When Janet Journey called Best Impression Painting in early 2026 about her exterior project, color choice was her source of anxiety. Site supervisor Jordyn sent out "a color specialist, Maria, to help. Came and painted large swatches of the colors I chose, on the house." The crew then completed the work over a weekend while she was away, surprising her on her return.
Owner Kyle Hillyard runs Best Impression Painting as a family operation. Kyle's brother Ben handles carpentry assignments while Jordyn leads project crews as site supervisor. The team handles interior and exterior residential painting, cabinet refinishing, deck and fence staining, wallpaper removal, popcorn ceiling removal, drywall repair, wood repair, and commercial work. The crew also installs holiday lighting in the off season, which is how several customers first found them.
Best Impression Painting is fully licensed and insured and serves Bexley, Columbus, Delaware, Dublin, Gahanna, Galena, Hilliard, Lewis Center, New Albany, Powell, Upper Arlington, Westerville, and Worthington. The company is a registered Ohio limited liability company and backs every project with a 100 percent satisfaction commitment.
Updated: 05-14-2026
Customers describe Jordyn as the steady point of contact from estimate through walk-through. Janet Journey called him "so patient and understanding every step of the way" about a stressful color decision, and Rashel said Jordyn "did a great job keeping me informed every step of the way." Amy Stadulis described how "the zillion questions both Kyle and Jordyn answered by text was amazing," noting they never left her hanging.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Carson Dickens, whose first floor and master bedroom were repainted, wrote that "Kyle, one of the owners, was incredibly helpful and walked his crew through the entire project, ensuring everything was done to perfection." Melissa Hodek said "Kyle was great to work with. His communication was great and he is committed to getting the results you want," and Mike NeCamp credited Kyle by name across two projects he hired the company for.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
For exterior projects, the team sends out specialists and paints large samples directly on the home. Janet Journey wrote that Jordyn "sent out a color specialist, Maria, to help. Came and painted large swatches of the colors I chose, on the house." Amy Stadulis described how they "helped with color choices, paint sampling for us to assure the colors we had approved were going to look great" during her exterior project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Yes, Kyle's brother Ben covers the carpentry side of the business. Summer B. on Yelp explained the practical benefit, writing "His brother Ben is a carpenter, as well, so we were able to get more than one project completed right away." Alyson Faryman echoed this on Google, noting "Ben took care of our carpentry work and took care to make sure it was done well," alongside the painting on her living room project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
The team installs Christmas lights in the off season, and it has been the first contact for multiple painting customers. Amy Stadulis spotted the crew installing lights on a neighbor's house and stopped to get a card, which led to a spring exterior paint job. Mike NeCamp wrote that his lighting experience "led me to have them quote my painting job and then ultimately in hiring them." Tarik called the lighting setup "seamless."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple reviewers mention shopping competitors before choosing. Mike NeCamp wrote "I had multiple quotes and albeit they were not the cheapest, it was a very competitive quote. They were professional, timely, and delivered everything they promised." John Lee said the pricing was "very reasonable, offering great value for the level of craftsmanship they provide," and Michael H noted "Competitive, fair pricing" on his exterior project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Painting the City of Worthington's fire hydrants stands out. Steve Tennant wrote that "Best Impression Painting did an awesome job painting the City of Worthington's fire hydrants last season." That municipal contract sits alongside more conventional work, and Ginger Brehl noted she first hired the company "on a commercial project, and their impressive work made me choose them for my own home painting project."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Yes. Best Impression Painting LLC is registered with the Ohio Secretary of State as a domestic limited liability company under entity number 4650834, with an original filing date of March 31, 2021. The registered address is 1358 Mentor Dr, Westerville, OH 43081. Ohio does not require a state-level painting contractor license, and Columbus and Westerville municipal codes do not require contractor registration for painting-only work. Verification is available through the Ohio Secretary of State business search.
-Verification Sources: Ohio Secretary of State Business Search, BBB Profile of Best Impression Painting LLC, Painting Contractor License Lookup project file
Updated: 05-14-2026