Best Painters Near Williston Park, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Williston Park, NY have built strong reputations across Nassau County for quality workmanship, reliable communication, and thorough prep work. The top-rated companies in the area hold consistently high marks across multiple review platforms, with patterns in customer feedback pointing to shared strengths: owners who stay personally involved, crews that treat homes with care, and results that hold up over time. Here are the top-ranked painters in and around Williston Park, NY based on the Chooz Score.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Elite Painting Services Plus had over 90 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.3% - the highest among contractors we analyzed serving the Williston Park, NY area. Based in Malverne, the company has been serving Nassau County for over 14 years, with owner Benny leading the field while Kelly handles office operations, color consultations, and scheduling. Reviews describe a well-coordinated process from first contact through final walkthrough. If you want a team that handles the full process - estimate, color selection, crew scheduling, and careful follow-through - Elite Painting Services Plus is a strong fit for Nassau County homeowners.

One of the more distinctive patterns in Elite's reviews is how often customers mention turning to them for projects that go beyond standard room painting. The company has painted commercial spaces like churches and libraries, handled smoke-damaged condos being prepped for sale, and taken on complex ceiling and water-damage restoration alongside typical interior and exterior work. First-time customers describe feeling comfortable because Benny and Kelly explain the process in advance, from crew assignments to color choices.

• EPA RRP lead-safe certified and PDCA member, with a Nassau County Home Improvement License verified active through the county's Department of Consumer Affairs, with zero complaints or violations on file
• A two-time 'Best of Long Island' winner (2015, 2016), confirming their regional standing beyond online reviews
• Color consultation with Kelly is built into the standard process - customers arrive prepared on day one with selections already made
• Repeat customers across multiple projects are the norm; several reviewers describe calling Elite for their third or fourth project

"Highly recommend for anybody looking for high quality and professional painters. The team that worked in my home was punctual and took great care in their work. Great communication throughout." - Bryan McComb, Google Review

While Elite Painting Services Plus leads on Chooz Score by a narrow margin, JAT PAINTERS INC has built an extraordinary review volume that reflects how actively they're working right now. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.2% and, at the time of our analysis, had over 400 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - one of the highest review volumes among Long Island contractors at that level of consistency. They're also 100% recommended on Facebook and hold 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Juan brings over 20 years of experience to every project, handling estimates personally and working alongside his crew on-site. His wife Tanya manages scheduling and client communication, and customers frequently name her for her organization and responsiveness. If you want an owner who is actively on the job and a team where communication is a clear priority, JAT PAINTERS INC is a good fit.

The range of services JAT handles extends well beyond standard painting. Commercial accounts - including a Nassau County restaurant painted while customers were still coming and going - appear alongside residential interiors and exteriors in their reviews. The company also takes on epoxy floor coatings, hardwood floor refinishing, laminate installation, skim coating, and drywall replacement, making them a single point of contact for homeowners with multiple project types. Reviewers consistently note that Juan's quotes are detailed and accurate, with final invoices matching what was discussed upfront and no surprises at the end.

• Zero negative reviews across all platforms at the time of analysis - a rare distinction at over 400 Google reviews
• Project scope extends beyond painting: flooring, epoxy coatings, skim coating, drywall replacement, and wood staining are all in their service range
• Juan walks customers through every step before work begins, setting clear expectations upfront so both sides know exactly what to expect
• Commercial and event-driven projects are handled alongside residential work - from restaurant interiors to party-prep jobs with tight deadlines

"Juan is a great communicator. We discussed every detail of the job before we agreed on a price, so no surprises for either of us. His crew is fast, friendly and efficient. We have already planned our next project with them." - Rudolph Vilardi, Google Review

With over 25 years serving Long Island homeowners, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has built a level of customer loyalty that runs deep and shows up clearly in their reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.7% and, at the time of our analysis, had over 245 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, 4.8 stars on Yelp with over 25 Yelp reviews, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 80 Angi reviews, and 16 Faves on Nextdoor. Co-owner Sal Sciame is described across dozens of reviews as personally present at estimates and returning to the job site each morning during active projects - something multiple reviewers specifically call out as unusual for any contractor. Walker also holds both a Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License and a NYC DCWP license. For homeowners looking for a company with a long track record and a co-owner who personally oversees each project, Walker Painting is a reliable choice.

Walker's service range goes beyond standard paint work. Crown molding installation, base molding, deck staining, floor painting, and shutter replacement all appear in their reviews. The extended family referral chain in their reviews is also notable - customers frequently describe their siblings, children, in-laws, and neighbors all becoming Walker clients after hearing about their experience.

• Walker employs its own full-time painters rather than rotating subcontractors; reviewers note the company runs multiple trucks and crews, all staffed by trained professionals
• Sal is present at estimates and visits the job site each morning - a practice multiple reviewers specifically call out as something they have never experienced with other contractors
• Services include carpentry, crown molding installation, deck staining, shutter replacement, and floor painting alongside standard interior and exterior work
• Multi-generational family loyalty is common; several reviewers describe extended family members all turning to Walker after being referred by a relative

"I have been using Walker Painting for the last 20 years. Sal always gives me an honest opinion on what the work will cost and explains everything that has to be done and the work required." - Linda Dougherty, Google Review

For homeowners who want a highly organized process backed by clear project management, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge brings a structured approach that stands out in the reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.8% and had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating at the time of our analysis. The company is 100% recommended on Facebook, holds a Better Business Bureau accreditation since 2015, and carries a Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License verified active through January 2028. With over 18 years in business, the company runs a multi-project-manager structure - David Maloney, Brendan, and Jason Eng each lead dedicated field crews - giving customers a consistent primary contact from estimate through final walkthrough. For larger or more complex projects where clear communication and defined roles matter, Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge is worth considering.

The project types this crew takes on include some that other painters pass on. Garage floor epoxy coatings, kitchen cabinet repainting, vaulted stairwells, and whole-home renovations spread across multiple days all appear regularly in their reviews. At least one customer coordinated an entire multi-room project from out of state and described the process as straightforward. The crew also adapts to homeowners' schedules, and each workday wraps with full cleanup before the crew leaves.

• BBB accredited since 2015, with a Suffolk County HIC License verified active through January 2028
• Multiple dedicated project managers - David, Brendan, and Jason - give customers a named, consistent point of contact throughout the project
• Specialty work includes garage floor coatings, vaulted stairwell painting, kitchen cabinet finishing, and deck staining
• Remote project coordination is possible; out-of-state homeowners can manage projects without being on-site

"I live out of state and working with PPP was simple. They did a fantastic job and I highly recommend their services." - Jim Patti, Google Review

Rounding out the top-ranked contractors in Williston Park, NY, Long Island Painting and Restoration is an owner-operated company with a perfect ratings record and a hands-on approach that shows in every review. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.2% and had over 55 Google reviews at the time of our analysis - every single one a five-star rating. Owner Andres Gallego personally handles each estimate, spending significant time walking through properties and offering color recommendations before any crew arrives. With over 6 years serving Nassau and Suffolk counties, the company has built its reputation almost entirely through word-of-mouth referrals. If you want a highly responsive owner-operated company with competitive pricing and fast turnaround times, Long Island Painting and Restoration is a good option.

Historic and older homes are not a barrier for this crew. One reviewer had a nearly 100-year-old house and detached garage restored and painted, requiring wood rot repair and multi-layer exterior prep - work many newer companies decline. Andres also handles commercial spaces alongside residential projects, and for large jobs the company scales crew sizes up to six painters to complete whole-house projects in a single day.

• A perfect five-star average across all Google reviews - every rating in their history is five stars
• Historic home restoration, including wood rot repair and multi-layer paint stripping on older exterior surfaces, is part of their service range
• Color consultation is built into Andres's estimate process, not an add-on charge
• For tight timelines, the company can send crews of up to six painters to complete whole-house projects within a single day

"From initial consultation to the final product, we had a 10/10 experience with Andres and his team. Pricing was fair and competitive. His team did an efficient, professional, clean job and even got the work done ahead of schedule." - Patrick Healy, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, Angi

Quality of workmanship is the most consistently praised element across reviews for painting contractors serving Williston Park, NY. What stands out is how often customers go beyond general praise to describe specific details that impressed them: clean lines along trim, smooth finishes after skim coating, careful surface prep on challenging walls, and results that hold up long after the crew leaves.

At Elite Painting Services Plus, reviewers describe crews that attend to the kind of details that distinguish professional work from an average job - patching drywall damage left by other tradespeople, priming challenging surfaces correctly, and delivering clean results on ceiling work and water-damage repairs. At JAT PAINTERS INC, Juan's crew regularly goes beyond the original scope without additional charges; one customer noted the team fixed far more spots than initially identified because they noticed them during the job. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting customers specifically call out prep work as the foundation of results - sanding, spackling, and surface preparation done thoroughly before any brush touches the wall. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, specialty projects like kitchen cabinet repainting and garage floor epoxy show up in reviews alongside standard rooms, with customers consistently impressed at how precisely the work was executed on challenging surfaces. For Long Island Painting and Restoration, reviewers note that speed never comes at the expense of quality - projects frequently finish ahead of schedule while still delivering results customers describe as flawless.

"Not a spec of dust or paint left behind. I highly recommend Elite Painting Services Plus." - Sharon Sheby, Google Review"The work done by Amilcar and his crew was amazing. They were clean, neat, quiet, and really did such a great job. My project manager Dave was excellent and addressed every issue." - Brett Huzar, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication and responsiveness come up so frequently in reviews for painting contractors across the Williston Park, NY area that they are clearly a point of differentiation customers pay attention to. Whether it is a quick estimate turnaround, same-day callbacks, or regular status updates during active projects, the top-rated companies have made reliable communication part of how they operate - not an afterthought.

JAT PAINTERS INC's owner Juan is described by multiple reviewers as someone who walks through every detail before work begins, sets clear expectations upfront, and follows up after completion. His wife Tanya manages scheduling and logistics, and customers regularly name her separately for her organization and responsiveness. At Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting, Sal Sciame comes to the job site every morning during active projects - a practice multiple reviewers specifically call out as something they have never seen from other contractors. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge has dedicated project managers whose job is to serve as a consistent point of contact; customers describe always knowing exactly where their project stood on any given day. Elite Painting Services Plus uses an office team led by Kelly to handle scheduling, color consultations, and logistics, giving customers a reliable contact who isn't part of the field crew. For Long Island Painting and Restoration, owner Andres is described as quickly responsive by phone and in person, with multiple reviewers noting same-day or next-day responses for both estimates and mid-project questions.

"Sal came to the house for an estimate the next day. Price quote was sent within 2 hours. Job was started in 2 weeks. Sal came every day to check on how things were going." - Geraldine Moore, Google Review"Benny was very easy to work with. He answered all of my questions and was always quick to respond. Tony and his crew were amazing. They were clean, precise and efficient." - Julie Levin, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Cleanup and home protection during the job is one of the most commonly praised elements across reviews for painting contractors in the Williston Park, NY area. Customers consistently describe arriving home to find their house in better condition than expected, or noting that rooms remained livable throughout multi-day projects without any accumulation of dust or mess.

At Elite Painting Services Plus, reviewers describe crews covering furniture with plastic sheeting, papering floors, and vacuuming before leaving each evening - even on complex projects involving skim coating, ceiling replacement, and water damage repair. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting customers highlight prep work as a key reason their results look so good: sanding, spackling, and careful surface preparation before any paint is applied. At Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp, the crew's consistent routine of photographing items before moving them, removing wall decor, laying protective paper, and covering belongings with plastic before starting is mentioned across multiple reviews. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers note that even on projects lasting several days, rooms were left in usable condition at the end of each workday. At JAT PAINTERS INC, reviewers describe crews that went as far as mopping floors after completing the job - going beyond standard cleanup expectations.

"They come in, take pictures, then take all decorations and pictures down before they start, and replace them all when they're done. Not a single hole or scuff is left behind." - Tom Wedell, Google Review"JAT does meticulous paint work and clean up. They pretty much mopped my floors from where they had put their footsteps." - Lisa Lombardi, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality and keeping to the agreed timeline are themes that appear consistently across reviews for painting contractors in the Williston Park, NY area. Customers describe crews showing up on time from day one, projects finishing within the estimated timeframe, and - in many cases - work wrapping up ahead of schedule without any cuts to quality.

Long Island Painting and Restoration earns specific praise for quick turnarounds. Multiple reviewers note that large projects were completed significantly faster than expected, with one reviewer describing their whole-house project finished days ahead of what was quoted, and another noting a large crew completed an extensive job in a single day. JAT PAINTERS INC reviewers describe the team arriving early in the morning, working through long days, and completing jobs ahead of the original estimate. At Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting, Sal is praised for setting realistic timelines at the estimate stage and consistently meeting them, even on large multi-room projects. Elite Painting Services Plus customers note the team arrives on time each morning and completes projects within the quoted timeframe, with at least one reviewer describing their job finished ahead of schedule. At Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge, the project manager structure means timelines are tracked and customers are kept informed throughout each stage of the work.

"I told them I needed it done within the next few days, ahead of a planned outdoor party we were hosting. They squeezed us in and the result was perfect." - Elaine Leung, Google Review"Juan and his team completed our indoor makeover project earlier than originally scheduled. Everyone was so neat and friendly! A real nice experience and everything looks amazing!" - John T., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Pricing and value are recurring topics across reviews for painting contractors serving the Williston Park, NY area. The consistent pattern is that customers who do comparison shopping frequently find the highest-rated companies are competitive in price while delivering noticeably better results than lower-cost alternatives they considered. Several reviewers describe returning for repeat projects without getting competing estimates, because the first experience proved the pricing and quality were consistently fair.

Anthony's Painting And Decorating, Corp earns specific praise for transparent pricing across both residential and exterior projects, with multiple reviewers describing repeat jobs booked without shopping around. At Elite Painting Services Plus, reviewers describe overall value as strong - competitive pricing paired with quality that exceeded what other companies offered at similar or higher price points. JAT PAINTERS INC customers describe Juan's estimates as honest and detailed, with final invoices matching what was quoted and no surprises at billing time. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting is described by multiple reviewers as reasonably priced given the quality of the results, with Sal praised for giving straight, honest assessments of scope and cost at the estimate stage. Precision Painting Plus of Hauppauge customers note that despite receiving multiple competing estimates, Precision came in competitively priced while offering the strongest communication and project management structure of the options they considered.

"Highly recommend Precision Painting! David and crew did an excellent job painting the exterior of my home. Very reasonable estimate! David is prompt and professional." - Mary, Google Review"Manny and his crew were professionals. They painted the exterior of our home quickly and with attention to detail for an affordable price. We were extremely happy with the work." - Stephanie Windler, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook