Buckeye House Painting
About Buckeye House Painting
When John W. returned to Buckeye House Painting after fifteen years, he received a "significant repeat customer discount" and crews that were "fast, efficient, thorough, and neat." This pattern of customers returning across decades defines how owner Bob Klem runs this Powell-based operation, where loyalty gets remembered and rewarded.
Bob Klem purchased Buckeye House Painting on January 1, 2022 from founder Dan McClurg, having worked his way up from crew member to management since joining in 2004. Dan Hartwell handles estimates and scheduling, bringing fifteen years of Sherwin-Williams experience to the quoting process. The company specializes in interior and exterior residential painting, deck and fence staining, power washing, and color consultation services.
The BBB-accredited team has earned the Angi Super Service Award for fourteen consecutive years. Based in Powell, they serve Columbus, Dublin, Westerville, Worthington, Delaware, and surrounding Central Ohio communities.
Updated: 02-16-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Buckeye House Painting
Q: Why do so many customers return to Buckeye House Painting years later?
The pattern of repeat business stands out in reviews. John W. came back after "fifteen years" and received a repeat customer discount. Laurie C. noted "this is the second time we've used Buckeye House Painting" for similar interior work. Dave Riedinger mentions this was his second deck staining project with them. Richard Hall returned for interior work after having his exterior painted approximately ten years prior.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Q: Does Buckeye House Painting complete projects quickly?
Multiple customers praise the speed without sacrificing quality. Michael Hutchinson had his "very tall great room, bed rooms, and hallways" completed with the crew "in and out in a day." Laurie C. confirms "both jobs were completed in 1 day" including furniture moving, hole patching, and painting. The company manages to balance efficiency with thorough prep work.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Q: How does Buckeye House Painting handle furniture and protection during interior projects?
Customers consistently mention the prep work quality. Michael Hutchinson states the crew "made sure every surrounding area was taped off and covered" and that "they even move all furniture and take down blinds." Laurie C. confirms they "moved and covered all the furniture, patched holes, painted, and moved everything back." This full-service approach eliminates homeowner prep work.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Q: What do customers say about Dan Hartwell's estimates at Buckeye House Painting?
Dan Hartwell receives specific praise for his quoting process. Harley Haas notes "Dan Hartwell came out and provided us with a quote and some suggestions" before the work began. Claire Voisard mentions the owner "went into detail on the whole process and what to expect which was greatly appreciated." The company emphasizes transparent communication before work begins.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Buckeye House Painting leave properties clean after finishing?
Cleanup quality appears frequently in reviews. Kathryn Higa on Facebook describes crews leaving the house "so spotless, we had houseguests the evening they finished." Robert Orr confirms "my yard was left clean" after exterior work on shutters and porch posts. Cathy Latimer praises the "great clean up" as part of her overall positive experience.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: How does Buckeye House Painting respond to negative reviews or complaints?
Owner Bob Klem responds personally to criticism with detailed explanations rather than dismissiveness. When a reviewer claimed social media interaction issues, Bob responded by explaining they investigated thoroughly and "tried to reach out to them through direct message" to resolve concerns. When a one-star review appeared from someone who never received service, he noted "we have never done work for this person" while remaining professional.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What crew members do customers mention by name at Buckeye House Painting?
Reviews frequently call out specific crew members. Karlene Coulson gives a "special call out to Ricardo and his crew" for her interior and exterior project. Harley Haas praises "Jorge and his crew" for communicating throughout the project so "results were exactly as we wanted." This crew consistency suggests the company maintains experienced, long-term painters.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Is Buckeye House Painting pricing competitive compared to other quotes?
Customers describe the value positively. Multiple Google reviews tag the company as "great price" or "reasonable price." John W. emphasizes "the quoted estimate is what you pay" with no surprises. Claire Voisard specifically mentions "reasonable price" alongside praising the detailed quoting process. The company appears competitively priced without hidden charges.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Updated: 02-16-2026