
Updated: 06-02-2026
Worked with this company?
All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.
Additional Questions Answered
What makes the crew preparation process stand out from other painting companies?
Reviewers describe a level of preparation that goes well beyond basic drop cloths. Frank Gallucci noted that the team covered everything top to bottom and spent days making sure surfaces were perfectly prepped before any paint was applied to his kitchen and laundry room. Shana Parker watched the crew move furniture, tape craft paper across floors, and drape every vulnerable item in plastic before starting. Multiple homeowners single out the caulking, sanding, and multi-coat taping steps as reasons the finished product holds up over time.
How do customers describe working with specific crew members on interior projects?
Named painters appear in nearly every review, and homeowners credit that consistency for the trust they place in the company. Judy Wince praised Wade and Mike Hunter for always consulting her and going over and beyond on decisions. Matt McLaughlin singled out Derick, Joe, and Josh for laying down drop cloths without being asked and striving for excellence on every surface. Greg Willis described Justin as conscientiously thorough and precise in all he did, comparing his rarity to a once-in-a-generation find.
What kinds of projects has the team handled beyond standard wall painting?
The scope of completed work stretches well past interior repaints. Dan Kinzinger listed metal painting, faux finishes, water damage repair, drywall painting, and cabinet work in a single review. Sue Spaur hired the team for kitchen and hallway ceiling repairs, while M M reported a full garage door transformation. Mary Vogel on Facebook noted that the crew power washed and painted a privacy fence alongside a front-door repaint, showing the range from fine detail to outdoor structural work.
How does the company handle historic or older homes that need careful attention?
Several reviewers own century-old properties and chose Stoller Precise for that reason. Debra Rodgers, who owns a 170-year-old historic home, said the team delivered quality and professionalism she trusted with a property that matters deeply to her. Julie Hohulin hired them during the remodel of a 100-year-old home and described their attention to detail as beyond reproach. Nestor Gutierrez brought them back twice for a bathroom remodel and then a full first-floor renovation, both times on an older property requiring sanding and spraying over existing finishes.
Do customers return for additional projects after their first experience?
Repeat business is a recurring theme. Ed Matesevac called Stoller Precise the definition of a company that earns repeat customers, noting he has hired them for projects ranging from a whole-house interior to an exterior refresh. K Breen stated they are the only painters I use and praised the craftsmanship on every visit. John Armstrong has used the company for several jobs on his commercial building and returned again for touch-up work two years later. Thomas Benson mentioned two additional future jobs planned immediately after his bedroom project was completed.
What do reviews reveal about the company's responsiveness to scheduling and timelines?
Homeowners consistently note that projects finish on or ahead of schedule. John Krupka reported that Wade, Mike, and Stan knocked the basement renovation out of the park a day ahead of schedule. Karen Wingo said the crew finished ahead of the estimated timeline for her entire interior repaint. Brendan Wiesner described how the team quickly worked his exterior job into their schedule before year-end weather closed the window. Ashley O'Leary confirmed that her entire first floor was completed in the expected 3 to 4 days.
How is the business structured, and what credentials does it hold?
Stoller Precise Painting and Finishes operates as Stoller Painting, LLC, an active domestic LLC registered with the Illinois Secretary of State since March 2008 under File Number 02495562. Jaime R. Stoller is listed as the principal owner on both the BBB profile and the state filing. The company earned BBB A+ Accreditation and has maintained an A+ rating. Illinois does not require a state-level painting contractor license, so no separate trade license applies.
-Verification Sources: Illinois Secretary of State, BBB of Central Illinois