Chooz Score Insights
Once You Use Them, You Don't Switch
If you're looking for a painting company you can call for years to come, Precision Painting Plus of Manhattan has built the kind of loyalty most contractors only dream about. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators: multiple reviewers mention returning for 2nd, 3rd, and even 12th projects:
- Chris McAllister has hired them for more than a dozen projects in his Manhattan co-op and keeps coming back
- Bill Wolfsthal has used them for three separate paint jobs in his pre-war apartment, including bathroom, hallway, and detailed molding work
"I have now used Precision Plus for three paint jobs in my Manhattan pre-war apartment. They are quick to respond to questions, they were on-time with both the start and finish of their work, and the finished job was excellent." - Bill W., Google Review
Years of Consistent Results
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Precision Painting Plus of Manhattan had over 145 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 85.9%. With over 18 years in business and consistent ratings across platforms, they've established a strong presence across the New York metro area:
- Over 460 reviews on Angi with a 4.6-star rating, plus nine consecutive Angi Super Service Awards from 2012 through 2021
- The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, reviews spanned multiple platforms including 4.2 stars on Yelp with over 25 reviews, and real estate professionals actively recommending the company
"I am a real estate broker in Manhattan, this is the second high end property that Precision has painted for me. They have consistently been the best price with incredible service and punctuality plus top notch performance." - Paul M., Google Review
The Details Matter Here
Crew members like Freddy, Sean, Javier, and Gabriel get called out by name across dozens of reviews for their precision and care. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong: reviewers mention specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines:
- Multiple customers praise the detailed trim work and clean edges, with one calling the results "flawless" and another noting paint lines that were "crisp and precise"
- The team uses Benjamin Moore paints as standard and offers a two-year limited warranty on completed work
- NYC DCWP Home Improvement Contractor License No. 1460161-DCA verified active through 2027
"Freddy was already aware of the special request I had with the bathroom shelf and after a quick run-down, work started and was done in a couple of hours. Freddy and Steve knew exactly what they were doing and everything was completed in a couple of hours!" - Che Hee H., Google Review
Worked with this company?
All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.
Additional Questions Answered
How does Precision Painting Plus handle co-op and condo board approval requirements in Manhattan?
Clients describe a process where the administrative team takes on insurance documentation and building approval paperwork. Diana Holmer noted that Trisha helped with the paperwork and building approvals to get the project moving, while Che Hee Han pointed out that the company was on top of all required paperwork and approvals for building insurance requirements. This practice removes a layer of complexity that many Manhattan apartment owners face when coordinating renovation projects.
What do repeat customers say about working with this company across multiple projects?
A notable number of reviewers have returned for second and third projects. JM Chilgren, who completed 3 separate painting projects, highlighted consistent communication and punctuality. FFNY used the company twice and described the pricing as reasonable both times, adding I am quite fussy and I wouldn't use anyone else. Chris McAllister has hired them for more than a dozen projects and praised their reliability.
How does the team approach older pre-war Manhattan apartments with multiple paint layers and uneven surfaces?
Pre-war properties present unique challenges with accumulated paint layers and aging architectural details. Jonathan Engel described a project in an old pre-war apartment with many coats of paint and noted the crew worked hard. Bill Wolfsthal praised the work around the old moldings in his Manhattan pre-war apartment. Jeff Adelson had a cork ceiling covering removed, sanded, and repainted with a high gloss finish, a restoration-level project requiring extensive prep.
What specific crew members do customers mention, and what roles do they play?
Reviewers frequently name individual team members and their contributions. Sean manages estimates and client relationships. Trish and Jason handle administrative coordination and scheduling. Javier serves as a project manager who meets clients on-site before work begins. Freddy and Steven are painters praised for their efficiency and attention to detail. Victor Leiner noted Sean and the team were excellent and helped him navigate a massive coop application.
How does Precision Painting Plus handle wallpaper projects alongside painting work?
The company performs both wallpaper removal and installation as part of broader painting projects. Rachel Fioroni described a project where the team removed wallpaper on 6 floors and replaced with paint, cleaning up wall unevenness in the process. Linda Luppino had paint and amazing wallpaper in the living room combined with a color-drenched master bedroom. Victor Leiner similarly praised the combined painting and wallpaper installation work.
How do clients describe the communication and project management experience?
Transparent communication runs through the majority of reviews. Nikolay Afanasyev noted the company provided a comprehensive scope of work and communicated throughout the process. Nathan Guarino, who worked on several projects, praised Sean and Trish as great communicators who were always willing to answer questions and work within a budget. Aileen Fernandez valued the open and transparent communication after a previous negative experience with another company.
How are pricing and estimates handled, and what should customers know about value for the investment?
The company provides free, no-obligation estimates and reviewers consistently mention fair pricing. Alan Bayles described receiving the absolute most competitive bid for the job. Cynthia Rose was pleased with an excellent job at a reasonable price and suggested requesting an estimate that includes supply costs for full upfront transparency. The website confirms transparent pricing with no hidden fees, and the company offers 18-month interest-free financing for larger projects.
What is the licensing and business entity status for Precision Painting Plus in New York?
The company operates under a New York City Department of Consumer and Worker Protection Home Improvement Contractor license, verified active through February 2027. The business is registered with the New York Department of State as a Domestic Business Corporation, incorporated in August 2019 in Nassau County. The parent legal entity is Blue Chip Painting and Contracting with the trade name Precision Painting Plus.
-Verification Sources: NYC DCWP License Database, NY Department of State Division of Corporations