3 Best Painters Near Clayton, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Clayton, NJ and surrounding Gloucester County communities have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors. Reviews consistently highlight responsive communication, thorough preparation, and crews that treat homes with care. Whether you need interior refreshes, exterior work, or specialty services like cabinet refinishing, these contractors have earned strong reputations through years of consistent results.

Original Design Painting leads the area with a Chooz Score of 88.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 320 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook with over 30 recommendations. Owner Recep Ozbas and his son Beytu run a family operation with over 20 skilled painters. Reviewers frequently mention how the team handles color selection with patience, often applying multiple samples until homeowners are satisfied. If you have an older home with challenging surfaces or want extra guidance on color choices, Original Design Painting is a good choice.

With over 22 years in business and recognition as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2023 and 2024, this company has built a loyal following. Repeat customers appear throughout the reviews, returning years later for additional projects.

• Multiple reviewers describe Recep personally visiting job sites to check on progress and ensure satisfaction
• Several customers note getting quotes within 24 hours of their initial request
• Exterior projects on older homes with challenging wood conditions receive particular praise

"Working with Original Design Painting was one of the best contractor experiences ever. They came to look at the scope of the work and got me a quote that evening. The price was fair and the workmanship was excellent." - David Ruesch, Google Review

A second-generation family business with nearly six decades of history, Cherry Hill Painting earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%. They have maintained over 130 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp with over 20 reviews, and 100% recommended on Facebook. Doug Andersen has led the company since 1983, continuing a tradition that started in 1968. For homeowners who value working with an established company that has deep roots in Burlington, Camden, and Gloucester Counties, Cherry Hill Painting offers that stability.

Reviews reveal a distinctive pattern: the same crew members, particularly Mac and Muhammad, appear across dozens of reviews spanning different years. This consistency suggests an in-house team rather than rotating subcontractors, which many customers appreciate for accountability.

• The company handles both residential and commercial projects, including historic buildings like The Haddon Fortnightly in Haddonfield
• With 58 years in business, they hold New Jersey Home Improvement Contractor License No. 13VH02201400
• Dana handles scheduling and billing while crews like Mac and Muhammad execute the work

"Highly recommend Cherry Hill Painting! They came out on schedule and did an amazing job! The crew, Mac, Ogur, Muhammet and Ali, were very professional and friendly. They cleaned up after themselves daily and you couldn't even tell they were here." - S R, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Clayton, NJ, Wallpro Painting earned a Chooz Score of 83.4% with over 120 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Mark Lynch personally handles estimates and oversees projects, and reviewers consistently mention crew members Joe, Kaleb, Joey, and Michael by name. If you need drywall repair, popcorn ceiling removal, or wallpaper removal alongside painting, Wallpro Painting specializes in these combination projects.

What distinguishes Wallpro is their community commitment through the "Painting It Forward" initiative, dedicating 5% from all projects toward free services for community members in need. Customers also note that over 20% of their reviews include before-and-after photos, showing the scope of improvements.

• Several reviewers describe leaving crews alone all day with complete trust
• The team handles challenging surfaces, including damaged walls from prior renovations
• Commercial clients like Little Lamb Preschool praise their work on playgrounds, fences, and buildings

"I was stressed about a large family reunion in a few days. Mark and his crew worked quickly and got the job done in time. It was a relief to hear 'we'll take care of it' rather than excuses you get from other companies." - Nancy Christy, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality and attention to detail are the most frequently mentioned themes in reviews for Clayton, NJ area painting contractors. Customers describe finished work that exceeds expectations, with particular praise for how crews handle preparation before any paint is applied.

Original Design Painting receives consistent praise for their thorough approach to older homes. One reviewer with a 115-year-old Victorian noted how Recep and his crew addressed extremely dry cedar siding with care, resulting in a beautiful finished product. "The team was punctual, respectful, and incredibly detail-oriented, taking great care in their prep work and ensuring a flawless finish." - Ej Connell, Google Review. Cherry Hill Painting customers highlight the work Mac and his crew deliver, with one reviewer noting they "showed up everyday on time" and "didn't cut any corners." - Douglas Coleman, Google Review. Wallpro Painting frequently receives praise for drywall repair work, with customers describing walls that look better than when the house was new. "The finished product was a better finish on the ceiling and walls than when everything was new." - Bill E., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Professionalism and clear communication run through reviews for painting contractors serving Clayton, NJ. Customers appreciate contractors who are responsive from the first estimate through final walkthrough.

Cherry Hill Painting operates with distinct roles that customers find reassuring. Brandon handles estimates, Dana manages scheduling and billing, and crews like Mac execute the work. "Brandon came out for the estimate, Dana handled scheduling and billing, and Mack did the painting quickly and professionally. Great team!" - Andrea Hearing, Google Review. Original Design Painting is noted for quick response times, with multiple reviewers mentioning same-day or next-day estimates. "Recep was super responsive - he came out for an estimate within 24hrs of submitting an online request." - Jen B, Google Review. Wallpro Painting customers describe Mark as highly communicative throughout projects. "Mark gave me a reasonable price, came out when he said he would and got the job done so much faster—and better—than I could have done it myself." - John Worthington, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness emerges as a consistent strength among top-rated painting contractors in the Clayton, NJ area. Reviewers frequently mention crews arriving on time each day and completing projects within promised timeframes.

Original Design Painting helped one customer meet insurance requirements with a quick turnaround exterior job. "Needed quick turnaround for exterior paint job for insurance reasons. Original Designs did a great job, were highly professional, and started and finished well within my timeline." - Michael Davenport, Google Review. Cherry Hill Painting accommodates tight schedules, with one reviewer noting they fit in the project early so everything was done before a move-in date. "They were even able to fit us in early so everything could be done before our move in." - Natalie Parkes, Google Review. Wallpro Painting receives praise for daily punctuality and efficient work. "Workmanship was excellent, kept the work area clean and neat and showed up exactly on time everyday." - Jackie Kelley, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and fair pricing appear frequently in reviews for Clayton, NJ area painting contractors. Customers note competitive estimates combined with quality work that justifies the investment.

Original Design Painting receives multiple mentions for being reasonably priced compared to competitors. "They completed everything in only two days and were very patient with me and all my color changes. They were also by far the most reasonably priced!" - Briana Pachelli, Google Review. Cherry Hill Painting customers describe pricing as fair given the company's experience and quality. "A friendly team, they are skilled, caring, and also surprisingly affordable compared to the competition." - Dan McDevitt, Google Review. Wallpro Painting is praised for transparent estimates that don't change during the project. "They did not go over the estimate that I was given, and if there was something that I didn't like and wanted to change, they changed it without complaining or trying to charge me more money." - Sue L, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google