Makley Painting LLC
About Makley Painting
Led by owner Tony Makley and a team of seasoned professionals including foreman Franklin, Makley Painting has served Central Ohio homeowners. The Delaware-based company handles interior and exterior residential painting, cabinet refinishing, deck and fence staining, pressure washing, drywall repair, and wood rot replacement. One customer described their finished exterior as "by far the best experience and painting expertise we've ever had."
The fully bonded and insured team partners with Sherwin Williams, Creative Paints, and PPG Architectural Finishes for premium materials. Tony personally handles estimates and color consultations, while crews maintain a strict no-subcontracting policy. Every project stays with in-house painters from start to finish.
Makley Painting is BBB Accredited and serves Columbus, Delaware, Dublin, Powell, Westerville, New Albany, Upper Arlington, Worthington, Lewis Center, Hilliard, and surrounding communities within the Central Ohio metro area.
Updated: 02-24-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Makley Painting
Q: Does Makley Painting follow through on the prep work that makes paint jobs last?
Customers consistently highlight preparation as a standout practice. Reviews mention thorough surface preparation including scraping, sanding, caulking, and priming before any paint touches the walls. One homeowner noted the caulking was "well done" with trim boards replaced where needed. Another described how the crew "prepared the room before they started painting" with careful attention to protecting surfaces and ensuring proper adhesion.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, BBB
Q: How does Makley Painting handle communication throughout a project?
Tony Makley personally oversees customer communication from initial estimate through final walkthrough. Customers describe him as responsive and transparent about timelines, costs, and any issues that arise. One reviewer praised the team's "dependability" as "outstanding," while another noted they were "very professional" in keeping homeowners informed. Tony responds to virtually every online review, demonstrating ongoing engagement with past customers.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, BBB
Q: What do customers say about Franklin and the Makley Painting crew?
Foreman Franklin receives specific praise across multiple reviews for his work ethic and attention to detail. Customers mention the crew arrives on time, works efficiently, and maintains a clean job site throughout the project. One homeowner described the team as "very careful" in their approach, while another noted they were "equally thorough with the clean-up" after completing the work. The consistency of the same crew members builds trust with repeat customers.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, BBB
Q: Does Makley Painting leave homes cleaner than they found them?
Daily cleanup and final site condition receive frequent mentions in reviews. Customers describe crews who protect furniture, cover floors, and remove all debris at the end of each workday. One reviewer specifically noted the team was "thorough" with cleanup procedures, leaving no trace of the painting process behind. The attention to protecting homeowner property during work appears as a consistent theme across platforms.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: How precise is Makley Painting's actual paint application?
The quality of finished work draws specific compliments for clean lines, even coverage, and professional results. One customer described their project as having "precise" painting with excellent attention to trim and detail work. Another called their completed exterior "amazing" and noted they would "absolutely use them for future painting inside and out." Reviews frequently mention that finished rooms and exteriors look refreshed and professionally done.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, BBB
Q: Does Makley Painting use subcontractors or in-house employees?
Makley Painting maintains an explicit no-subcontracting policy. The company website states projects "will never be sold to another contractor or subcontractor." This means the same in-house team that provides the estimate handles the actual work. Customers benefit from crew consistency, with foreman Franklin and other regular team members appearing across multiple reviews over time.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What is Makley Painting's approach to color selection and consultation?
The company partners with Sherwin Williams to offer complimentary color consultation services. Tony assists homeowners with selecting appropriate color schemes, and customers can access the Sherwin Williams Color Visualizer tool or schedule in-home visits. Multiple reviews mention appreciation for guidance on color choices, with one customer noting the team helped them achieve exactly the look they envisioned for their space.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do Makley Painting customers come back for additional projects?
Repeat business and referrals appear throughout the review history. Customers mention using Makley Painting for multiple projects over the years, from interior rooms to full exterior repaints. One reviewer stated they would "absolutely use them for future painting" after their experience. The pattern of returning customers and neighbor referrals suggests satisfaction extends well beyond the initial project completion.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, BBB
Updated: 02-24-2026