9 Best Painters Near New Hyde Park, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The painting contractors serving New Hyde Park, NY cover a wide range of project types - from full exterior repaints to specialty decorative finishes - and their collective review record across Google, Yelp, Angi, and Facebook is one of the strongest we have seen in Nassau County. The top-rated companies in this area combine for hundreds of five-star reviews across multiple platforms, with consistent customer retention signals and strong owner engagement throughout.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, NYCA Contractors, LLC had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews and 100% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.9%, the highest in the New Hyde Park, NY area on Chooz Painters. What sets NYCA apart is their off-site cabinet refinishing process: doors and drawer fronts are removed, transported to their shop for professional spray application using Italian-brand paints, and returned fully installed - producing results that repeatedly prompt guests to ask if the cabinets were replaced entirely. Owner Al (Albano) handles every quote personally, responds same-day to requests, and coordinates directly with building management for NYC co-op and condo customers.

Several reviewers describe calling NYCA back for a second project after seeing how their cabinet refinishing held up over the years. Color matching from a single paint chip is documented across reviews, even on veneer and lacquered surfaces. If you want to update your kitchen cabinets without the cost of full replacement, NYCA Contractors, LLC is a strong choice.

• Cabinet doors are taken off-site for spraying, keeping kitchens fully functional throughout the process
• Al works weekends and coordinates directly with building management for co-op and condo buildings
• Color matching from a single paint sample is documented in reviews, including on difficult veneer and lacquered cabinet surfaces
• Multiple customers describe returning for additional projects after seeing how results held up over several years

For homeowners looking for a full-service contractor who handles large projects with a structured, owner-led approach, Teall Painting has built a strong reputation across Long Island with a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and matching marks on Yelp confirm the consistency. Owner Charlie Cascio backs all work with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and holds a Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License (No. 204692), with over 12 years in business serving Nassau and Suffolk County homeowners.

Charlie personally checks in with customers daily during active projects - a detail that comes up consistently in reviews from unrelated customers on different jobs. The range of work on record goes well beyond interior walls: Teall has refinished mahogany front doors that prior contractors couldn't get right, restored western red cedar siding and decks, completed commercial renovations for fitness studios, and installed wainscoting alongside full house repaints. All painters carry 5+ years of professional experience and pass background checks before joining the team. Teall Painting is a good choice if you have a large or multi-phase project and want a responsive owner closely involved throughout.

• Owner Charlie checks in daily during active projects and is praised for communication from the initial estimate through final walkthrough
• Crew members like Victor, Rene, and Oscar are requested by name for return projects by customers who have worked with them previously
• Specialty capabilities include mahogany door refinishing, cedar restoration, exterior stucco, deck staining, and wainscoting installation

While most painters focus on standard interior and exterior work, Interior Finishing NYC handles the projects others won't take on. Owner Dorian Golemi, who studied at the University of Fine Arts in Tirana, Albania, specializes in limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, metallic applications, and ceiling gilding. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 120 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, and have been in business for over 22 years since 2003, with a 3-year workmanship warranty on all projects.

Dorian physically works on-site alongside his crew rather than managing from a distance, and multiple reviewers describe hiring him for one room, seeing the results, and immediately expanding the scope. Frishta Yaqubie originally hired the company for her nursery; after seeing the limewash results, she had them return for the powder room and then the office as well. The company also handles commercial projects in Manhattan, ceiling gilding, and pre-war woodwork restoration in NYC co-ops - taking on jobs that other contractors have declined. If you're looking for decorative finishes or specialty work that standard painters can't do, Interior Finishing NYC is a strong option.

• Dorian physically works on-site for most projects, personally applying finishes alongside his crew
• Multiple clients expand the scope of their project after seeing results from the first room
• The company takes on projects other contractors decline - matching damaged decorative finishes, gilding ceilings, and restoring original pre-war woodwork

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for CRD Painting Inc. Owner Camilo has earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 90 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating and matching marks on Yelp, with over 8 years serving Long Island homeowners. Multiple reviewers document relationships spanning 10 to 15 years - calling Camilo back for interior repaints, exterior work, deck staining, and small touch-up jobs alike. A Long Island drywall business with 60 years in the trade refers CRD Painting to their builders and contractors as the go-to painting recommendation.

The scope of work in the reviews ranges from single-room spackle repairs to full multi-day exterior and interior repaints of large homes. Camilo accommodates small jobs as readily as large ones, and when a color doesn't look right after painting, several reviewers describe him returning the next day to repaint without pushback. He also uses a specialty multi-coat process for bathroom ceilings designed to prevent sweating in high-humidity environments. CRD Painting Inc is a strong choice for Long Island homeowners who want a reliable contractor they can keep calling back year after year.

• Customers describe calling Camilo for small spackle repairs and single-room touch-ups as readily as full-house projects
• A specialty multi-coat ceiling process is documented in reviews for preventing moisture buildup in bathrooms during hot showers
• Multiple reviewers describe Camilo returning the next day when a color choice didn't work out - no pushback or added charge
• A Long Island drywall contractor with 60 years in business refers CRD Painting to their own clients as their go-to recommendation

Owner Denis Erazo of Big Expert Painting LLC stays personally involved from the first phone call through job completion - a detail that appears in review after review from different customers on different projects. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% with over 130 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating and matching marks on Yelp. Denis holds an EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes - relevant for older Nassau and Suffolk County housing - and a Suffolk County Home Improvement License (No. HI-68388, active through 2027).

The project range in the reviews goes well beyond standard painting: pool bottom painting, crown molding installation, sheetrock repair, marble flooring, gym floor installation, and cabinet resurfacing all appear alongside full interior and exterior repaints. Several reviewers describe starting with a smaller job and immediately booking Denis for additional work after seeing the quality. If you're looking for an owner who stays personally involved from estimate through completion, Big Expert Painting LLC is a good choice.

• Denis holds an EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes, relevant for older Nassau County housing stock
• Project range includes pool bottom painting, crown molding installation, marble flooring, and gym flooring alongside standard painting
• Multiple reviewers describe Denis following up by phone weeks after a job wrapped to confirm everything still looked right

Rounding out the top contractors serving New Hyde Park, NY, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings over 18 years of experience to interior and exterior projects across Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% with over 75 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, BBB accreditation since 2015, and 100% recommended on Facebook, with a Suffolk County Home Improvement License (No. HI-73176, active through January 2028).

Territory manager David Maloney personally walks every job, producing itemized written estimates that detail each aspect of the scope before any work begins. Jeffrey Negrin, who had his entire 2,300-square-foot home repainted across a multi-day project, describes liking the crew so much that he handed them a house key and trusted them to work unsupervised. The company's structured approach - with crews led by project supervisors Jason Eng and Brendan, supported by office manager Trish Gates - suits homeowners who want clear accountability on larger or longer projects. If you have a large or complex project and want a team-based contractor with formal management in place, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is a strong choice.

• David Maloney provides written itemized estimates, walks every job site in person, and checks in throughout the project
• Multiple reviewers describe handing over house keys for multi-day projects, reflecting strong trust in the crew
• Crews clean up thoroughly at the end of each work day, leaving homes usable during even six-day whole-home projects

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

The review record for painters serving New Hyde Park, NY is remarkably consistent when it comes to finished quality. Customers across companies repeatedly describe results that exceed expectations - finishes described as looking new or better than the original, even on surfaces with years of wear. NYCA Contractors, LLC uses an off-site spray process that produces factory-level cabinet finishes, with many customers noting that guests assume the cabinets were replaced rather than refinished. Interior Finishing NYC takes a different approach with decorative specialty finishes - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, and ceiling gilding - with owner Dorian Golemi applying fine arts training to every project. Meanwhile, CRD Painting Inc and Teall Painting draw consistent praise for precision on walls, trim, and moldings, with customers noting crisp lines and even coverage that hold up well over time.

The quality observations in these reviews go well beyond generic praise. Reviewers for Big Expert Painting LLC describe ceiling sheetrock repairs and water damage remediation that blended seamlessly into surrounding surfaces. Customers of Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge note crews who sand, skim-coat, and caulk before any paint goes on, addressing imperfections that most painters would skip over. At JRT Pro Painters LLC, reviewers point to careful prep - hole filling, sanding, priming, and skim coating - as the reason results hold up as well as they do. "Brayan and his co-worker are extremely punctual, precise and perfectionist at what they work on. Everyday they clean up the work space to start fresh and new the next day." - Christina S., Google Review. "The guys at Teall got the door sanded and refinished in a day and it looks like it is brand new! I have tried to have it refinished in the past and it did not come out good." - Steve M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Communication is one of the most frequently cited strengths across painters serving New Hyde Park, NY. Multiple companies earn specific praise not just for doing good work, but for keeping customers informed at every stage - from the initial estimate through daily check-ins to post-job follow-up. Teall Painting owner Charlie Cascio is cited across dozens of reviews for checking in every day during active projects and responding quickly to calls and texts. CRD Painting Inc's owner Camilo is praised for being easy to reach by phone or text and for addressing requests without delay - including returning the next day to repaint when a color choice didn't work. NYCA Contractors, LLC's owner Al (Albano) responds same-day to quote requests and keeps customers updated throughout the off-site spraying process with clear timelines and transparent explanations of each step.

Larger companies in the area have built formal communication systems around their team-based approach. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge assigns a territory manager - typically David Maloney, Jason Eng, or Brendan - to each project, with the manager walking the job, producing a detailed written estimate, checking in throughout, and remaining available by call or text throughout the work. Office manager Trish Gates handles scheduling, and reviewers consistently mention the reliability of that back-office communication. Interior Finishing NYC's owner Dorian Golemi responds to nearly every Google review personally and is described by multiple clients as easy to reach even for remote project management while they were out of town. "From day 1 we were in constant communication with Charlie about what projects were being worked on and what to expect that day. We are beyond thrilled with the finished result." - John C., Google Review. "David told me in the beginning the job should take 4 to 5 days, and sure enough his crew was done on time." - Jean A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Protecting the home and maintaining clean work areas are recurring themes in reviews for painters serving New Hyde Park, NY. Customers consistently cite the standard of care for their belongings as one of the things that sets top contractors apart. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge receives repeated praise for moving furniture, covering floors, and cleaning up at the end of every work day throughout multi-day projects, leaving homes usable each evening. CRD Painting Inc's owner Camilo is described across reviews for covering all furniture and flooring before any paint is opened, with daily cleanup that customers say made their spaces look untouched by the end of each day. Big Expert Painting LLC receives similar comments, with reviewers noting the crew covered everything and cleaned service areas thoroughly on completion.

Prep work before painting is an equally strong theme. Teall Painting is praised for covering floors with plastic sheathing, builder's paper, and drop cloths before any brushes touch the walls. JRT Pro Painters LLC reviewers consistently mention hole filling, sanding, priming, and skim coating as steps the crew takes before color goes on - including identifying and fixing improper drywall installation from a prior contractor that wasn't in the original scope. NYCA Contractors, LLC takes a different approach by removing cabinet doors entirely and transporting them off-site for spraying, so there is no dust or overspray in the kitchen during the process. "Covered everything and took great care to keep dust and overspray down. I can't believe how much we like the look of our new cabinets." - Michael S., Google Review. "They covered all my flooring and furniture and worked through the job." - Anthony L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing and value come up frequently in reviews for painters serving New Hyde Park, NY, and the feedback is generally positive across the board. Most customers describe receiving quotes that were competitive or better than other estimates they had gathered, and many specifically note that the final price matched the original quote without added charges. Teall Painting owner Charlie Cascio is praised for holding to his quoted price even when the scope expanded during a project - several reviewers describe this as a notable departure from typical contractor behavior. CRD Painting Inc's owner Camilo is described as "fair" and "reasonable" in pricing across reviews spanning 10+ years of customer relationships. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis earns similar comments, with multiple long-term customers describing his pricing as the reason they keep calling back.

For specialty work, pricing still compared favorably in the reviews. NYCA Contractors, LLC's cabinet refinishing is described as a dramatically less expensive option than full replacement, with several customers noting they had been putting off the project for years because they assumed it would cost more than it did. Interior Finishing NYC's decorative finish work - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster - is described by reviewers as "reasonably priced" compared to other specialty contractors they consulted. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge wins consistent praise for transparent itemized estimates that help customers understand exactly what they are paying for before the job starts. "Of all the price quotes we received, theirs was right in the middle. We definitely got high value for the price we paid." - Kent C., Google Review. "The price was the most competitive - I got 4 estimates, all with great Google reviews." - Susan M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Reliability with scheduling and on-time arrival is a strong consistent theme across painters serving New Hyde Park, NY. The most frequent observations aren't just about showing up on time for day one - customers regularly mention that crews arrived on schedule every day of multi-day projects. CRD Painting Inc's owner Camilo is described across reviews as consistently punctual, with a recent review specifically noting a job that started on January 5th and was completed by January 8th, exactly as promised. JRT Pro Painters LLC's owner Brayan is praised for working full 8-9 hour days throughout projects and cleaning up each evening before returning the next morning. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge has a formal scheduling process managed by office staff, with project managers setting clear timelines and consistently meeting them.

Several reviewers across these companies note that their painters finished ahead of schedule. Teall Painting customer Greg Schaeffer describes a full interior and exterior job where the crew finished before the estimated completion date. NYCA Contractors, LLC reviewers regularly describe the entire cabinet refinishing process - from quote to completion - wrapped up in under two weeks. Big Expert Painting LLC's Denis has been noted for checking the weather forecast before exterior jobs and showing up days early to get ahead of rain. Interior Finishing NYC's owner Dorian is consistently described as arriving on time every day and completing projects on the schedule communicated at the start. "They arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review. "The whole process from quote to complete in 1.5 weeks!" - A Google User, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Several painters serving New Hyde Park, NY go well beyond standard brush-and-roll interior painting to offer specialized services. NYCA Contractors, LLC focuses specifically on kitchen cabinet refinishing, using an off-site spray process with professional-grade equipment that produces finishes most on-site painters cannot match. Their work spans wood, veneer, and lacquered cabinet surfaces, with customers documenting results on cabinets 20 to 30 years old that now look factory-fresh. Interior Finishing NYC specializes in decorative finishes - limewash, Roman clay, Venetian plaster, marmorino, and ceiling gilding - with owner Dorian Golemi bringing formal fine arts training to projects in residential apartments, commercial spaces, and historic buildings with pre-war woodwork. These are techniques most general painters don't offer at all, and multiple reviewers describe contacting Dorian specifically because other contractors turned the work down.

Beyond those two specialty-focused companies, others in the area handle specialty work as part of a broader service range. Teall Painting has refinished mahogany doors that prior contractors couldn't complete correctly and restored western red cedar siding and decks. Big Expert Painting LLC handles crown molding installation, pool bottom painting, marble flooring, and gym floor installation alongside standard painting. JRT Pro Painters LLC has documented experience with kitchen cabinet painting, deck staining, and drywall repair including skim coating. CRD Painting Inc uses a specialty multi-coat process for bathroom ceilings to prevent moisture buildup and has completed projects on homes with complex architectural detail work. If you have a project that goes beyond standard walls and ceilings, several contractors in this area are equipped to handle it. "I needed someone to do wallpaper hanging, some drywall repair and gilding in my home. It was hard to find a contractor that does all of the services we needed." - Kha A., Google Review. "My kitchen cabinets painted and they came out absolutely beautiful. The whole process from start to finish was less than two weeks." - Deb M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp