3 Best Painters in Pelham, NH - Chooz Score Ranked

Why Customers Choose Castle Complements Painting Co., Inc.

Long-Term Relationships, Not One-Time Jobs

Customers don't just hire Castle Complements once, they keep coming back for decades. The Chooz Score's customer retention indicators are exceptional: owner Mat Richards has built relationships spanning 15, 20, and even close to 25 years with some clients. That kind of loyalty doesn't happen by accident:

• Stephen Sakakeeny has been using Castle Complements "for at least 10 years (inside and outside)"
• Owner responses reveal customers like Karen Giaquinto have been clients "for almost 20 years"
• J.P. L. describes working with them "for almost fifteen years" across "several jobs"

"We've had Castle Complements for several jobs for almost fifteen years. Mat does a great job, especially with prep work so that the paint looks good for a long time." - J.P. L., Google Review

Hundreds of Happy Customers

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Castle Complements had over 110 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 91.0%. With 25 years in business since owner Mat Richards returned from Army active duty in 2000, they've built a reputation across the Merrimack Valley:

• 4.4 stars on Angi with over 8 reviews confirming consistent quality
• MA Home Improvement Contractor License No. 157414 verified and prominently displayed
• EPA Lead-Safe Renovation certified for work in older homes

"The best experience with a contractor we've had in quite some time! Mat and his entire crew were very professional and went above and beyond all of our expectations." - Nicholas T., Google Review

Familiar Faces, Consistent Results

Castle Complements keeps the same crew on projects, and customers notice. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component shows consistency: the same names appear across multiple reviews, and customers praise the team chemistry:

• Chuck, David, and Mat are mentioned by name repeatedly across reviews
• Jill DelGrosso gives a "huge shout-out to Mat, Chuck and David" for their interior painting work
• Angela Hughes notes "Mat and his team (Chuck the lead on this job) always go above and beyond"

"I can't say enough positive things about Castle Complements and their crew. The experience from end-to-end was seamless. Excellent communication, on-time crew and they finished our internal painting in no-time." - Jill D., Google Review

Questions to Ask Castle Complements Painting Co., Inc.

Post-project cleanup expectations

One reviewer noted that cleanup after interior work took more effort than expected. While the painting quality was praised, the timing of protective plastic removal during sanding created additional cleanup. Ask them directly: "What's your cleanup process during and after the project, especially for interior work with sanding?"

"Not giving a 5 because the clean up afterwards was pretty intense. I feel they took down plastic too soon, and ended up doing more sanding without the plastic…..it was quite messy and took hours to clean" - Gail H., Google Review (no owner reply)

Why Customers Choose Paint Bros MA

The Reviews Speak for Themselves

Over 140 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating is rare in any industry. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Bros MA earned a Chooz Score of 90.1% - the highest among comparable local painters. This isn't just high volume; it's consistency across platforms:

• 4.67 stars on BBB with over 10 reviews
• 4.5 stars on Yelp with detailed project feedback
• 100% response rate to every Google review with personalized replies from owner Justin

"The best contractor I have dealt with. Fair price, great work and efficient. I barely knew they were there when they were working." - Michael L., Google Review

Pride in the Finished Product

Customers don't just say "good job" - they describe watching meticulous prep work unfold. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong: 85% of reviews mention specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines. Interior, exterior, drywall, deck staining - the quality comments stay consistent:

• Prep work praised repeatedly: "best patchwork I've ever seen" appears in multiple variations
• Crew members Alyssa, Thias, Youseff, and Geovanni called out for careful attention to detail
• Before/after transformations noted, with neighbors thinking entire siding was replaced

"Their prep work was extensive and meticulous, including some of the best patchwork I've ever seen. The final result is flawless - truly perfection." - Jeanne B., Google Review

Responsive from First Call to Final Walkthrough

Owner Justin answers calls and texts personally - nights and weekends included. The Chooz Score's review response quality shows personalized responses to every single review, with specific project details and genuine thank-yous. When issues arise, they get handled fast:

• Project manager Mike praised for coming back multiple times for finishing touches
• One reviewer noted getting an estimate and resolution "as soon as" they posted feedback
• Payment options including credit card and low-interest financing simplify the process

"Whenever I had a question, they were very prompt in answering me via text or phone call. Nights and weekends included!" - Ann R., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Fresh Coat Painters of Andover

Familiar Faces, Consistent Results

Customers consistently mention the same crew names across reviews: Dennis, Victor, Cesar, Joseph, Eder, Harvey, and Ricco. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component shows consistency: the same painters appear across multiple projects, which means you're likely to get experienced professionals who know their craft:

• Multiple reviews praise specific painters by name for their professionalism and skill
• One customer has used Fresh Coat multiple times on their historic home over the past two years, praising the same level of quality each time

"Cesar and his crew are incredible. Cesar is so knowledgeable and patient. He waited patiently until we were able to have him come out again to redo the deck. It's absolutely gorgeous!" - S L., Google Review

Quick Work, Quality Results

Fast turnaround without cutting corners comes up frequently in reviews. Owner Fadi Francis is praised for quick response times and getting projects scheduled promptly:

• One customer contacted them on a Saturday, received an on-site quote on Sunday, and had their entire first floor painted in a single day
• Another customer had their whole house interior quoted by Sunday and completed by the following Saturday

"We contacted them on a Saturday, they came same day to assess. By Sunday, they provided a very detailed quote. By Thursday they started painting and were done by end of day Saturday." - Daniel H., Google Review

Established and Still Going Strong

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Fresh Coat Painters of Andover had over 50 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 90.1%. As part of the Fresh Coat national franchise network with over 15 years of experience, this local operation brings franchise-backed systems to the Andover area:

• MA Home Improvement Contractor License No. 200396 displayed on website
• Serving 26+ cities across Massachusetts and New Hampshire

"I have used Fresh Coat multiple times on my historic home and they are the best. Detailed quote, fast service and the work is top notch." - Ian C., Google Review

Questions to Ask Fresh Coat Painters of Andover

Cabinet painting project details

One detailed Yelp review describes challenges with a cabinet painting project, including issues with door installation, hinge replacement, and handle holes not being drilled as agreed. While most reviews are positive, cabinet refinishing involves many steps and coordination. If you're considering cabinet work, ask directly: "Can you walk me through exactly how the cabinet painting process works, including how doors are handled, what prep is included, and how you ensure quality control before final installation?"

"The doors had no additional holes for handles, although I was charged additionally for extra holes that I requested. So, he had to take them back and drill them." - Pavel S., Yelp Review (no owner reply)