5 Best Painters Near Allendale, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Allendale, NJ have access to several highly rated painting contractors with strong track records across multiple review platforms. These companies have built reputations through consistent quality, responsive communication, and crews that customers trust to work inside their homes.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Spectrum Painting had over 650 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 92.9%. With over 35 years in business since 1989, they maintain an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and reviews spanning multiple platforms including 4.9 stars on Angi with nearly 300 reviews. If you want a company where the same crew leaders show up project after project, Spectrum is a strong choice.

Customers describe a company where relationships span decades. Multiple reviewers mention returning after 10, 15, or even 20 years and finding the same level of care. Crew leaders like Greivin, Marcin, Hector, and Gregor appear throughout reviews, with customers specifically requesting them by name for new projects. The company backs their work with a lifetime warranty on concrete coatings and a three-year warranty on all painting.

• Repeat customers account for a significant portion of reviews, with several mentioning three or more projects completed over the years
• Owner Rich remains involved in follow-up calls and quality checks after project completion
• Services extend beyond painting to include garage floor coatings, deck staining, power washing, and cabinet refinishing

"From day one Brian from Spectrum was on point. The prices were fair, communication was great, questions or concerns were responded to right away and the entire process was almost painless." - D X, Yelp Review

For homeowners looking for a newer company with strong initial reviews, That 1 Painter North Jersey has quickly built a reputation in the Allendale, NJ area. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.1% with over 140 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. This Fair Lawn-based company offers a three-year transferable warranty covering peeling, bubbling, cracking, or splitting, and holds EPA Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes.

Reviews highlight a team structure where George handles estimates and consultations, while Paulo manages on-site project work. Customers frequently mention how the team moved furniture carefully, wore shoe covers without being asked, and left spaces cleaner than they found them. The company handles everything from single-room refreshes to whole-house exteriors.

• Several customers hired them based on social media advertising and describe being pleasantly surprised by the professionalism
• Crew members Todd, Keith, Walter, and Juan Carlos appear across multiple positive reviews
• Multiple reviewers mention hiring them again within weeks of their first project

"I recently contacted That 1 Painter for a small project based on Google reviews. I honestly have to say they greatly exceeded my expectations. Everyone I worked with was friendly and pleasant. Most importantly, the finished paint job was incredible." - Chen H, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Allendale, NJ, Five Star Painting of Bergen County earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 220 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Reviews also show 4.6 stars on Yelp with over 30 reviews. As part of the Neighborly franchise network, they offer a two-year workmanship warranty plus the Neighborly Done Right Promise.

Owner Christian Cruz appears in the majority of reviews, with customers describing him providing estimates, answering questions, and working alongside his crew throughout projects. Response time stands out in the reviews, with multiple customers noting same-day estimates and projects starting within days of initial contact. If you need work done quickly without sacrificing quality, this company moves fast.

• Several reviews mention Christian accommodating urgent timelines and rearranging schedules to fit customer needs
• The team handles cabinet refinishing, deck staining, and aluminum siding painting in addition to standard interior and exterior work
• Cleanup receives consistent praise, with customers noting the crew left spaces spotless

"I reached out to five companies for a quote and got no response. This company reached out within a matter of hours. They had my whole store done in 2 days. I am truly amazed how beautiful the store came out." - Carmen Bucco, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Painting contractors serving Allendale, NJ consistently receive praise for responsive communication and professional conduct. Customers describe crews that arrive on time, explain their process clearly, and keep homeowners informed throughout projects.

Spectrum Painting customers frequently mention Brian, their estimator, for his upfront and honest approach during initial consultations. One reviewer noted that Brian explained costs and expected quality before work began, and the finished product matched exactly what was promised. That 1 Painter North Jersey stands out for detailed proposals and follow-through, with George providing thorough walkthroughs and responding quickly to questions. "Keith was great with communicating the entire way with our project. Any questions I had was answered. The crew was 5 stars!" - Rob De Menna, Google Review. Five Star Painting of Bergen County earns mentions for speed, with Christian responding to estimate requests the same day and starting projects within days of initial contact. "Christian was very professional and communicative throughout the process. He personally manages his team and he works together with his team throughout the project." - Mete G, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Cleanup consistently ranks among the most praised aspects of painting contractors serving Allendale, NJ. Customers describe crews that protect furniture, cover floors, and leave homes cleaner than they found them.

Spectrum Painting crews receive particular recognition for daily cleanup routines. Multiple reviewers mention arriving home to find work areas tidied each evening before crews left. "Excellent work, neat and clean. The crew arrived early and was professional and pleasant." - Daniel Lapin, Google Review. That 1 Painter North Jersey customers describe careful furniture handling and thorough post-project cleanup. One reviewer noted the team wore shoe covers throughout the project without being asked because small children were in the home. "Cleanup was spotless. Results were beyond expectations." - Chris Rahey, Google Review. Five Star Painting of Bergen County earns similar praise, with customers noting Christian and his crew cleaned up every day and addressed areas others might overlook. "They were very detailed oriented and did a fantastic job cleaning up after themselves. The whole project took just a day and a half and the place looks amazing!" - Megan, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality and attention to detail appear as recurring themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Allendale, NJ. Customers describe smooth finishes, clean lines, and results that exceed expectations.

Spectrum Painting customers frequently mention Marcin for interior work that produces what one reviewer called a glass-like finish on doors and trim. Their prep work receives consistent praise, with customers noting thorough sanding, priming, and taping before any paint goes on. "Quality work and professional service from beginning to end. Highly recommend." - Linda Zahn, Google Review. That 1 Painter North Jersey handles both simple refreshes and challenging projects like water-damaged ceilings and popcorn ceiling removal. "Everything came out perfectly! Our ceilings were damaged with several areas of water stains, and we even had zebra stripes on the half bath ceiling. Everything is fully covered and looks brand new!" - Kaitlyn, Google Review. Five Star Painting of Bergen County customers describe careful attention to edges and trim work, with several mentioning how the team went beyond basic painting to polish mailboxes and ensure house numbers popped against fresh paint. "The quality of the paint job is fantastic as everything looks fresh, vibrant, and well done." - Leonardo Flores, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Timeliness and scheduling reliability stand out in reviews for painting contractors serving Allendale, NJ. Customers describe crews that arrive on time, stick to quoted timelines, and often finish ahead of schedule.

Spectrum Painting customers mention projects completed within the estimated timeframe, with one reviewer noting the timeline quoted was about 95% accurate, which they called unheard of for home improvement work. "Second time we used Spectrum, they run a very strong operation, on-time, high quality, clean and competitive." - Dan Andersen, Google Review. That 1 Painter North Jersey receives praise for quick turnarounds, with several customers mentioning entire homes painted in just a few days. "Amazing job! Super clean and on point with timing of completion. Will be using them again!" - Thalia Faiella, Google Review. Five Star Painting of Bergen County stands out for fast response times and rapid project completion. Multiple customers describe receiving quotes on Tuesday and having work completed by Friday. "They started on Thursday and finished the whole house by Friday noon. Christian was very professional and communicative throughout the process." - Mete G, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp