Stewart Painting
Updated: 10-31-2025
About Stewart Painting Inc.
With over 250 five-star Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating, Stewart Painting Inc. has established itself as Cape Cod's go-to painting contractor through four decades of consistent excellence. Founded in 1980 by Sheldon Stewart, this Hyannis-based company employs over 30 full-time professionals across specialized divisions for painting, carpentry, and power washing. Unlike competitors who rely on subcontractors, Stewart maintains quality control through dedicated in-house teams. Recent reviews highlight crews like Tim and Rabi who leave properties "looking brand new" after power washing, Rocky who returns the next day to ensure customer satisfaction, and carpenter Matt who "really cared about what we, as customers, wanted" when crafting custom Dutch doors.
The company's services span from deck refreshes to multi-week commercial transformations. Their EPA RRP certification enables safe lead paint remediation in pre-1978 homes, while OSHA certification ensures workplace safety standards. Stewart's reach extends across 15 Cape Cod towns, Nantucket, and the South Shore from their dual locations in Hyannis and Hingham. Beyond technical expertise, the company demonstrates community commitment through their annual Paint It Forward program, providing free services to deserving veterans. With an A+ BBB accreditation since 2012, a standard two-year warranty on all work, and response rates showing active owner engagement with customer feedback, Stewart Painting combines old-school craftsmanship with modern customer service to maintain their position as the region's trusted painting authority.
Updated: 10-31-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Stewart Painting Inc.
Q: Why do so many customers specifically mention Tim and Rabi from Stewart Painting Inc.?
Tim and Rabi appear in numerous recent reviews as Stewart's power washing specialists who consistently exceed expectations. Customers describe them as "professional and polite," taking time to explain the process beforehand and walking properties afterward to ensure satisfaction. They're noted for being "considerate of my plantings & window air conditioners" while delivering results that make homes look "brand new." Their names appear in over 10 reviews from the past month alone, suggesting they're Stewart's primary wash team.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Stewart Painting Inc. handle scheduling and communication challenges?
Communication experiences vary significantly among customers. While many praise that "communication on when they would arrive, etc., was always on point," others report frustration with scheduling. One customer noted it was "frustrating having to call repeatedly to get a schedule," particularly when coordinating electrical access and landscapers. Stewart acknowledges these lapses in their responses, citing staffing and weather challenges, and promises process improvements. The office staff including Carissa, Liam, and Kim generally receive positive mentions for responsiveness.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What makes Stewart Painting Inc.'s approach to carpentry different from typical painting contractors?
Stewart maintains a full carpentry division with specialized crews, unusual for painting contractors. Carpenter Matt and apprentice McKenzie receive praise for creating custom Dutch doors, while Jeremy excels at replacing rotten window sills so cleanly "you'd never know anyone had been working on the house." The carpentry team handles everything from simple trim repairs to complex restoration work on 104-year-old homes. This integration allows seamless coordination between trades, though one customer noted confusion when carpentry preceded painting, leaving trim temporarily mismatched.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Stewart Painting Inc. stand behind their work when problems arise?
Stewart demonstrates mixed but generally positive resolution practices. They honor their two-year warranty, with one customer confirming they "came back and repainted the house without question" when stain peeled. When John Shorrock documented extensive issues with photos, Stewart sent a different crew to address all concerns. However, responses vary; one customer reported unresolved floor damage from paint spills, while another mentioned missed blue trim spots they fixed themselves to avoid further issues.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How do Stewart Painting Inc.'s prices compare to other Cape Cod painters?
Pricing generates polarized reactions, with Stewart positioned as premium-priced but quality-focused. Multiple reviews mention "reasonable price" or "great price," while others find them "very expensive compared to other companies." One Yelp reviewer noted a $7,000 quote for deck painting when another company charged $2,000. A dissatisfied customer mentioned finding another painter to complete work for "$2,400 less than the paint price from Stewart." Most customers who choose Stewart seem aware of premium pricing but value the reputation and warranty.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
Q: What's the experience like working with Stewart Painting Inc.'s different crew leaders?
Each crew leader brings distinct strengths repeatedly mentioned in reviews. Earl receives praise for being "courteous and diligent" with exceptional attention to detail, finding issues customers miss. Rocky ensures satisfaction by returning the next day to verify happiness with projects. Gilson goes "out of his way to be sure we were happy with every detail." Wayne demonstrates exceptional cleanup and kindness. This consistency across different teams suggests strong training and standards, though crew assignment can significantly impact experience quality.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Are they actually reliable about showing up and completing work on time?
Reliability generally ranks high, though initial scheduling can be problematic. Customers consistently report crews "arrived when promised" once work begins, with many projects completed "within the allotted time" or even ahead of schedule. The recurring praise includes being "on time from start to finish" and maintaining steady progress. However, project starts sometimes face delays, with one customer noting they "didn't come on the day they committed to," though end results typically satisfy.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Stewart Painting Inc. really leave properties cleaner than they found them?
The cleanup quality receives exceptional and consistent praise across reviews. Customers repeatedly mention crews who "left no trace of work having been done" and maintain sites so well there were "virtually no signs of them having been there." Multiple reviews specifically state properties were left "cleaner than when they started." The company appears to treat this as a signature service element, with even carpentry crews maintaining the same standard, suggesting it's embedded in company culture rather than individual initiative.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews