Best Impression Painting
About Best Impression Painting
When Amy Stadulis spotted the Best Impression Painting crew installing Christmas lights on her neighbor's house, she stopped to grab a card. Months later, her exterior project unfolded across a two-week ocean vacation, a roof replacement delay, and back-to-back weekend sessions the crew arranged to beat an approaching weather window. That combination of flexibility, forward planning, and follow-through captures how co-owners Kyle Hillyard and Joe built this Columbus-area operation from the ground up.
Founded in 2021, Best Impression Painting is a locally owned contractor serving Columbus and surrounding communities including Westerville, Powell, Worthington, Dublin, and Gahanna. The team specializes in exterior and interior residential painting, cabinet refinishing, deck and fence staining, drywall repair, wood rot repair, and holiday lighting installation. Jordyn, the company's site supervisor, leads most field projects and has earned recognition across reviews for his communication and attention to detail. Ben, who handles carpentry alongside the painting crews, allows customers to bundle trim work and wood repair into a single project visit.
The fully licensed and insured team serves Central Ohio within approximately a 25-mile radius of Columbus, with dedicated coverage across 13 communities. The company backs all work with a 100% satisfaction commitment and uses premium-brand paints including Sherwin-Williams.
Updated: 03-20-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Best Impression Painting
Q: Why do so many Best Impression Painting reviews specifically mention Jordyn by name?
Jordyn serves as the primary site supervisor and point of contact on most projects, and customers consistently praise the way he manages communication from estimate to final walkthrough. Rashel describes how he "did a great job keeping me informed every step of the way" and came back after completion to walk through the finished project together. Amy Stadulis notes he answered a seemingly endless stream of texts and "never did they leave me hanging." That hands-on accessibility appears to be a deliberate practice rather than an exception.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What does Best Impression Painting's exterior painting process look like from start to finish?
Reviews describe a thorough sequence that begins well before the first brush touches a wall. Anjali Parekh details "a very thorough job with the pre washing, prepping, painting and clean up," while Ryan Jurden notes his crew leader surfaced issues mid-project and offered recommendations rather than waiting to be asked. The process concludes with a final walkthrough — Rashel specifically mentions Jordyn returning post-completion to confirm the result met both her standards and the company's own.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Best Impression Painting's pricing compare when customers get multiple quotes?
Several reviewers specifically mention shopping around before choosing Best Impression Painting. Mike NeCamp is direct about it, writing that "albeit they were not the cheapest, it was a very competitive quote" — and he returned a second time for a painting project after a positive Christmas lights experience. Dana Shady on Facebook noted that Joey came in with a competitive bid and then "came up with a more cost effective solution" for certain areas, prioritizing the best overall result over billing for the original scope.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: Can Best Impression Painting handle carpentry and wood repair as part of a painting project?
Yes, and this combination is something multiple customers highlight as a practical advantage. Summer Bowers explains that "his brother Ben is a carpenter, as well, so we were able to get more than one project completed right away." Alyson Faryman similarly notes that "Ben took care of our carpentry work and took care to make sure it was done well," allowing the living room painting and trim work to be handled in a single visit. Tammy Coyer also had wood trim replaced with composite before the exterior painting began.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Best Impression Painting help customers choose colors before a project starts?
Color guidance comes up consistently in reviews, particularly for customers who felt uncertain about their selections. Jaanki Thakkar writes that the team was "amazing at helping me choose the paint color" for a cabinet painting project. Amy Stadulis describes the company providing paint sampling so she could confirm her approved colors would look right on the actual exterior before the crew applied a single coat. The website also notes color samples are offered as part of the free estimate process.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Best Impression Painting handle scheduling challenges like weather delays or homeowner travel?
Amy Stadulis offers the most detailed account — her exterior project required coordinating around a two-week vacation and a roof replacement that had to finish first. Best Impression Painting "was very flexible to wait out the roof replacement" and then monitored the weather forecast, arranging Saturday and Sunday sessions with her approval to complete the work before conditions changed. Maranda Camelin on Facebook echoes the urgency theme, praising "the sense of urgency Kyle & Jordyn offered to ensure my home was completed BEFORE the deadline."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: Why do contractors and repeat customers keep coming back to Best Impression Painting?
The repeat customer pattern runs throughout the reviews. Contractor Drew Lansing, who brought Best Impression Painting onto a full-scale exterior project, writes that "out of all the money the client spent they were the most impressed by the professionalism and quality" of the painting team — and committed to using them exclusively going forward. PJ Shotwell describes the company as the family's go-to painter for years, having handled multiple homes. Julie Fishman notes hiring the team for multiple jobs and planning to continue.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Is Best Impression Painting licensed and registered in Ohio?
Ohio does not require a state-level painting contractor license — the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board regulates electrical, HVAC, plumbing, and similar trades but not painting contractors. Best Impression Painting LLC is registered as an active Domestic Limited Liability Company with the Ohio Secretary of State, Entity No. 4650834, with an original filing date of 3/31/2021. The company also states on its website that it is fully licensed and insured. You can verify the business entity registration directly at the Ohio Secretary of State business search at businesssearch.ohiosos.gov.
-Verification Sources: Ohio Secretary of State, bestimpressionpainting.com/about-us/
Updated: 03-20-2026