4 Best Painters Near Pine Island, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The painting contractors serving Pine Island, NY have built strong track records across hundreds of verified reviews. Here is how the top-ranked companies on Chooz Painters compare, ordered by Chooz Score.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Willow Tree Painting & Home Improvement LLC had nearly 100 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp, earning the top Chooz Score of 90.8% in the area. Based in Warwick and in business for 6 years, the team holds Google Guaranteed status. Owner James Obrotka leads estimates personally, project manager Peter coordinates daily communication, and admin Kelley in the office earns regular praise for fast, clear responses. One pattern that shows up repeatedly in the reviews: homeowners who left for the day - or managed the project from out of state - came home to spotless, completed work. Cabinet specialist Ron gets called out separately for finish-level detail on refinishing projects. If you have an older property or an unusual project, Willow Tree is worth the call - they regularly take on work other contractors pass on.

• Crew completed side repairs during jobs including shingle replacement and sheetrock patching - at no added hassle to the homeowner.
• Several homeowners describe returning home to find the space cleaner than when they left.

For those who want a painter who gets into the details - color mixing, proactive finishing touches, and corrections if something is not right - Ryan's Painting has earned a strong following. They hold a Chooz Score of 88.6% with over 110 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 30 reviews, 100% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. In business for 5 years and BBB accredited since 2025, Ryan Clarkin has completed everything from an 1869 historic exterior restoration to full church sanctuary work. One customer hired the team specifically to correct a previous painter's work - and the crew handled it efficiently. Ryan's Painting is a strong fit for detail-heavy or color-sensitive projects.

• Ryan proactively suggests small finishing details customers hadn't considered, such as painting vanity mirrors to match trim or touching up cabinet hinges.
• Foreman Dave is mentioned across multiple reviews as a consistent on-site presence from start to finish on larger projects.

With over 12 years in business, CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY has earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% and one of the most established reputations in Orange County. Their profile includes over 175 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, 4.9 stars on Angi across more than 20 reviews, and Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition in both 2022 and 2023. Owner Brendan McManus handles estimates across a wide range of project types, and office coordinator Joanne Stefanacci is praised for calling back within minutes. Multiple reviews note jobs finished ahead of schedule. CertaPro is a strong fit for homeowners who want a company with deep local history and a responsive office team.

• The team has painted log cabins, 1800s church buildings, and commercial properties, showing strong range beyond standard residential work.
• Multiple longtime customers return for exterior staining, deck work, power washing, and interior repaints across different seasons.

When it comes to specialty surfaces and hard-to-match materials, Pro Painting Plus out of Monroe stands out. They hold a Chooz Score of 87.6% with all 5-star Google reviews. Owner Rob McRae personally inspects work throughout each project and reviewers mention him stopping by daily to confirm the customer is satisfied. The crew has tackled a 52-year-old lakeside dock, a historic 1865 tin roof, and cedar and teak siding - and has been called in to correct a botched job from a previous contractor. Pro Painting Plus is a good option for older homes with unusual materials or specialty outdoor projects.

• The crew identifies prep and repair issues during the initial walkthrough - and addresses them before paint goes on.

Rounding out the top contractors serving Pine Island, NY, KB Quality Painting out of Highland Mills has earned a Chooz Score of 83.2% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Kevin handles estimates personally, helps with color selection, uses Benjamin Moore products exclusively, and works alongside his crew on site. One deck staining job was wrapped in half the expected time, and multiple repeat customers describe using Kevin for ongoing work across their properties. KB Quality Painting is ideal for homeowners who want an owner-led crew where the person giving the estimate stays involved through completion.

• Kevin replies to texts and calls faster than any contractor multiple customers say they have worked with.
• Crew member Caesar is praised for clean lines and careful trim work on interior projects.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities across painters serving Pine Island, NY. Customers return to the same themes: contractors who respond quickly, explain the process clearly, and keep homeowners updated without needing to be chased. Ryan's Painting draws particular attention here - reviewer after reviewer mentions Ryan Clarkin answering questions quickly and laying out the plan before work begins. At CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY, office coordinator Joanne Stefanacci is praised as a separate contact who calls back within minutes, so customers are never left waiting. "They were super responsive to any and all questions I had. The office manager Joanne called me back within minutes even if she wasn't in the office. Communication is everything to me." - Linda Fisher, Google Review

Willow Tree Painting & Home Improvement LLC coordinates communication through both project manager Peter in the field and admin Kelley in the office, so homeowners always know who to contact. Reviewer Danielle Trep managed the entire project from California while closing escrow on her new New York home - only possible because communication was seamless from the first call through completion. Certified Painting LLC's Brian Shannon earns similar praise for sending out-of-state clients periodic progress photos throughout the work. Pro Painting Plus's Rob McRae is noted for checking in daily to confirm the homeowner is satisfied with the direction of the work. "We live out of state and Brian sent photos periodically to keep us updated on the project. Who does that? Brian does. We highly recommend Certified Painting." - Terry Wolfson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanup are where a paint job either holds up or starts failing, and the contractors serving Pine Island, NY take both seriously. Across the review record, customers describe spackling, sanding, caulking, priming, and sheetrock patching as steps that happened consistently before any paint went on. Willow Tree Painting & Home Improvement LLC is praised for arriving with tarps, covering furniture and landscaping, and leaving job sites cleaner than they found them. On one exterior job involving aging wood shingles, the crew replaced missing shingles and removed old wiring before prepping the surface. Pro Painting Plus is specifically noted for identifying repair issues during the initial walkthrough that homeowners had not noticed - seams, nail pops, surface damage - and addressing them before painting begins. "Herbie and Juan meticulously repaired cracks, seams, nail pops, and other wall blemishes. They were hard workers, polite, and professional. Each time an area was finished, it was clean and perfect." - Cathie Swyka, Google Review

For interior work on older homes, Certified Painting LLC's Brian Shannon is known for skim coating and multi-coat priming before painting to prevent bleed-through and uneven finishes. Ryan's Painting completes nail pop, water damage, and ceiling repairs as part of the project rather than requiring a separate contractor. KB Quality Painting draws consistent praise for cleaning up at the end of every workday rather than just at project completion, with customers noting that not a single item around the work area was marked or damaged. "They repaired holes and damage and skim coated the ceiling. They were very neat, cleaning up at the end of each day." - J. Weatherstone, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Showing up on time and finishing when they say they will is among the most common praises in reviews for painters serving Pine Island, NY. Ryan's Painting earns consistent recognition for setting clear daily expectations and following through - on one large whole-house interior project, Ryan added extra hands near the end to wrap up on Saturday as promised. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY has multiple reviews mentioning jobs finished ahead of the original estimate, which several customers describe as something they had never experienced with a contractor before. "They finished in less time than they estimated. Painters were professional and friendly and went out of their way to patch and fix our walls." - Valerie Goyzueta, Google Review

Pro Painting Plus is noted for combining speed with quality - one customer expected a three-day deck staining job and had it done in a day and a half. Willow Tree Painting & Home Improvement LLC receives regular mention for punctuality, with one reviewer noting that living room, kitchen, foyer, and pantry were all completed in five hours with the space left spotless. For homeowners working around move-in deadlines or rental turnovers, all of the top-rated contractors serving this area have strong track records for delivering on time. "His crew is fast, thorough and professional. They come to work. Very glad I went with him to paint my 100 plus year old house." - Scott Stewart, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing comes up frequently in reviews for painters serving Pine Island, NY, and the feedback is consistent: customers who gathered multiple quotes describe these contractors as competitive without sacrificing quality. Ryan's Painting earns specific praise for transparent pricing - Michael Wilkinson compared four quotes for a deck and fence job and chose Ryan not for the lowest price, but for clear communication and detailed expectations. KB Quality Painting's pricing is repeatedly described as coming in lower than expected for the level of finished work delivered. "The pricing was most reasonable when compared to other painters. I would definitely hire him again for many other projects." - Kathleen Witte, Google Review

Willow Tree Painting & Home Improvement LLC customers frequently pair "reasonable price" with their five-star reviews, with several noting they were surprised by the value given the full scope of repairs and improvements the crew completed. Pro Painting Plus is mentioned by customers who describe the company taking on smaller or unusual jobs other contractors declined - and pricing them fairly for the actual scope. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY earns steady praise for estimates that are clear and accurate with no surprise charges after the job begins. "Ryan was great to work with, communicates well, best price and did a perfect job." - Glenn Kamp, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Quality runs through nearly every review for the contractors serving Pine Island, NY. Customers describe finished work as exceeding expectations - often on projects with real challenges. Willow Tree Painting & Home Improvement LLC takes on work many contractors pass on: aging horse barns, weathered wood shingle homes, custom doors, and textured ceilings with significant damage. Their prep work shows up in the finished result, with many customers returning for second and third projects. Ryan's Painting brings the same attention to surfaces that require careful prep - one reviewer documents a full exterior restoration on an 1869 historic property where Ryan hand-mixed pigments to match the building's original color details. "From start to finish, Ryan was incredibly professional, provided impeccable craftsmanship, and was attentive to detail. His expertise truly elevated our space into something beautiful. We couldn't be happier." - Kim Arbelo, Google Review

Pro Painting Plus's Rob McRae earns recognition for specialty surfaces - cedar, teak, pine, and historic tin roofing - where prep and product selection matter far more than on a standard interior. KB Quality Painting reviews highlight clean lines, careful trim work, and surfaces that look new even on older structures, with crew member Caesar praised individually for his focused detail on interior rooms. Certified Painting LLC's Brian Shannon brings the same standard to older Hudson Valley homes, with multiple reviewers describing strong results on walls that were in rough shape before he arrived. "Brian and his team did an amazing job prepping and painting our circa 1938 home. It wasn't an easy task - lots of trees, a steep hillside, tricky gables and unbearable heat - but they knocked it out of the park." - Arthur T. Rollin, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

A number of homeowners in Pine Island, NY and the surrounding Orange County area own older properties - farmhouses, Victorians, log homes, and pre-1900 structures - that require more than a standard paint job. Several contractors on Chooz Painters have documented this kind of specialized experience. Ryan's Painting completed a full exterior restoration on an 1869 Second Empire home, carefully matching historic trim colors and navigating intricate architectural details including arches and ornate window surrounds. Pro Painting Plus has worked on an original 1865 tin roof, a 52-year-old lakeside dock, and a historic church exterior - projects requiring knowledge of how older materials behave and which products hold up outdoors. "Pro-painting did an amazing job painting our historical church's shingles and restoring it so it looks almost new. The team were hard-working and professional, and gave our buildings a new lease on life for a reasonable price." - Barbara Stone, Google Review

CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY has tackled log cabin sealing and staining, 1800s-era church building exteriors, and multi-building commercial properties throughout Orange County, with over 12 years of local experience behind them. Willow Tree Painting & Home Improvement LLC stands out here as well: their reviews include a horse barn restoration, an exterior job on a cedar-shingled 1940s home where missing shingles were replaced before painting began, and multiple deck restorations on older properties. If your home has peeling from prior paint failures, weathered wood, unusual materials, or difficult access, these contractors have the documented experience to handle the work well. "Brian and his team did an amazing job prepping and painting our circa 1938 home. It wasn't an easy task - lots of trees, a steep hillside, tricky gables - but they knocked it out of the park." - Arthur T. Rollin, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook