Owner Matthew Agueli founded Long Island Pro Painting, LLC in Rocky Point in April 2021, establishing the company as a full-service painting contractor serving Suffolk and Nassau County. Matthew oversees estimates and client relations while working alongside an in-house crew that includes painters Antonio, Dave, Catalina, and Andre, with reviewers naming crew members across jobs, including Jeffrey Weiner's reference to Andre as "the consummate professional."
The company handles interior and exterior residential painting alongside commercial work, with particular strengths in cabinet refinishing, deck and fence staining, power washing, skim coating, and full-home transformations. Projects range from single-room refreshes to complex surface restoration requiring skim coating and drywall repair alongside paint application. The crew uses premium Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore paints on every job and works through color selection with clients from the initial estimate.
The fully insured team serves Nassau and Suffolk County, including Huntington, Smithtown, Stony Brook, Babylon, Bay Shore, Rocky Point, and surrounding Long Island communities. Free written estimates are provided before any work begins.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Homeowner protection and end-of-day cleanup appears consistently across Long Island Pro Painting reviews. Karin Waslo describes crew member Antonio as "careful in protecting our living space with plastic" who "did not leave any mess behind at the end of the day." Patricia Buchala was surprised to return and find rooms "cleaned with all the furniture in place" after a two-day interior job. Eric Shellman confirms the crew "cleaned up immaculately" upon completion.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers who gathered multiple estimates before committing describe Long Island Pro Painting's pricing as the most competitive among bids received. Laura Russo calls the final cost "reasonably priced, based on other quotes I received," while Bobby Hamilton confirms the estimate was "the most affordable." On Yelp, No T. reports the quote came in "significantly cheaper than two other companies," with the quality exceeding what the lower price suggested.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
Aaron's project stands out in Long Island Pro Painting's review history as a job requiring skim coating of all interior surfaces across a 2,300 sq ft home, a scope well beyond standard painting. David Denara adds related context, crediting Long Island Pro Painting for completing Sheetrock and molding work alongside painting and calling the entire experience "wonderful." Viveca Tress, whose project required extensive hole patching from removed built-in shelves, notes the repaired room "looked brand new" upon completion.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Rebecca Riggs was traveling during her home's full exterior repaint and reports that "Matt kept in constant communication so I was regularly updated" throughout the job. Viveca Tress calls Matthew "incredibly responsive and very easy to work with throughout the entire process." One reviewer notes that Matthew noticed an unfinished area after a job and "came back and made sure the job was perfect" without being asked, returning on his own initiative.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The crew consistency at Long Island Pro Painting produces reviewer-level familiarity unusual for short-term contractor relationships. Karin Waslo names Antonio and describes him working "quietly and diligently all day" while remaining "polite and respectful" of the home. Jeffrey Weiner calls Andre "the consummate professional." Rosemary Scott, who arrived through a referral from a prior Long Island Pro Painting client, named both Dave and Catalina in her full-home project review.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Deck and exterior work generates notable repeat business for Long Island Pro Painting. Lynn L describes the crew completing a large wrap-around front porch in two days with "beautiful work at a fair price." Michael Brown details the team sanding a hardwood deck and applying Penofin Penetrating Oil "according to the manufacturer's specifications." Robin Strecker returned for a second Long Island Pro Painting project, hiring them for a historical cottage exterior and then a multi-level deck restoration, calling both results "fantastic."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Long Island Pro Painting's response pattern to criticism is uneven. Owner Matthew Agueli responded to Cate M's review with a direct offer to resolve the issue, and Bobby Hamilton, who noted minor quality concerns, still concluded "I'd still recommend" and cited the pricing as most competitive among bids. However, a detailed Google complaint from .maria Ingoglia describing paint damage, incomplete work, and no owner contact after full payment, along with a Facebook no-show complaint from Tara McCabe Schwack, remain publicly unaddressed.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Long Island Pro Painting LLC is registered as an active domestic LLC with the New York State Department of State, DOS ID 5980237, filed April 2, 2021, with Matthew Agueli listed at 12 Hazel Road, Rocky Point, NY 11778. Note: the entity's biennial statement has been past due since April 2023. Suffolk County requires a Home Improvement Contractor License for residential painting. No active HIC license was found for Long Island Pro Painting LLC in the Suffolk County DCA database. A prior HIC license, HS-61913, held under a different Agueli business, expired January 2020.
-Verification Sources: NY Department of State Division of Corporations, Suffolk County DCA license search
Updated: 04-07-2026