Best Painters Near Lloyd Harbor, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Finding a reliable painting contractor in Lloyd Harbor, NY means navigating a competitive Long Island market where the best companies stand out through owner accountability, thorough preparation, and crews that treat client homes with care. Across over 200 combined reviews, customers consistently highlight painters who communicate throughout projects and leave homes cleaner than when they arrived.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Based in Massapequa Park with over 12 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County, Teall Painting is a family-owned operation run by owner Charlie Cascio - the name TEALL is an acronym built from his five children's names. Their review record covers an unusually wide range of project types: new homeowners preparing houses before move-in, cedar restoration, mahogany door refinishing, commercial studio renovations, cabinet painting, and carpentry alongside standard interior and exterior work. Charlie checks in daily during active projects and responds quickly by call or text, which reviewers describe as a key differentiator from contractors who go quiet after the deposit. Teall Painting holds Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692 and backs all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. If you're a new homeowner with a tight move-in timeline or a specialty project that has stumped other contractors, Teall Painting is a good choice.

• Crew leaders Thomas, Omar, and Douglas appear by name across multiple unrelated reviews, and some customers have requested specific crew members for follow-on projects - a sign of stable in-house staffing rather than rotating subcontractors.
• Several reviewers describe leaving for errands or going about their day while the crew worked, and returning to find everything finished and spotless without needing to supervise.
• Charlie's estimates are described as detailed and itemized, with no surprises at billing. Multiple reviewers note the final price matched the quoted price even when crews handled extra work during the project.

"The outside of the house needed a lot of TLC. The head painter made multiple trips to Home Depot to fix wood on the exterior as well as railings and the price stayed the same. The quote is the quote. If you need your house painted, seriously this is the company." - Steve G., Google Review

For Long Island homeowners who want a contractor they can call back for multiple projects over time, JRT Pro Painters LLC has built its reputation almost entirely on repeat business and referrals. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.3%. At the time of our analysis, they had over 65 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas has been in business around 4 years and holds Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-66725. A pattern that stands out across the review record: several customers hired JRT Pro Painters LLC after a prior contractor left problems behind, and Brayan's crew went beyond the original scope to correct those issues - identifying nail pops from improper drywall installation, skim coating rough surfaces, and patching ceiling damage until results were completely invisible. Quick quote response is consistently noted, with multiple reviewers mentioning Brayan replied and scheduled within a day of first contact. If you're looking for a growing local company with a loyal client base and an owner who takes problem areas personally, JRT Pro Painters LLC is a strong match.

• Kitchen cabinet painting is a recurring specialty, with reviewers describing results that look comparable to new cabinetry at a fraction of the replacement cost.
• Deck staining alongside interior painting appears across multiple reviews, with the same quality attention paid to outdoor surfaces as indoor ones.
• Brayan's crew removes all job-site debris and garbage when the project is finished - a detail multiple reviewers mention as something they had not expected but deeply appreciated.
• Exterior work including siding and front door painting appears alongside interior projects, giving homeowners a single contractor for inside and outside updates.

"Brayan and his colleague, Antonio, were professional, respectful and kind. They exhibited exceptional discipline and care in their painting. They thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up when they were finished. Their work was excellent. I will be using Brayan for future painting projects." - Janette P., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Lloyd Harbor, NY, CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY brings the deepest bench of experience in this market. They earned a Chooz Score of 83.9%, with over 150 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating - every review in the two-year analysis window was five stars. Owner John Paulik has been building his CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY franchise for over 20 years, and the company is BBB accredited since 2018 and 88% recommended on Facebook. Two patterns emerge from the review record that speak to CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY's positioning in this area: reviewers with historical homes or specialty surfaces specifically credit John with understanding older construction needs and treating delicate materials carefully, and several reviews describe the crew handling structural repairs - rotted cedar boards, exterior carpentry, plaster work - during the paint project without surprise charges. John personally visits job sites during projects and returns after completion, which reviewers credit as the reason they keep coming back. If you have an older home, a waterfront property, or simply want the consistency of a franchise-backed company with two decades of local history, CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY is worth calling first.

• Color consultation is part of the estimate process, including computer-enhanced color previews and physical samples brought to customer homes before any painting starts.
• Repeat customers spanning ten or more years appear across the review record, with some noting they have used CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY for three or four separate projects.
• The company is EPA Lead Certified, which is particularly relevant for homeowners in older Lloyd Harbor, NY properties where lead-based paint may be present.

"Having an historical house with some rather ornate details, I was concerned about the care being taken of the old wooden parts of the house. John explained his team's experience with old houses and was reassuring of my concerns. The work was done carefully and not rushed. The results were great." - Dorothy W., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Across reviews for painters in Lloyd Harbor, NY, workmanship quality consistently shows up in specifics rather than generalities. Customers don't just say the work was good - they describe exactly what impressed them. At Teall Painting, reviewers note that surfaces were thoroughly cleaned and smoothed before any paint went on, with attention to edges, trim, and areas prior contractors had done poorly. Specialty challenges appear frequently in the review record: cathedral ceiling crack repair using specialty products, stucco exteriors, mahogany door refinishing that two previous contractors could not complete successfully, wainscoting installation, and cabinet refinishing to a near-factory finish. At CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY, reviewers describe detailed prep work including scraping, sanding, spackling, filling nail holes, and - in several cases - replacing damaged wood shingles or exterior carpentry, all within the original estimate and without surprise charges.

"The painting and spackle work were excellent. They even managed to match an old paint color perfectly. I could not recommend them more highly." - Michele C., BBB Review

At JRT Pro Painters LLC, the quality emphasis shows up in how the crew handles problem surfaces left by prior work. Multiple reviewers describe Brayan's team identifying and correcting issues beyond the original scope - nail pops from improper drywall installation, water damage ceiling repairs that left no visible trace, and skim coating over rough or uneven walls before paint was applied. One reviewer had their ceiling completely repaired and repainted after a roof leak and noted the result was so seamless no one could locate where the damage had been. Across all three companies serving Lloyd Harbor, NY, a consistent pattern emerges: reviewers describe outcomes that look like a new house, and many specifically note that no touch-up visits were needed after the crew completed the job.

"Bryan and his partner did a wonderful job repairing my ceiling damage from a roof leak. Replaced sheet rock and insulation, spackle, and painted the entire ceiling to perfection. You can't tell at all where the damage was. They were prompt, organized, and extremely neat." - Louise T., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB

Owner accessibility throughout a project is one of the most consistently praised qualities across the top-rated painters in Lloyd Harbor, NY. At Teall Painting, owner Charlie checks in daily during active jobs and remains available by call or text as questions come up. Several reviewers describe situations where concerns arose mid-project - a color adjustment, an unexpected surface issue, a scheduling change - and Charlie addressed each the same day. His estimates are described as thorough and clearly itemized so homeowners know what is covered before any work begins. At JRT Pro Painters LLC, owner Brayan Rivas Ticas is credited with same-day or next-day responses to quote requests and straightforward conversations about pricing and scheduling from the first contact. Multiple reviewers note he accommodated changes to timing or scope without friction, including one customer who experienced a medical delay that Brayan worked around without complaint.

"Charlie also checked in with us on a daily basis to evaluate the progress of the job, make sure there weren't any problems, and see if we had any additional needs. Due to our scheduling limitations, only one painter was available. However, Victor worked late most nights to finish the project as quickly as possible." - Michael D., Google Review

At CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY, John Paulik's communication style is woven throughout the customer relationship from start to finish. Reviewers describe him walking through the complete scope before crews arrive, visiting job sites during multi-day projects, and returning after completion to confirm satisfaction. One customer who added extra rooms during an active project noted that John absorbed the changes and the crew still finished within the original timeline. For homeowners in Lloyd Harbor, NY who have dealt with contractors that become unreachable after the deposit clears, the review record for all three of these companies reflects a different pattern - owners who treat communication as part of the service, not an afterthought.

"They were very easy to work with and kept us informed throughout the process. The end results were beautiful! I would highly recommend them!" - Maureen D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Cleanup and surface protection consistently rank among the most praised qualities for painters in Lloyd Harbor, NY, and all three top-rated companies show the same approach across their reviews. At Teall Painting, customers describe crews covering finished floors with plastic sheeting, builder's paper, and drop cloths before any work begins - a specific detail that comes up in multiple separate reviews from unrelated customers. Several reviewers had just installed new floors and were particularly pleased by how carefully the crew worked around them. The workspace is cleaned at the end of each workday, and the team asks for a walkthrough after completion to address any final touch-up requests before leaving. At CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY, multiple reviewers note that furniture was fully covered and floors protected from the start, with crews working through multi-day projects without leaving any mess overnight. One reviewer who tends toward the detail-oriented end of the spectrum noted that no touch-ups were needed after the crew finished.

"They protected everything from paint spills and left the room spotless. They were on time each day, and were patient with our decisions. I cannot sing their praises enough. I highly recommend Teall Painting." - Cindy R., Google Review

At JRT Pro Painters LLC, the cleanup attention extends to a detail that multiple reviewers specifically call out: Brayan's crew takes all job-site debris and garbage with them when the project finishes, so homeowners have nothing to dispose of afterward. One reviewer mentioned she had not expected that and found it a welcome surprise. Across all three companies, the language reviewers use follows the same pattern - "spotless," "like they were never there," "cleaned up every single day" - suggesting this is a genuine shared standard rather than an occasional exception among the area's top painters. For Lloyd Harbor, NY homeowners who have been left with paint-splattered floors or debris after prior projects, this track record across all three companies is worth noting before you book.

"Arrived exactly on time. Did a great job and not a drop of paint spilled. Highly recommended." - Barbara O., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB

Value comes up across all three top-rated painters in Lloyd Harbor, NY, though customers frame it less as "cheapest option" and more as "fair for what you get." At Teall Painting, several reviewers describe gathering multiple estimates and choosing Teall Painting because their pricing was the most competitive while still delivering strong workmanship. One homeowner preparing a house for sale collected over half a dozen quotes and found Teall Painting offered the best combination of price and quality. Charlie's practice of providing detailed, itemized estimates upfront is mentioned across multiple reviews as something that built confidence before work began - customers knew exactly what they were getting and what it cost before agreeing to anything. At JRT Pro Painters LLC, reviews describe pricing as fair and mid-range among quotes received, with value coming from the prep work quality and the crew's willingness to address issues beyond the original scope without adding charges.

"Everything you want in a contractor: quality, price, efficiency and thoroughness." - Seth L., Google Review

At CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY, some reviewers acknowledge it is not always the lowest number on the page, but consistently describe the results as worth the investment. The company offers a senior citizen discount noted in at least one review, and John works with customers on budgeting during the estimate process. Several customers describe choosing CertaPro Painters of Huntington NY after learning from past experience that the cheapest bid rarely delivers the same quality. For homeowners in Lloyd Harbor, NY who want a strong sense of what they're getting before the job starts - and a crew that doesn't create extra costs through surprises - all three of these contractors have review records that support their value claims.

"The team did a great job and were super fairly priced and flexible. Already reached back out for another project." - Haley A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB