Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Precision Painting Plus of Manhattan
When Manhattan co-op owner Chris McAllister needed painters for his 12th project, he returned to Precision Painting Plus of Manhattan without hesitation. This level of loyalty defines the company that brothers Jonathan Richards and Michael Zilberman built from Northeastern roots into a multi-state operation while maintaining the hands-on, detail-focused service that earned that trust in the first place.
The fully licensed and insured team specializes in interior apartment painting, cabinet refinishing, drywall repair, and wallpaper installation. Estimator Sean Cunningham conducts detailed walkthroughs while account manager Trish Gates coordinates scheduling and provides daily project updates. Lead painters including Freddy, Gabriel, and Steven handle everything from Upper East Side pre-wars to Midtown commercial spaces. The company uses Benjamin Moore paints as standard and offers 18-month interest-free financing through Hearth.
Based in Garden City with Manhattan offices at 1325 6th Avenue, they serve all five boroughs plus Long Island and Westchester County. The team provides a two-year limited warranty on completed projects and handles co-op and condo building approval requirements.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Reviews frequently highlight specific team members. Che Hee Han praised painter Freddy as "meticulous and thorough." Eleni Stamas noted that "Javier ran the project like a well-oiled machine." Alisoun PRICE specifically mentioned "Gabriel and his team were wonderful" during her repeat project. Account manager Trish Gates appears across dozens of reviews for her communication.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers consistently praise worksite protection. Natalia Fidelholtz reported her apartment was "cleaner than when they started." Barbara noted the crew "covered everything meticulously with plastic." Jason Schindler mentioned "not a single drop of paint on my floors" after a full apartment repaint. The team uses multiple layers of drop cloths and plastic sheeting on all projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Sean Cunningham's thorough estimates receive frequent praise. Wendy Maitland described him as "incredibly detailed and patient with all my questions." Paula Barr noted "Sean walked through every room and explained exactly what they would do." Once scheduled, Trish Gates coordinates timing and provides regular updates throughout the project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple customers who obtained competing quotes chose PPP. Ashish Kumbhat stated he "got quotes from six different companies" and found their pricing competitive for the quality offered. Lauren Anesta called them "fairly priced for Manhattan." Grace Hui noted the final result was "worth every penny we paid." The company provides detailed written estimates with itemized costs.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Punctuality emerges as a consistent theme. Eleni Stamas reported the crew was "on time every single day." Jason Schindler noted they "started exactly when they said they would and finished a day early." Paul Magyar mentioned "no delays, no excuses, just professional execution." The company's project managers coordinate daily arrival times with clients.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The July 2024 Angi review from Brian S. described ceiling paint cracking and peeling two days after completion. The company responded professionally, with the reviewer noting "they came back to address the issue." While Brian remained partially dissatisfied with the final outcome, the response demonstrates accountability rather than defensiveness when problems arise.
-Review Snippet Sources: Angi
Finish quality receives consistent praise across reviews. Paul Magyar described the results as "flawless, like a showroom." Carolyn Grisko noted "Freddy's trim work was perfection, not a single drip." Multiple reviewers mention the company uses Benjamin Moore paints as standard. Che Hee Han observed "the walls looked better than when the apartment was new."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The 9% repeat customer rate reflects strong loyalty. Chris McAllister has completed "12 projects with them over the years." Bill Wolfsthal calls them his "go-to painters" after three separate jobs. Mollie B. mentioned returning because "why would I try anyone else when they're this reliable?" Real estate professionals also provide repeated referrals.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Yes. New York City requires Home Improvement Contractor licensing for painting work. Precision Painting Plus operates under the legal entity Blue Chip Painting & Contracting (DBA Precision Painting Plus), holding NYC DCWP License No. 1460161-DCA with Active status, issued 2/28/2025 and expiring 2/28/2027. The parent corporation, Precision Painting of NY + LI Inc., is registered with the New York Department of State as a Domestic Business Corporation (DOS ID 5600628), incorporated 8/7/2019 with Active status. Scott DiDonna serves as Chief Executive Officer with the registered address at 990 Corporate Drive, Suite 204, Westbury, NY 11590.
-Verification Sources: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, NY Department of State Division of Corporations
Updated: 04-07-2026